乾嘉閨秀的才名意識與文化轉型：以駱綺蘭為中心

Women Writers' Consciousness of Talent and Fame During the Qian-Jia Reigns and Cultural Transition

趙厚均(Zhao Hou-jun)

才名意識 ； 閨秀文化 ； 駱綺蘭 ； 歸懋儀 ； 汪端 ； 吳藻 ； talent and fame ； women's writing culture ； Luo Qilan ； Gui Maoyi ； Wang Duan ； Wu Zao

中正漢學研究

32期（2018 / 12 / 01）

143 - 160

繁體中文

經過明末清初的才德之辨，閨秀文學發展到乾嘉時期，進入了一個新的階段。此期的閨秀有著更強的才名意識，她們充分運用文壇領袖所掌握的文化權力，通過拜師等舉措拓展交往空間，從而與著名文人唱和、題贈，躋身文壇，顯揚聲名。駱綺蘭通過結交袁枚、王文治和王昶等，以畫作、詩集遍求題贈，並編選《聽秋軒贈言》和《聽秋軒閨中同人集》，得以聲名鵲起；歸懋儀在乾嘉文人與閨秀之間構築了一個非常龐大的交游網絡，她執著於詩史留名的願望，成功藉助男性文人的資助，令詩稿付梓，並憑藉才名遊走於江浙間擔任閨塾師，承擔起養家的重任；汪端則欲通過選詩修史來達到不朽，其《元明逸史》的撰寫和詩集中大量的詠史詩，可見其修史的努力，編選《明三十家詩選》更見其不凡的識見。吳藻創作雜劇《喬影》，並繪《飲酒讀騷圖》，體現出懷才不遇的苦悶和強烈的性別意識。總體而言，乾嘉閨秀已經不滿足于內闈狹小的空間，做出了跨越閨門的種種努力，是晚清民國閨秀文化近代轉型的先聲。

Following the debates on female talent during the late Ming and early Qing eras, women's literary production entered a new stage. Women poets who were active during the Qian-Jia reigns had a stronger sense of establishing their literary fame through making use of the cultural power held by the leading poets of their time. They became the female disciples of these leading figures, and expanded their networks by communicating and exchanging poetic works with larger communities of eminent literati. Luo Qilan, in particular, succeeded in achieving fame through her important connections, including Yuan Mei, Wang Wenzhi, and Wang Chang. She broadly solicited inscriptions for her paintings and collections of poetry, and published The Collection of Inscriptions for the Autumn Pavilion and The Anthology of Poetic Works by Friends of the Autumn Pavilion. Gui Maoyi, another well-connected woman poet, built a literary community that included both male and female poets. She obtained help from the male literati to publish her poetry collection, thereby realizing her ambition of establishing an undying literary reputation. At the same time, she turned her poetic talent into a means of providing for her family, travelling all over Jiangsu and Zhejiang provinces to teach in elite families. Other well-known examples included Wang Duan and Wu Zao. Wang revealed her ambition of authoring history in a broad array of works, including An Informal History of the Yuan and the Ming, Selected Works by Thirty Ming Poets, and numerous poetic works on historical events. Wu was best known for her variety play, A Shadow in Disguise, as well as for her painting, ＂Drinking Wine and Reading the Sorrow of Departure.＂ In these works Wu lamented her unfulfilled ambitions and the limitations of gender roles. In general, women poets of this time made all kinds of efforts to venture beyond the inner quarters and can be viewed as the pioneer of the modern transformation of women's writing culture during the late Qing and early Republican era.

1. 〔清〕王昶：《春融堂集》，續修四庫全書影印清嘉慶十二年（1807）塾南書舍刻本。
2. 〔清〕任兆麟輯：《吳中女士詩鈔》，清乾隆五十四年（1789）刻本。
3. 〔清〕汪啟淑：《擷芳集》，清乾隆五十九年（1794）飛鴻堂刻本。
4. 〔清〕汪端：《明三十家詩選》，清同治癸酉（1872）刻本。
5. 〔清〕汪端：《自然好學齋詩鈔》，清光緒十年（1884）刻本。
6. 〔清〕查為仁：《蓮坡詩話》，清乾隆刻本。
7. 〔清〕袁枚輯：《隨園女弟子詩選》，清嘉慶元年（1796）刻本。
8. 〔清〕陳文述：《頤道堂文鈔》，清嘉慶十二年（1807）刻道光增修本。
9. 〔清〕陳文述：《西泠閨詠》，清道光刻本。
10. 〔清〕惲珠：《國朝閨秀正始集》，清道光十一年（1831）紅香館刻本。
11. 〔清〕駱綺蘭：《聽秋軒閨中同人集》，清嘉慶元年（1796）句曲駱氏刻本。
12. 〔清〕駱綺蘭：《聽秋軒詩集》三卷，清乾隆六十年（1795）刻本。
13. 〔清〕駱綺蘭：《聽秋軒詩集》六卷，清嘉慶刻本。
14. 〔清〕駱綺蘭：《聽秋軒贈言》，清嘉慶刻本。
15. 〔清〕歸懋儀：《繡余續草》，南京圖書館藏稿本。
16. 方秀潔編、魏愛蓮編(2014)。跨越閨門：明清女性作家論。北京:北京大學出版社。
17. 包亞明譯(1997)。文化資本與社會煉金術—布爾迪厄訪談錄。上海:上海人民出版社。
18. 高彥頤(2005)。閨塾師—明末清初江南的才女文化。南京:江蘇人民出版社。
19. 崔琇景(2010)。乾嘉之際女性作家的文學交游關係及其意義—以駱綺蘭為例。蘇州大學學報，3
20. 張思夢、黃曉丹(2018)。清代女性著作編輯出版的支持網絡—以汪端〈明三十家詩選〉為例。蘇州科技大學學報，2
21. 趙厚均(2010)。王文治致駱綺蘭佚劄二十通考釋。古籍研究，上半年卷
22. 趙厚均(2008)。袁枚致駱綺蘭佚劄二十六通考釋。中國典籍與文化論叢，11
23. 劉詠聰(1998)。德．才．色．權—論中國古代女性。香港:麥田出版股份有限公司。
24. 錢東：《三朵花圖》，西泠印社拍賣有限公司「西泠2006 年秋季大型藝術品拍賣會」中的拍品，網路地址：http://www.xlysauc.com/auction5_det.php?ccid=223&id=30999&n=241（2018 年6 月16 日檢索）
25. 駱綺蘭：《三朵花圖》，上海泓盛2016 年秋季拍賣會「風姿綽約—歷代女畫家及女性題材專場」拍品，見http://www.hosane.com/hosane-site/auction/detail/1640002（2018 年6月15 日檢索）
26. 魏愛蓮(2016)。晚明以降才女的書寫、閱讀與旅行。上海:復旦大學出版社。
27. 蘇珊影(2016)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。上海，華東師範大學。

1. (2023)。女貞之歌：論駱綺蘭〈擬玉溪生燕臺四首〉對李商隱的承變及其意義。中國文學研究，56，207-251。