由族群研究到原住民族研究

From Ethnic Studies to Indigenous Studies

10.29910/TJIS.201103.0001

施正鋒(Cheng-Feng Shih)

族群研究 ； 原住民族研究 ； Ethnic Studies ； Indigenous Studies

台灣原住民族研究季刊

4卷1期（2011 / 03 / 01）

1 - 37

繁體中文

本文先由族群研究這個學術領域的發展著手，接著，把重點放在族群研究的課題，包括研究方法、研究領域、以及研究定位。再來，我們要探究原住民族研究的發展，包括行政組織、以及師資聘任兩個層面。最後，我們要討論原住民族研究在教學、研究、以及服務上的挑戰。

We start with the development of Ethnic Studies as an academic discipline and move to its focuses, including research methods, research areas, and self-identity. Secondly, we will look into how the field of Indigenous Studies ahs been developed over the years by scrutinizing two dimensions, administrative organization and recruitment of the faculty. Finally, we will discuss how we may face the challenges in teaching, research, and service.

1. Mutu, Margaret(2009).A History of Māori Studies at the University of Auckland, New Zealand.Taiwan Journal of Indigenous Studies,2(3),131-48.
   連結：
2. 王思為(2010)。Métis 族群意識建構在全球化下的挑戰。台灣國際研究季刊，6(1)，59-74。
   連結：
3. 范盛保(2010)。我是 Métis─族群意識與認同建構：從 1996 年談起。台灣國際研究季刊，6(1)，39-57。
   連結：
4. 謝國斌(2010)。從混血兒到原住民─加拿大梅蒂人之認同歷程。台灣國際研究季刊，6(1)，19-38。
   連結：
5. Nelson, Robert M., ed. 2010. “A Guide to Native American Studies Programs in the United States and Canada.” (http://oncampus.richmond.edu/faculty/ASAIL/guide/guide.html) (2010/4/17).
6. Australian Vice-Chancellor's Committee. n.d. “Indigenous Culture in Higher Education.” (http://www.universitiesaustralia.edu.au/documents/policies_programs/indigenous/Indigenous_culture_in_Higher-Education.pdf) (2010/4/17).
7. Wikipedia. 2010. “Disciplinary.” (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disciplinary) (2010/4/17)
8. D'Errico, Peter. n.d. “Native American Indian Studies: A Note on Names.”(http://www.umass.edu/legal/derrico/name.html) (2010/4/17).
9. Reilly, Michael P. J. 2008. “What is Māori Studies?” (http://eprintstetumu.otago.ac.nz/56/01/Reilly_1.pdf) (2010/4/17).
10. Reilly, Michael. 2008. “Ngā Tari Māori ki te Ao: Māori Studies in the World.” Keynote speech at the Te Kāhui Kura Māori (Schools of Māori Studies Assembly) held at Te Kawa a Māui, School of Māori Studies, Victoria University of Wellington (http://eprintstetumu. otago.ac.nz/64/01/Reilly_5.pdf) (2010/4/17).
11. Declaration on the Rights of Persons Belonging to National or Ethnic, Religious or Linguistic Minorities, 1992 (http://www.ohchr.org/Documents/Publications/GuideMinoritiesDeclarationen.pdf) (2010/4/18).
12. Aagaard, Kaare(ed.),Siune, Karen(ed.)(2002).The Design and Delivery of Inter- and Pluri- Disciplinary Research.Aarhus:Danish Institute for Studies in Research and Research Policy.
13. Adams, Bluford(2003).Reading the Re-Revival: Competing Approaches in US Ethnic Studies.American Literary History,15(2),396-408.
14. American Indian Higher Education Consortium(2000).Globalization of Tribal Colleges and Universities.Alexandria, Va.:American Indian Higher Education Consortium.
15. Anderson, Talmadge(ed.)(1990).Black Studies: Theory, Method, and Cultural Perspectives.Pullman, Wash.:Washington State University Press.
16. Aoudé, Ibrahim G.(ed.)(1999).The Ethnic Studies Story: Politics and Social Movement in Hawai'i: Essays in Honor of Marion Kelly,Mānoa:
17. Artibise, Alan F. J.(ed.)(1990).Interdisciplinary Approaches to Canadian Society: A Guide to the Literature.Montreal:McGill-Queen's University Press.
18. Baker, Brian(ed.),Mosupyoe, Boatamo(ed.),Muñoz, Robert, Jr.(ed.),Maeda, Wayne(ed.),Vega, Erid(ed.),Gregory(ed.)(2004).Introduction to Ethnic Studies.Dubuque, Ia.:Kendall/Hunt Publishing Co..
19. Banks, James A.(1997).Teaching Strategies for Ethnic Studies.Boston:Allyn & Bacon.
20. Banton, Michael(2001).Progress in Ethnic and Racial Studies.Ethnic and Racial Studies,24(2),173-94.
