题名

翻轉教室與問題導向學習融入全英語課程之行動研究

并列篇名

Action Research on the Integration of Flipped Classroom and Problem-based Learning into EMI Courses

作者

戰寶華(Pao-Hwa Chan)

关键词

全英語課程 ； 行動研究 ； 問題導向學習 ； 翻轉教室 ； action research ； EMI ； flipping classroom ； problem-based learning

期刊名称

教育實踐與研究

卷期/出版年月

35卷2期（2022 / 12 / 01）

页次

1 - 57

内容语文

繁體中文;英文
中文摘要

肇因於2030雙語政策與2024大專校院學生雙語化學習計畫，全英語課程在目標達成上，扮演不可或缺的角色，因而本研究藉由行動研究剖析翻轉教室與問題導向學習融入全英語課程之歷程及影響。本研究以行動研究探索A大學博士班學生，並藉由期初、期中、期末三大循環之螺旋循環探索模式分析行動影響，而每一大循環包含「規劃－實施－觀察－省思－調整」等五項步驟之小循環，環環相扣、相輔相成。本研究之貢獻在於發現可行的課程融入模式，且研究發現，透過期初預行階段、期中執行階段、期末評估階段之行動歷程可有效融合翻轉教室與問題導向學習於全英語課程，有益於學生之學習投入及成長，並能展現參與意願強化、專業能力增強與學習滿意提高之成果。最後，據以提出對開設、講授及修習全英語課程者之建議，以利為推展全英語課程提供實務上之啟發。
英文摘要

