開放政府資料：一個系統性文獻探討的系統性文獻探討

Open Government Data: a Systematic Literature Review of Systematic Literature Review

高浩恩(Hao-En Kao)

開放政府資料 ； 系統性文獻探討 ； 開放政府 ； 開放資料 ； Open Government Data ； Systematic Literature Review ； Open Government ； Open Data

國家與社會

24期（2023 / 06 / 01）

1 - 66

繁體中文;英文

開放政府資料（Open Government Data, OGD）是一種哲學，近年來在各國也逐漸成為一種政策。從政府資訊自由（Freedom of Information）一路演變而來的開放政府資料，也在實務界與學術界逐漸受到重視。系統性文獻探討（Systematic Literature Review, SLR）作為研究方法的一種，在學術界運用在開放政府資料研究方法上，且有日漸增加的趨勢。本文正是運用系統性文獻探討的方式，檢視了2009～2021年的36篇對開放政府資料的相關文章，進行系統性文獻探討，並對這些文獻的主題、理論、結論與未來建議進行分類與整理。結果發現，開放政府資料的系統性文獻探討有逐年增加的趨勢，且相對於研討會論文，是以期刊論文為大宗。作者區域方面，以歐洲為最多，亞洲居次。主題而言，初期以整個OGD為主體的文獻探討為最多，後期針對OGD的細項分類文獻探討逐漸增加，並出現了許多關於OGD的困難／阻礙／挑戰與促進因素的探討。不過，開放政府資料中的系統性文獻探討，關於相關理論的應用與建立仍有待努力。再者，開放政府資料的系統性文獻探討的結論仍以分類與整理為主，找出窒礙難行的原因次之，提出次領域的研究發現再次之。最後，這些系統性文獻探討的未來建議，共有9種類型，其中以品質的提昇為主，其次則是加入市民的參與與對話，以及運用其他研究工具輔助。本文整理了過去已經發表過的開放政府資料系統性文獻探討文章，除了讓學者能夠瞭解過去已經進行過的研究，同時也提出了未來相關研究可以探索的方向。

Open Government Data(OGD) is a philosophy that has gradually become a policy in recent years. Following this line of Freedom of Information, OGD has received attention in both practice and academia. Systematic Literature Review (SLR), as one of the research methods, is increasingly used in OGD research. This study uses SLR as a research method, reviewing 36 articles from 2009 to 2021, focusing on articles related to SLR in open government data research and their topics, theories, conclusions, and future directions. The results reveal that OGD SLR research has more journal articles than conference articles. The authors were mostly from Europe, followed by Asia. On the research topic, the entire OGD was at the top of the list in the first few years, however, an increasing number of articles have highlighted the sub-categories of OGD and focused on the difficulties, obstacles, challenges, and facilitators more recently. Further, theories in related fields require more attention. Moreover, the conclusions are more of a categorization and arrangement of articles, followed by determining the reason for the aforementioned difficulty and the research results of the sub-fields. Finally, data quality improvement is one of the top recommendations in this research, followed by engaging citizen participation and dialogue and using other research methods. This research reviewed published OGD-related SLR articles, not only revealing past research conclusions and recommendations, but also identifying the future direction of OGD research.

