徵納雙方人際互動行為對稅捐稽徵人員工作投入的影響

The Enhancing Effects of Interaction Behaviors between Taxpayers and Tax Collectors on Tax Collectors' Job Involvement

10.30163/BR.200712.0003

陳津美(Chin-Mei Chen)

徵納雙方人際互動行爲 ； 徵納雙方和諧關係 ； 工作投入 ； interaction behavior ； relationship between taxpayers and tax collectors ； job involvement

文大商管學報

12卷2期（2007 / 12 / 01）

41 - 63

繁體中文

稅捐稽徵機關之組織績效對國家建設財源的籌措具有舉足輕重的影響力。影響組織績效的重要前置變數之一爲員工工作投入，較高的員工工作投入有助於提升組織之生產力。而將納稅義務人視爲顧客，並促進稅務人員與納稅義務人的互動以提升徵納雙方和諧關係，取得納稅義務人的合作，成爲近年來各國稅捐稽徵機關經營哲學演進的新趨勢。納稅義務人在納稅服務的過程中與稅捐稽徵人員互動，對其工作態度可能產生衝擊，本研究之目的即在探討徵納雙方人際互動行爲對稅捐稽徵人員工作投入之影響。研究對象爲財政部台北市國稅局與台北市稅捐稽徵處之稅捐稽徵人員。 研究結果顯示，徵納雙方之人際互動行爲，與稅捐稽徵人員之工作投入度成顯著的正相關，且其對稅捐稽徵人員工作投入度之變異的解釋力大於其他控制變數（勞動道德承諾、自尊、技術多樣性、回饋、主管的體諒及參與式領導）。根據實證結果，本研究探討徵納雙方人際互動行爲對稅捐稽徵人員工作投入管理上之意涵，並提出後續研究之建議。

The performance of tax authorities is critical to the resources available for public expenditure. One of the keys to an organization's performance is employees' job involvement. In the last decade, treating taxpayers as customers and fostering the attention in the tax authority of many countries. Taxpayers' behaviors during the interaction between taxpayers and tax collectors have gained considerable recent interaction with tax collectors could have an enormous impact on the work attitudes of tax collectors. The purpose of this paper is to investigate the impact of interaction behaviors between taxpayers and tax collectors on tax collectors' job involvement. The respondents of this research are the tax collectors of the National Tax Administration of Taipei (NTAT) and the Taipei Revenue Service (TRS). The results show that the interaction behavio0rs between taxpayers and tax collectors are positively related to tax collectors' job involvement. The effect size of interaction behaviors are greater than those of the other independent variable used in this paper (i.e. work ethic endorsement, self-esteem, skill variety, feedback, leadership consideration, leadership participation). Theoretical implications and further research suggestions are discussed.

