跨領域課程探究教師領導理念、實施、與啟示－以一所國中【島嶼記憶】課程發展歷程為例

Exploring the Concept, Implementation, and Enlightenment of Teacher Leadership Through Interdisciplinary Curriculum-Take the Development Process of the Course [Memory of the Island] in a Junior High School as an Example

廖玉枝(Liao, Yu-Chih)

教師領導 ； 領導理論 ； 學校領導 ； teacher leadership ； leadership theory ； school leadership

教育學誌

50期（2023 / 11 / 01）

63 - 92

繁體中文;英文

學校教師足夠的專業能力，願意承擔起教師領導者的任務，致力於專業精進，促進學校正向發展，提升教室與學校進步，是學校成功與課程實踐的關鍵元素。本研究透過一所公立國中跨領域課程的實踐歷程，從Murphy（2005）提出的教師領導內嵌邏輯：專業、學校健康、教室與學校進步的三個層面探究教師領導在學校運作的影響與其間的相互關係並提出教師領導對當前學校領導的啟示。研究發現：一、教師領導透過課程專業發展中的授權增能，提升專業及擁有權。二、教師自主承諾提升課程效率與教師認同，促成專業生涯的期待。三、教師領導促進學習社群，帶動學校課程持續精進能量。四、教師領導促進行政科層與課程領導合作，強化學校組織運作。五、教師領導促成學校進步與社區正向的改變。六、教師領導促進班級進步，提升學生學習，獲得家長高度肯定。七、個案學校教師領導內嵌邏輯相互影響的催化劑－外部專業培訓與激勵機制，催化教師領導。前六點研究發現，在內嵌邏輯的三個層面範疇，第七點則是外部所帶來的催化教師領導力量，可以做為學校領導的參考啟示。

Teachers' sufficient professional competence, willingness to undertake leadership roles, being dedicated to professional development, and supporting positive school development and classroom progress are critical elements for the success of schools and curriculum implementation. This study examines the impact of teacher leadership and its interrelationships in the context of a public junior high school's interdisciplinary curriculum practice, based on the embedded logic of teacher leadership by Murphy (2005), which includes three phases: professional expertise, school health, and classroom and school progress. The study also presents insights on teacher leadership for current school leadership. Findings of the research are as follows: 1. Teacher leadership enhances ownership and expertise through authorization in the curriculum development. 2. Teachers' self-commitment to improve curriculum efficiency and identity fosters expectations for teacher profession. 3. Teacher leadership promotes learning communities, driving continuous improvement in the school's curriculum. 4. Teacher leadership encourages collaboration between administrative bureaucracy and curriculum leadership, strengthening the school's organization and operations. 5. Teacher leadership makes school progress and lead to positive community changes. 6. Teacher leadership promotes classroom progress, improve student learning, and gains significant parental recognition. 7. External professional training and incentive mechanisms act as catalysts for the interaction of teacher leadership in the case study school. The first six findings are within the scope of the three phases of the embedded logic, while the last one represents external influence that serve as catalysts for teacher leadership and can offer valuable enlightenment for school leadership.

