探索與重塑：大一年研究之文獻計量分析

Exploring and Reframing: A Bibliometric Analysis of First-Year Experience Studies in Taiwan

10.6360/TJGE.202306_(31).0002

吳明錡(Wu, Ming-Chi)；彭心儀(Peng, Hsinyi)

大學新生 ； 大一年 ； 學生轉銜 ； 大學入門 ； 新生專題 ； freshman ； first-year experience (FYE) ； student transition ； first-year seminar ； university 101 program

通識教育學刊

31期（2023 / 06 / 01）

35 - 76

繁體中文;英文

為了系統性回顧臺灣2000年以後與大一年相關研究成果，進而勾勒整體研究輪廓，本研究以收錄於華藝線上圖書館及Web of Science（WOS）資料庫之大一年相關期刊論文為範圍，排除灰色文獻後，共篩選出733篇論文進行分析。本研究系統性地建構大一年研究的發展樣貌，也指出後續研究方向，是國內少數以實徵研究文獻作為分析單位的原創研究。研究方法主要採文獻計量分析，探討大一年研究在臺灣的成長趨勢、主要研究機構及主要研究主題，據以了解大一年目前在臺灣之整體研究概況。研究發現在政策驅動下，雖然大一年研究有明顯成長的趨勢，但研究主題集中在通識教育、學院低年級必修課程、體育課程的學習動機、學習方法、學習成效與影響學生持續學習的關鍵因素，與國外關注的主題有明顯差異，且在研究方法與資料解讀的理論觀點上，亦待進一步擴充。本研究期藉此指引未來研究與實務創新方向，以有別以往的視角來深化問題意識，配合素養導向的教育創新趨勢，帶動可持續的研究熱潮，形成大一年教育與研究發展的跨領域實踐社群，也為通識教育的發展注入新的能量。

This study systematically reviews Taiwan's first-year experience (FYE) research since 2000 by examining 733 journal articles from the Airiti Library and Web of Science (WOS) databases, excluding grey literature. It provides a developmental profile of FYE research and suggests future directions, using empirical research literature as units of analysis. It uses bibliometric analysis to explore trends, prominent institutions, key themes, and co-occurrence patterns in FYE studies, illustrating the overall Taiwanese FYE landscape. This study found that, while there has been significant growth in FYE research under policy drivers, the research themes focused mainly on courses offered through general education (such as freshman Chinese and English class), motivation for learning in first- or second-year student-required courses, physical education, learning methods, learning effectiveness, and critical factors influencing student persistence, which differ significantly from the themes in other countries. Additionally, further expansion is needed in terms of research methods and theoretical perspectives on data interpretation. This study aims to provide insights for future research and inspire a sustainable research trend, forming an interdisciplinary community of practice for FYE education and research development in Taiwan.

