個人社區意識的機制與地方政府的角色：微觀與中觀觀點的整合型模式

Sense of Community and Local Government-A Micro-Meso Perspective

10.30174/JSS.201112.0004

徐淑瑤(Shu-Yao Hsu)；李俊豪(Chun-Hao Li)

社區意識 ； 微觀取向 ； 中觀取向 ； 地方政府 ； sense of community ； micro-perspective ； meso-perspective ； local governance

國家與社會

11期（2011 / 12 / 01）

159 - 189

繁體中文

國內學術界與實務界於1990年代中期起積極投入社區研究與實務活動。學者多主張社區凝聚有助於社區發展活動的推展，繼之而起的研究則探討個人社區意識的影響因子或如何增進社區住民的凝聚力。然而，多數量化的社區意識實證研究以微觀取徑觀點為基礎，因此其研究結果無助於理解地方政府對於個人社區意識的形構所扮演的可能角色。研究者企圖透過本研究以中觀取徑觀點為基礎，建構可理解個人社區意識形構機制的概念性模式，並進而討論地方政府的可能角色。社會學者明確指出「社區」是個人與大社會（society）間的緩衝區；每個社區因其社區形構過程的差異性，由於人口組成份子不盡相同，而有其獨特之生命週期。爰此，社區不僅是一個居住的空間，其對於形構個人的社區態度與社區行為有決定性影響力；儘管是生活在同一都市中，社區調節大社會對個人身心狀態之影響力，都市居民因此不必然發展出相同的社區意識或社區行為。藉由整理相關文獻，研究者將建立解釋形構個人社區意識的整合的概念性模式，其中討論社區脈絡（contexts）對個人社區意識形構之影響效果。針對社區脈絡特徵的直接影響與調節效果的討論不僅可檢驗社區因子的重要性，研究者可進而分析地方政府可能扮演的角色，甚至可對地方政府提出政策性建議，以協助社區居民發展社區意識。因此本研究的重要性有二，首先，在學術研究上將提供後續社區意識研究一個概念性研究架構，其次，做為探討地方政府在形塑個人社區意識上所扮演的角色，並對地方政府提出政策性建議的工具。

The cohesion of communities has been a major national concern in Taiwan since the mid-1990s. Scholars have been involved in community research and activities. Local community research in the past, however, was limited theoretically and empirically. Most research has frequently relied on the micro-perspective to identify factors facilitating community cohesion. These studies, however, are powerless in figuring out the role local governments playing. The intention of the present study is to construct an integrated theoretical framework relying on both the micro and the meso perspectives to understand how local governments can perform to facilitate personal psychological sense of community.The community research of the micro-perspective examines individual factors which influence personal psychological sense of community, but ignores the importance of communities. Local communities reflect their ecological, normative and institutional variables. Additionally, because of the characteristics of local communities, inhabitants might develop specific attitudes and patterns of social behaviors toward their local communities. Therefore, the meso-perspective suggests community contexts can explain the differential personal attitudes and behaviors toward their communities. Further, identifying community contexts that facilitate personal psychological sense of community is meaningful to understand the role of local governments playing in promoting community/neighborhood cohesion. To surmise, the importance of the present study is twofold. First, it proposes an integrated theoretical framework. Second, it will help understand the role of local governments playing. It further will help local governments develop strategic plans to facilitate community cohesion and personal psychological sense of community.

