課程革新制度化之探析

A Review of Innovative Curriculum Institutionalization

10.3966/207136492019041201003

侯一欣(Yi-Hsin Hou)；高新建(Shin-Joann Gau)

課程革新 ； 制度化 ； 制度理論 ； 課程實施 ； 課程擴散 ； curriculum innovation ； institutionalization ； institutionalization theory ； curriculum implementation ； curriculum diffusion

師資培育與教師專業發展期刊

12卷1期（2019 / 04 / 01）

59 - 82

繁體中文

課程革新的制度化約自1980年代始展開研究，其進展恰與制度理論的興革背景相呼應，皆受到理性選擇論、組織社會學和歷史制度主義等影響，而有不同的關注焦點。細究制度化的運作，發現其過程大抵可區分為：調控、規範和認知等三種模式；並且衍生相應的指標行為有：人們的從眾傾向、工作的例行化與規範價值的內在化等。長期以往，課程革新的制度化遠不若實施研究較受重視，學術研究累積的成果委實有限，期許未來該研究能與其它理論（如實施、擴散或推廣等）跨領域合作，豐實有關革新進程研究之全貌。

Studies on innovative curriculum institutionalization (ICI) have burgeoned since the 1980s, synchronizing with the developmental background of the institutionalization theory. Both of them were influenced by the rational choice theory, organizational sociology, and historical institutionalism and appeared to focus on different issues. The three models of ICI consist of regulative, normative, and cognitive aspects, and some indicative behaviors are included, such as herd mentality, routine work, and enculturation of normative value. Compared to curriculum implementation, ICI was never highly respected as a field of study, and its accumulated research results are rather limited. Hopefully, future studies in the field of ICI may cooperate with other different domains (such as implementation or dissemination) in order to enrich the scope of research on the process of curriculum innovation.

