教師行動學習團體互動機制之研究

The Mechanism of Interaction in Action Learning Group

徐綺穗(Chi-Sui Hsu)

行動學習 ； 教師行動學習團體 ； 反思 ； action learning ； action learning group ； reflection

教育學誌

30期（2013 / 11 / 01）

1 - 40

繁體中文

為了適應快速變遷的社會，學校推動教師專業發展已成必然趨勢。有關推動的方式，相較於傳統的教師研習，行動學習更能聚焦於教學實務的需要，教師持續參與行動學習團體，與其他成員對話、反思，探討實務問題及對策，進行有系統的學習。然而，實施教師行動學習團體的挑戰是需要有效的掌握團體過程，否則難以發揮學習的功效（徐綺穗，2012；Butterfield，2001）。因此本研究採用文獻分析法，針對教師行動學習團體成員反思、回饋及同理心的互動機制，建構其理論觀點、運作流程及實施要領，使團體的過程有更具體的原則可以依循。本研究的結果如下：一、教師行動學習團體主動機制的理論觀點，包括行動學習、團體動力及學習者中心論等三大項。二、教師行動學習團體主動機制的運作流程由九個要素構成：1.教師行動2.教學問題3.行動後的反思4.發表、同理與回饋的互動5.反思的敘述與問題探究6.再反思7.對策與知識的形成8.開始、工作及結束團體階段9.教師專業發展。其中行動與反思的要素具有雙向的互動關係；團體的對話帶動發表、回饋及同理的互動關係。三、教師行動學習團體互動機制的實施要領有：1.使教師成員認識多層次反思的意義及進行方式2.以團體教師成員的回饋、同理對話激發深層反思3.催化者、發表者及成員三種角色在不同團體階段，確實扮演好其角色行為及語言。

The purpose of the research is to construction the mechanism of interaction in action learning group, including the theoretical concepts, the flow procedure of reflection, feedback, and empathy in the action learning group meeting, and the main points in practice. Qualitative research methodology had been employed in this research.The results are as follows:1) The theoretical concepts including action learning, group dynamic, and humanism.2) There are nine elements in the flow procedure of the mechanism of interaction in the action learning group. It displays that the interaction between actions and reflections, also between presentation, feedback, and empathy in the procedure.3) There are three main points in practice. First, making teachers understand the concepts and practice of action learning. Secondly, activating members' dialogue through feedback, empathy, leading to more deep reflections. Finally, the roles of presenter, facilitator and member in the action learning group need behave the role behaviors effectively.

