從競爭均衡觀點看大專籃球聯賽之發展策略

The Development Strategy of University Basketball Association - the Viewpoint of Competitive Balance

10.6569/NTUJPE.201409_(27).0007

曹健仲(Chien-Chung Tsao)；徐嘉良(Chia-Liang Hsu)

全美大學運動聯盟 ； 勝率標準差 ； 勝率基尼係數 ； 赫芬達爾-赫希曼指數 ； National Collegiate Athletic Association ； standard deviation of winning percentages ； Gini coefficients of winning percentages ； Hirfindahl-Hirschman index

臺大體育學報

27輯（2014 / 09 / 01）

77 - 88

繁體中文

本研究目的在透過競爭均衡的觀點，探討大專籃球聯賽公開組第一級競爭均衡之現況，比較公開組第一級男、女聯賽競爭均衡之差異，並以全美大學運動聯盟的作法為基礎，提供大專籃球聯賽作為提升球隊競爭均衡及發展的依據。本研究透過勝率標準差、赫芬達爾—赫希曼指數及勝率基尼係數等計算方式，探討89~101學年度大專公開組第一級男、女籃球聯賽晉級前八強球隊之競爭均衡變化情形。研究結果顯示：一、94學年度後，由於「世大運條款」及「大專條款」的實施，使得公開組第一級籃球聯賽之競爭較過去幾年趨於均衡。二、公開組第一級男、女籃球聯賽的冠軍仍為少數球隊壟斷的局面。三、公開組第一級女子籃球聯賽的競爭較為失衡。本研究結論發現公開組第一級籃球聯賽之競爭趨於均衡，但女子組仍有進步空間。在促進競爭均衡的作法上建議學校在招募球員時，應提供球員財務（獎學金）及非財務（訓練、家教、設施等）上的誘因，並避免優秀球員集中於少數球隊中。此外仿照NCAA對球員學業上的要求，將有助於聯賽更健全的發展。

The purpose of this study was to examine the competitive balance issue of University Basketball Association (UBA), and compared the competitive balance between Division I male and female teams that advanced to final 8. Furthermore, this research provided some propositions to reduce the competitive unbalance situation based on the regulations of National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA). The statistical methods of Standard deviation of winning percentages, Hirfindahl-Hirschman index, and Gini coefficients of winning percentages were applied to compare the competitive balance during the period from 89 to 101 academic years. The result showed that: 1. The competition was more balance after 94 academic years. 2. UBA has been dominated by relatively few teams over last decade. 3. There was greater competitive balance among the men's basketball teams than for the women's teams. In conclusion, the imbalance situation was reduced because of the regulations. In order to increase the competitive balance this study suggested that teams could offer financial compensation (scholarships) and nonmonetary benefits (training, tuition, facilities) as recruited players. Besides, UBA could follow the NCAA's ＂Academic Enhancement＂ program as a model to improve the healthy development of players.

1. 王龍意(2004)。由聯賽成績探討高中女子籃球之發展。中華體育季刊，18(1)，94-101。
   連結：
2. 李纘德(2005)。從經濟學「供給」、「需求」及「收入」的角度分析美國大學運動市場。輔大體育學刊，4，354-363。
   連結：
3. 陳忠誠、李永祥、余宗龍(2009)。大學籃球隊之經營與管理—策略性人力資源管理觀點。海峽兩岸體育研究學報，3(2)，57-73。
   連結：
4. 黃正揚、陳淑貞(2006)。大專籃球運動聯賽的辦理現況與推展策略。大專體育雙月刊，86，40-47。
   連結：
5. 維基百科 (2010)。超級籃球聯賽。2013 年 4 月 2 日。資料引自維基百科 http://zh.wikipedia.org/zh-tw/超級籃球聯賽
6. 賴意文 (2008)。NCAA 簡介 (下)。2013 年 4 月 3 日。資料引自 TSNA http://www.tsna.com.tw/?q=node/531
7. Baird, K.(2004).Dominance in college football and the role of scholarship restrictions.Journal of Sport Management,18,217-235.
8. Butler, M. R.(1995).Competitive balance in Major League Baseball.American Economist,39(2),46-52.
9. Depken, C. A., II(2002).Free agency and the concentration of player talent in Major League Baseball'.Journal of Sports Economics,3,335-353.
10. Depken, C. A., II,Wilson, D.P.(2006).NCAA enforcement and competitive balance in college football.The Southern Economic Journal,72(4),826-845.
11. Hadley, L.,Ciecka, J.,Krautmann, C.(2005).Competitive balance in the aftermath of the 1994 players' strike.Journal of Sports Economics,6(4),379-89.
12. Humphreys, B.(2002).Alternative measures of competitive balance in sports leagues.Journal of Sports Economics,3(2),133-148.
13. Krautmann, A. C.,Hadley, L.(2006).Dynasties versus pennant races: Competitive balance in Major League Baseball.Managerial and Decision Economics,27,287-292.
14. Lambert, P. J.(1993).The distribution and redistribution of income: A Mathematical analysis.Manchester:Manchester University Press.
15. Leeds, M.,Von Allmen, P.(2005).The Economics of Sports.Boston:Pearson-Addison Wesley.
16. Lewis, M.(2008).Individual team incentives and managing competitive balance in sports leagues: An empirical analysis of Major League Baseball.Journal of Marketing Research,45(5),535-549.
17. NCAA(2009).NCAA membership report 2009.
18. Parent, M.M.(Ed.),Slack, T.(Ed.)(2007).International Perspectives on the Management of Sport.MA:Butterworth-Heinemann.
19. Perline, M. M.,Stoldt, C.(2007).Competitive balance in Men's and Women's basketball: The cast of the Missouri Valley Conference.The Sport Journal,10(4)
20. Quirk, J.,Fort, R.(1992).Pay Dirt: The Business of Professional Team Sports.Princeton:Princeton University Press.
21. Rottenberg, S.(1956).The baseball player's labor market.Journal of Political Economy,64,242-258.
22. Schmidt, M.,Berri, D.(2002).Competitive balance and market size in major league baseball: a response to baseball's blue ribbon panel.Review of Industrial Organization,21,41-54.
23. Scully, G. W.(1989).The Business of Major League Baseball.Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
24. Utt, J.,Fort, R.(2002).Pitfalls to measuring competitive balance with gini coefficients.Journal of Sports Economics,3(4),367-373.
25. Zimbalist, A.(2002).Competitive balance in sports leagues: an introduction.Journal of Sports Economics,3,111-121.
26. 王宗吉(2000)。運動社會學。臺北市:洪葉文化。
27. 吳弦峰、陳怜潔(2001)。現行運動績優保送制度問題之研究。南師體育，9，50-79。
28. 唐昭鈞(2007)。中華職棒大聯盟代訓選秀制度與聯盟競爭程度關係之探討。長榮運動休閒學刊，1，86-91。
29. 陳志成、陳天賜、徐生明(2008)。中華職棒聯盟選秀制度與聯盟競爭程度關係之研究。真理大學運動知識學報，5，23-29。
30. 陳泰良(2008)。從兩岸大學籃球聯賽制度看 UBA 之發展。運動健康與休閒學刊，8，63-70。
31. 彭仁暉(2006)。臺北市，國立臺灣師範大學。

1. 盧譽誠,陳子威,石明宗(2019)。國立臺灣師範大學男子籃球隊之團隊文化個案研究。大專體育，151，1-12。