瑜珈輔助療法改善思覺失調症病人正性和負性症狀之系統性文獻回顧暨統合分析

A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Yoga Adjunctive Therapy to Improve Positive and Negative Symptoms of Schizophrenia Patients

10.6530/YYN.202111_15(3).0008

蔡佳玲(Chia-Ling Tsai)；黃心樹(Hsin-Shu Huang)

瑜珈 ； 輔助療法 ； 思覺失調症 ； 系統性文獻回顧 ； 統合分析 ； Yoga ； adjunctive therapy ； schizophrenic ； systematic review ； meta-analysis

源遠護理

15卷3期（2021 / 11 / 01）

54 - 65

繁體中文

背景：藥物治療是思覺失調症最主要的治療方法，而輔助療法改善藥物副作用和舒緩症狀已普遍受到重視。目的：檢視瑜珈輔助療法於思覺失調症之訓練處方，並探討瑜珈輔助療法改善思覺失調症病人正性和負性症狀之成效。方法：以系統性文獻回顧方法，搜尋2020年3月前發表於The Cochrane Library、PubMed、CINAHL、Medline及臺灣碩博士論文系統、臺灣期刊論文索引系統、華藝線上圖書館共7個資料庫之文獻，設立關鍵字：Schizophrenia or schizoaffective or psychosis or psychotic／思覺失調症或情感性思覺失調症或精神病、yoga or yogic or yogi／瑜珈，進行檢索搜查共有1227篇相關期刊文獻，經篩選最後採納12篇隨機對照試驗文章，以2017年JBI隨機對照試驗檢核表評讀研究品質；以RevMan 5.3版套裝軟體進行統合分析比較瑜珈、運動、及常規治療改善思覺失調症病人正性與負性症狀的成效。結果：在專業瑜珈教練指導之下進行為期4～8週短期性訓練最多，進行瑜珈頻率每週3～7天不等，每次60分鐘；第8週瑜珈組和常規治療組相較於改善正向症狀達顯著成效（p=.05），但未顯著改善負性症狀成效（p=.40）。第12週瑜珈組和常規治療組相較於改善整體PANSS總分具有顯著成效（p＜0.00001）。瑜珈組和運動組在第16週對改善正性症狀（p=.08）和負性症狀（p=.55）並無顯著差異。結論／實務應用：短期瑜珈輔助療法對思覺失調症病人改善正性症狀和提高PANSS總分是有益的，然而長期瑜珈輔助療法對改善正性和負性症狀之成效證據尚需更多研究加以證實。

Background: Drug therapy is the major treatment for schizophrenia, and adjunctive therapy has been widely recognized for improving drug side effects and soothing symptoms. Purpose: The purpose of this study was to examine the training prescriptions for yoga adjunctive therapy in schizophrenic patients. Investigate the effect of yoga adjunctive therapy on the improvement of positive and negative symptoms of schizophrenic patients. Methods: In the systematic reviews examine the training prescriptions and meta- analysis of yoga adjunctive therapy in schizophrenic patients to compare the effects of yoga, exercise, and conventional treatment on positive and negative symptoms of schizophrenia. According to empirical research, we process from the formation of problems, literature search, screening of literature, literature quality evaluation, extraction integration, and evaluation of results. And search for related literature in The Cochrane Library, PubMed, CINAHL, Medline and Taiwan Master's Thesis System, Taiwan Journal Paper Index System, Airiti Library Huayi Online Library, etc. before March 2020. Search for keywords: Schizophrenia or schizoaffective or psychosis or psychotic, yoga or yogic or yogi, also search for literature published in Chinese and English journals at home and abroad, to find out that it is relevant for the purpose of this study. The article was included in the review for meta-analysis. Results: A total of 12 research samples were included for systematic reviews. The yoga training was guided by a yoga professional or coach. The short-term intervention was 4-8 weeks. The frequency of yoga was 3 to 7 days per week and each session no more than 60min. Seven of the study samples entered the meta-analysis and found that 8-week yoga adjunctive therapy had a significant effect on improving positive symptoms compared with conventional therapy (p = .05), but did not achieve a significant effect on improving negative symptoms (p = .40). Compared with conventional treatment, the 12-week comparison of yoga adjunctive therapy had a significant effect on improving the PANSS total score (p ＜ 0.00001). There was no significant difference between the improvement of positive symptoms (p = .08) and negative symptoms (p = .55) between the yoga group and the exercise group at 16 weeks. Conclusions: Short term Yoga therapy is effective for the positive symptoms and PANSS total score of schizophrenic patients. Yet the effectiveness of long term Yoga therapy for positive and negative symptoms needs further researches.

