概念圖表徵形式對護理學生批判思考的影響

Effects of Different Forms of Concept-Map Representation on Nursing Students' Critical Thinking Performances

賴錦緣(Chin-Yuan Lai)；陳勝美(Sheng-Mei Chen)；吳正己(Cheng-Chih Wu)

批判思考 ； 表徵工具 ； 概念圖 ； 護理教育 ； concept maps ； critical thinking ； nursing education ； representation tools

教育實踐與研究

28卷1期（2015 / 06 / 01）

1 - 31

繁體中文

表徵是問題解決重要的工具。本文探討護生運用不同形式概念圖來表徵精神科病人護理問題表現之差異。研究採準實驗設計，參與者為某護專四年級修習「精神科護理學」課程的兩班學生，一班為實驗組48人，以網狀概念圖表徵個案問題；另一班控制組50人，以傳統樹狀階層圖。研究結果發現：實驗組在指出護理問題、舉證支持護理問題、以及瞭解護理問題關聯等三個向度皆明顯優於控制組。網狀概念圖可擴大學生思考並促進因果關係推理，不同概念圖表徵影響了學生問題解決的歷程。網狀概念圖的教學活動加強了實驗組學生對個案照顧內涵與作法的認知。未來可應用不同形式概念圖於護理過程各階段的教學，以探討其他概念圖表徵對學生的影響。

Representation is important for problem solving. This study examined the effects of different forms of concept maps on nursing students' performances of conceptualizing psychiatric patients' problems. A quasi-experimental research design was adopted to investigate the effects. The participants were two classes of fourth-year students who were enrolled in a psychiatric nursing course in a nursing college. One class with 48 students served as the experimental group, and used web-based concepts map to represent patients' problem. The other class with 50 students served as the control group, and used the traditional hierarchical concept mapping method. The results indicated that the concept maps drawn by the experimental group showed more nursing problem, supporting evidence, and relationships between nursing problems than those drawn by the control group. The web-based concept maps helped expand students' thinking and promoted their causality reasoning. Different concept-map representation tools affected the process of students' problem solving. The experimental learning activities promoted students' understanding of concepts and ways of psychiatric patients' care taking. To understand the effects of other types of concept maps, future research may guide students in using different forms of concept maps throughout the stages of nursing process.