Owing to the "Bilingual 2030" policy and the plan of "Program on Bilingual Education for Students in College" by 2024, English as a Medium of Instruction (EMI) courses play an integral role in goal achievement. This is an action research study that analyzed the impact of the integration of flipped classroom and problem-based learning into EMI courses by examining doctoral students from a university in Taiwan. The spiral exploration mode of the three major cycles was the fundamental concept for analyzing the impact of actions. For each cycle, five steps were implemented: "planning-implement-observation-reflection-adjustment". The study discovered feasible integration models through the action procedure of the preparatory period, the implementation period, and the evaluation period, where flipped classroom and problem-based learning were effectively integrated into the courses. In addition, the integrated model was beneficial to students' learning growth, strengthening their willingness to participate, and enhancing their professional ability and learning satisfaction. Finally, suggestions were put forward for those who wish to set up, teach and take EMI courses to provide practical inspirations.
主题分类 社會科學 > 教育學
参考文献
  1. 于曉平, H. -P.,吳育雅, Y. -Y.,孫譽真, Y. -C.(2016)。資優學生概念構圖教學之實施與成效探究。資優教育季刊，138，1-10。
    連結：
  2. 呂秀蓮, H. -L.(2019)。課綱為本課程設計經驗之研究：以國中教師為對象。教育實踐與研究，32(1)，1-31。
    連結：
  3. 宋佩芬, P. -F.(2021)。歷史教學備課：國中楷模教師的個案研究。教育實踐與研究，34(2)，1-40。
    連結：
  4. 林淑華, S. -H.,田秀蘭, H. -S.,盧鴻文, H. -W.(2020)。學校輔導教師督導者之督導經驗與學校輔導督導系統建構。教育心理學報，52(2)，311-336。
    連結：
  5. 洪郁婷, Y. -T(2019)。向學生學習：教師建構學科學生知識之個案研究。教育實踐與研究，32(1)，107-143。
    連結：
  6. 張德銳, D. -R.,林縵君, M. -C.(2016)。PBL 在教學實習上的應用成效與困境之研究。師資培育與教師專業發展期刊，9(2)，1-26。
    連結：
  7. 陳雅齡, Y. -L.,廖柏森, P. -S.(2012)。以溝通式翻譯輔助大學全英語教學之探討。輔仁外語學報，9，45-65。
    連結：
  8. 陳麗珠, L. -J.,程台生, T. -S.(2011)。大學分子生物學課程實施全英語教學的困境。嘉南學報（人文類），37，431-440。
    連結：
  9. 曾淑賢, S. -H.(2021)。學前融合教育課程調整模式之探討。教育實踐與研究，34(2)，125-147。
    連結：
  10. 曾意儒, Y. -J.,石家安, C. -A.(2021)。應用翻轉教室於大學資料科學課程之學習行為與滿意度分析。科學教育學刊，29(4)，375-396。
    連結：
  11. 蔡曉楓, H. -F.,陳欣希, H. -H.(2019)。增進學生文本理解的國小國語文專家教師提問策略分析。教育實踐與研究，32(2)，1-38。
    連結：
  12. 鍾智林, C. -L.,羅美蘭, M. -L(2021)。英語授課一定會降低大學課程的教學評量嗎？一個縱貫性個案研究。教育研究與發展期刊，17(3)，41-70。
    連結：
  13. 簡梅瑩, M. -Y.(2008)。促進反思教學發展與實施之行動研究。中等教育，59(1)，22-35。
    連結：
  14. 羅寶鳳, P. -F.(2016)。學教翻轉：翻轉課堂的課程與教學。課程與教學季刊，19(4)，1-22。
    連結：
  15. Abdelkader, A. M.,Almefarfesh, A. A.(2020).Effect of using case study teaching strategy on nursing students’ perception of teaching effectiveness.International Journal of Nursing Education,12(4),285-291.
  16. Abdullah, N. S.,Mohamad, M.(2020).The Implementation of highly immersive programme towards language proficiency of primary school pupils: A literature review.Creative Education,11(8),1336.
  17. Abedi, P.,Keshmirshekan, M. H.,Namaziandost, E.(2019).The comparative effect of flipped classroom instruction versus traditional instruction on Iranian intermediate EFL learners’ English composition writing.Journal of Applied Linguistics and Language Research,6(4),43-56.
  18. Adnyani, L. D. S.,Ratnadi, N. N. A.(2020).The implementation of flipped classroom on classroom management course.Journal of Physics: Conference Series,1516,1-9.
  19. Aldiabat, K. M.,Le Navenec, C. L.(2018).Data saturation: The mysterious step in grounded theory methodology.The Qualitative Report,23(1),245-261.
  20. Al-Naabi, I. S.(2020).Is it worth flipping? The impact of flipped classroom on EFL students’ grammar.English Language Teaching,13(6),64-75.
  21. Amstelveen, R.(2019).Flipping a college mathematics classroom: An action research project.Education and Information Technologies,24(2),1337-1350.
  22. Arviana, R.,Dewi, M. P.(2018).Problem based learning in mathematics education and its effect on student’s critical thinking.Advanced Science Letters,24(1),211-213.
  23. Awidi, I. T.,Paynter, M.(2019).The impact of a flipped classroom approach on student learning experience.Computers & Education,128,269-283.
  24. Barrow, L.,Markman-Pithers, L.(2016).Supporting young English learners in the United States.The Future of Children,26(2),159-183.