1. Agostino, D.,Saliterer, I.,Steccolini, I.(2021).Digitalization, accounting and accountability: A literature review and reflections on Future Research in Public Services.Financial Accountability & Management,38(2),152-176.
2. Ali Hassan, M. I.,Twinomurinzi, H.(2018).A systematic literature re-view of open government data research: Challenges, opportunities and gaps.Open Innovations Conference (OI)
3. Assumpção, C. A.,Brega, J. R.(2021).A proposal for viewing Govern-ment open data information, based on user profiles.Computational Science and Its Applications - ICCSA
4. Attard, J.,Orlandi, F.,Scerri, S.,Auer, S.(2015).A systematic review of Open Government Data Initiatives.Government Information Quarterly,32(4),399-418.
5. Bachtiar, A.,Suhardi,Muhamad, W.(2020).Literature review of open government data.2020 International Conference on Information Tech-nology Systems and Innovation (ICITSI)
6. Baheer, B. A.,Lamas, D.,Sousa, S.(2020).A systematic literature review on existing Digital Government Architectures: State-of-the-art, challenges, and prospects.Administrative Sciences,10(2),25.
7. Bhattacharjee, S.,Yaghmaei, N.,Phuong, C. T.,Neupane, D.(2021).Fac-tors influencing the readiness to tackle the burden of ischaemic heart dis-ease in India: A systematic review protocol.BMJ Open,11(8)
8. Brandt, Baptista M,Vidotti, B.G.,Aparecida, S.,Segundo, S.,Eduardo, J.(2018).LEGISLATIVE LINKED OPEN DATA: a proposal of linked open data modelling for legislative information. Informacao & Sociedade-estu-dos.Campina Grande Pb: Univ Federal Campina Grande,28(2),149-161.
9. Charalabidis, Y.,Alexopoulos, C.,Loukis, E.(2016).A taxonomy of open gov-ernment data research areas and topics.Journal of Organizational Comput-ing and Electronic Commerce,26(1-2),41-63.
10. Crusoe, J.,Melin, U.(2018).Investigating open government data barriers.Lec-ture Notes in Computer Science
11. Dalenogare, L.G.C.,de Araujo, M.A.D.(2019).Theoretical approaches in open government data.Gestao & Tecnologia,19,5.
12. Danneels, L.,Viaene, S.,Van den Bergh, J.(2017).Open data platforms: Dis-cussing alternative knowledge epistemologies.Government Information Quarterly,34(3),365-378.
13. Danneels. L.(2016).Digital Business Innovation of Public Services.15th IFIP Electronic Government (EGOV) / 8th IFIP WG 8.5 International Confer-ence on Electronic Participation (ePart)
14. de Oliveira, E. F.,Silveira, M. S.(2018).Open government data in Brazil a systematic review of its uses and issues.Proceedings of the 19th Annual International Conference on Digital Government Research: Governance in the Data Age
15. Eberhardt, A.,Silveira, M. S.(2018).Show me the data!.Proceedings of the 19th Annual International Conference on Digital Government Research: Governance in the Data Age
16. Feitosa, D.,Dermeval, D.,Ávila, T.,Bittencourt, I. I.,Lóscio, B. F.,Isotani, S.(2018).A systematic review on the use of best practices for publish-ing Linked Data.Online Information Review,42(1),107-123.
17. Francey, A.,Mettler, T.(2021).The effects of open government data: Some stylised facts.Information Polity,26(3),273-288.
18. Gao, Y.,Janssen, M.,Zhang, C.(2021).Understanding the evolution of open government data research: Towards Open Data Sustainability and smart-ness.International Review of Administrative Sciences,002085232110099.
19. Gonzalez-Zapata, F.,Heeks, R.(2015).The multiple meanings of open govern-ment data: Understanding different stakeholders and their perspectives.Government Information Quarterly,32(4),441-452.
20. Haini, S. I.,Ab. Rahim, N. Z,Mohd. Zainuddin, N. M.,Ibrahim, R.(2020).Factors influencing the adoption of open government data in the Public Sector: A Systematic Literature Review.International Journal on Advanced Science, Engineering and Information Technology,10(2),611.
21. Haini, S. I.,Rahim, N. Z.,Zainuddin, N. M.(2019).Adoption of open govern-ment data in local government context.Proceedings of the 2019 5th Inter-national Conference on Computer and Technology Applications
22. Hossain, M. A.,Dwivedi, Y. K.,Rana, N. P.(2015).State-of-the-art in Open Data Research: Insights from existing literature and a research agenda.Journal of Organizational Computing and Electronic Commerce,26(1-2),14-40.
23. Huang, R.,Lai, T.,Zhou, L.(2017).Proposing a framework of barriers to open-ing government data in China.Library Hi Tech,35(3),421-438.
24. Khurshid, M. M.,Zakaria, N. H.,Rashid, A.,Ahmad, M. N.,Arfeen, M. I.,Faisal Shehzad, H. M.(2020).Modeling of open government data for public sector organizations using the potential theories and determinants—a systematic review.Informatics,7(3),24.