21. Banton, Michael(1967).Race Relations.New York:Basic Books.
22. Barlow, Andrew(1991).The Student Movement of the 1960s and the Politics of Race.Journal of Ethnic Studies,19(3),1-22.
23. Barot, Rohit(2006).Reflections on Michael Banton's Contribution to Race and Ethnic Studies.Ethnic and Racial Studies,29(5),785-96.
24. Bengelsdorf, Winnie(1972).Ethnic Studies in Higher Education: State of the Art and Bibliography.Washington, D.C.:American Association of State Colleges and Universities.
25. Bixler-Márquez, Dennis J.,Ortega, Carlos F.,Torres, Rosalía Solórzano,LaFarelle, Lorenzo G.(2001).Chicano Studies: Survey and Analysis.Dubuque, Ia.:Kendall/Hunt Publishing Co..
26. Blassingame, John W.(ed.)(1973).New Perspectives on Black Studies.Urbana:University of Illinois Press.
27. Brown, Patrcia K.(1979).The 1990s': Decade for Ethnic Studies?.History Teacher,12(3),359-71.
28. Bruun, Henrik,Hukkinen, Janne,Huutoniemi, Katri,Klein, Julie Thompson(2005).Promoting Interdisciplinary Research: The Case of the Academy of Finland.Helsinki:Academy of Finland.
29. Butler, Johnnella E.(ed.)(2001).Color-Line to Borderline: The Matrix of American Ethnic Studies.Seattle:University of Washington Press.
30. Capture, George Horse(ed.),Champagne, Duane(ed.),Jackson, Chandler C.(ed.)(2007).American Indian Nations: Yesterday, Today, and Tomorrow.Lanham, Md:Altamira Press.
31. Champagne, Duane(2007).In Search of Theory and Method in American Indian Studies.American Indian Studies,31(3),353-72.
32. Champagne, Duane(1996).American Indian Studies Is for Everyone.American Indian Studies,20(1),77-82.
33. Champagne, Duane(ed.),Stauss, Jay(ed.)(2002).Native American Studies in Higher Education: Models for Collaboration between Universities and Indigenous Nations.Walnut Creek, Calif.:Altamira Press.
34. Clarke, Anthony(1977).Ethnic Studies: Reflection and Re-Examination.Journal of Negro Education,46(2),124-32.
35. Cook-Lynn, Elizabeth(1991).The Radical Conscience in Native American Studies.Wicazo Sa Review,7(2),9-13.
36. Cook-Lynn, Elizabeth(1997).Who Stole American Indian Studies?.Wicazo Sa Review,12(1),9-28.
37. Cook-Lynn, Elizabeth(1999).American Indian Studies: An Overview.Wicazo Sa Review,14(2),14-24.
38. Corntassel, Jeff J.(2003).An Activist Posing as an Academic?.American Indian Quarterly,27(1-2),160-71.
39. Darder, Antonia(ed.),Torres, Rodolfo D.(ed.)(1998).The Latino Studies Reader: Culture, Economy and Society.Malden, Mass.:Blackwell Publishing.
40. Deloria, Vine, Jr.(1986).Indian Studies: The Orphan of Academia.Wicazo Sa Review,2(2),1-7.
41. Deloria, Vine, Jr.,Wilkins, Daivd E.(1999).Racial and Ethnic Studies, Political Science, and Midwifery.Wicazo Sa Review,14(2),67-76.
42. Dudgeon, Pat,Fielder, John(2006).Third Spaces within Tertiary Places: Indigenous Australian Studies.Journal of Community and Applied Social Psychology,16(5),396-409.
43. Duffié, Mary Katharine,Chavis, Ben(1997).American Indian Studies and Its Evolution in Academic.Social Science Journal,34(4),435-45.
44. Duran, Livie Isaro(ed.),Bernard, H. Russell(ed.)(1973).Introduction of Chicano Studies.New York:Macmillan.
45. Fixico(2006).Daily Life of Native Americans in the Twentieth Century.Westport, Conn.:Greenwood Press.
46. Foerster, Leona(1982).Moving from Ethnic Studies to Multicultural Education.Urban Review,14(2),121-26.
47. Ford, Nick Aaron(1973).Black Studies: Threat or Challenge?.Port Washington, N.Y.:Kennikat Press.
48. García, Eugene E.(ed.),Lomelí, Francisco A.(ed.),Ortiz(ed.)(1984).Chicano Studies: A Multidisciplinary Approach.New York:Teachers College Press, Columbia University.
49. Garza, Hisauro(1999).JSRI Occasional Paper, No. 58JSRI Occasional Paper, No. 58,未出版