1. Bateson, J. E. G.,Hoffman, K. D.(1999).Managing Services Marketing: Text and Readings.Orlando:Dryden Press.
2. Bateson, J. E. G.,J. A. Czepiel,M. R. Solomon,C. F. Suprenant (Eds.)(1985).The Service Encounter.Massachusetts:Lexington Book.
3. Beckett, J.(2000).The "government should run like a business" mantra.American Review of Public Administration,30(2),185-204.
4. Bentler, P. M.,Bonett, D. G.(1980).Significance tests and goodness of fit in the analysis of covariance structures.Psychological Bulletin,88(4),588-606.
5. Bitner, M. J.,Booms, B. H.,Mohr, L. A.(1994).Critical service encounters: The employee`s viewpoint.Journal of Marketing,58(4),95-106.
6. Bowen, D. E.,Schneider, B.,J. A. Czepiel,M. R. Solomon,C. F. Surprenant (Eds.)(1985).The Service Encounter: Managing Employee/Customer Interaction in Service Businesses.Lexington, Massachusetts:D. C. Heath and Company.
7. Bowers, M. R.,Martin, C. L.,Luker, A.(1990).Trading places, employees as customers, customers as employees.Journal of Services Marketing,4(2),56-69.
8. Brockner, J.,Grover, S. L.,Blonder, M. D.(1988).Predictors of survivors` job involvement following layoffs: A field study.Journal of Applied Psychology,73(3),436-442.
9. Brown, S. P.(1996).A meta-analysis and review of organizational research on job involvement.Psychological Bulletin,120(2),235-255.
10. Browne, M. W.,Cudeck, R.,K. A. Bollen,J. S. Long (Eds.)(1993).Testing structural equation models.Newbury Park, CA:Sage.
11. Buchanan, B.(1975).Red tape and the service ethic: Some unexpected differences between public and private managers.Administration and Society,6(4),423-438.
12. Buchanan, B.(1974).Government managers business executives, and organizational commitment.Public Administration Review,34(4),339-347.
13. Cheloha, R. S.,Farr, J. L.(1980).Absenteeism, job involvement, and job satisfaction in an organizational setting.Journal of Applied Psychology,65(4),467-473.
14. Chen, Y. S.,Sawyers, R. B.(1994).TQM at the IRS.Journal of Accountancy,178(1),77-80.
15. Dabholkar, P. A.(1996).Consumer evaluations of new technology-based self-service options: An investigation of alternative models of service quality.International Journal of Research in Marketing,13(1),29-51.
16. Denhardt, R. B.(1995).Public Administration: An Action Orientation.Orlando, Florida:Harcourt Brace & Company.
17. Dwyer, F. R.,Schurr, P. H.,Oh, S.(1987).Developing buyer-seller relationships.Journal of Marketing,51(2),11-27.
18. Elffers, H.,Weigel, R. H.,Hessing, D. J.(1987).The consequences of different strategies for measuring tax evasion behavior.Journal of Economic Psychology,8(3),311-337.
19. Ennew, C. T.,Binks, M. R.(1999).Impact of participative service relationships on quality, satisfaction and retention: An exploratory study.Journal of Business research,46(2),121-132.
20. Fitzsimmons, J. A.,Fitzsimmons, M. J.(1994).Service Management for Competitive Advantage.New York:McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc.
21. Flynn, D. M.,Tannenbaum, S. I.(1993).Correlates of organizational commitment: Differences in the public and private sector.Journal of Business and Psychology,8(1),103-116.
22. Furnham, A.(1983).The protestant work ethic, human values and attitudes towards taxation.Journal of Economic Psychology,3(2),113-128.
23. Gibson, J. L.,Ivancevich, J. M.,Donnelly, J. H.(1973).Organizations, Structure, Processes, Behavior.Dallas:Business Publications, Inc.
24. Glaser, M. A.,Hildreth, W. B.(1999).Service delivery satisfaction and willingness to pay taxes: citizen recognition of local government performance.Public Productivity & Management Review,23(1),48-67.