1. Behere, R. V.,Arasappa, R.,Jagannathan, A.,Varambally, S.,Venkatasubramanian, G.,Thirthalli, J.,Subbakrishna, D. K.,Nagendra, H. R.,Gangadhar, B. N.(2011).Effect of yoga therapy on facial emotion recognition deficits, symptoms and functioning in patients with schizophrenia.Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica,123(2),147-153.
2. Bhatia, T.,Mazumdar, S.,Wood, J.,He, F.,Gur, R. E.,Gur, R. C.,Nimgaonkar, V. L.,Deshpande, S. N.(2017).A randomised controlled trial of adjunctive yoga and adjunctive physical exercise training for cognitive dysfunction in schizophrenia.Acta Neuropsychiatrica,29(2),102-114.
3. Broderick, J.,Crumlish, N.,Waugh, A.,Vancampfort, D.(2017).Yoga versus non-standard care for schizophrenia.Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews,9,CD012052.
4. Broderick, J.,Knowles, A.,Chadwick, J.,Vancampfort, D.(2015).Yoga versus standard care for schizophrenia.Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews,10,CD010554.
5. Broderick, J.,Vancampfort, D.(2017).Yoga as part of a package of care versus standard care for schizophrenia.Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews,9,CD012145.
6. Cabral, P.,Meyer, H. B.,Ames, D.(2011).Effectiveness of yoga therapy as a complementary treatment for major psychiatric disorders: A meta-analysis.The Primary Care Companion for CNS Disorders,13(4),PCC.10r01068.
7. Chan, C. P.(2014).Pokfulam, Hong Kong SAR,University of Hong Kong.
8. Cramer, H.,Lauche, R.,Klose, P.,Langhorst, J.,Dobos, G.(2013).Yoga for schizophrenia: A systematic review and meta-analysis.BMC Psychiatry,13(1),32-44.
9. Dauwan, M.,Begemann, M. J. H.,Heringa, S. M.,Sommer, I. E.(2016).Exercise improves clinical symptoms, quality of life, global functioning, and depression in schizophrenia: A systematic review and meta-analysis.Schizophrenia Bulletin,42(3),588-599.
10. Duraiswamy, G.,Thirthalli, J.,Nagendra, H. R.,Gangadhar, B. N.(2007).Yoga therapy as an add-on treatment in the management of patients with schizophrenia-A randomized controlled trial.Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica,116(3),226-232.
11. Ikai, S.,Suzuki, T.,Uchida, H.,Saruta, J.,Tsukinoki, K.,Fujii, Y.,Mimura, M.(2014).Effects of weekly one-hour Hatha yoga therapy on resilience and stress levels in patients with schizophrenia-spectrum disorders: An eight-week randomized controlled trial.Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine,20(11),823-830.
12. Ikai, S.,Uchida, H.,Suzuki, T.,Tsunoda, K.,Mimura, M.,Fujii, Y.(2013).Effects of yoga therapy on postural stability in patients with schizophrenia-spectrum disorders: A single-blind randomized controlled trial.Journal of Psychiatric Research,47(11),1744-1750.
13. Jayaram, N.,Varambally, S.,Behere, R. V.,Venkata-subramanian, G.,Arasappa, R.,Christopher, R.,Gangadhar, B. N.(2013).Effect of yoga therapy on plasma oxytocin and facial emotion recognition deficits in patients of schizophrenia.Indian Journal of Psychiatry,55(3, Suppl 3),S409-S413.
14. Kamradt, J. M.(2017).Integrating yoga into psychotherapy: The ethics of moving from the mind to the mat.Complementary Therapies in Clinical Practice,27,27-30.
15. Keil, J.,Roa Romero, Y.,Balz, J.,Henjes, M.,Senkowski, D.(2016).Positive and negative symptoms in schizophrenia relate to distinct oscillatory signatures of sensory gating.Frontiers in Human Neuroscience,10,104.
