應用Fuzzy AHP探討自行車旅遊產品選擇準則

Multi-Criteria Product Selection of Bike tour Event Using Fuzzy AHP

林濰榕(Wei-Rong Lin)；周弘奇(Hung-Chi Chou)；羅斯婷(Szu-Ting Luo)

自行車旅遊 ； 套裝旅遊產品 ； 修正德菲法 ； 模糊層級分析法 ； Bicycle tourism ； Package tourism products ； Modified Delphi Method(MDM) ； Fuzzy Analytical Hierarchy Process(FAHP)

觀光旅遊研究學刊

17卷1期（2022 / 06 / 01）

37 - 58

繁體中文

觀光局訂定2021年為自行車旅遊年，民眾也開始關注自行車旅遊產品。本研究目的在探討經驗車友與一般消費者在選購自行車旅遊產品時所考量的準則，並發展準則權重，以提供旅遊業者做為自行車遊程設計的參考指標。本研究首先以文獻回顧歸納整理出自行車旅遊產品選擇準則共42項，接著邀請自行車旅遊領域的11位專家進行共識篩選，並輔以訪談修正準則用詞及定義，而剩下24項準則。最後再以修正德菲法問卷進行最終共識確認，得到六個因素及24項準則。本研究將最終因素及準則設計成AHP問卷，以模糊層級分析法（FAHP）進行分析，探討經驗車友與一般消費者兩個客群在自行車旅遊產品選擇準則上之權重。研究結果顯示，經驗車友在整體層級串聯排序前五項準則依序為「團費合理」、「過去參團經驗」、「資訊完整」、「騎乘距離」及「親友推薦」；一般消費者在在整體層級串聯排序前五項準則依序為「團費合理」、「親友推薦」、「過去參團經驗」、「網路評語佳」及「資訊完整」。研究結果可為旅行社在未來設計自行車遊程上，提供客觀且符合市場需求的標準。

The Tourism Bureau set 2021 as the year of bicycle tourism, and people began to pay attention to bicycle tourism products. The purpose of this study is to explore the criteria for experienced riders and general consumers when purchasing bicycle tourism products, and develop guidelines to provide tourists as a reference index for bicycle travel design. In this study, the literature reviewed 42 standards for the choice of bicycle tourism product selection, and then invited 11 experts in the field of bicycle tourism to conduct consensus screening, supplemented by interviews to correct the standards and definitions, and 24 guidelines were left. Finally, the revised Delphi questionnaire was used for final consensus confirmation, and six factors and 24 criteria were obtained. In this study, the final factors and criteria are designed into an AHP questionnaire and analyzed by Fuzzy Analytical Hierarchy Process (FAHP) to explore the selection guidelines between the experienced riders and general consumers in the bicycle tourism products. The results show that the top five criteria of experienced riders are ＂reasonable tour fee＂, ＂past tour experience＂, ＂complete information＂, ＂riding distance＂ and ＂relatives and friends recommendation＂; The top five criteria for general consumers are ＂reasonable tour fee＂, ＂recommended by relatives and friends＂, ＂past experience in participating in tour groups＂, ＂good online comments＂ and ＂complete information＂. The results of the study can provide an objective and market-oriented standard for travel agencies in designing bicycle trips in the future.