1. 黃哲彬(2005)。論行動學習之理念及其在教師進修上的啟示。學校行政，36，50-59。
   連結：
2. Dewey, J. (1933). How We Think. New York: D. C.
3. Argyris, C.,Schon, D.(1974).Theory in practice: Increasing professional effectiveness.London, UK:Jossey-Bass.
4. Bransford, J. D.,Brown, A. L.,Cocking, R. R.(2000).How people learn: brain, mind, experience, and school.Washington, D. C.:National Academy Press.
5. Brockbank, A,McGill, I(1998).Facilitating Reflective Learning in Higher Education.
6. Butterfield. S. D.(2001).Action Learning: Case Studies of Most Valued Learning and Application.2001 AHRD Conference, symposium
7. Corey, G.,Corey, M. S.(2001).Groups: Process and practice.Pacific Grove, CA:Brooks/Cole.
8. Davis, K.,Brownie, S.,Doran, F.,Evans, S.,Hutchinson, M.,Mozolic-Staunton, B.,Provost, S.,van Aken, R.(2012).Action learning enhances professional development of research supervisors: an Australian health science exemplar.Nursing & Health Sciences,14(1),102-108.
9. Dinham. S,Aubusson, P,Brady. L(2008).Distributed Leadership as a Factor in and Outcome of Teacher Action Learning.International Electronic Journal for Leadership in Learning,12(4),1-13.
10. Dyer, W.,Vriend, J.(1980).Group counseling for personal mastery.New York, NY:Sovereign Books.
11. Eyler, J. S.,Giles, D. E.(1999).Where's the learning in service-learning?.San Francisco, CA:Jossey-Bass.
12. Graves, S.,Jones, M.(2008).Enabling the journey from experienced practitioner to para-professional: using reflective dialogue in action learning triads.Journal of Further and Higher Education,32(4),309-319.
13. Grossman, R.(2008).Structures for facilitating student reflection.College Teaching,57(1),15-22.
14. Hill, S.(Ed.)(1982).Improving interpersonal competence.Dubuque, IA:Kendall/Hunt.
15. Jacobs, E.,Masson, L.,Harvil, L.(2007).Group Counseling: Strategies & Skills.Belmont, CA:Brooks/Cole Pub.
16. Johnson, D. W.,Johnson, F. P.(2003).Joining together.Boston:Allyn & Bacon.
17. Kegan, R.(1994).In over our heads: The mental demands of modern life.Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press.
18. Koch, S.(Ed.)(1959).Psychology: A study of a science.New York, NY:McGraw Hill.
19. Kolb, D.(1984).Experiential Learning.Englewood Cliffs, NJ:
20. Lee, I.(2011).Teachers as presenters at continuing professional development seminars in the English-as a foreign language context: I find it more convincing.Australian Journal of Teacher Education,36(2),30-42.
21. MacNaughton, G,Hughes, P,Smith, K(2007).Rethinking Approaches to Working with Children Who Challenge: Action Learning for Emancipatory Practice.International Journal of Early Childhood,39(1),39-57.
22. Manouchehri, A.(2002).Developing teaching knowledge through peer discourse.Teaching and Teacher Education,18,715-737.
23. Marsick, V.J,O Neil, J(1999).The Many Faces of Action Learning.Management Learning,30(2),159-176.
24. McGill, I.,Beaty, L.(1995).Action learning: A guide for professional, managerial and educational development.London, UK:Kogan Page.
25. McGill, I.,Brockbank, A.(2004).The Action Learning Handbook.London, UK:Routledge Falmer.
26. Mezirow, J.(1978).Perspective Transformation.Adult Education,28,100-110.
27. Mezirow, J.(1997).Transformative Learning: Theory to Practice.New Directions for Adult and Continuing Education,74,5-12.
28. Mezirow, J.(1990).Fostering Critical Reflection in Adulthood.San Francisco:Jossey-Bass.
29. Pella, S.(2011).A situative perspective on developing writing pedagogy in a teacher professional learning community.Teacher Education Quarterly,38(1),107-125.
30. Posthuma, B. W.(2002).Small groups in therapy settings: Process and leadership.Boston, Mass:Allyn & Bacon.
31. Revans, R.(1980).Action Learning: New Technique for Action Learning.London, UK:Blonds and Briggs.
32. Revans, R.(1982).The Origins and Growth of Action Learning.Bromley Kent:Chartwell-Bratt.
33. Stark, S.(2006).Using action learning for professional development.Educational Action Research,14(1),23-43.
34. Trotzer, J.(1999).The counselor and the group: Integrating theory, training, and practice.Philadelphia, PA:Accelerated Development, Inc.
35. Tuckman, B.,Jensen, M.(1977).Stages of small group development revisited.Group and Organizational Studies,2,419-427.
36. Wade, S.,Hammick, M.(1999).Action learning circles: Action learning in theory and practice.Teaching in Higher Education,4(2),163-178.
37. Weinstein, K.(1999).Action Learning: a Practical Guide for Managers.Aldershot, UK:Gower.
38. 王淑俐(2000)。做個「教學溝通」的智者。臺北市:師大書苑。
39. 吳武典(1987)。國小怎樣實施輔導工作。臺北市:心理。
40. 徐綺穗(2007)。行動學習理論及其對教師教學的啟示。國教之友，58(3)，50-56。
41. 徐綺穗(2007)。行動學習理論及其在促進教師專業知能之應用。「課程改革與教學輔導」國際學術研討會，台北市:
42. 徐綺穗(2012)。教師參與行動團體促進教師專業發展之探討。教育研究月刊，215，30-39。
43. 徐綺穗(2011)。行政院國家科學委員會專題研究計畫成果報告行政院國家科學委員會專題研究計畫成果報告,行政院國家科學委員會。
44. 鄭佩芬(2000)。人際關係與溝通技巧。臺北市:揚智。
45. 鄭燕祥(2005)。多元思維和多元創造利的行動學習。教育研究月刊，134，76-105。
46. 謝旻蒼(2008)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立臺南大學。

1. 郭浩芸,范熾文(2023)。一所高中參與科技輔助自主學習計畫執行之個案研究。學校行政，148，244-265。
2. (2019)。大學教師對校外參訪見學的問題意識與經驗詮釋。教育研究學報，53(1)，1-24。