1. 林從一(2014)。臺灣通識教育發展歷程。長庚人文社會學報，7(2)，191-253。
   連結：
2. Babbie, E.(2012).The practice of social research.Wadsworth.
3. Barefoot, B.(2005).Current institutional practices in the first college year.Challenging and supporting the first-year student: A handbook for improving the first year of college
4. Brubacher, J. S.,Rudy, W.(1997).Higher education in transition: A history of American colleges and universities.Transaction.
5. Council for the Advancement of Standards in Higher Education(2021).The CAS book of professional standards for higher education.ACT.
6. Creswell, J.,Poth, C.(2017).Qualitative inquiry and research design: Choosing among five approaches.Sage.
7. Feldman, R. S.(Ed.)(2017).The first year of college: Research, theory, and practice on improving the student experience and increasing retention.Cambridge University Press.
8. Gale, T.,Parker, S.(2012).Navigating change: A typology of student transitions in Australian higher education.Studies in Higher Education,39(5),734-753.
9. Gardner, J. N.(1986).The freshman year experience.College and University,61(4),261-274.
10. Greenfield, G. M.,Keup, J. R.,Gardner, J. N.(2013).Developing and sustaining successful first-year programs: A guide for practitioners.Jossey-Bass.
11. Gulley, N. Y. (Ed.)(2022).Multiple perspectives on college students: needs, challenges, and opportunities.Routledge.
12. Harvey, L.,Drew. S.,Smith, M.(2006).The first-year experience: A review of literature for the higher education academy.HEA.
13. Kift, S.(2015).A decade of transition pedagogy: A quantum leap in conceptualizing the first year experience.HERDSA Review of Higher Education,2,51-86.
14. Koch, A. K.,Gardner, J. N.(2014).A history of the first-year experience in the United States during the twentieth and twenty-first centuries: Past practices, current approaches, and future directions.The Saudi Journal of Higher Education,11,11-44.
15. Kuh, G. D.,O’Donnell, K.,Reed, S.(2013).Ensuring quality and taking high-impact practices to scale.Association of American Colleges and Universities.
16. Mayhew, M. J.,Rockenbach, A. B.,Bowman, N. A.,Seifert, T. A.,Wolniak, G. C.(2016).How college affects students: 21st century evidence that higher education works.Jossey-Bass.
17. Moher, D.,Liberati, A.,Tetzlaff, J.,Slymsn, D. G.(2009).Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analysis: The PRISMA statement.Annals of Internal Medicine,151(4),264-269.
18. National Resource Center for The First-Year Experience and Students in Transition. (n.d.). Our history. https://sc.edu/about/offices_and_divisions/national_resource_center/about/index.php
19. Nutt, D.,Calderon, D.(2009).National Resource Center for the First-Year Experience & Students in Transition.
20. Pascarella, E. T.,Terenzini, P. T.(2005).How college affects students.Jossey-Bass.
21. Pascarella, E. T.,Terenzini, P. T.(1991).How college affects students.Jossey-Bass.
22. Sanford, N.(1967).Where colleges fail: A study of the student as a person.Jossey-Bass.
23. Sanford, N. (Ed.)(1962).The American college.Wiley.
24. Thelin, J. R.(2019).History of American higher education.Johns Hopkins University Press.
25. Tight, M.(2019).Higher education research: The developing field.Bloomsbury Academic.
26. United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization. (2022). Beyond limits. New ways to reinvent higher education. https://www.whec2022.org/EN/homepage/Roadmap2030
27. Upcraft, M. L.(Ed.),Gardner, J. N.(Ed.)(1989).The freshman year experience: Helping students survive and succeed in college.Jossey-Bass.
28. Upcraft, M. L.(Ed.),Gardner, J. N.(Ed.),Barefoot, B. O.(Ed.)(2005).Challenging and supporting the first-year student: A handbook for improving the first year of college.Jossey-Bass.
29. Upcraft, M. L.,Gardner, J. N.(1989).The freshman year experience.Jossey-Bass.
30. Ward-Roof, J. A.(2010).Designing successful transitions: A guide for orienting students to college.University of South Carolina, National Resource Center for the First-Year Experience and Students in Transition.
31. Ward-Roof, J. A.,Guthrie, K. L.(2010).Reflections on the history and future of orientation, transition and retention programs.Designing successful transitions: A guide for orienting students to college
32. Yang, T.,Fu, H.,Hwang, G.,Yang, S.(2017).Development of an interactive mathematics learning system based on a two-tier test diagnostic and guiding strategy.Australasian Journal of Educational Technology,33(1),62-80.
33. Yorke, M.,Longden, B.(2007).,The Higher Education Academy.
34. 林博文（編）,江東亮（編）,黃榮村（編）(2018).臺灣校務研究實務.高等教育.
35. 國家發展委員會（無日期）。大專院校境外學生人數。國家發展委員會。 https://www.ndc.gov.tw/Content_List.aspx?n=80C3A12901E1F481
36. 康正男,黃國恩(2001)。我國大專校院體適能實施現況調查。臺大體育學報，4，101-113。
37. 張雪梅,彭森明(2009).台灣大學生的學習歷程與表現.國立臺灣師範大學教育評鑑與發展研究中心.
38. 教育部（無日期-b）。教學實踐研究計畫成果交流平台。https://tpr.moe.edu.tw/achievement/report
39. 教育部（2013 年 3 月 30 日）。大學協助高中優質精進計畫 101 學年度執行成果，高中大學攜手共創好品質。https://www.moe.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=9E7AC85F1954DDA8&sms=169B8E91BB75571F&s=4BE79F59B47652FD
40. 教育部（無日期-a）。素養導向高教學習創新計畫。https://xplorer.tw/
41. 陳昭珍（2020）。108 學年全國大一新生學習銜接與適應調查報告。https://rcs.ocu.edu.tw/var/file/24/1024/attach/60/pta_39564_4289631_77663.pdf
42. 陳婉琪（2022 年 7 月 25 日）。學習歷程做白工？大學教授：多數輿論只看到「選才」功能。翻轉教育。https://flipedu.parenting.com.tw/article/007504
43. 陳德華(2008).臺灣高等教育面面觀.文景.
44. 黃玉,劉若蘭,劉杏元,林至善,柯志堂,楊昌裕(2004)。教育部委託專案報告教育部委託專案報告,國立臺灣師範大學公民教育與活動領導學系。
45. 黃國恩,康正男(2000)。我國大專校院學生體適能護照之規劃與發展。大專體育，50，73-75。

1. (2024)。探索大一年之旅：國際眼中的臺灣。學生事務與輔導，63(1)，1-6。