25. Goodwin, C.(1988)."I can do it myself:" training the service consumer to contribute to service productivity.The Journal of Services Marketing,2(4),71-80.
26. Hackman, J. R.,Oldham, G. R.(1980).Work Redesign.Reading, MA:Addison-Wesley.
27. Hair, J. F.,Anderson, R. E.,Tatham, R. L.,Black, W. C.(1995).Multivariate Data Analysis.Englewood Cliffs, NJ:Prentice Hall.
28. Hartline, M. D.,Ferrell, O. C.(1996).The management of customer-contact service employees: An empirical investigation.Journal of Marketing,60(4),52-70.
29. House, R.(1971).A path-goal theory of leader effectiveness.Administrative Science Quarterly,16(3),321-338.
30. House, R. J.,Dessler, G.,J. G. Hunt,L. L. Larson (Eds.)(1974).Contingency Approaches to Leadership.Carbondale:Southern Illinois University Press.
31. Hsieh, A. T.,Chou, C. H,Chen, C. M.(2002).Job standardization and service quality: A closer look at the application of total quality management to the public sector.Total Quality Management,13(7),923-936.
32. Jöreskog, K. G.(1969).A general approach to confirmatory maximum likelihood factor analysis.Psychometrika,34(2),183-202.
33. Jöreskog, Karl G.,Sörbom, D.(1986).LISREL VI.Moorseville, IN:Scientific Software.
34. Kanungo, R. N.(1979).The concepts of alienation and involvement revisited.Psychological Bulletin,86(2),119-138.
35. Kanungo, R. N.(1982).Measurement of job and work involvement.Journal of Applied Psychology,67(3),341-349.
36. Larsson, R.,Bowen, D. E.(1989).Organization and customer: Managing design and coordination of services.Academy of Management Review,14(2),213-233.
37. Lawler, E. E.(1992).The Ultimate Advantage: Creating the High-involvement Organization.San Francisco:Jossey-Bass.
38. Lawler, E. E.(1986).High-involvement Management: Participative Strategies for Improving Organizational Performance.San Francisco:Jossey-Bass.
39. Lazarus, R. S.(1991).Emotion and Adaptation.New York, NY:Oxford University Press.
40. Lengnick-Hall, C. A.(1996).Customer contributions to quality: A different view of the customer-oriented firm.Academy of Management Journal,21(3),791-824.
41. Lent, R. W.,Brown, S. D.,Hackett, G.(1994).Toward a unifying social cognitive theory of career and academic interest, choice, and performance.Journal of Vocational Behavior,45(1),79-122.
42. Lewis, A.(1982).The Psychology of Taxation.Oxford:Martin Roberston.
43. Lodahl, T. M.,Kejner, M.(1965).The definition and measurement of job involvement.Journal of Applied Psychology,49(1),24-33.
44. Lovelock, C.,Wright, L.(1999).Principles of Service Marketing and Management.New Jersey:Prentice Hall.
45. Mills, P. K.,Moberg, D. J.(1982).Perspectives on the technology of service operations.Academy of Management Review,7(3),467-478.
46. Mills, P. K.,Morris, J. H.(1986).Clients as "partial" employees of service organizations: Role development in client participation.Academy of Management Review,11(4),726-735.
47. Mirels, H. L.,Garrett, J. B.(1971).The Protestant work ethic as a personality variable.Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology,36(1),40-44.
48. Morrow, P. C.,McElroy, J. C.(1986).Research notes on assessing measures of work commitment.Journal of Occupational Behavior,7(1),139-145.
49. Naylor, J. C.,Pritchard, R. D.,Ilgen, D. R.(1980).A Theory of Behavior in Organizations.New York, NY:Academic Press.
50. Nunnally, J. C.(1978).Psychometric Theory.New York, NY:McGraw-Hill.
51. Parasuraman, A.,Berry, L. L.,Zeithaml, V. A.(1991).Refinement and reassessment of the SERVQUAL scale.Journal of Retailing,67(4),420-450.
