國際安全機構對族群衝突的干預──制度化的研究途徑

International Security Institutions' Intervention in Ethnic Conflicts-An Institutionalized Approach

10.30114/CGJHSS.201110.0006

張棋炘(Chi-Shin Chang)

國際安全機構 ； 族群衝突 ； 衝突解決 ； 制度化 ； International Security Institution ； Ethnic Conflict ； Conflict Resolution ； Institutionalization

長庚人文社會學報

4卷2期（2011 / 10 / 01）

357 - 397

繁體中文

在冷戰期間，受到美、蘇對峙以及兩極體系結構牽制，「國際安全機構」──特別是聯合國──在衝突解決方面並無法發揮應有功能。在冷戰結束後，原有結構性束縛解除，國際安全機構的運作與功能重新回歸正常，甚至獲得了提昇，也更受到世人重視與期待。本文的目的首先要針對所謂的「國際安全機構」做概念以及理論方面的釐清及討論、檢視國際安全機構的制度作用，並進一步分析其在制度化解決族群衝突過程當中扮演的角色。本文主張國際安全機構干預族群衝突的乃是內部制度化轉型的結果；從另外一個角度來看，族群衝突的初步解決同時也反映了國際安全機構嘗試將衝突解決予以制度化的努力。

During the Cold War era, international security institutions, especially the United Nations, are restrained by the structure of the bipolar system and have limited effect in conflict resolution. After the Cold War, the operation of international security institutions is back to normal, even getting promoted. And the whole world is watching and deeply concerned about this change. First of all, the concept of “international security institutions” and theoretical analysis will be introduced. Secondly, the article will review the institutionalization process, and claims that intervention of ethnic conflicts is the result of the international security institutions' institutionalization and transformation. On the other hand, the intervention of ethnic conflicts shows the international security institutions are going to institutionalize conflict resolution as part of their conflict regulating procedures.