  25. Bashith, A.,Amin, S.(2017).The effect of problem-based learning on EFL students’ critical thinking skill and learning outcome.Al-Ta lim Journal,24(2),93-102.
  26. Boelt, A. M.,Kolmos, A.,Holgaard, J. E.(2022).Literature review of students’ perceptions of generic competence development in problem-based learning in engineering education.European Journal of Engineering Education,2022,1-22.
  27. Bogdan, R. D.,Biklen, S. K.(2007).Qualitative research for education: An introduction to theory and methods.New York, NY:Pearson.
  28. Bojke, L.,Soares, M. O.,Claxton, K.,Colson, A.,Fox, A.,Jackson, C.,Taylor, A.(2022).Reference case methods for expert elicitation in health care decision making.Medical Decision Making,42(2),182-193.
  29. Bonney, K. M.(2015).Case study teaching method improves student performance and perceptions of learning gains.Journal of Microbiology & Biology Education,16(1),21-28.
  30. Bowen, G. A.(2008).Naturalistic inquiry and the saturation concept: A research node.Qualitative Research,8(1),138-152.
  31. Ceker, E.,Ozdamli, F.(2016).Features and characteristics of problem-based learning.Cypriot Journal of Educational Sciences,11(4),195-202.
  32. Cevikbas, M.,Kaiser, G.(2022).Can flipped classroom pedagogy offer promising perspectives for mathematics education on pandemic-related issues? A systematic literature review.ZDM-Mathematics Education,2022,1-15.
  33. Chao, C. -Y.,Chen, Y. -T.,Chuang, K. -U.(2015).Exploring students’ learning attitude and achievement in flipped learning supported computer aided design curriculum: A study in high school engineering education.Computer Applications in Engineering Education,23(4),514-526.
  34. Chis, A. E.,Moldovan, A. N.,Murphy, L.,Pathak, P.,Muntean, C. H.(2018).Investigating flipped classroom and problem-based learning in a programming module for computing conversion course.Journal of Educational Technology & Society,21(4),232-247.
  35. Cladera, M.(2021).An application of importance-performance analysis to students’ evaluation of teaching.Educational Assessment, Evaluation and Accountability,33(4),701-715.
  36. Conderman, G.(2001).Program evaluation: Using multiple assessment methods to promote authentic student learning and curricular change.Teacher Education and Special Education,24(4),391-394.
  37. Correa, M.(2015).Flipping the foreign language classroom and critical pedagogies: A (new) old trend.Higher Education for the Future,2(2),114-125.
  38. Denzin, N. K.,Lincoln, Y. S.(2018).The SAGE handbook of qualitative research.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  39. Diningrat, S. W. M.,Setyosari, P.,Ulfa, S.,Widiati, U.(2020).Integrating PBI in the flipped classroom: A framework for effective instruction.World Journal on Educational Technology: Current Issues,12(2),117-127.
  40. Dolmans, D. H.,Loyens, S. M.,Marcq, H.,Gijbels, D.(2016).Deep and surface learning in problem-based learning: A review of the literature.Advances in Health Sciences Education,21(5),1087-1112.
  41. Ericsson, A.,Pool, R.(2017).Peak: Secrets from the new science of expertise.Boston, MA:Eamon Dolan/Mariner Books.
  42. Forster, M.,Maur, A.,Weiser, C.,Winkel, K.(2022).Pre-class video watching fosters achievement and knowledge retention in a flipped classroom.Computers & Education,179(99),1-14.
  43. Frydenberg, M.(2013).Flipping excel.Information Systems Education Journal,11(1),63-73.
  44. Genc, B.,Bada, E.(2010).English as a world language in academic writing.The Reading Matrix,10(2),142-151.
  45. Gillette, C.(2017).Consideration of problem-based learning in athletic training education.Athletic Training Education Journal,12(3),195-201.
  46. Gillispie, V.(2016).Using the flipped classroom to bridge the gap to generation Y.The Ochsner Journal,16(1),32-36.
  47. Glaser, B. G.,Strauss, A. L.(2017).The discovery of grounded theory: Strategies for qualitative research.New York, NY:Routledge.
  48. Griffin, R.(2019).Fundamentals of management.Boston, MA:Cengage.
  49. Gunung, I. N.,Darma, I. K.(2019).Implementing the context, input, process, product (CIPP) evaluation model to measure the effectiveness of the implementation of teaching at Politeknik Negeri Bali (PNB).International Journal of Environmental and Science Education-IJESE,14(1),33-39.
