國小教科書評選規準制定過程與內涵之分析

An Analysis of the Content of and the Process Used to Establish Selection Criteria for Elementary School Textbooks in Taiwan

10.6481/JTR.201012.0001

賴光真(Kwang-Jen Lai)

教科書 ； 教科書評選 ； 評鑑規準 ； 評選規準 ； textbook ； textbook selection ； evaluation criteria ； selection criteria

教科書研究

3卷2期（2010 / 12 / 15）

1 - 25

繁體中文

本研究探討國內國民小學教科書評選規準的現況。研究發現，19所參與調查的學校，其教科書評選規準，無論在規準制訂與提供、規準結構、規準內容等方面，都仍有若干未盡合理完善之處，法規規範與評選規準的內容間存在差異，學校也未必能夠知覺這些問題缺失。依據研究發現，本研究對國民小學提出9項教科書評選規準的改進建議，亦建議學校或教育行政機關針對教科書評選規準（或整個教科書評選程序）實施系統檢視，獲取回饋資訊，以期發覺評選規準的現況與得失，開啟改善精進評選規準品質的契機。

This study seeks to understand the process currently used for developing textbook selection criteria for Taiwan's elementary schools and the content thereof. Nineteen elementary schools participated in the survey. The results show that some shortcomings exist in the textbook selection criteria used, including the development and provision of criteria, the criteria structure, and the criteria content. What's more, a number of discrepancies exist between textbook selection regulations and textbook selection criteria. In addition, the staff in elementary schools might be unaware of these shortcomings and discrepancies.Nine suggestions were made for the improvement of the elementary schools textbook selection criteria based on the findings of this study. Finally, suggestions regarding the implementation of systematic reviews of textbook selection criteria and the entire selection process were offered as reference to the elementary schools and educational authorities.

1. 黃曙東、蘇錦麗(2005)。後設評鑑研究：以2001 年大學校院實施自我評鑑計畫成果報告書為例。教育研究集刊，51(2)，31-65。
   連結：
2. Bichelmeyer, B. A. (2003). Checklist for formatting checklists. Retrieved July 15, 2010, from http:// www. wmich.edu/evalctr/checklists/cfc.pdf
3. Scriven, M. (2007). The logic and methodology of checklists. Retrieved July 15, 2010, from http://www.mich.edu/evalctr/checklists/papers/logic&methodology_oct05.pdf
4. Stufflebeam, D. L. (2000). Guidelines for developing evaluation checklists: The checklists development checklist(CDC). Retrieved July 15, 2010, from http://www.wmich.edu/evalctr/checklists/guidelines_cdc.pdf
5. Bailey, G. D.(1988).Guidelines for improving the textbook/material selection process.NASSP Bulletin,72(506),87-92.
6. Delaware State Department of Public Instruction(1987).State policy and guidelines for selecting textbooks and other instructional materials.Dover, DE:Delaware State Dept. of Public Instruction.
7. Dole, J. A.,Rogers, T.,Osborn, J. H.(1987).Improving the selection basal reading programs: A report of the textbook adoption guidelines project.Elementary School Journal,87(3),283-298.
8. Farr, R.,Tulley, M. A.,Powell, D.(1987).The evaluation and selection of basal readers.Elementary School Journal,87(3),267-281.
9. Guba, E. G.,Lincoln, Y. S.(1989).Fourth generation evaluation.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
10. Joint Committee on Standards for Educational Evaluation(1994).The program evaluation standards.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
11. Marshall, J. D.(1986).University of Texas. TX..
12. Ohio State Department of Education.(1983).Materials selection guidelines-minimum standards implementation series.Columbus, OH:Ohio State Dept. of Education.
13. Rice, G.,Rice, G. H., Jr.(1982).A selection guide for elementary social studies textbooks.Social Studies,73(2),61-67.
14. Senn, P. R.(1983).How to think about the new instructional technology and social science education: Making proper distinctions.The annual conference of the Social Science Education Consortium,Athens, GA:
15. 李麗娥(2003)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。新竹市，國立新竹師範學院進修暨推廣部教師在職進修國民教育研究所課程與教學班。
16. 曾火城(1996)。臺北市，國立臺灣師範大學教育研究所。
17. 游家政(1998)。從國小教科書的開放來看高中選書。教育新生活，1，4-13。
18. 黃政傑(1995)。國民小學教科書審查標準之研究。臺北市:國立臺灣師範大學教育研究中心。
19. 黃政傑(1994)。國民中小學教科書審定制度與審查標準之研究。臺北市:國立臺灣師範大學教育研究中心。
20. 賴光真(2006)。整合審查機制簡化學校教科書評選規準之研究。國立編譯館館刊，34(3)，3-12。
21. 賴光真(1999)。教科書評選規準的建構原則。教學新生活，4，12-15。
22. 賴光真(2007)。課程發展與設計講義。臺北市:東吳大學師資培育中心。
23. 賴光真(2009)。行政院國家科學委員會專題研究計畫行政院國家科學委員會專題研究計畫,臺北市:東吳大學師資培育中心。

1. (2024)。疫情影響教科書選書決策行為之研究。教育科學研究期刊，69(1)，35-68。