25. Krah, R. D.,Mertens, G.(2020).Transparency in local governments: Patterns and practices of twenty-first century.State and Local Government Review,52(3),200-213.
26. Lourenço, R. P.,Piotrowski, S.,Ingrams, A.(2017).Open Data Driven Public Accountability.Transforming Government: People, Process and Policy,11(1),42-57.
27. Mukti, I. Y.,Iacob, M. E.,Aldea, A.,Govindaraju, R.,van Hillegersberg, J.(2021).Defining rural smartness and its impact: A systematic literature review.Journal of the Knowledge Economy,13(2),956-1007.
28. Novais, T,de Albuquerque, J.P. ,Craveiro, G.S.(2013).An Account of Research on Open Government Data (2007-2012): A Systematic Literature Review.Electronic Government and Electronic Participation - Joint Pro-ceedings of Ongoing Research of IFIP EGOV and IFIP ePart 2020,Bonn:
29. Nugroho, R. P.,Zuiderwijk, A.,Janssen, M.,de Jong, M.(2015).A comparison of national open data policies: lessons learned.Transforming Government: People, Process and Policy,9(3),286-308.
30. OECD（n.d.）Open Government Data https://www.oecd.org/gov/digital-govern-ment/open-government-data.htm.
31. Purwanto, A.,Zuiderwijk, A.,Janssen, M.(2020).Citizen engagement with Open Government Data.Transforming Government: People, Process and Policy,14(1),1-30.
32. Purwanto, A.,Zuiderwijk, A.,Janssen, M.(2020).Citizen engagement with Open Government Data.International Journal of Electronic Government Research,16(3),1-25.
33. Roa, H. N.,Loza-Aguirre, E.,Flores, P.(2019).Open data policy-making: A review of the state-of-the-art and an emerging research agenda.2019 Sixth International Conference on EDemocracy & EGovernment (ICEDEG)
34. Ruijer, E. H. J. M.,Martinius, E.(2017).Researching the Democratic impact of Open Government Data: A systematic literature review.Information Pol-ity,22(4),233-250.
35. Safarov, I.,Meijer, A.,Grimmelikhuijsen, S.(2017).Utilization of open gov-ernment data: A systematic literature review of types, conditions, effects and users.Information Polity,22(1),1-24.
36. Saxena, S.(2017).Prospects of open government data (OGD) in facilitating the Economic Diversification of GCC Region.Information and Learning Sci-ence,118(5/6),214-234.
37. Saxena, S.(2018).Summarizing the decadal literature in Open Government Data (OGD) research: A systematic review.Foresight,20(6),648-664.
38. Shah, S. I.,Peristeras, V.,Magnisalis, I.(2021).DaLiF: A Data Lifecycle Framework for data-driven governments.Journal of Big Data,8(1)
39. Silva, PN,Pinheiro, MMK(2018).Metrics for Open Government Data.Revista Ibero-Americana de Ciência da Informação,11(1),314-332.
40. Šlibar, B.,Oreški, D.,Begičević Ređep, N.(2021).Importance of the open data assessment: An insight into the (META) Data Qual-ity Dimensions.SAGE Open,11(2),215824402110231.
41. Susha, I.,Johannesson, P.,Juell-Skielse, G.(2016).Open Data Research in the Nordic region: Towards a Scandinavian approach?.Lecture Notes in Com-puter Science
42. Syarif, A.,Salamat, M. A.,Syafari, R.(2019).A comparative analysis of open government data in several countries: The practices and Problems.Advances in Intelligent Systems and Computing
43. Tai, K.-T.(2021).Open government research over a decade: A systematic review.Government Information Quarterly,38(2),101566.
44. Virkar, S.,Viale Pereira, G.(2018).Exploring open data state-of-the-art: A re-view of the social, economic and political impacts.Lecture Notes in Com-puter Science
45. Warraich, N. F.,Rasool, T.,Sajid, M.(2019).Challenges to Use Open Govern-ment Data through the Citizens’ Lens: A Systematic Review.Journal of Political Studies,26(2)
46. Xiao, Y.,Watson, M.(2019).Guidance on Conducting a Systematic Literature Review.Journal of Planning Education and Research,39(1),93-112.
47. Yang, T.M.,Wu, Y.J.(2016).Examining the socio-technical determinants influ-encing government agencies’ open data publication: A study in Taiwan.Government Information Quarterly,33(3),378-392.
48. Zuiderwijk, A.,Helbig, N.,Gil-García, J. R.,Janssen, M.(2014).Innovation through open data: A review of the state-of-the-art and an emerging re-search agenda.Journal of Theoretical and Applied Electronic Commerce Research,9(2),I-XI.
49. Zuiderwijk, A.,Hinnant, C. C.(2019).Open data policy-making: A review of the state-of-the-art and an emerging research agenda.Information Polity,24(2),117-129.
50. 王慧瑜,葉明功(2018)。系統性回顧與統合分析方法概述。藥學雜誌，34(1)，21-26。