52. Parasuraman, A.,Berry, L. L.,Zeithaml, V. A.(1988).SERVQUAL: A multiple-item scale for measuring consumer perceptions of service quality.Journal of Retailing,64(1),12-40.
53. Pegnato, J. A.(1997).Is a citizen a customer?.Public productivity & Management Review,20(4),397-404.
54. Pfeffer, J.(1994).Competitive Advantage through People: Unleashing the Power of the Work Force.Boston:Harvard Business School Press.
55. Price, L. L.,Arnould, E. J.,Deibler, S. L.(1995).Consumers` emotional responses to service encounters: The influence of the service provider.International Journal of Service Industry Management,6(3),34-63.
56. Rainey, H. G.(1983).Public agencies and private firms: Incentive structures, goals, and individual roles.Administration & Society,15(2),207-242.
57. Romzek, B.,Hendricks, J.(1982).Organizational involvement and representative bureaucracy: Can we have it both ways?.American Political Science Review,76(1),75-82.
58. Rosenberg, M.(1979).Conceiving the self.New York, NY:Basic Books.
59. Rowley, J.(1998).Quality measurement in the public sector: Some perspectives from the service quality literature.Total Quality Management,9(2&3),321-333.
60. Saal, F. E.(1978).Job involvement: A multivariate approach.Journal of Applied Psychology,63(1),53-61.
61. Saint-Martin, D.(2001).When industrial policy shapes public sector reform: Total quality management in Britain and France.West European Politics,24(4),105-124.
62. Schmölders`, G.(1970).Survey research in public finance-A behavioral approach fiscal theory.Public Finance,25(2),300-306.
63. Schneider, B.,Bowen, D. E.(1993).The service organization: Human resources management is crucial.Organizational Dynamics,21(4),39-52.
64. Sims, H. P.,Szilagyi, A. D.,Keller, R. T.(1976).The measurement of job characteristics.Academy of Management Journal,19(2),195-212.
65. Solomon, M. R.,Surprenant, C.,Czepiel, J. A.,Gutman, E. G.(1985).A role theory perspective on dyadic interactions: The service encounter.Journal of Marketing,49(1),99-111.
66. Spicer, M. W.,Lundstedt, S. B.(1976).Understanding tax evasion.Public Finance,2(3),195-304.
67. Swiss, J. E.(1992).Adapting total quality management (TQM) to government.Public Administration Review,52(4),356-362.
68. Teas, R. K.(1983).Supervisory behavior, role stress, and the job satisfaction of industrial salespeople.Journal of Marketing Research,20(1),84-91.
69. Viano, R. P.,Foster, S. T.(1996).Using quality management to improve customer responsiveness at the Internal Revenue Service.Production and Inventory Management Journal,37(2),37-43.
70. Wallschutzky, I. G.(1984).Possible causes of tax evasion.Journal of Economic Psychology,5(4),371-384.
71. Wheaton, B.,Muthën, B.,Alvin, D. F.,Summers, G. F.,D. R. Herse (Ed.)(1977).Sociological Methodology.San Francisco, CA:Jossey-Bass.
72. White, R. A.,Curatola, A. P.,S. M. Jones (Ed.)(1990).Advances in Taxation.London:JAI Press.
73. Zeithaml, V. A.,Bitner, M. J.(2000).Service Marketing: Integrating Customer Focus Across the Firm.Boston:McGraw-Hill.
74. 方代青(2000)。國立成功大學企業管理研究所未出版之碩士論文。
75. 財政部台北市國稅局(2001)。台北市國稅統計。台北:
76. 財政部統計處(2007)。中華民國95年賦稅統計年報。台北:
77. 財政部統計處(2006)。中華民國94年財政統計年報。台北:
78. 陳松穗(1993)。國立中山大學企業管理研究所未出版之碩士論文。
79. 陳彥霖(2006)。查稅人員罰緩獎金與離職率。政策週報，34，7-8。
80. 黃燕輝、蔡培元、陳美琳、林桂英(1999)。稽徵機關運用ISO品質保證系統建立內部稽核制度之研究。高雄:財政部高雄市國稅局。
81. 臺北市稅捐稽徵處(2007)。納稅服務你我他－財稅類爲民服務白皮書。台北:
82. 賴柏甫(1995)。國立中興大學企業管理研究所未出版之碩士論文。
83. 謝長宏、張美燕(1989)。稅務人員工作負荷分析（財政部賦稅改革委員會，No.63）。台北:財政部賦稅改革委員會。
84. 簡俊彥、黃惠絹、高淑敏、鍾瓊慧(1999)。提升國稅局稽徵所（分局）服務功能及品質之研究。台北:財政部台北市國稅局。

1. 葉欣婷、許順旺(2010)。國際觀光旅館員工工作價值觀、工作態度與工作績效之相關研究─以主管領導風格為干擾變項。企業管理學報，87，77-110。