50. Goldstein-Shirley, David(2002).American Ethnic Studies, or American Studies vs. Ethnic Studies?.American Quarterly,54(2),691-99.
51. Gollnick, Donna,Klassen, Frank H.,Yff, Joost(1976).Multicultural Education and Ethnic Studies in the United States.Washington, D.C.:American association of Colleges for Teacher Education.
52. Goodin, Robert E.(ed.),Klingemann, Hans-Dieter(ed.)(1996).A New Handbook of Political Science.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
53. Guyette, Susan,Heth, Charlotte(1985).Issues for the Future of American Indian Studies: A Needs Assessment and Program Guide.Los Angel:American Indian Studies Center, University of California.
54. Harrison, Spintz Stiles(2006).University of Arizona.
55. Hayes, Floyd W., III(ed.)(1992).A Turbulent Voyage: Readings in African American Studies.San Diego:Collegiate Press.
56. Heidenreich, C. Adrian(1991).Native American Studies: An Introduction.New York:McGraw-Hill.
57. Holt, Robert T.(ed.),Turner, John E.(ed.)(1970).The Methodology of Comparative Research.New York:Free Press.
58. Hu-DeHart, Evelyn(1993).The History, Development, and Future of Ethnic Studies.Phi Delta Kappa,75(1),50-55.
59. Hu-DeHart, Evelyn(1995).The Undermining of Ethnic Studies.Chronicle of Higher Education,October 20
60. In, James Riding(2008).American Indian Studies: Our Challenges.Wicazo Sa Review,23(2),65-75.
61. James, Patrock(ed.),Kasoff, Mark(ed.)(2008).Canadian Studies: In the New Millennium.Toronto:University of Toronto Press.
62. Karenga, Maulana(1993).Introduction to Black Studies.Los Angel:University of Sankore Press.
63. Kidwell, Clara Sue(2009).American Indian Studies: Intellectual Navel Gazing or Academic Discipline?.American Indian Quarterly,33(1),1-17.
64. Kidwell, Clara Sue,Velie, Alan(2005).Native American Studies.Lincoln:University of Nebraska Press.
65. Klein, Julie Thompson(ed.),Doty, William G.(ed.)(1994).Interdisciplinary Studies Today.San Francisco:Jossey-Bass Publishers.
66. Kuokkanen, Rauna(2003).Toward a New Relation of Hospitality in the Academy.American Indian Quarterly,27(1-2),267-95.
67. La Belle, Thomas J.,Ward, Christopher R.(1996).Ethnic Studies and Multiculturalism.Albany:State University of New York.
68. Laliberte, Ron F.(ed.),Settee, Priscilla(ed.),Waldram, James B.(ed.),Innes, Rob(ed.),Macdougall, Brenda(ed.),MaBain, Lesley(ed.),Barron, F. Laurie(ed.)(2000).Expressions in Canadian Native Studies.Saskatoon, Sask.:University Extension Press.
69. Lauren, Paul G.(ed.)(1979).Diplomacy: New Approaches in History, Theory and Policy.
70. Littlefield, Daniel F., Jr.(1986).The American Indian Press and American Indian Studies.Wicazo Sa Review,2(2),51-57.
71. Lowy, Richard E.(1995).Eurocentrism, Ethnic Studies, and the New World Order: Toward a Critical Paradigm.Journal of Black Studies,25(6),712-36.
72. Mark, Gregory Yee(ed.),McGregor, Davianna Pomaika'i(ed.),Revilla, Linda A.(ed.)(1996).Our History Our Way: An Ethnic Studies Anthology.Dubuque, Ia.:Kendall Hunt Publishing Co..
73. Morrison, Dane(ed.)(1997).American Indian Studies: An Interdisciplinary Approach to Contemporary Issues.New York:Peter Lang.
74. Muga, David A.(1990).The Marxist Problematic as a Model Interdisciplinary Approach to Ethnic Studies.Journal of Ethnic Studies,17(4),53-80.
75. Nakata, Martin(2006).Australian Indigenous Studies: A Question or Discipline.Australian Journal of Anthropology,17(3),265-75.
76. Niemann, Yolanda Flores,Lugo-Lugo, Carmen R.,Alamillo, José,Guerrero, Lisa,Ong, Rory,Streamas, John(2005).Racial Crossroads: A Reader in Comparative Ethnic Studies.Dubuque, Ia.:Kendall/hunt Publishing Co..
77. Nunpa, Chris Mato(2003).Native Faculty, Higher Education, Racism, and Survival.American Indian Quarterly,27(1-2),349-85.