1. Feng, R. -C.,Chen, M. -J.,Chen, M. -C.,Pai, Y. -C.(2010).Critical thinking competence and dispositionof clinical nurses in a medical center.Journal of Nursing Research,18(2),77-86.
   連結：
2. 台灣護理教育評鑑委員會（2010）。評鑑準則。取自 http://www.heeact.edu.tw/lp.asp?ctNode=352&CtUnit=118&BaseDSD=7&mp=5[Taiwan Nursing Accreditation Council (2010). Assessment criteria. Retrieved from http://www.heeact.edu.tw/lp.asp?ctNode=352&CtUnit=118&BaseDSD=7&mp=5]
3. 維基百科（2014）。概念圖。取自 http://zh.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E6%A6%82%E5%BF%B5%E5%9B%BE[Wikipedia (2014). Concept map. Retrieved from http://zh.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E6%A6%82%E5%BF%B5%E5%9B%BE]
4. Alfaro-LeFevre, R.(1999).Critical thinking in nursing: A practical approach.Philadelphia, PA:Saunders.
5. All, A.,Huycke, L. I.,Fisher, M. J.(2003).Instructional tools for nursing education: Concept maps.Nursing Education Perspective,24(6),311-317.
6. American Association of Colleges of Nursing(1998).The essentials of baccalaureate education for professional education.Washington, DC:Author.
7. Bartlett, R.,Bland, A.,Rossen, E.,Kautz, D.,Benfield, S.,Carnevale, T.(2008).Evaluation of the outcome-present state test model as a way to teach clinical reasoning.Journal of Nursing Education,47(8),337-344.
8. Bodner, G. M.,Domin, D. S.(2000).Mental models: The role of representations in problem solvingin chemistry.University Chemistry Education,4(1),24-30.
9. Burrows, D. E.(1995).The nurse teacher's role in the promotion of reflective practice.Nursing Education Today,15,346-350.
10. Conger, M.,Mezza, I.(1996).Fostering critical thinking in nursing students in the clinical setting.Nurse Educator,21(3),11-15.
11. Corrigan, P. W.(2000).Mental health stigma as social attribution: Implications for research methods and attitude change.Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice,7,48-67.
12. Crabtree, B. F.,Miller, W. L.(1999).Doing qualitative research.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
13. Daley, B. J.,Shaw, C. R.,Balistrieri, T.,Glasenapp, K.,Piacentine, L.(1999).Concept map: A strategy to teach and evaluate critical thinking.Journal of Nursing Education,38(1),42-47.
14. Duval, R.(2000).Basic issues for research in mathematics education.Proceedings of the Conference of the International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics Education (PME)
15. Facione, P. A.(1990).Executive summary: Critical thinking: A statement of expert consensus for purposes of educational assessment and instruction.Millbrae, CA:The California Academic Press.
16. Hoffman, E.,Trott, J.,Neely, K. P.(2002).Concept mapping: A tool to bridge the disciplinary divide.American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology,187(3 Suppl),S41-S43.
17. Kautz, D. D.,Kuiper, R. A.,Pesut, D. J.,Knight-Brown, P.,Daneker, D.(2005).Promoting clinical reasoning in undergraduate nursing students: Application and evaluation of the outcome-present state-test (OPT) model of clinical reasoning.International Journal of Nursing Education Scholarship,2(1)
18. Kautz, D. D.,Kuiper, R.,Pesut, D. J.,Williams, R. L.(2006).Using NANDA, NIC, and NOC (NNN) language for clinical reasoning with the outcome-present state-test (OPT) model.International Journal of Nursing Terminologies and Classifications,17(3),129-138.
19. Kuiper, R.,Heinrich, C.,Matthias, A.,Graham, M. J.,Bell-Kotwall, L.(2008).Debriefing with the OPT model of clinical reasoning during high fidelity patient simulation.International Journal of Nursing Education Scholarship,5(1)
20. Levett-Jones, T.,Hoffman, K.,Dempsey, J.,Jeong, S. Y.,Noble, D.,Norton, C. A.(2010).The 'five rights' of clinical reasoning: An educational model to enhance nursing students' ability to identify and manage clinically 'at risk' patients.Nurse Education Today,30(6),515-520.
21. Moattari, M.,Soleimani, S.,Moghaddam, N. J.,Mehbodi, F.(2014).Clinical concept mapping: Does it improve discipline-based critical thinking of nursing students?.Iranian Journal of Nursing and Midwifery Research,19(1),70-76.
22. NANDA International、高紀惠（譯）, C. -H.(trans.)(2009).NANDA-I 護理診斷手冊2009~2011.臺北市=Taipei:華杏=Farseeing.