1. Bitner, M. J.,Booms, B. H.(1981).Deregulation and the future of the US travel agent industry.Journal of Travel Research,20(2),2-7.
2. Chang, H. L.,Chang, H. W.(2009).Exploring recreational cyclists' environmental preferences and satisfaction: experimental study in Hsinchu technopolis.Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design,36(2),319-335.
3. Chen, C. F.,Chen, P. C.(2013).Estimating recreational cyclists’ preferences for bicycle routes–Evidence from Taiwan.Transport Policy,26,23-30.
4. Chou, C. C.,Liu, L. J.,Huang, S. F.,Yih, J. M.,Han, T. C.(2011).An evaluation of airline service quality using the fuzzy weighted SERVQUAL method.Applied Soft Computing,11(2),2117-2128.
5. Dannenberg, A. L.,Needle, S.,Mullady, D.,Kolodner, K. B.(1996).Predictors of injury among 1638 riders in a recreational long-distance bicycle tour: Cycle Across Maryland.The American journal of sports medicine,24(6),747-753.
6. Day, J.,Bobeva, M.(2005).A generic toolkit for the successful management of Delphi studies.Electronic Journal of Business Research Methods,3(2),103-116.
7. Donohoe HM, Needham RD(2009).Moving best practice forward: Delphi characteristics, advantages, potential problems, and solutions.Int J Tour Res,11(5),415-437.
8. Donohoe, H. M.,Needham, R. D.(2009).Moving best practice forward: Delphi characteristics, advantages, potential problems, and solutions.International Journal of Tourism Research,11(5),415-437.
9. Downward, P.,Lumsdon, L.(2001).The development of recreational cycle routes: An evaluation of user needs.Managing Leisure,6(1),50-60.
10. Fay, P.(1992).Oxygen relations of nitrogen fixation in cyanobacteria.Microbiological reviews,56(2),340-373.
11. Goodman, C. M.(1987).The Delphi technique: a critique.Journal of advanced nursing,12(6),729-734.
12. Han, H.,Meng, B.,Kim, W.(2017).Bike-traveling as a growing phenomenon: Role of attributes, value, satisfaction, desire, & gender in developing loyalty.Tourism Management,59,91-103.
13. Hinch, T.,Higham, J.(2001).Sport tourism: A framework for research.International Journal of Research,3,45-58.
14. Hsu, C. C.,Sandford, B. A.(2007).The Delphi technique: making sense of consensus.Practical assessment, research, and evaluation,12(1),10.
15. Kaplan, S.,Manca, F.,Nielsen, T. A. S.,Prato, C. G.(2015).Intentions to use bike-sharing for holiday cycling: An application of the Theory of Planned Behavior.Tourism Management,47,34-46.
16. Lang, J.(1994).Urban design: the American experience.John Wiley & Sons.
17. Liou, T. S.,Wang, M. J. J.(1992).Ranking fuzzy numbers with integral value.Fuzzy sets and systems,50(3),247-255.
18. Lumsdon, L.(2000).Transport and tourism: cycle tourism–a model for sustainable development?.Journal of Sustainable Tourism,8(5),361-377.
19. Macklon, A. E. S.,Lumsdon, D. G.,Sim, A.,McHardy, W. J.(1996).Phosphate fluxes, compartmentation and vacuolar speciation in root cortex cells of intact Agrostis capillaris seedlings: effect of non-toxic levels of aluminium.Journal of experimental botany,47(6),793-803.
20. Mapes, J.(2009).Pedaling revolution.Portland, OR:Portland State University.
21. Matzler, K.,Faullant, R.,Renzl, B.,Leiter, V.(2005).The relationship between personality traits (extraversion and neuroticism), emotions and customer self-satisfaction.Innovative Marketing,1(2),32-39.
22. McCarthy, J.(1960).Recursive functions of symbolic expressions and their computation by machine, part I.Communications of the ACM,3(4),184-195.
23. Middleton, V. T.,Fyall, A.,Morgan, M.,Ranchhod, A.(2009).Marketing in travel & tourism.Routledge.
24. Mullin, B. J.,Hardy, S.,Sutton, W.(2014).Sport marketing.Human Kinetics.
25. Murry, J. W., Jr.,Hammons, J. O.(1995).Delphi: A versatile methodology for conducting qualitative research.The review of higher education,18(4),423-436.
26. Pesses, M. W.(2010).Automobility, vélomobility, American mobility: An exploration of the bicycle tour.Mobilities,5(1),1-24.
27. Pine, B. J.,Gilmore, J. H.(1998).Welcome to the experience economy.Harvard Business Review,97-105.
28. Rejón-Guardia, F.,Alemany-Hormaeche, M.,García-Sastre, M. A.(2020).Ibiza dances to the rhythm of pedals: The motivations of mountain biking tourists competing in sporting events.Tourism Management Perspectives,36,100750.
29. Rejón-Guardia, F.,García-Sastre, M. A.,Alemany-Hormaeche, M.(2018).Motivationbased behaviour & latent class segmentation of cycling tourists: A study of the Balearic Islands.Tourism Economics,24(2),204-217.
30. Ritchie, B. W.(1998).Bicycle tourism in the South Island of New Zealand: planning & management issues.Tourism management,19(6),567-582.
31. Saaty, T. L.(1990).Decision making for leaders: the analytic hierarchy process for decisions in a complex world.RWS publications.
32. Schiefelbusch, M.,Jain, A.,Schäfer, T.,Müller, D.(2007).Transport and tourism: roadmap to integrated planning developing and assessing integrated travel chains.Journal of Transport Geography,15(2),94-103.
33. Simonsen, P.,Jorgenson, B.(1996).,Bornholm Research Centre.
34. Smith, S. L.(1994).The tourism product.Annals of tourism research,21(3),582-595.
35. Tsaur, S. H.,Lin, W. R.(2014).Selection criteria of an overseas travel intermediary for group package tours: application of fuzzy analytic hierarchy process.Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Research,38(3),283-303.
36. Von Bergner, N. M.,Lohmann, M.(2014).Future challenges for global tourism: A Delphi survey.Journal of Travel Research,53(4),420-432.
37. 中華民國交通部，(2020)。2021 自行車旅遊年跟喔熊騎遊台灣以 15 公里的速度體驗台灣之美。2020 年 11 月 28 日，摘自來源：https://pse.is/3kx3ch