  50. Hack, C.(2016).The benefits and barriers of using virtual worlds to engage healthcare professionals on distance learning programmes.Interactive Learning Environments,24(8),1836-1849.
  51. Hadad, Y.,Keren, B.,Naveh, G.(2020).The relative importance of teaching evaluation criteria from the points of view of students and faculty.Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education,45(3),447-459.
  52. Hennink, M. M.,Kaiser, B. N.,Marconi, V. C.(2017).Code saturation versus meaning saturation: How many interviews are enough?.Qualitative Health Research,27(4),591-608.
  53. Henson, K.(2003).Foundations for learner centered education: A knowledge base.Education,124,5-17.
  54. Hmelo-Silver, C.(2004).Problem-based learning: What and how do students learn?.Educational Psychology Review,16(3),235-266.
  55. Hussain, H.,Anwar, N.(2017).Effects of problem-based learning on students’ critical thinking skills, attitudes towards learning and achievement.Journal of Educational Research,20(2),28-41.
  56. Kawinkoonlasate, P.(2019).Integration in flipped classroom technology approach to develop English language skills of Thai EFL learners.English Language Teaching,12(11),23-34.
  57. Lee, B.(2017).TELL us ESP in a flipped classroom.Eurasia Journal of Mathematics, Science and Technology Education,13(8),4995-5007.
  58. Long, T.,Cummins, J.,Waugh, M.(2017).Use of the flipped classroom instructional model in higher education: Instructors’ perspectives.Journal of Computing in Higher Education,29(2),179-200.
  59. Love, B.,Hodge, A.,Corritore, C.,Ernst, D. C.(2015).Inquiry-based learning and the flipped classroom model.Primus,25(8),745-762.
  60. Lune, H.,Berg, B. L.(2017).Qualitative research methods for the social sciences.London, UK:Pearson.
  61. Macintyre, C.(2000).The art of action research in the classroom.New York, NY:Routledge.
  62. Marshall, B.,Cardon, P.,Poddar, A.,Fontenot, R.(2013).Does sample size matter in qualitative research? A review of qualitative interviews in IS research.Journal of Computer Information Systems,54(1),11-22.
  63. Maya, J.,Luesia, J. F.,Perez-Padilla, J.(2021).The relationship between learning styles and academic performance: Consistency among multiple assessment methods in psychology and education students.Sustainability,13(6),3341.
  64. McKernan, J.(1996).Curriculum action research.New York, NY:Kogan Page.
  65. McNiff, J.(2013).Action research: Principles and practice.New York, NY:Routledge.
  66. Meyer, O.,Coyle, D.,Halbach, A.,Schuck, K.,Ting, T.(2015).A pluriliteracies approach to content and language integrated learning-mapping learner progressions in knowledge construction and meaning-making.Language, Culture and Curriculum,28(1),41-57.
  67. Mohammed, H. J.,Daham, H. A.(2021).Analytic hierarchy process for evaluating flipped classroom learning.Computers, Materials & Continua,66(3),2229-2239.
  68. Moran, K.,Milsom, A.(2015).The flipped classroom in counselor education.Counselor Education and Supervision,54(1),32-43.
  69. Moraros, J.,Islam, A.,Yu, S.,Banow, R.,Schindelka, B.(2015).Flipping for success: Evaluating the effectiveness of a novel teaching approach in a graduate level setting.BMC Medical Education,15(1),1-10.
  70. Namaziandost, E.,Cakmak, F.(2020).An account of EFL learners’ self-efficacy and gender in the flipped classroom model.Education and Information Technologies,25(5),4041-4055.
  71. Nantha, C.,Pimdee, P.,Sitthiworachart, J.(2022).A quasi-experimental evaluation of classes using traditional methods, problem-based learning, and flipped learning to enhance Thai student-teacher problem-solving skills and academic achievement.International Journal of Emerging Technologies in Learning,17(14),20-38.
  72. Nja, C. O.,Orim, R. E.,Neji, H. A.,Ukwetang, J. O.,Uwe, U. E.,Ideba, M. A.(2022).Students’ attitude and academic achievement in a flipped classroom.Heliyon 2,8(1),1-14.
  73. Nynke de Jong, N.,van Rosmalen, P.,Brancaccio, M. T.,Bleijlevens, M. H.,Verbeek, H.,Peeters, I. G.(2022).Flipped classroom formats in a problem-based learning course: Experiences of first-year bachelor European public health students.Public Health Reviews,43(1604795),1-9.
