環境策略、環境管理、公司治理關聯性之研究－以台灣上市櫃製造業為例

The Relationships among Environmental Strategy, Environmental Management and Corporate Governance- Evidence from Taiwan's Manufacturing Firms

10.3966/207321472019061102004

黃振豊(Cheng-Li Huang)；孔繁華(Fan-Hua Kung)；周純伊(Chun-Yi Chou)

環境策略 ； 環境管理 ； 公司治理 ； 企業社會責任 ； 製造業 ； Environmental Strategy ； Environmental Management ； Corporate Governance ； Corporate Social Responsibility ； Manufacturing Firms

商略學報

11卷2期（2019 / 06 / 01）

151 - 168

繁體中文

本研究旨在探討台灣上市櫃製造業環境策略、環境管理及公司治理之間的關聯性，以2015年及2016年發行企業社會責任報告書之公司為樣本，發展環境策略及環境管理評分量表，採內容分析法對企業社會責任報告書進行評分；公司治理則採公司治理中心評鑑之結果衡量。本研究採二階段估計方法探討企業環境策略與環境管理之關聯性，研究結果指出，環境策略與環境管理之間有正向之關聯性，彼此相互影響，而公司治理與環境策略之間則無直接顯著之關聯性，但公司治理與環境管理會交互影響環境策略，且公司治理會透過環境管理影響環境策略。本研究之結果除了補充相關文獻之不足外，亦可作為企業對環境保護採取之策略及管理上之參考。

The objective of this study was to examine the relationships among environmental strategies, environmental management, and corporate governance in public-listed manufacturing companies in Taiwan. With corporate social responsibility (CSR) reports in 2015 and 2016 as our samples, we developed an environmental management evaluation scale and employed content analysis to assess the CSR reports. Corporate governance was assessed by the evaluations from the Corporate Governance Center of the Taiwan Stock Exchange. This study used a two-stage estimation approach to examine the connection between the environmental strategies and environmental management of firms. The results indicate a positive association between environmental strategies and environmental management. No direct effect existed between corporate governance and environmental strategies; however, there is an interaction between corporate governance and environmental management with respect to their effect on environmental strategies, and corporate governance impacts environmental strategies via environmental management. The results of this study complement for the gap in relevant literature and offer firms reference for strategies and management in environmental protection.