1. Bourtros, B.-G. (1995), Supplement to "An Agenda for Peace" : Position Paper of the Secretary-General on the Occasion of the Fiftieth Anniversary of the United Nations. Retrieved March 12, 2011, from http://www.un.org/Docs/SG/agsupp.html
2. Gallis, P. E. (1997), “NATO: Article V and Collective Defense,” CRS Report for Congress. Retrieved February 24, 2011, from http://www.fas.org/man/crs/97-717f.htm
3. Archer, C.(2001).International Organization.New York:Routledge.
4. Baldwin, D. A.(1993).Neorealism and Neoliberalism: The Contemporary Debate.New York:Columbia University Press.
5. Brooks, R. E.(2005).Failed States, or the State as Failure.The University of Chicago Law Review,72(4),1159-1196.
6. Caplan, R. D.(2005).International Governance of War-Torn Territories: Rule and Reconstruction.New York:Oxford University Press.
7. Claude, I. L.(1962).Power and International Relations.New York:Random.
8. Dayton, B. W.,Kriesberg, L.(2009).Conflict Transformation and Peacebuilding.New York:Routledge.
9. Doyle, M. W.,Sambanis, N.(2006).Making War and Building Peace.Princeton:Princeton University Press.
10. Galtung, J.(1996).Peace by Peaceful Means: Peace and Conflict, Development and Civilization.London:Sage.
11. Gordon, P. H.(1996).Recasting the Atlantic Alliance.Survival,38(1),32-57.
12. Gurr, T. R.(1993).Minorities at Risk: A Global View of Ethnopolitical Conflicts.Washington, D. C.:U.S. Institute of Peace.
13. Gurr, T. R.,Harff, B.(1994).Ethnic Conflict in World Politics.Boulder, Colo.:Westview Press.
14. Haftendorn, H.,Keohane, R. O.,Wallander, C.(1999).Imperfect Unions: Security Institutions over Time and Space.New York:Oxford University Press.
15. Helman, G. B.,Ratner, S. R.(1993).Saving Failed State.Foreign Policy,89,3-20.
16. Jervis, R.(1978).Cooperation under the Security Dilemma.World Politics,30(2),167-214.
17. Jervis, R.(1982).Security Regimes.International Organization,36(2),357-378.
18. Joseph, S. J.(1985).Cyprus: Ethnic Conflict and International Concern.New York:Peter Lang Publishing.
19. Kaufmann, C. D.(1996).Possible and Impossible Solutions to Ethnic Civil Wars.International Security,20(4),136-175.
20. Keohane, R. O.(1989).International Institutions and State Power.Boulder:Westview Press.
21. Keohane, R. O.(1998).International Institutions: Can Independence Work?.Foreign Policy,110,82-96.
22. Keohane, R. O.(2005).After Hegemony: Cooperation and Discord in the World Political Economy.Princeton, NJ:Princeton University Press.
23. Keohane, R. O.,Martin, L. L.(1995).The Promise of Institutionalist Theory.International Security,20(1),39-51.
24. Keohane, R. O.,Nye, Nye(1977).Power and Interdependence: World Politics in Transition.Mass.:Little, Brown.
25. Krasner, S. D.(1983).International Regimes.Ithaca:Cornell University Press.
26. Kydd, A.(2001).Trust Building, Trust Breaking: The Dilemma of NATO Enlargement.International Organization,55(4),801-828.
27. Leff, C. S.(1988).Conflict in Czechoslovakia: The Making and Remaking of a State, 1919-1987.Princeton:Princeton University Press.
28. Lobell, S. E.,Mauceri, P.(2004).Ethnic Conflict and International Politics.New York:Palgrave Macmillan.
29. Manogaran, C.(1987).Ethnic Conflict and Reconciliation in Sri Lanka.Honolulu:University of Hawaii.
30. Martin, P.,Brawley, M. R.(2000).Alliance Politics, Kosovo, and NATO' s War: Allied Force or Forced Allies?.New York:Palgrave.
31. Mearsheimer, J. J.(1990).Back to the Future: Instability in Europe after the Cold War.International Security,15(1),5-56.
32. Mearsheimer, J. J.(1995).The False Promise of International Institutions.International Security,19(3),5-49.
33. Miall, H.,Ramsbotham, O.,Woodhouse, T.(1999).Contemporary Conflict Resolution.Cambridge, UK:Polity Press.
34. Mitrany, D.(1975).The Functional Theory of Politics.New York:St. Martin' s Press.
35. Nolan, J. E.(1994).Global Engagement: Cooperation and Security in the 21st Century.Washington, D.C.:Brookings Institution.
36. Rittberger, V.(1990).International Regimes in East-West Politics.New York:Pinter Publishers.
37. Roberts, A.,Kingsbury, B.(1993).United Nations, Divided World.Oxford:Clarendon Press.
38. Ryan, S.(1990).Ethnic Conflict and International Relations.Brookfield, VT.:Dartmouth.
39. Schneckener, U.,Wolff, S.(2004).Managing and Settling Ethnic Conflict.London, UK:C Hurst and Co. Ltd..
40. Thies, W. J.(2009).Why NATO Endures.New York:Cambridge University Press.
41. Union of International Association(1987).Yearbook of International Organization.Munchen:K. G. Saur.
42. United Nations(2008).United Nations Peacekeeping Operations: Principles and Guidelines.New York:United Nations.
43. United Nations(1986).Everyone' s United Nations.New York:United Nations.
44. Wallensteen, P.(1997).International Intervention: New Norms in The Post-Cold War Era?.Uppsala, Sweden:Uppsala University.
45. Wallensteen, P.(2007).Understanding Conflict Resolution.London:Sage Publications Ltd..
46. Waltz, K. N.(1993).The Emerging Structure of International Politics.International Security,18(2),44-79.
47. Wolff, S.(2006).Ethnic Conflict: A Global Perspective.Oxford, N.Y.:Oxford University Press.
48. Woods, N.(1996).Explaining International Relations since 1945.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
49. 田野(2006)。國際關係中的制度選擇：一種交易成本的視角。上海:上海人民出版社。
50. 朱建民(1976)。國際組織新論。臺北:正中書局。
51. 李大中(1996)。北約之轉型：德國與大西洋兩岸秩序的重建。問題與研究，35(3)，65-80。
52. 周煦(1993)。聯合國與國際政治。臺北:黎明文化事業公司。
53. 周煦(2000)。聯合國集體安全與維持和平之演變。淡江人文社會學刊五十週年校慶特刊，143-191。
54. 林佾靜(2008)。失敗國家與國家安全。全球政治評論，24，121-158。
55. 保羅．肯尼迪、卿劼譯(2008)。聯合國：過去與未來。海口:海南出版社。
56. 唐永勝、徐棄郁(2004)。尋求複雜的平衡：國際安全機制與主權國家的參與。北京:世界知識出版社。
57. 徐能武(2008)。國際安全機制：理論與分析。北京:中國社會科學出版社。
58. 盛紅生(2006)。聯合國維持和平行動法律問題研究。北京:時事出版社。
59. 郭承天(1996)。國際建制與國際組織。臺北:時英出版社。
60. 楊永明(1997)。聯合國維持和平行動之發展：冷戰後國際安全的轉變。問題與研究，36(11)，23-40。
61. 楊光海(2010)。國際安全制度及其在東亞的實踐。北京:時事出版社。
62. 戴萬欽(2000)。聯合國邁入二十一世紀─維持世界和平之挑戰與機會。淡江人文社會學刊五十週年校慶特刊，193-234。
63. 蘇長和(2009)。全球公共問題與國際合作：一種制度的分析。上海:上海人民出版社。