  74. Olivan-Blazquez, B.,Aguilar-Latorre, A.,Gascon-Santos, S.,Gomez-Poyato, M. J.,Valero-Errazu, D.,Magallon-Botaya, R.,Porroche-Escudero, A.(2022).Comparing the use of flipped classroom in combination with problem-based learning or with case-based learning for improving academic performance and satisfaction.Active Learning in Higher Education,00(0),1-16.
  75. Pandit, N. R.(1996).The creation of theory: A recent application of the grounded theory method.The Qualitative Report,2(4),1-15.
  76. Park, J. E.(2017).A study of teaching methods on English literature using flipped learning and problem based learning.International Information Institute (Tokyo) Information,20(6B),4345-4354.
  77. Parkin, M.(2019).Economics.New York, NY:Pearson.
  78. Pollock, J. E.,Tolone, L. J.(2021).Improving student learning one teacher at a time.Alexandria, VA:ASCD.
  79. Rogal, S. M.,Snider, P. D.(2008).Rethinking the lecture: The application of problem-based learning methods to atypical contexts.Nurse Education in Practice,8(3),213-219.
  80. Roh, Y. S.,Kim, S.(2015).Integrating problem-based learning and simulation: Effects on student motivation and life skills.CIN: Computers, Informatics, Nursing,33(7),278-284.
  81. Saldana, J.(2021).The coding manual for qualitative researchers.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  82. Schon, D. A.(2017).The reflective practitioner: How professionals think in action.London, UK:Routledge.
  83. Schon, D. A.(1987).Educating the reflective practitioner: Toward a new design for teaching and learning in the professions.San Francisco, CA:Jossey-Bass.
  84. Schwandt, T.,Lincoln, Y.,Guba, E.(2007).Judging interpretations: But is it rigorous? Trustworthiness and authenticity in naturalistic evaluation.New Directions for Evaluation,114,11-25.
  85. Seibert, S. A.(2021).Problem-based learning: A strategy to foster generation Z’s critical thinking and perseverance.Teaching and Learning in Nursing,16(1),85-88.
  86. Senali, M. G.,Iranmanesh, M.,Ghobakhloo, M.,Gengatharen, D.,Tseng, M. L.,Nilsashi, M.(2022).Flipped classroom in business and entrepreneurship education: A systematic review and future research agenda.The International Journal of Management Education,20(1),1-18.
  87. Sim, J.,Wright, C.(2005).The kappa statistic in reliability studies: Use, interpretation, and sample size requirements.Physical Therapy,85(3),257-268.
  88. Singh, H.,Singh, C. K. S.,Mohtar, T. M. T.,Mostafa, N. A.(2017).A review of research on flipped classroom approach for teaching communication skills in English.International Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences,7(10),100-118.
  89. Soleymani, S.,Aliabadi, K.,Zaraii Zavaraki, I.,Delavar, A.(2022).Designing and validating a flipped learning pattern to enhance problem-based teaching in higher education instructors for teaching the English language.Journal of Modern Research in English Language Studies,9(3),73-100.
  90. Soleymani, S.,Aliabadi, K.,Zaraii Zavaraki, I.,Delavar, A.(2021).The effect of flipped learning pattern (FLP) in terms of problem-based teaching approach (PBTA) on applicants’ self-directed learning (SDL) towards the English courses.Journal of Foreign Language Teaching and Translation Studies,6(2),87-116.
  91. Stegall, J.(2021).Peaks and valleys: The lived experiences of international students within an English immersion program using the integrated skills approach.Journal of International Students,11(3),723-741.
  92. Strayer, J.(2012).How learning in an inverted classroom influences cooperation, innovation and task orientation.Learning Environments Research,15(2),171-193.
  93. Strelan, P.,Osborn, A.,Palmer, E.(2020).The flipped classroom: A meta-analysis of effects on student performance across disciplines and education levels.Educational Research Review,30,1-22.
  94. Stringer, E.(2014).Action research.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  95. Sugiono, S.(2021).Multiple assessment methods towards the improvement of students’ English language learning.International Journal of English Education and Linguistics (IJoEEL),3(2),90-97.