23. National League for Nursing Accrediting Commission(1997).Interpretive guidelines for standards and criteria.New York, NY:Author.
24. Norris, S. P.,Ennis, R. H.(1989).Evaluating critical thinking.Pacific Grove, CA:Midwest Publications.
25. Novak, J.,Gowin, D.(1984).Learning how to learn.London, UK:Cambridge University Press.
26. Perner, J.(1991).Understanding the representational mind.Cambridge, MA:MIT Press.
27. Pesut, D. J.,Herman, J.(1998).OPT: Transformation of nursing process for contemporary practice.Nursing Outlook,46,29-36.
28. Pesut, D. J.,Herman, J.(1999).Clinical reasoning: The art and scienceof critical and creative thinking.Clifton Park, NY:Thomson Delmar Learning.
29. Plötzner, R.,Spada, H.(1998).Constructing quantitative problem representations on the basis of qualitative reasoning.Interactive Learning Environments,5(2),95-107.
30. Reising, D. L.(2004).The outcome-present state-testing model applied to classroom settings.Journal of Nursing Education,43,431-432.
31. Rubenfeld, M.,Scheffer, B.(2010).Critical thinking tactics for nurses: Achieving the IOM competencies.Sudbury, MA:Jones and Bartlett Publisher.
32. Samawi, Z.(2006).The effect of concept mapping on critical thinking skills and dispositions of junior and senior baccalaureate nursing students.Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Concept Mapping
33. Scheffer, B. K.,Rubenfeld, M. G.(2000).A consensus statement on critical thinking in nursing.Journal of Nursing Education,39(8),352-359.
34. Schuster, P. M.(2000).Concept mapping: Reducing clinical care plan paperwork and increasing learning.Nurse Educator,25(2),76-81.
35. Sedlak, C. A.(1996).Dressing up nursing diagnoses: A critical thinking strategy.Nurse Educator,21(4),19-22.
36. Simpson, E.,Courtney, M.(2002).Critical thinking in nursing education: A literature review.International Journal of Nursing Practice,8,89-98.
37. Stokes, S.(2001).Visual literacy in teaching and learning: A literature perspective.Electronic Journal for the Integration of Technology in Education,1(1)
38. Tanner, C. A.(2006).Thinking like a nurse: A research-based model of clinical judgment in nursing.Journal of Nursing Education,45(6),204-211.
39. Taylor, C.(2002).Assessing patients' needs: Does the same information guide expert and novice nurses?.International Nursing Review,49(1),11-19.
40. Vacek, J. E.(2009).Using a conceptual approach with a concept map of psychosis as an exemplar to promote critical thinking.Journal of Nursing Education,48(1),49-53.
41. West, D.,Pomeroy, J.,Park, J.,Gerstenberger, E.,Jonathan, S.(2000).Critical thinking in graduate medical education: A role for concept mapping assessment?.Journal of the American Medical Association,284(9),1105-1111.
42. Wheeler, L. A.,Collins, K. R.(2003).The influence of concept mapping on critical thinking in baccalaureate nursing students.Journal of Professional Nursing,19(6),339-346.
43. Wilgis, M.,McConnell, J.(2008).Concept mapping: An educational strategy to improve graduate nurses' critical thinking skills during a hospital orientation program.Journal of Continuing Education in Nursing,39,119-126.
44. Wong, T. K. S.,Chung, J. W. Y.(2002).Diagnostic reasoning processes using patient simulation in different learning environments.Journal of Clinical Nursing,11(1),65-72.
45. Yildirim, B.,Özkahraman, Ş.(2011).Critical thinking in nursing process and education.International Journal of Humanities and Social Science,1(13),257-262.
46. 周書毓(2005)。問題解决－專家與生手教師能力知多少？。網路社會學通訊期刊，51
47. 林美伶、熊秉荃、林淑蓉、胡海國(2002)。精神分裂症患者之烙印處境。慈濟醫學雜誌，14(6)，381-388。
48. 張瓊珠(2009)。運用理情行為治療理論概念於重鬱症患者之護理經驗。精神衛生護理雜誌，4(1)，57-64。
49. 教育部編、國立臺灣師範大學編(2004)。九年一貫課程自然與生活科技學習領域科學素養的內涵與解析。臺北=Taipei:教育部=Ministry of Education。
50. 葉玉珠(2003)。批判思考的涵意與有效教師行為。清華大學通識教育季刊，9(3)，151-170。
51. 蘇麗智、阮玉梅、胡月娟、林明珍、李引玉、羅筱芬(2006)。最新護理學導論。臺北=Taipei:華杏=Farseeing。

1. 蕭淳浩、黃耀萱、曾一偵、莊秋蘭、李文瑜(2018)。以建模導向課程促進海洋永續觀點發展之初探。環境教育研究，14(1)，117-158。
2. 鄭佳蓉,練美華,黃心蘭,陳盈嫣,陳冬蜜,高巧如,洪美鳳,何妙靜(2021)。運用多元教學提升急診二年期護理人員急救復甦處置完整性之專案。長庚護理，32(3)，77-94。
3. 鄭巧晨,張綺紋,姜月桃,邱雅儀,林淑芳,余幸宜(2018)。運用心智圖教學法顧兒科護理臨床實習教學。源遠護理，12(2)，50-57。
4. (2023)。人體護理問題關聯圖對臨床實習護生學習成效之探究。長庚護理，34(4)，1-13。
5. (2024)。探討繪圖導向科學建模教學對國小六年級學童模型建立及系統思考能力影響之研究。科學教育學刊，32(1)，33-61。