金融合併與風險傳染：台灣實證研究

Financial Consolidation and Risk Contagion: An Empirical Study of Taiwan

蔡永順(Yung-Shun Tsai)

金融合併 ； 風險傳染 ； 風險分散 ； 金融複雜 ； Financial Consolidation ； Risk Contagion ； Diversification ； Institution Complexity

商略學報

4卷2期（2012 / 06 / 01）

93 - 113

繁體中文

本文探討金融合併對風險傳染的影響，以台灣金融控股公司（以下簡稱金控）與銀行為例，運用Dieboldand Yilmaz（2009）的方法，衡量風險外溢效果，比較金控之間與銀行之間，在不同「風險分散度」與「機構複雜度」之下的風險傳染效果。結果發現：一、金控之間的風險傳染大於銀行之間的風險傳染。二、機構複雜度對風險傳染的影響大於風險分散對風險傳染的影響。三、金控對股價指數風險外溢效果大於銀行對股價指數風險外溢效果。四、金控之間的風險傳染，隨著落後期數增加而先增後減，以落後2期的影響效果最大。銀行之間的風險傳染，則隨著落後期數增加而逐期遞減，以落後1期的影響效果最大。整合上述結果可知：金控之間的風險傳染較大，效果持續性較強，而且較容易引發系統風險。

This paper evaluates the impact of financial consolidation on the risk contagion. We use the method of Diebold and Yilmaz (2009) to measure the risk contagion of financial holding companies and other banks in Taiwan. Simultaneously, we also examine the effects on risk contagion of the degree of diversification and institution complexity. The key findings are as follows: 1. the risk contagion in financial holding companies is larger than the risk contagion in other banks; 2. the institution complexity has larger influence on risk contagion than the degree of diversification; 3. the financial holding company has larger spillover effects on stock index than other banks; 4. the risk contagion in financial holding companies increases when risk starts at the beginning period and then decreases in later periods, and the risk contagion is the largest when the lag period is equal to 2; the risk contagion in other banks decreases when the lag period increases. Therefore, we conclude that financial consolidations will increase the risk contagion. The risk contagion in financial holding companies is larger, more persistent and more easily to introduce systemic risk than other banks.