78. O'Brien, Jean M.(2003).Why Here? Scholarly Locations for American Indian Studies.American Quarterly,55(4),689-96.
79. Okihiro, Garry Y.(ed.)(1989).Ethnic Studies.New York:Markus Wiener Publishing.
80. Orona-Cordova, Roberta(ed.)(2003).Chicano/a Studies Reader: A Bridge to Writing.Dubuque, Ia.:Kendall/Hunt Publishing Co..
81. Pannekoek, Frits(2001).Métis Studies: The Development of a Field and New Directions.Rupert's Land to Canada: Essays in Honour of John E. Forster,Edmonton:
82. Pino-Robles, Rodolfo(2000).Indigenous Studies as an International Field.Annual Conference of Canadian Indigenous and Native Studies Association,Edmonton, Alberta, Canada:
83. Poblete, Juan(ed.)(2003).Critical Latin American and Latino Studies.Minneapolis:University of Minnesota Press.
84. Porter, Robert B.,Bird, Michael J. Yellow(2000).Why Indigenous Nations Studies?.Indigenous Nation Studies Journal,1(1),71-82.
85. Price, John A.(1978).Native Studies: American and Canadian Indians.Toronto:McGraw-Hill Pyerson.
86. Przeworski, Adam,Teune, Henry(1970).The Logic of Comparative Social Inquiry.New York:Wiley-Interscience.
87. Ragin, Charles C.(1987).The Comparative Method: Moving beyond Qualitative and Quantitative Strategies.Berkeley:University of California Press.
88. Robinson, Armstead L.(ed.),Foster, Craig C.(ed.),Ogilvie, Donald H.(ed.)(1969).Black Studies in the University: A Symposium,New Haven:
89. Rosaldo, Renato(1985).Chicano Studies, 1970-1984.Annual Review of Anthropology,14,405-27.
90. Sawchuj(ed.)(1991).Readings in Aboriginal Studies.Brandon, Man.:Bearpaw Publshing.
91. Siemerling, Winfried(2005).The New North American Studies: Culture, Writing and the Politics of Re/cognition.Oxon:Routledge.
92. Smith, Linda Tuhiwai(1999).Decolonizing Methodologies: Research and Indigenous Peoples.London:Zed Books.
93. Stein, Maurice(ed.)(1960).The Eclipse of Community: An Interpretation of American Studies.Princeton:Princeton University Press.
94. Stein, Wayne J.(1986).Indian/Tribal Studies Programs in the Tribally Controlled Community Colleges.Wicazo Sa Review,2(2),29-33.
95. Symons, T. H. B.(1975).To Know Ourselves: The Report of the Commission on Canadian Studies.Ottawa:Association of Universities and College of Canada.
96. Taner, Shona(1999).The Evolution of Native Studies in Canada: Descending from the Ivory Tower.Canadian Journal of Native Studies,19(2),289-319.
97. Thornton, Russell(1977).American Indian Studies as an Academic Discipline.Journal of Ethnic Studies,5(3),1-15.
98. Thornton, Russell(ed.)(1998).Studying Native America: Problems and Prospects.Madison:University of Wisconsin Press.
99. Trask, Haunani-Kay(1999).From a Native Daughter: Colonialism and Sovereignty in Hawai'i.Honolulu:University of Hawai'i Press.
100. Vallier, Ivan(ed.)(1971).Comparative Method in Sociology: Essays on Trends and Applications,Berkeley:
101. Washburn, Wilcomb E.(1975).American Indian Studies: A Status Report.American Quarterly,27(3),264-74.
102. Wheeler, Winona(2001).Thoughts on the Responsibilities for Indigenous/ Native Studies.Canadian Journal of Native Studies,21(1),97-104.
103. Willard, William,Downing, Mary Kay(1991).American Indian Studies and Inter-Cultural Education.Wicazo Sa Review,7(2),1-8.
104. Wilson, Terry P.(1979).Custer Never Would Have Believed It: Native American Studies in Academia.American Indian Quarterly,5(3),208-27.
105. Yang, Philip Q.(2000).Ethnic Studies: Issues and Approaches.Albany:State University of New York Press.
106. 施正鋒(1998)。族群與民族主義─集體認同的政治分析。台北:前衛。
107. 謝國雄編(2008)。群學爭鳴─台灣社會學發展史。台北:群學。

1. Huang, Yu-Chao,Chi, Chun-Chieh-紀駿傑(2012).Citation Analysis of Indigenous Research in Taiwan: A Study of the Taiwan Journal of Indigenous Studies.台灣原住民族研究季刊,5(4),65-82.