台灣主要報紙政治漫畫之分析：以2004年立委選舉期間為例

The Analysis of Political Comics in Taiwan's Major Newspapers: A Case of the 2004 Legislative Election

10.30075/TJER.201006.0002

鈕則勳(Tse-Hsun Niu)；莊伯仲(Po-Chung Chuang)

政治漫畫 ； 政治傳播 ； 競選傳播 ； 競選論述功能論 ； political comics ； political communication ； election campaign communication ； functional theory of political campaign discourse

選舉評論

8期（2010 / 06 / 01）

19 - 46

繁體中文

Based on the functional theory of political campaign discourse, this research attempts to explore the format and content of Taiwan's political comics. A systematic content analysis is designed to examine the message strategies of political comics during the period of the 2004 Legislative Election campaign. A total of 180 samples from 3 leading newspapers: the China Times, the United Daily, and the Liberty Times are analyzed. In sum, the findings demonstrate the three dailies differ regarding the use of negativity in political comic discourse to attack the ruling and opponent parties, which are highly reflective of perspective stands in political arena. Despite similar in the formats, political stands may play a striking role in the practice of the contents of indigenous political comics.

Based on the functional theory of political campaign discourse, this research attempts to explore the format and content of Taiwan's political comics. A systematic content analysis is designed to examine the message strategies of political comics during the period of the 2004 Legislative Election campaign. A total of 180 samples from 3 leading newspapers: the China Times, the United Daily, and the Liberty Times are analyzed. In sum, the findings demonstrate the three dailies differ regarding the use of negativity in political comic discourse to attack the ruling and opponent parties, which are highly reflective of perspective stands in political arena. Despite similar in the formats, political stands may play a striking role in the practice of the contents of indigenous political comics.

1. 吳志怡(2002)。女性政治人物媒體形象之政治漫畫分析。傳播與管理研究，2(1)，65-79。
   連結：
2. Benoit, W. L. (2001). Presidentia1 campaign rhetoric: Does it matter? Unpublished manuscript..
3. Benoit, W. L.(1999).Seeing spots: A functional analysis of presidential television advertising, 1952-1997.Westport, CT:Praeger.
4. Benoit, W. L.(2000).A functional analysis of political advertising across media, 1988.Communication Studies,51(3),274-295.
5. Benoit, W. L.,Airne, D.(2005).Political television advertising in campaign 2000.Communication Quarterly,53(4),473-92.
6. Benoit, W. L.,Airne, D.(2005).Issue ownership for non-presidential television spots.Communication Quarterly,53(4),493-503.
7. Benze, J. G.,Declercq, E. R.(1985).Content of television political spot ads for female candidates.Journalism Quarterly,62,278-283.
8. Brazeal, L. M.,Benoit, W. L.(2001).A functional analysis of congressional television spots,1986-2000.Communication Quarterly,49,436-454.
9. Denton, R. E.,Jr.(ed.)(1998).The 1996 presidential campaign: A Communication perspective.Westport, Conn:Praeger.
10. Desousa, M. A.,Medhurst, M. J.(1982).Political cartoons and American culture: Significant symbols of campaign 1980.Studies in Visual Communication,8(1),84-97.
11. Devlin, L. P.(1989).Contrasts in presidential campaign commercial of 1988.American Behavioral Scientist,32,389-414.
12. Diamond, E.,Bates, S.(1984).The spots: The rise of political advertising on television.Cambridge, MA:MIT Press.
13. Hansen, G. J.,Benoit, W. L.(2002).Presidential television advertising and public policy priorities, 1952-2000.Communication Studies,53(3),284-96.
14. Holsti, O. R.(1969).Content analysis for the social science and humanities.Reading, MA:Addison-Wesley.
15. James, K. E.,Hensel, P. J.(1991).Negative advertising: The malicious strain of comparative advertising.Journal of Advertising,20,53-69.
16. Jamieson, K. H.(1989).Context and the creation of meaning in the advertising of the 1988 presidential campaign.American Behavioral Scientist,32,415-424.
17. Johnson-Cartee, K. S.,Copeland, G. A.(1993).Negative political advertising: Coming of age.Hillsdale, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum.
18. Johnston, A.,White, A. B.(1994).Communication styles and female candidates: A study of the political advertising during the 1986 Senate elections.Journalism Quarterly,71,321-329.
19. Joslyn, R. A.(1980).The Content of political spot ads.Journalism Quarterly,57,92-98.
20. Kahn, K. F.,Kenney, P. J.(1999).The spectacle of U.S. Senate campaigns.Princeton, NJ:Princeton University Press.
21. Kaid, L. L.,Johnston, A.(1991).Negative versus positive television advertising in U.S. presidential campalgns 1960-1988.Journal of Communications,41,53-64.
22. Lee, C.,Benoit, W. L.(2004).A functional analysis of presidential television spots: A comparison of Korean and American Ads.Communication Quarterly,52(1),68-79.
23. Levine, M. A.(1995).Presidential campaigns and elections: Issues and images in the media Age.Itasca, IL:Peacock Publishers.
24. Payne, J. G.,Baukus, R. A.(1988).Trend analysis of the 1984 GOP senatorial spots.Political Communication and Persuasion,5,161-177.
25. Procter, D. E.,Schenck-Hamlin, W. J.(1996).Form and variations in negative political advertising.Communication Research Reports,13,147-159.
26. Streicher, H. W.(1973).The girls in the cartoons.Journal of Communication,1,123-129.
27. Wimmer, R. D.,Dominick, J. R.(1994).Mass media research: An introduction.Belmont, CA:Wadsorthing Company.
28. 許雯如(1996)。銘傳大學。
29. 程之行(1984)。評論寫作。台北:三民。
30. 歐陽瑜(1991)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。輔仁大學大眾傳播所。
31. 瀟湘文(2002)。漫畫研究。台北:五南。

1. (2020)。負面競選廣告設計之效果：議題／形象訴求、醜化對手之照片或漫畫與色調運用。傳播與社會學刊，51，141-198。