1. Slijkermany, J. F., Schoenmaker, D. and de Vries, C. G., 2005. Risk Diversification by European Financial Conglomerates, Discussion Paper (No. 2005-110/2), Tinbergen Institute
2. Winton, A., 1999. Don't Put All Your Eggs in One Basket? Diversification and Specialization in Lending, Working Paper (No. 00-16), Wharton School Center for Financial Institutions, University of Minnesota
3. Allen, F.,Carletti, E.,Marquez, R.(2011).Credit Market Competition and Capital Regulation.The Review of Financial Studies,24(4),983-1018.
4. Allen, F.,Gale, D.(2001).Comparing Financial Systems.Cambridge, MA:MIT Press.
5. Allen, F.,Gale, D.(2000).Financial Contagion.Journal of Political Economy,108(1),1-33.
6. Allen, F.,Gale, D.(2007).Systemic Risk and Regulation.The Risks of Financial Institutions
7. Allen, F.,Gale, D.(2004).Competition and Financial Stability.Journal of Money, Credit and Banking,36(3),453-480.
8. Allen, L.,Jagtiani, J.(2000).The Risk Effects of Combining Banking, Securities and Insurance Activities.Journal of Economics and Business,52(6),485-497.
9. Bae, K. H.,Karolyi, G. A.,Stulz, R. M.(2003).A New Approach to Measuring Financial Contagion.The Review of Financial Studies,16(3),717-763.
10. Beck, T.,Demirgüç-Kunt, A.,Levine, R.(2006).Bank Concentration, Competition and Crises: First Results.Journal of Banking and Finance,30(5),1581-1603.
11. Boyd, J. H.,de Nicoló, G.,Jalal, A. M.(2007).IMF Working PaperIMF Working Paper,International Monetary Fund.
12. Carlson, M.,Mitchener, K. J.(2006).Branch Banking, Bank Competition and Financial Stability.Journal of Money, Credit and Banking,38(5),1293-1328.
13. Corsetti, G.,Pericoli, M.,Sbracia, M.(2005).Some Contagion, Some Interdependence: More Pitfalls in Tests of Financial Contagion.Journal of International Money and Finance,24(8),1177-1199.
14. de Bandt, O.,Hartmann, P.(2000).ECB Working PaperECB Working Paper,European Central Bank.
15. de Nicoló, G.,Bartholomew, P.,Zaman, J.,Zephirin, M.(2004).Bank Consolidation, Internationalization and Conglomeration: Trends and Implications for Financial Risk.Financial Markets, Institutions & Instruments,13(4),173-217.
16. de Nicoló, G.,Kwast, M. L.(2002).Systemic Risk and Financial Consolidation: Are They Related?.Journal of Banking & Finance,26(5),861-880.
17. Demsetz, R. S.,Strahan, P. E.(1997).Diversification, Size and Risk at Bank Holding Companies.Journal of Money, Credit and Banking,29(3),300-313.
18. Diamond, D. W.,Dybvig, P. H.(1983).Bank Runs, Deposit Insurance and Liquidity.Journal of Political Economy,91(3),401-419.
19. Diebold, F. X.,Yilmaz, K.(2009).Measuring Financial Asset Return and Volatility Spillovers, with Application to Global Equity Markets.The Economic Journal,119(534),158-171.
20. Elsas, R.,Hackethal, A.,Holzhäuse, M.(2010).The Anatomy of Bank Diversification.Journal of Banking & Finance,34(6),1274-1287.
21. Engle, R. F.,Ito, T.,Lin, W. L.(1990).Meteor Showers or Heat Waves? Heteroskedastic Intradaily Volatility in the Foreign Exchange Market.Econometrica,58(3),525-542.
22. Forbes, K. J.,Rigobon, R.(2002).No Contagion, Only Interdependence: Measuring Stock Market Co-movement.The Journal of Finance,57(5),2223-2261.
23. Fufine, C. H.(2003).Interbank Exposures: Quantifying the Risk of Contagion.Journal of Money, Credit and Banking,35(1),111-128.
24. Goldstein, I.,Pauzner, A.(2004).Contagion of Self-fulfilling Financial Crises Due to Diversification of Investment Portfolios.Journal of Economic Theory,119(1),151-183.
25. Hartmann, P.,Straetmans, S.,de Vries, C. G.(2005).NBER Working PaperNBER Working Paper,National Bureau of Economic Research, Inc..
26. Hoggarth, G.,Reis, R.,Saporta, V.(2002).Costs of Banking System Instability: Some Empirical Evidence.Journal of Banking and Finance,26(5),825-855.
27. Impson, M.(2000).Contagion Effects of Dividend Reduction or Omission Announcements in the Electric Utility Industry.The Financial Review,35(1),121-136.
28. Jacklin, C. J.,Bhattacharya, S.(1988).Distinguishing Panics and Information-based Runs: Welfare and Implications.Journal of Political Economy,96(3),568-592.
29. Kim, S. J.(2004).Bailout and Conglomeration.Journal of Financial Economics,71(2),315-347.
30. Kwast, M. L.,Passmore, S. W.(1997).The Subsidy Provided by the Federal Safety Net: Theory, Measurement and Containment.Proceedings of the 34th Conference on Bank Structure and Competition
31. Laeven, L.,Levine, R.(2007).Is There a Diversification Discountin Financial Conglomerates?.Journal of Financial Economics,85(2),331-367.
32. Levinson, M.(2006).Guide to Financial Markets.London:The Economist.
33. Liedorp, F. R.,Medema, L.,Koetter, M.,Koning, R. H.,Lelyveld, I. V.(2010).DNB Working PaperDNB Working Paper,Research Department, Netherlands Central Bank.
34. Longin, F.,Solnik, B.(2001).Extreme Correlation of International Equity Markets.The Journal of Finance,56(2),649-676.
35. Longstaff, F. A.(2010).The Subprime Credit Crisis and Contagion in Financial Markets.Journal of Financial Economics,97(3),436-450.
36. Mishkin, F. S.(2006).How Big a Problem is Too Big to Fail? A Review of Gary Stern and Ron Feldman's Too Big to Fail: The Hazards of Bank Bailouts.Journal of Economic Literature,44(4),988-1004.
37. Mishkin, F. S.(1999).Financial Consolidation Dangers and Opportunities.Journal of Banking & Finance,23(2-4),675-691.
38. Perotti, E. C.,Suarez, J.(2002).Last Bank Standing: What Do I Gain if You Fail?.European Ecomonic Review,46(9),1599-1622.
39. Schmid, M. M.,Walter, I.(2009).Do Financial Conglomerates Create or Destroy Economic Value?.Journal of Financial Intermediation,18(2),193-216.
40. Stiroh, K. J.,Rumble, A.(2006).The Dark Side of Diversification: The Case of US Financial Holding Companies.Journal of Banking & Finance,30(8),2131-2161.
41. Uhde, A.,Heimeshoff, U.(2009).Consolidation in Banking and Financial Stability in Europe: Empirical Evidence.Journal of Banking & Finance,33(7),1299-1311.
42. Wagner, W.(2010).Diversification at Financial Institutions and Systemic Crises.Journal of Financial Intermediation,19(3),373-386.
43. Wagner, W.,Marsh, I. W.(2006).Credit Risk Transfer and Financial Sector Stability.Journal of Financial Stability,2(2),173-193.

1. 劉清標(2014)。業務自由化對個別銀行利益與整體銀行系統穩定性之衝突。兩岸金融季刊，2(2)，69-103。
2. (2016)。銀行併購之風險效益研究─臺灣實證分析。臺灣銀行季刊，67(3)，25-41。