1. 張德銳, D. R.(2010)。喚醒沈睡的巨人－論教師領導在我國中小學的發展。臺北市立教育大學學報，41(2)，81-110。
   連結：
2. 張德銳, D. R.(2020)。我國教師領導研究成果分析與發展方向。教育研究與發展期刊，16(1)，101-154。
   連結：
3. 陳玉桂, Y.-K.(2006)。學校革新中不可忽略的面向：談教師領導。學校行政雙月刊，45，26-46。
   連結：
4. 劉世雄, S. H.(2019)。教師學習與教師領導教師社群運作的內容分析。教科書研究，12(2)，133-147。
   連結：
5. 蔡進雄, C. H.(2007)。國民中學教師教學領導之建構與發展－以學習領域召集人為例。學校行政雙月刊，52，20-43。
   連結：
6. Anderson, K. D.(2004).The nature of teacher leadership in schools as reciprocal influences between teacher leaders and principals.School Effectiveness and School Improvement,15(1),97-113.
7. Barth, R. S.(2001).Teacher leader.Phi Delta Kappan,82(6),443-449.
8. Biddle, B. J.(Ed.),Good, T. L.(Ed.),Goodson, I. F.(Ed.)(1996).International handbook of teachers and teaching.Dordrecht:Kluwer Academic.
9. Blasé, J.,Blasé, J.(2004).Handbook of instructional.Thousand Oaks, CA:Corwin.
10. Harris, A.(2003).Teacher leadership as distributed leadership: Heresy, fantasy, or possibility?.School Leadership & Management,23(3),313-324.
11. Harris, A.(2003).Teacher leadership and school improvement.Effective leadership for school improvement,London:
12. Katzenmeyer, M.,Moller, G.(2009).Awakening the sleeping giant: Helping teachers develop as leaders.Newbury Park, CA:Corwin Press.
13. Keedy, J. L.(1999).Examining teacher instructional leadership within the small group dynamics of collegial groups.Teaching and Teacher Education,15(7),785-799.
14. Keiser, N. M.,Shen, J.(2000).Principals’ and teachers’ perceptions of teacher empowerment.Journal of Leadership Studies,7(13),115-122.
15. Lambert, L.(2003).Leadership capacity for lasting school improvement.Alexandria, VA:Association of Supervision and Curriculum Development.
16. Lambert, L.,Walker, D.,Zimmerman, D.,Cooper, J.,Lambert, M.,Gardner, M.,Slack, P. J. F.(1995).The constructivist leader.New York:Teachers College Press.
17. Lieberman, A.(Ed.)(1988).Building a professional culture in schools.New York:Teachers College Press.
18. Lightfoot, S.L.(1986).On goodness of schools: Themes of empowerment.Peabody Journal of Education,63(3),9-28.
19. Lin, H. Y.(2009).Taichung City,National Taichung University of Education.
20. Murphy, J.(2005).Connecting teacher leadership and school improvement.Thousand Oaks, CA:Corwin Press.
21. Murphy, J.(Ed.),Datnow, A.(Ed.)(2003).Leadership for school reform: Lessons from comprehensive school reforms.Thousand Oaks, CA:Corwin Press.
22. Smylie, M. A.,Smylie, M. A.,Fendt, C. R.(2003).The Chicago Annenberg Challenge: Lessons on leadership for school development.Leadership for school reform: Lessons from comprehensive school reforms,Thousand Oaks, CA:
23. Somech, A.(2005).Directive versus participative leadership: Two complementary approaches to managing school effectiveness.Educational Leadership Quarterly,41(5),777-800.
24. Spillane, J.,Hallett, T.,Diamond, J.(2003).Forms of capital and the construction of leadership: Instructional leadership in urban elementary schools.Sociology of Education,76(1),1-17.
25. Weiner, J.M.(2011).Finding common ground: Teacher leaders and principals speak out about teacher leadership.Journal of School Leadership,21,7-41.
26. Wise, A.,Liebbrand, J.(1996).Profession-Based Accreditation: A Foundation for High-Quality Teaching.Phi Delta Kappan,78(3),202-206.
27. York-Barr, J.,Duke, K.(2004).What do we know about teacher leadership? Finding from two decades of scholarship.Review of Educational Research,74(3),255-316.
28. Zepeda, Sally J.,Mayers, R. Stewart,Benson, Brad(2003).The call to teacher leadership.Poughkeepsie, NY:Eye On Education.
29. 張德銳, D. R.(2016)。學校革新的巨大潛能－教師領導。師友月刊，587，33-38。
30. 張德銳, D. R.,林偉人, W. J.(2018)。以教師領導促進素養導向教學的發展。臺灣教育評論月刊，7(4)，130-135。
31. 陳佩英(2008)。教師領導之興起與發展。教育研究月刊，171，41-57。
32. 歐用生(1999)。落實學校本位的課程發展。國民教育，39(4)，2-7。
33. 蔡進雄, C. H.(2005)。中小學教師領導理論之探究。教育研究月刊，139，92-101。
34. 蔡進雄, C. H.(2004)。談教師領導的趨勢與發展。教育資料與研究，59，92-98。