1. 陳利銘, L. M.,王文科, W. K.(2006)。制化文本對課程改革的影響：以九年一貫課程為例。教育理論與實踐學刊，15，1-14。
   連結：
2. Acemoglu, D.,Robinson, J.A.,吳國卿（譯）,鄧伯宸（譯）(2013).國家為什麼會失敗：權力、富裕與貧困的根源.臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan:衛城出版=Acropolis.
3. Anderson, S. E.,Stiegelbaue, S.(1994).Institutionalization and renewal in a restructured secondary school.School Organisation,3(14),279-293.
4. Arendt, H.,蔡佩君（譯）(2010).政治的承諾.臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan:左岸文化=Sino Book.
5. Azano, A.,Missett, T. C.,Callahan, C. M.,Oh, S.,Brunner, M.,Foster, L. H.,Moon, T.R.(2011).Exploring the relationship between fidelity of implementation and academic achievement in a third-grade gifted curriculum: A mixed-methods study.Journal of Advanced Academics,22(5),693-719.
6. Berstein, B.,王瑞賢（譯）(2006).教育論述之結構化.臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan:國立編譯館.
7. Carless, D.(2004).Continuity and 'teacher-centred' reform: Potential paradoxes in educational change.Curriculum Perspectives,24(1),42-51.
8. Carlsnaes, W.(Ed.),Risse, T.(Ed.),Simmons, B.(Ed.)(2012).Handbook of international relations.London, UK:Sage.
9. Colbeck,C. L(2002).Assessing institutionalization of curricular and pedagoglcal reforms.Research in Higher Education,43(4),397-421.
10. Cooke, M.(2000).The dissemination of a smoking cessation program: Predictors of program awareness, adoption and maintenance.Health Promotion International,15(2),113-123.
11. Cotton, D. R. E.(2006).Implementing curriculum guidance on environmental education: the importance of teachers' beliefs.Curriculum Studies,38(1),67-83.
12. Denemark, R.(Ed.)(2010).The international studies encyclopedia.Malden, MA:Blackwell Publishing.
13. DiMaggio, P.,Powell, W. W.(1983).The iron cage revisited: Collective rationality and institutional isomorphism in organizational fields.American Sociological Review,48(2),147-160.
14. Dinani, A. E.,Nasr, A. R.,Soltani, M. S. K.(2012).A study on strong and weak points of change process in domains of codification and design, dissemination and publication of qualitative-descriptive evaluation project in the province of Isfahan.Journal of Life Science and Biomedicine,2(2),11-20.
15. Farkas, M.,Jette, A. M.,Tennstedt, S.,Haley, S. M.,Quinn, V.(2003).Knowledge dissemination and utilization in gerontology:An organizing framework.The Gerontologist,43(1),47-56.
16. Fogarty, B. J.,Pete, B. M.(2007).From staff room to classroom: A guide for planning and coaching professional development.Chicago, IL:SAGE.
17. Frank, K.A.,Zhao, Y.,Penuel, W. R.,Ellefson, N.,Porter, S.(2011).Focus, fiddle, and friends: Experiences that transform knowledge for the implementation of innovations.Sociology of Education,84(2),137-156.
18. Fullan, M.(2007).The new meaning of educational change.New York, NY:Teachers College Press.
19. Fullan, M.(2001).Leading in a culture of change.San Francisco, CA:Wiley.
20. Giddens, A.(1984).The Constitution of Society.Cambridge, England:Polity Press.
21. Gingiss, P. M.,Gray, R. C.,Boerm, M.(2006).Bridge-it: A system for predicting implementation fidelity for school-based tobacco prevention programs.Prev. Sci.,7(2),197-207.
22. Greenwood, R.(Ed.),Oliver, C.(Ed.),Suddaby, R.(Ed.),Sahlin, K.(Ed.)(2008).The Sage handbook of organizational institutionalism.London:SAGE Publications.
23. Hall, P. A.,Taylor, R. C. R.(1996).Political science and the three new institutionalisms.Political Studies,44,936-957.
24. Immergut, E. M.(1998).The theoretical core of the New Institutionalism.Politics and Society,26(1),5-34.
25. Jakobi, A. P.(2012).International organisations and policy diffusion: The global norm of lifelong learning.Journal of International Relations and Development,15(1),31-64.
26. Jakobi, A. P.(2009).International organizations and lifelong learning.Basingstoke, England:Palgrave Macmillan.
27. Kane, G. C.,Johnson, J.,Majchrzak, A.(2014).Emergent life cycle: the tension between knowledge change and knowledge retention in open online coproduction communities.Management Science,60(12),3026-3048.
28. Kelly, A.V.(2004).The curriculum theory and practice.Los Angeles, CA:SAGE.
29. Krasner, S. D.(1988).Sovereignty: An institutional perspective.Comparative Political Studies,21(1),66-94.
30. Leicht, K. T.(Ed.),Jenkins, J. C.(Ed.)(2010).Handbook of politics: State and society in global perspective.New York, NY:Springer.
31. Magrini, J. M.(2015).Phenomenology and curriculum implementation: Discerning a living curriculum through the analysis of Ted Aoki's situational praxis.Journal Curriculum Studies,47(2),274-299.
32. Mayer, D.,Mitchell, J.,Macdonald, D.,Bell, R.(2005).Professional standards for teachers: A case study of professional learning.Asia-Pacific Journal of Teacher Education,33(2),159-179.