  96. Supriyono, Y.,Saputra, Y.,Dewi, N. S. N.(2020).English immersion program in EFL setting: A modified model, implementation, and effectiveness.Journal of English Education and Linguistics Studies,7(1),137-160.
  97. Tarnopolsky, O.(2013).Content-based instruction, CLIL, and immersion in teaching ESP at tertiary schools in non-English-speaking countries.Journal of ELT and Applied Linguistics,1(1),11-10.
  98. Tartwijk, J.,Brok, P.,Veldman, I.,Wubbels, T.(2009).Teachers’ practical knowledge about classroom management in multicultural classrooms.Teaching and Teacher Education,25(3),453-460.
  99. Thislethwaite, J.(2014).The stories we hear and the stories we tell.The Clinical Teacher,11(2),77-79.
  100. Thomson, J.,Anderson, K.,Haesler, E.,Barnard, A.,Glasgow, N.(2014).The learner’s perspective in GP teaching practices with multi-level learners: A qualitative study.BMC Medical Education,14(1),55-64.
  101. Tian, L.,Hennebry, M.(2016).Chinese learners’ perceptions towards teachers’ language use in lexical explanations: A comparison between Chinese-only and English-only instructions.System,63,77-88.
  102. Wang, A.,Xiao, R.,Zhang, C.,Yuan, L.,Lin, N.,Yan, L.,Liao, H.(2022).Effectiveness of a combined problem-based learning and flipped classroom teaching method in ophthalmic clinical skill training.BMC Medical Education,22(1),1-10.
  103. Webb, M.,Doman, E.(2016).Does the flipped classroom lead to increased gains on learning outcomes in ESL/EFL contexts?.CATESOL Journal,28(1),39-67.
  104. Weiner, I. B.(Ed.),Craighead, W. E.(Ed.)(2010).The corsini encyclopedia of psychology.Hoboken, NJ:John Wiley & Sons.
  105. Williams, M.,Moser, T.(2019).The art of coding and thematic exploration in qualitative research.International Management Review,15(1),45-55.
  106. Yin, R. K.(2018).Case study research and applications: Design and methods.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  107. Yurniwati, Y.,Utomo, E.(2020).Problem-based learning flipped classroom design for developing higher-order thinking skills during the COVID-19 pandemic in geometry domain.Journal of Physics: Conference Series,1663,1-6.
  108. Zadina, J.(2014).Multiple pathways to the student brain: Energizing and enhancing instruction.San Francisco, CA:John Wiley & Sons.
  109. Zainuddin, Z.,Halili, S. H.(2016).Flipped classroom research and trends from different fields of study.The International Review of Research in Open and Distributed Learning,17(3),313-340.
  110. 行政院國家發展委員會、教育部、行政院人事行政總處、考選部、考試院公務人員保障暨培訓委員會（ 2021 ）。 2030 雙語政策整體推動方案。 取自https://ws.ndc.gov.tw/Download.ashx?u=LzAwMS9hZG1pbmlzdHJhdG9yLzEwL3JlbGZpbGUvMC8xNDUzMi83NDBlMTY5Ny1lZmIwLTRjZGItYjYxMi03M2UzMTVhMTM5ZjIucGRm&n=MjAzMOmbmeiqnuaUv%2betli5wZGY%3d&icon=..pdf [National Development Council of the Executive Yuan, Ministry of Education, General of Personnel Administration of the Executive Yuan, Ministry of Examination, & Civil Service Protection and Training Commission of the Examination Yuan. (2021). The promotion plans of bilingual 2030 policy. Retrieved from https://ws.ndc.gov.tw/Download.ashx?u=LzAwMS9hZG1pbmlzdHJhdG9yLzEwL3JlbGZpbGUvMC8xNDUzMi83NDBlMTY5Ny1lZmIwLTRjZGItYjYxMi03M2UzMTVhMTM5ZjIucGRm&n=MjAzMOmbmeiqnuaUv%2betli5wZGY%3d&icon=..pdf]
  111. 吳清山, C. -S.(2002)。創意教學的重要理念與實施策略。臺灣教育，614，2-8。
  112. 林麗菊, L. -C.(2014)。用 EGAP 教學新思維，奠定學術英語力。托福季刊，5，2-4。
  113. 洪秀菊, H. -C.(2014).國際跨語言與文化.台北=Taipei:商鼎數位=Shinning Culture.
  114. 胡全威, C. -W.(2014)。全英語通識課程教學之困境與突破。全人教育集刊，1，137-156。
  115. 張芬芬, F. -F.(2010)。質性資料分析的五步驟：在抽象階梯上爬升。初等教育學刊，35，87-120。
  116. 教育部（2021）。大專校院學生雙語化學習計畫。取自 https://depart.moe.edu.tw/ED2200/News_Content.aspx?n=5E9ABCBC24AC1122&s=3DFEC1726D932EE7 [Ministry of Education. (2021). The program on bilingual education for students in college.Retrieved from https://depart.moe.edu.tw/ED2200/News_Content.aspx?n=5E9ABCBC24AC1122&s=3DFEC1726D932EE7]
  117. 陳超明, C. -M.(2014).語言管理：面對世界人才大戰的臺灣策略.台北=Taipei:聯經=Linking.
  118. 陳麗芳, L. -F.,蘇秀妹, X. -M.,游淑儀, S. -Y.(2011)。英聽課實施全英語教學之成效。長庚科技學刊，14，79-104。
  119. 黃政傑, J. -J.(2014)。翻轉教室的理念、問題與展望。臺灣教育評論月刊，3(12)，161-186。
  120. 甄曉蘭, H. -L.(2003).課程行動研究：實例與方法解析.台北=Taipei:師大書苑=Lucky Bookstore.
  121. 蔡清田, C. -T.(2013).行動研究新論.台北=Taipei:五南=Wu-Nan.
被引用次数
  1. (2024)。以ARCS動機模式進行國中資訊科技課程之雙語教學學習成效研究。教育實踐與研究，37(2)，79-117。
print cancel