邁向都會政府　北臺都會整合之分析

Toward a Metropolitan Government an Analysis of the Northern Taiwan Metropolitan Integration Program

10.30174/JSS.200712.0002

王佳煌(Chia-Huang Wang)

都會政府 ； 都會治理 ； 台北市 ； 府際論 ； metropolitan government ； metropolitan governance ； Taipei ； intergovernmentalism

國家與社會

3期（2007 / 12 / 01）

35 - 62

繁體中文

本文針對北臺都會的整合過程，探討北臺是否能以台北市爲中心，發展爲正式的都會政府或形成都會治理的架構。本文要探討的問題包括：北臺都會整合的過程如何？北臺都會整合的過程與西方或東亞各國的都會政府、都會治理不同？北臺都會整合發展成正式都會政府受到哪些限制？對立基於西方都會政府與都會治理的理論，北臺都會整合的特質有何理論意涵？本文最後提出兩項研究意涵。

This paper aims at the issue whether the Northern Taiwan Metropolitan Integration NTMI) will evolve into a full-fledged and institutionalized metropolitan government or a framework of metropolitan governance with Taipei City at the core? The research questions include: how has the NTMI been evolving? What are the differences and similarities of the NTMI in contrast to the Western cases and experiences? What factors have been enabling and constraining the institutionalization of a Northern Metropolitan Government or the framework of a Northern Metropolitan Governance? What contributions could the research of the NTMI make to the theory of metropolitan government and governance? Finally, two research implications are discussed at the end of the paper.

