論馬克佛森自由民主政治理論的形成與內涵

The Argumentation of Macpherson's Political Theory on Liberal Democracy

王之相(Chih-Shiang Wang)

馬克佛森 ； 歷史 ； 政治理論 ； C. B. Macpherson ； History ； Political Theory

長庚人文社會學報

9卷1期（2016 / 04 / 01）

87 - 114

繁體中文

馬克佛森對於自由民主的批判，是將其政治理論鑲嵌於比較的及歷史的架構下來進行，同時將過去、現在與未來勾串在同一個理念與政治經濟背景的互動辯證中來鋪陳其改革訴求，這樣的作法涉及馬克佛森於方法論上的獨特風格。本文選取馬克佛森若干實質論述，將方法論相關的部分整理分析，觀察馬克佛森如何將歷史意義、政治理論與邏輯問題納入其批判與建構之同一過程。此一以「歷史」為脈絡之政治理論方法論，仍可為今日政治理論者參考與反省。

C. B. Macpherson's criticism of the liberal-democratic theory is embedded in his comparative and historical way of argumentation, which connects pastand present to the possible desirable future with the dialectical interaction between ethical ideas and political economy. Such way of doing history reflects the unique characteristic of Macpherson's methodological style. This paper selects some substantial discussion of his theory, but focuses on the relevant methodological significance. The paper tries to show up how Macpherson takes history, theory and logic reconsiderations into the same process of theory criticism and theory building. Macpherson's ＂historical' restructure of political theory may be valuable and still critical to contemporary theorists.

1. Berry, C. J.(1986).Human Nature.London:MacMillan.
2. Crowley, R. W.(1969).A Comment on Professor Macpherson's Interpretation of Friedman's Capitalism and Freedom.Canadian Journal of Political Science,2(2),256-261.
3. Cunningham, F.(1987).Democratic Theory and Socialism.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
4. de Crespigny, A.(ed.),Minogus, K.(ed.)(1975).Contemporary Political Philosophers.New York:Dodd, Mead and Company.
5. Franco, P.(2004).Michael Oakeshott: An Introduction.New Haven:Yale University Press.
6. Gutting, G.(1999).Michel Foucault's Archaeology of Scientific Reason.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
7. Kukathas, C.,Pettit, P.(1990).Rawls: A Theory of Justice and its Critics.Cambridge:Polity Press.
8. Lindsay, P.(1996).Creative Individualism: the Democratic Vision of C. B. Macpherson.New York:State University of New York Press.
9. MacIntyre, A.(1976).On Democratic Theory: Essays in Retrieval by C. B. Macpherson.Canadian Journal of Philosophy,6(2),177-181.
10. Macpherson, C. B.(1969).Interpretation vs. Criticism: A Rejoinder to Professor Crowley.Canadian Journal of Political Science,2(3),356-358.
11. Macpherson, C. B.(1976).Humanistic Democracy and Elusive Marxism: A Response to Minogue and Svacek.Canadian Journal of Political Science,9(3),423-430.
12. Macpherson, C. B.(1989).The Political Theory of Possessive Individualism: Hobbes to Locke.New York:Oxford University Press.
13. Macpherson, C. B.(1987).The Rise and Fall of Economic Justice.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
14. Macpherson, C. B.(1990).The Life and Times of Liberal Democracy.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
15. Macpherson, C. B.(1972).Criticism of Concepts and the Concept of Criticism.Canadian Journal of Political Science,5(1),141-145.
16. Macpherson, C. B.(1990).Democratic Theory: Essays in Retrieval.Oxford:Clarendon Press.
17. Macpherson, C. B.(1966).The Real World of Democracy.New York:Oxford University Press.
18. Macpherson, C. B.(ed.)(1989).Property: Mainstream and Critical Positions.Buffalo:University of Toronto Press.
19. Marx, K.,McLellan, D.(ed.)(1977).Karl Marx: Selected Writings.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
20. Minogus, K.(1973).Humanist Democracy: The Political Thoughts of C. B. Macpherson.Canadian Journal of Political Science,9(3),377-394.
21. Sabine, G. H.(1973).A History of Political Theory.Chicago:Dryden Press.
22. Svacek, V.(1976).The Elusive Marxism of C. B. Macpherson.Canadian Journal of Political Science,9(3),395-422.
23. Wand, B.(1971).C. B. Macpherson's Conceptual Apparatus.Canadian Journal of Political Science,4(4),526-540.
24. 江宜樺(2000)。自由民主的理路。臺北:聯經出版事業股份有限公司。
25. 許國賢(1993)。馬克弗森。臺北:東大書局。
26. 許瓊斯、張明貴譯(2005)。現代政治思想史。臺北:五南圖書出版股份有限公司。
27. 摩爾、蕭純美譯(1992)。民主與獨裁的社會起源。臺北:遠流出版事業股份有限公司。