先秦道法之「心」的探究－從「自然心」到「自為心」的價值轉換

Pre-Qin Tao and Law on the ＂Mind＂ Study -From the value transformation on the ＂Instinct mind＂ into ＂Self advanced mind＂

郭梨華(Kuo, Li-Hua)

老子 ； 莊子 ； 黃老 ； 心 ； 自為 ； Laotzu ； Chuangtzu ； Yellow Emperor and Laotzu ； Mind ； Self advanced action

哲學論集

49期（2018 / 02 / 01）

105 - 130

繁體中文

道法之心，論述的是從道家「自然之心」，尤其是黃老道家道法論，以及《莊子》之心論的結合，以進至《韓非子》「自為」之心論。這一有關人心之論述，旨在探究如何從崇尚自然之「公心」，轉化為專注經驗、現實利益之「私心」。這一轉化的根源，就在價值或說崇尚之理念的差異所致；也是對「自然」之理解的本源義向現象義的發展使然。本文大致區分四個部分，首先是就《老子》之「心」言，論其「心」乃「容」、「公」之「自然心」；其次是就帛書《老子》乙本卷前古佚書論其「心」，已將「心」轉化為物之「自為」；再次是論《莊子》之「心」與「自為」之說；最後是以宗黃老之慎到之說、《韓非子》論「自為」轉化為「自利」；並藉由這四部分有關「自然」到「自為」的論述，窺見宗黃老之法家由「道」而「法」中，對於人心建構之轉換線索。

The mind of Tao and Law on its description is based on the Taoism ＂Instinct mind＂, especially on the theory of Yellow Emperor and Laotzu's Taoism, along associated with ＂Chuangtzu＂ his mind theory, furthermore advancing into ＂Hanfeitzu＂ ＂Self advanced action＂ on whose mind theory. This description is about the mind from human being. Its goal is focus from the nature admiration ＂Public interests mind＂ turns into specified experience, real world interests, ＂Private owned mind＂; the origin of the transformation. The difference is resulted from ideal or admiring value expression, meanwhile, the outcome on the concept of ＂Nature＂ was indeed from its metaphysical and original meaning into the individual and phenomenal meaning. On this study there are 4 topics, first is the ＂Mind＂ from the writing of ＂Laotzu＂, on its assumption ＂Mind＂ is for ＂Tolerance＂, ＂Public interests＂, as a ＂Instinct mind＂. Followed by the writing of ＂Laotzu＂ on the silk scroll, Scroll 2, the long missing writing material, from its content mentioned about ＂Mind＂, at that era, ＂Mind＂ had oriented into materialized ＂Self advanced action＂. The third topic ＂Mind＂ from the writing ＂Chuangtzu＂ the expression along with ＂Self advanced action＂, finally back to its derived from the Taoism of Yellow Emperor and Laotzu, Shengdao's theory, then ＂Hanfeitzu＂ assumed with ＂Self advanced action＂ into ＂Selfish profit＂. By studying on these 4 topics from ＂Natural instinct＂ to ＂Self advanced action＂ on their arguments in order to find out ＂Tao＂ and ＂Law＂ postulated by Yellow Emperor and Laozhu, later transformed into legalists concept, to fumble out the transformation between ＂Mind＂ from the establishment of human being and its later turnover clues.

1. 清郭慶藩(1995)。莊子集釋。北京:中華書局。
2. 王永祥、潘志鋒、惠吉興(2002)。燕昭先秦思想家：公孫龍、慎到、荀況研究。保定:河北大學出版社。
3. 王先慎(1998)。韓非子集解。北京:中華書局。
4. 王叔岷(1992)。先秦道法思想講稿。台北:中央研究院中國文哲研究所。
5. 任繼愈(1985)。老子新譯。上海:上海古籍出版社。
6. 阮廷焯撰輯(1980)。先秦諸子考佚。台北:鼎文書局。
7. 馬王堆漢墓帛書整理小組編(1976)。經法。北京:文物出版社。
8. 馬敘倫(1974)。老子校詁。北京:中華書局。
9. 高明(1996)。帛書老子校注。北京:中華書局。
10. 國家文物局古文獻研究室編(1980)。馬王堆漢墓帛書。北京:文物出版社。
11. 郭梨華(2015)。《老子》的容、公思想及其影響。道家文化研究，北京:
12. 郭梨華(2012)。老、莊「無為」意義探析。第三屆海峽兩岸國學論壇：道家研究―學術．信仰．生活，廈門:
13. 郭梨華(2008)。道家思想開展中的關鍵環節─《管子》「心─氣」哲學探究。文史哲，2008(5)，62。
14. 陳啟天(1994)。增訂韓非子校釋。台北:台灣商務印書館。
15. 陳鼓應(1999)。莊子今註今譯。台北:台灣商務印書館。
16. 陳鼓應(1995)。黃帝四經今註今譯。台北:台灣商務印書館。
17. 馮友蘭(1991)。中國哲學史新編。台北:藍燈文化事業股份有限公司。
18. 劉笑敢(1988)。莊子哲學及其演變。北京:中國社會科學出版社。
19. 劉榮賢(2004)。莊子外雜篇研究。台北:聯經出版事業股份有限公司。
20. 樓宇烈校釋(1981)。老子周易王弼注校釋。台北:華正書局。
21. 蔣錫昌注(1980)。老子校詁。台北:東昇文化事業有限公司。