33. Mazza, C.(Ed.),Quattrone, P.(Ed.),Riccaboni, A.(Ed.)(2008).European universities in transition: Issues, models, and cases.Northampton, MA:Edward Elgar Publishing.
34. McBeath, C. (1995). Overcoming barriers to effective curriculum change: A case study in dissemination practice. Retrieved from http://www.clare-mcbeath.id.au/pubs/bris95.html
35. Miles, M. B.,Ekholm, M.,Vanderberghe, R.(1987).Lasting school improvement:Exploring the process of institutionalization.Leuven:Acco.
36. Neal, J. W.,Neal, Z. P.,Atkins, M. S.,Henry, D. B.,Frazier, S. L.(2011).Channels of change: Contrasting network mechanisms in the use of interventions.Am Journal Community Psychology,47,277-286.
37. Nikolaeva, R.,Bicho, M.(2011).The role of institutional and reputational factors in the voluntary adoption of corporate social responsibility reporting standards.Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science,39,136-157.
38. Pedder, D.,MacBeath, J.(2008).Organisational learning approaches to school leadership and management: teachers' values and perceptions of practice.School Effectiveness and School Improvement,19(2),207-224.
39. Pierson, P.,Skocpol, T.(2002).Historical institutionalism in contemporary political science.Political science: The state of the discipline,3,693-721.
40. Pinar, W. F.(Ed.)(2003).International handbook of curriculum research.Mahwah, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum.
41. Powell, W. W., & Bromley, P. (2013). New institutionalism in the analysis of complex organizations. Retrieved from http://patriciabromley.com/PowellBromleyEncyclopedia.pdf
42. Rogers, E.M.(2003).Diffusion of Innovations.New York, NY:The Free Press.
43. Rudduck, J.(1976).Dissemination of innovation:The humanities curriculum project.London, England:Evans/Methuen Educational.
44. Samuelson, J.(2009).Toward sustainable change.BizEd Magazine,8(4),30-36.
45. Stambaugh, J. E.,Trank, C. Q.(2010).Not so simple: Integrating new research into textbooks.Academy of Management Learning & Education,9(4),663-681.
46. Stein, B. D.,Kataoka, S. H.,Hamilton, A. B.,Schultz, D.,Ryan, G.,Vona, P.,Wong, M.(2010).School personnel perspectives on their school’s implementation of a school-based suicide prevention program.The Journal of Behavioral Health Services & Research,37(3),338-349.
47. Wernet, S. P.,Singleton, J. L.(2010).Institutionalization of gerontological curricular change in schools of social work.Gerontology & Geriatrics Education,31,19-36.
48. Young, J.H.(1990).Curriculum implementation: An organizational perspective.Journal of Curriculum and Supervision,5(2),132-149.
49. 尹弘飈, H. B.(2014)。再論課程變革的制度化－概念內涵與分析框架。高等教育研究，35(4)，66-71。
50. 尹弘飈, H. B.(2009)。論課程變革的制度化－基於新制度主義的分析。高等教育研究，30(4)，75-81。
51. 王盈勛, Y. X.(2013)。傳播新制度經濟史初探。傳播文化，12，1-15。
52. 王恭志, G. J.(2004)。新右派課程政策的評析與啟示。教育研究資訊，12(5)，34-56。
53. 卯靜儒, C. J.(2014)。改革即改變嗎？ 教育改革理解路徑之探索。教育學刊，42，1-37。
54. 阮孝齊, H. C.(2015)。從擴散理論探究各縣市學習共同體推動與影響因素之研究。第八屆科技社會中課程與教學變革研討會，南投縣=Nantou, Taiwan:
55. 阮孝齊, H. C.(2016)。臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan，國立臺灣師範大學教育研究所=National Taiwan Normal University。
56. 林綺雲, C. Y.(2002)。制度學派的理論反思：臺灣教育組織的變革經驗。社會科學論叢，40，111-133。
57. 侯ㄧ欣, Y. H.(2017)。臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan，國立臺灣師範大學教育研究所=National Taiwan Normal University。
58. 侯一欣, Y. H.(2013)。美英兩國課程推廣發展背景之探析：從 1960 到 1980 年代。教育與心理研究，36(1)，63-87。
59. 侯一欣, Y. H.,高新建, S. J.(2014)。縣市推廣課程於學校實施的影響因素：以新北市品德教育家庭聯絡簿為例。「教改20 年回顧與前瞻」國際學術研討會，臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan:
60. 侯一欣, Y. H.,黃純敏, C.M.(2011)。臺灣與澳大利亞教師評鑑政策背景之比較研究。「社會變遷與教師地位之轉變」國際學術研討會，臺東市=Taitung, Taiwan:
61. 胡婉玲, A. W. L.(2001)。論歷史制度主義的制度變遷理論。新世紀智庫論壇，16，86-95。
62. 張俊列, J.(2015)。論課程改革的制度化。現代基礎教育研究，17，111-116。
63. 陳美智, M. C.,楊開雲, K.Y.(2000)。組織真是理性的嗎？一個組織社會學的新制度論觀點。東海社會科學學報，20，27-59。
64. 傅恆德, H. D.,林文謙, W.Q.(2009)。二十一世紀政治科學研究途徑之展望。「2009 年臺灣政治學會年會暨動盪年代中的政治學：理論與實踐」學術研討會，新竹縣=Hsinchu, Taiwan:
65. 黃嘉雄, C. H.(2000).轉化社會結構的課程理論：課程社會學的觀點.臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan:師大書苑=Shta Book.
66. 楊深坑（編）, S. K.(Ed.)(2009).比較與國際教育.臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan:高等教育出版社=Higher Education Publishing.
67. 劉曉芬, H. F.(2006)。歷史制度主義觀點的教育政策分析－以高職轉型綜合高中為例。教育政策論壇，9(2)，1-18。
68. 潘慧玲, H. L.(2001)。學校革新研究的構思與作法。學校革新研討會，臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan:
69. 蔡相廷, H. T.(2010)。歷史制度主義的興起與研究取向－政治學研究途徑的探討。臺北市立教育大學學報，41(2)，39-76。
70. 戴揚（2007）。新制度主義政治學中的理性選擇理論。取自 www.unirule.org.cn/xiazai/200711/5.pdf[Dai, Y.(2007). Rational choice theory Of new institutional politics. Retrieved from www.unirule.org.cn/xiazai/200711/5.pdf]