1. 李俊豪(2010)。台灣居民之社區意識─系統模式之分析。都市與計劃，37(2)，209-231。
   連結：
2. 郭瑞坤、王春勝(2004)。地區發展相關因素整合居民結構區隔研究。戶外遊憩研究，17(1)，23-49。
   連結：
3. 黃源協、蕭文高、劉素珍(2007)。社區意識及其影響因素之探索性研究。社會政策與社會工作學刊，11(2)，1-33。
   連結：
4. Wirth, L.(1938). "Urbanism as a Way of Life." American Journal of Sociology, 44(1):3-24.
5. Park, R. E.(1925). "The City, Suggestions for the Investigation of Human Behavior in the urban environment." Pp.1-45 in R. E. Park, E. W. Burgess, and R. D. McKenzie (eds.), The City. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
6. Ahlbrandt, R. S.(1984).Neighborhoods, People and Community.New York:Plenum Press.
7. Arcidiacono, C.,Procentese, F.(2005).Distinctiveness and Sense of Community in the Historical Center of Naples: A Piece of Participatory Action Research.Journal of Community Psychology,25(6),631-638.
8. Axelrod, M.(1956).Urban Structure and Social Participation.American Sociological Review,21(1),13-18.
9. Brehm, J. M.,Eisenhauer, B. W.,Krannich, R. S.(2004).Dimensions of Community Attachment and Their Relationship to Well-Being in the Amenity-Rich Rural West.Rural Sociology,69(3),405-429.
10. Brooks-Cunn, J.,Duncan, G. J.,Klebanov, P. K.,Sealand, N.(1993).Do Neighborhoods Influence Child and Adolescent Development?.American Journal of Sociology,99(2),353-395.
11. Buckner, J. C.(1988).The Development of an Instrument to Measure Neighborhood Cohesion.American Journal of Community Psychology,16(6),771-791.
12. Buttel, F. H.,Martinson, O. B.,Wilkening, E. A.(1979).Size of Place and Community Attachment: A Reconsideration.Social indicators Research,6(4),475-485.
13. Cantillon, D.,Davidson, W. S.,Schweitzer, J. H.(2003).Measuring Community Social Organization: Sense of Community as a Mediator in Social Disorganization Theory.Journal of Criminal Justice,31(4),321-339.
14. Chavis, D. M.,Hogge, J. H.,McMillan, D. W.,Wandersman, A.(1986).Sense of Community through Brunswik's Lens: A First Look.Journal of Community Psychology,14(1),24-40.
15. Chavis, D. M.,Wandersman, A.(1990).Sense of Community in the Urban Environment: A Catalyst for Participation and Community Development.American Journal of Community Psychology,18(1),55-81.
16. Colombo, M.,Mosso, C.,De Piccoli, N.(2001).Sense of Community and Participation in Urban Contexts.Journal of Community and Applied Social Psychology,11(6),457-464.
17. Darian-Smith, E.(1993).Neighborhood Watch-Who Watches Whom? Reinterpreting the Concept of Neighborhood.Human Organization,52(1),83-88.
18. Durkheim, E.,Halls, W. D.(trans.)(1984).The Division of Labor in Society.New York:Free Press.
19. Farrell, S. J.,Aubry, T.,Coulombe, D.(2004).Neighborhoods and Neighbors: Do They Contribute to Personal Well-being?.Journal of Community Psychology,32(1),9-25.
20. Fisher, A. T.(ed.),Sonn, C. C.(ed.),Bishop, B. J.(ed.)(2002).Psychological Sense of Community.New York:Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers.
21. Gans, H. J.(1968).People and Plans: Essays on Urban Problems and Solution.New York:Basic Books, Inc..
22. Glynn, T. J.(1986).Neighborhood and Sense of Community.Journal of Community Psychology,14(4),341-352.
23. Glynn, T. J.(1981).Psychological Sense of Community: Measurement and Application.Human Relations,34(9),789-818.
24. Gottdiener, Mark,Hutchson, Ray(2006).The New Urban Sociology (3rd edition).Boulder, Colorado:Westview Press.
25. Goudy, W. J.(1982).Further Consideration on Indicators of Community Attachment.Social indicators Research,11(2),181-192.
26. Greer, S.(1972).The Urbane View, Life and Politics in Metropolitan America.New York:Oxford University Press.
27. Greer, S.(1962).The Emerging City, Myth and Reality.New York:Free Press.
28. Hill, J. L.(1996).Psychological Sense of Community: Suggestions for Future Research.Journal of Community Psychology,24(4),431-438.
29. Kasarda, J. D.,Janowitz, M.(1974).Community Attachment in Mass Society.American Sociological Review,39(3),328-339.
30. Li, Chun-Hao,Hsu, Ping-Hsiang,Chang, Ying-Hwa(2009).Psychological Sense of Community among Urban Inhabitants: The Explanations of the Systemic Model and the Residential Environment.Symposium of Globalization, Urban and Housing Research,Hualian, Taiwan:
31. Logan, J.,Molotch, H.(1987).Urban Fortunes: The Political Economy of Place.Berkeley:University of California Press.
32. Loomis, C. P.(ed.)(1957).Community and Society.East Lansing, MI:Michigan State University.
33. McMillan, D. W.(1996).Sense of Community.Journal of Community Psychology,24(4),315-325.
34. McMillan, D. W.,Chavis, D. M.(1986).Sense of Community: A Definition and Theory.American Journal of Community Psychology,14(1),6-23.
35. Obst, P.,Smith, S. G.,Zinkiewicz, L.(2002).An Exploration of Sense of Community, Part 3: Dimensions and Predictors of Psychological Sense of Community in Geographic Communities.Journal of Community Psychology,30(1),119-133.
36. Plas, J. M.,Lewis, S. E.(1996).Environmental Factors and Sense of Community in a Planned Town.American Journal of Community Psychology,24(1),109-143.
37. Prezza, M.,Amici, M.,Roberti, T.,Tedeschi, G.(2001).Sense of Community Referred to the Whole Town: Its Relations with Neighboring, Loneliness, Life Satisfaction and Area of Residence.Journal of Community Psychology,29(1),29-52.
38. Robison, D.,Wilkinson, D.(1995).Sense of Community in a Remote Mining Town: Validating a Neighborhood Cohesion Scale.American Journal of Community Psychology,23(1),137-148.
39. Sampson, R. J.(1991).Linking the Micor-and Macrolevel Dimensions of Community Social Organization.Social Forces,70(1),43-64.
40. Sampson, R. J.(1988).Local Friendship Ties and Community Attachment in Mass Society: A Multilevel Systemic Model.American Sociological Review,53(5),766-779.
41. Sampson, R. J.,Groves, W. B.(1989).Community Structure and Crime: Testing Social-Disorganization Theory.American Journal of Sociology,94(4),774-802.
42. Sarason, S. B.(1974).The Psychological Sense of Community: Prospects for Community Psychology.San Francisco, CA:Jossey Bass.
43. Schulberg, H. G.(ed.),Killilea, M.(ed.)(1982).The Modern Practice of Community Mental Health.San Francisco, CA:Jossey Bass.
44. Schweitzer, J. H.,Rosenbaum, R.,Campo, S.,Gardi, J.(2002).Home Projects: Families and Communities Together Coalition(FACT)Home Projects: Families and Communities Together Coalition(FACT),East Lansing, MI:Michigan State University.
45. Skjæveland, O.,Gärling, T.,Mæland, J.(1996).A Multidimensional Measure of Neighboring.American Journal of Community Psychology,24(3),413-435.
46. Taylor, R. B.,Covington, J.(1993).Community Structural Change and Fear of Crime.Social Problems,40(3),374-395.
47. Theodori, G. L.(2004).Exploring the Association between Length of Residence and Community Attachment: A Research Note.Southern Rural Sociology,20(1),107-122.
48. Theodori, G. L.,Luloff, A. E.(2000).Urbanization and Community Attachment in Rural Areas.Society & Natural Resources,13(5),399-420.
49. Tittle, C. R.(1989).Influences on Urbanism: A Test of Predictions from Three Perspectives.Social Problems,36(3),270-288.
50. Unger, D. G.,Wandersman, A.(1985).Neighboring and Its Role in Block Organizations: An Exploratory Report.American Journal of Community Psychology,11(3),291-300.
51. Warner, B. D.,Pierce, G. L.(1993).Reexamining Social Disorganization Theory Using Calls to the Police as a Measure of Crime.Criminology,31(4),493-517.
52. Wasserman, I. M.(1982).Size of Place in Relation to Community Attachment and Satisfaction with Community Services.Social Indicators Research,11(4),421-436.
53. Wilensky, H. L.(1961).Orderly Careers and Social Participation: The Impact of Work History on Social Integration in the Middle Mass.American Sociological Review,26(4),521-539.
54. Wolff, Kurt H.(ed.)(1950).The Sociology of Georg Simmel.Glencoe, IL:Free Press.
55. 朱美珍(1995)。由人力資源網絡論社區意識的凝聚。社區發展季刊，69，69-74。
56. 李永展、馬立文(1996)。臺北縣市居民社區意識及環境認知之探討。台灣土地金融季刊，33(1)，75-89。
57. 李俊豪(2009)。影響台灣鄉村居民社區意識之機制。第四屆全球化與政治國際學術研討會，台灣，桃園:
58. 李增祿(1995)。論社區意識、社會建設與國家發展。社區發展季刊，69，21-24。
59. 林瑞欽(1995)。「社區意識」凝聚之道。社會福利，118，8-17。
60. 徐震(1995)。論社區意識與社區發展。社會建設，90，4-12。
61. 郭瑞坤、王春勝、陳香利(2007)。居民社區培力與社會資本、社區意識關聯性之研究─以高雄市港口社區為例。公共事務評論，8(2)，97-129。
62. 陳東升(1995)。金權城市：地方派系、財團與台北都會發展的社會學分析。台北市:巨流圖書。
63. 黃富順(1994)。加強社區意識，建立祥和社會的途徑。社會發展學刊，1，23-33。
64. 蔡祈賢(1996)。社區意識與社區發展。社會福利，124，21-26。