1. 陳立剛、李長晏(2003)。全球化治理－臺灣都會治理的困境與體制建構：地方政府跨區域合作探究。中國地方自治，56(2)，4-19。
   連結：
2. 北臺區域發展推動委員會網站
3. Barlow, M.(1992).Government and Governance: Metropolitan Developments in the United States, Britain, Australia and Canada.Nederlandse Geografische Studies,140,6-17.
4. Barlow, M.(1997).Administrative Systems and Metropolitan Regions.Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy,15(4),399-411.
5. Barlow, M.(1991).Metropolitan Government.London and New York:Routledge.
6. Brenner, N.(2002).Decoding the Newest `Metropolitan Regionalism` in the USA: A Critical Overview.Cities,19(1),3-21.
7. Clark, G.(2005).Cities, Regions, and Metropolitan Development Agencies.Local Economy,20(4),404-411.
8. Dostál, P.(2002).Development and Administration of Capital Cities and Metropolitan Areas: An Introduction.Acta Universitatis Carolinae, Geographica,37(2),3-15.
9. Friedmann, J. (Ed.)(1999).Urban and Regional Governance in the Asia Pacific.Vancouver:Institute of Asian Research, University of British Columbia.
10. Frisken, F.(2001).The Toronto story: Sober Reflections on Fifty Years of Experiments with Regional Governance.Journal of Urban Affairs,23(5),513-541.
11. Hamilton, D. K.(2004).The Government Centralization-Decentralization Debate in Metropolitan Areas.Review of Policy Research,21(5),663-680.
12. Hamilton, D.K.,Miller, D.Y.,Paytas, J.(2004).Exploring the Horizontal and Vertical Dimensions of the Governing of Metropolitan Regions.Urban Affairs Review,40(2),147-182.
13. Harpham, T.,Boateng, K. A.(1997).Urban Governance in Relation to the Operation of Urban Services in Developing Countries.Habitat International,21(1),65-77.
14. Jouve, B.,Lefévre, C. (Eds.)(2002).Local Power, Territory, and Institutions in European Metropolitan Regions.London and Portland:Frank Cass.
15. Kearns, A. J.(1992).Active Citizenship and Urban Governance.Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers,17,20-34.
16. Lane, J. E.(2002).The Economics of Metropolitan Policy-Making: Policy Convergence but Overall Cost Efficiency Differences Exist.International Journal of Organization Theory and Behavior,5(3),201-213.
17. Laquian, A. A.(2005).Beyond Metropolis: The Planning and Governance of Asia`s Mega-Uurban Regions.Washington, D.C.:Woodrow Wilson Center Press.
18. Laquian, A. A.(2005).Metropolitan Governance Reform in Asia.Public Administration and Development,25(4),307-315.
19. Lewis, P.G.(1998).Regionalism and Representation: Measuring and Assessing Representation in Metropolitan Planning Organization.Urban Affairs Review,33(6),839-853.
20. Mattoon, R. H.(1995).Can Alternative Forms of Governance Help Metropolitan Areas?.Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago Economic Perspectives,19(6),20-32.
21. McGee, T.G.(1998).Metropolitan Governments, Urban Planning and the Urban Poor in Asia: Lessons from the Past and Present.Regional Development Dialogue,9(4),1-20.
22. Morçöl, G.,Zimmermann, U.(2006).Metropolitan Governance and Business Improvement Districts.International Journal of Public Administration,29(1-3),5-29.
23. Norris, D.F.(2001).Whither Metropolitan Governance.Urban Affairs Review,36(4),532-550.
24. Phares, D.(2004).Metropolitan Governance without Metropolitan Government?.Aldershot:Ashgate.
25. Phelps, N. A.,Parsons, N.(2003).Edge Urban Geographies: Notes from the Margins of Europe`s Capital Cities.Urban Studies,40(9),1725-1749.
26. Pierre, J.(edited)(2000).Debating Governance.Oxford and New York:Oxford University Press.
27. Pierre, J.(edited)(1998).Partnerships in Urban Governance.New York:St. Martin`s Press.
28. Pugh, C.(1995).International Structural Adjustment and Its Sectoral and Spatial Impacts.Urban Studies,32(2),261-285.
29. Reese, L. A.(2004).Same Governance, Different Day: Does Metropolitan Reorganization Make a Difference?.Review of Policy Research,21(4),595-611.
30. Rothblatt, D. N.,Sancton, A. (Eds.)(1998).Metropolitan Governance Revisited: American/Canadian Intergovernmental Perspectives.Berkeley, California:Institute of Governmental Studies Press, University of California.
31. Sager, F.(2006).Metropolitan Institutions and Policy Coordination: The Integration of Land Use and Transport Policies in Swiss Urban Areas.Governance,18(2),227-256.
32. Sager, F.(2005).Policy Coordination in the European Metropolis: A Meta-Analysis.West European Politics,29(3),433-460.
33. Salet, W.,Thornley, A.,Kreukels, A. (Eds.)(2003).Metropolitan Governance and Spatial Planning: Comparative Case Studies of European City-Regions.London and New York:Spon Press.
34. Sancton, A.,D. N. Rothblatt (edited)(1998).Metropolitan Governance Revisited: American/Canadian Intergovernmental Perspectives.Berkeley, California:Institute of Governmental Studies Press, University of California.
35. Scott, A. J.(edited),Agnew, J.,Soja, E. W.,Storper, M.(2001).Global City-Regions: Trends, Theory, Policy.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
36. Sharpe, L. J. (Ed.)(1995).The Government of World Cities: The Future of the Metro Model.Chichester:John Wiley & Sons.
37. Smith, M. P.(2001).Transnational Urbanism: Locating Globalization.Malden, MA:Blackwell.
38. Stephens, G. R.,Wikstrom, N.(2000).Metropolitan Government and Governance: Theoretical Perspectives, Empirical Analysis, and the Future.New York and Oxford:Oxford University Press.
39. Togo, H.,L. J. Sharper(edited)(1995).The Government of World Cities: The Future of Metro Model.New York:John Wiley & Sons.
40. Wikstrom, N.(1997).Metropolitan Government and Governance: A Suggested Research Agenda.Regionalist,2(1),46-56.
41. Williams, G.(1999).Institutional Capacity and Metropolitan Governance: The Greater Toronto Area.Cities,16(3),171-180.
42. 孔憲法、紀俊臣編著(2006)。都市及區域治理。台北市:五南圖書出版有限公司。
43. 台北市都市發展局(2007)。北台相關資料。
44. 91年台鐵客運統計指標分析
45. 石文南、張力可(2003)。馬英九：中央放鴿子，欲哭無淚；九年來南港一直是首選，為何張景森到經建會後就改了，讓人懷疑政府拚經濟決心。中國時報(2003/02/21)。
46. 江大樹(2006)。邁向地方治理：議題、理論與實務。台北市:元照出版有限公司。
47. 紀俊臣(2005)。社會科學的研究新趨勢－都市治理的應用。社會科教育研究，10，23-42。
48. 紀俊臣編著(2006)。都市及區域治理。台北市:五南圖書出版有限公司。
49. 孫同文(2005)。全球化與都會治理：我國直轄市發展的評估。法政學報，18，49-87。
50. 張啓楷(2002)。中央刪預算，李應元戰馬包袱。中國時報(2002/05/30)。
51. 陳志平(2003)。南港經貿二館變卦，立委究責；1億元預算通過才2個月，經建會突然建議更改預定地，在野黨疑陰謀打馬。中時晚報(2003/02/20)。
52. 黃樹德(2007)。大台北合併，40年前老蔣曾同意。中國時報(2007/05/05)。
53. 趙揚清(2002)。地方政府財政赤字問題。國家政策論壇，2(3)，138-147。
54. 國政研究報告

1. 林文謙(2011)。全球環境治理與國內政治之互動：以ICCAI削減台灣大目鮪配額案為例。政治科學論叢，50，141-180。