16. Lin, J.,Chan, S. K.,Lee, E. H.,Chang, W. C.,Tse, M.,Su, W. W.,Sham, P.,Hui, C. L.,Glen, J.,Chan, C. L.,Khong, P. L.,So, K. F.,Honer, W. G.,Chen, E. Y.(2015).Aerobic exercise and yoga improve neurocognitive function in women with early psychosis.NPJ Schizophrenia,1(0),15047.
17. Mancevski, B.,Ilievski, B.,Trencevska, I.,Ortakov, V.,Serafimova, T.,Rosoklija, G.,Keilp, J.,Dwork, A. J.(2007).Frontal myelin histology and cognitive function in schizophrenia.Schizophrenia Bulletin,33,270.
18. Manjunath, R. B.,Varambally, S.,Thirthalli, J.,Basavaraddi, I. V.,Gangadhar, B. N.(2013).Efficacy of yoga as an add-on treatment for in-patients with functional psychotic disorder.Indian Journal of Psychiatry,55(Suppl 3),S374-S378.
19. McNamee, L.,Mead, G.,MacGillivray, S.,Lawrise, S. M.(2013).Schizophrenia, poor physical health and physical activity: Evidence-based interventions are required to reduce major health inequalities.British Journal of Psychiatry,203(4),239-241.
20. Najme, A. S.,Bahareh, R.,Bahareh, K.,Zakiye, T.,Ghazaleh, A. M.(2016).Study of relationship between depression and quality of life in patients with chronic schizophrenia.Global Journal of Health Science,8(3),224-229.
21. Paikkatt, B.,Singh, A. R.,Singh, P. K.,Jahan, M.,Ranjan, J. K.(2015).Efficacy of Yoga therapy for the management of psychopathology of patients having chronic schizophrenia.Indian Journal of Psychiatry,57(4),355-360.
22. Pittman-Polletta, B. R.,Kocsis, B.,Vijayan, S.,Whittington, M. A.,Kopell, N. J.(2015).Brain rhythms connect impaired inhibition to altered cognition in schizophrenia.Biological Psychiatry,77(12),1020-1030.
23. Streeter, C. C.,Whitfield, T. H.,Owen, L.,Rein, T.,Karri, S. K.,Yakhkind, A.,Perlmutter, R.,Prescot, A.,Renshaw, P. F.,Ciraulo, D. A.,Jensen, J. E.(2010).Effects of yoga versus walking on mood, anxiety, and brain GABA levels: A randomized controlled MRS study.Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine,16(11),1145-1152.
24. Tsui, M. C. M.(2012).Review of the effects of yoga on people with schizophrenia.Journal of Yoga & Physical Therapy,S1,001.
25. Vancampfort, D.,Vansteelandt, K.,Scheewe, T.,Probst, M.,Knapen, J.,De Herdt, A.,De Hert, M.(2012).Yoga in schizophrenia: A systematic review of randomised controlled trials.Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica,126(1),12-20.
26. Varambally, S.,Gangadhar, B. N.,Thirthalli, J.,Jagannathan, A.,Kumar, S.,Venkatasubramanian, G.,Muralidhar, D.,Subbakrishna, D. K.,Nagendra, H. R.(2012).Therapeutic efficacy of add-on yogasana intervention in stabilized out-patient schizophrenia: Randomized controlled comparison with exercise and waitlist.Indian Journal of Psychiatry,54(3),227-232.
27. Visceglia, E.,Lewis, S.(2011).Yoga therapy as an adjunctive treatment for schizophrenia: A randomized, controlled pilot study.Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine,17(7),601-607.
28. 陳淑齡, S. L,陳耀茂, Y. M.(2016).醫護統計與整合分析：RevMan5軟體操作.Taipei City, Taiwan, ROC.:五南=Wu-Nan Book Inc.
29. 蔡怡秀, Y. S.(2015)。台南市=Tainan City, Taiwan, ROC，國立成功大學職能治療學系=National Cheng Kung University, Department of Occupational Therapy。

1. 陳姿廷,陳俞琪(2023)。有氧運動對於乳癌接受化療病人心肺及身體功能之系統性文獻回顧。榮總護理，40(2)，180-189。
2. (2024)。極晚發型思覺失調症病人之護理經驗。精神衛生護理雜誌，18(3)，42-48。