1. Tien, C. L.,Chiu, H. J. C.(2010).The impact of strategic leadership turnover on governance effectiveness: The moderating perspective of industry effect.Journal of Management and Business Research,27(4),337-354.
   連結：
2. 李貴富,廖懿屏,翁偉傑(2016)。銀行業董事會特質如何影響信用評等？。會計學報，6(2)，39-54。
   連結：
3. 洪雪卿,陳薇如,傅雁鈴(2013)。影響企業社會責任績效之重要因素為何？。商管科技季刊，14(4)，405-441。
   連結：
4. 洪榮華,陳香如,林慧珍(2007)。公司治理機制對創新、多角化策略及公司績效之影響－研發密集產業之實證。中山管理評論，15(1)，37-60。
   連結：
5. 高明瑞,劉常勇,黃義俊,張乃仁(2010)。企業綠色管理、環境績效與競爭優勢關聯性之研究。管理與系統，17(2)，255-278。
   連結：
6. 陳宥杉,賴士葆,溫筆東(2005)。環保壓力對企業競爭優勢影響之研究－綠色創新之中介效果。企業管理學報，64，79-102。
   連結：
7. 楊馥如,王偉權,張曉楨,李念慈(2014)。企業社會責任與企業財務績效之關聯性分析。績效與策略研究，11(2)，103-126。
   連結：
8. 盧明滄,林希偉(2010)。綠色環境策略導向之多準則評估模式。運籌與管理學刊，9(2)，1-10。
   連結：
9. Albring, S.,Robinson, D,Robinson, M.(2014).Audit Committee Financial Expertise, Corporate Governance, and the Voluntary Switch from Auditor-Provided to Non-Auditor-Provided Tax Services.Advances in Accounting,30(1),81-94.
10. Berry, M.A.,Rondinelli, D.A.(1998).Proactive Corporate Environmental Management: A New Industrial Revolution.The Academy of Management Executive,12(2),38-50.
11. Brunninge, O.,Nordqvist, M.,Wiklund, J.(2007).Corporate Governance and Strategic Change in SMEs: The Effects of Ownership, Board Composition and Top Management Teams.Small Business Economics,29(3),295-308.
12. Buysse, K.,Verbeke, A.(2003).Proactive Environmental Strategies: A Stakeholder Management Perspective.Strategic Management Journal,24(5),453-470.
13. Carroll, A.B.(1979).The Three-Dimensional Conceptual Model of Corporate Performance.Academy of Management Review,4(4),497-505.
14. Ce´spedes-Lorente, J.,de Burgos-Jime´nez, J.,A´lvarez-Gil, M.J.(2003).Stakeholders Environmental Influence: An Empirical Analysis in the Spanish Hotel Industry.Scandinavian Journal of Management,19(3),333-358.
15. Chang, C.H.(2015).Proactive and Reactive Corporate Social Responsibility: Antecedent and Consequence.Management Decision,53(2),451-468.
16. Chang, C.H.(2011).The Influence of Corporate Environmental Ethics on Competitive Advantage: The Mediation Role of Green Innovation.Journal of Business Ethics,104(3),361-370.
17. Chen, Y.S.(2008).The Driver of Green Innovation and Green Image: Green Core Competence.Journal of Business Ethics,81(3),531-543.
18. Cox, P.,Brammer, S.,Millington, A.(2004).An Empirical Examination of Institutional Investor Preferences for Corporate Social Performance.Journal of Business Ethics,52(1),27-43.
19. de Villiers, C.,Naiker, V.,van Staden, C.J.(2011).The Effect of Board Characteristics on Firm Environmental Performance.Journal of Management,37(6),1636-1663.
20. Du, X.,Jian, W.,Zeng, Q.,Du, Y.(2014).Corporate Environmental Responsibility in Polluting Industries: Does Religion Matter?.Journal of Business Ethics,124(3),485-507.
21. Florida, R.,Davison, D.(2001).Gaining from Green Management: Environmental Management Systems Inside and Outside the Factory.California Management Review,43(3),64-84.
22. Gillan, S.,Starks, L.T.(2003).Corporate Governance, Corporate Ownership, and the Role of Institutional Investors: A Global Perspective.Journal of Applied Finance,13(2),4-22.
23. Groza, M.D.,Pronschinske, M.R.,Walker, M(2011).Perceived Organizational Motives and Consumer Responses to Proactive and Reactive CSR.Journal of Bussiness Ethics,102(4),639-652.
24. Gunningham, N.,Kagan, R. A.,Thornton, D.(2003).Shades of Green: Business, Regulation and Environment.CA:Stanford University Press.
25. Hart, S. L.(1995).A Natural-Resource-Based View of the Firm.Academy of Management Review,20(4),986-1014.
26. Henderson, R.,Cockburn, I.(1994).Measuring Competence? Exploring Firm Effects in Pharmaceutical Research.Strategic Management Journal,15(S1),63-84.
27. Holland, L.,Foo, Y.(2003).Differences in Environmental Reporting Practices in the UK and the US: The Legal and Regulatory Context.The British Accounting Review,35(1),1-18.
28. Kim, Y.(2017).Consumer Responses to the Food Industry’s Proactive and Passive Environmental CSR, Factoring in Price as CSR Tradeoff.Journal of Business Ethics,140(2),307-321.
29. Klassen, R. D.,McLaughlin, C. P.(1996).The Impact of Environmental Management on Firm Performance.Management Science,42(8),1199-1214.
30. Klein, A.(2002).Audit Committee, Board of Director Characteristics, and Earnings Management.Journal of Accounting and Economics,33(3),375-400.
31. Ljungdahl, F.(2004).Factors Influencing Environmental and Social Disclosures.Asian-Pacific Interdisciplinary Perspectives on Accounting Conference,Singapore:
32. Lo, A. W.,Wong, R. M.,Firth, M.(2010).Can Corporate Governance Deter Management from Manipulating Earnings? Evidence from Related-Party Sales Transactions in China.Journal of Corporate Finance,16(2),225-235.
33. Pane Haden, S. S.,Oyler, J. D.,Humphreys, J. H.(2009).Historical, Practical, and Theoretical Perspectives on Green Management: An Exploratory Analysis.Management Decision,47(7),1041-1055.
34. Patten, D. M.(2002).The Relation between Environmental Performance and Environmental Disclosure: A Research Note.Journal of Accounting, Organizations and Society,27(8),763-773.
35. Shrivastava, P.,Addas, A.(2014).The Impact of Corporate Governance on Sustainability Performance.Journal of Sustainable Finance & Investment,4(1),21-37.
36. Torugsa, N.A.,O'Donohue, W,Hecker, R.(2013).Proactive CSR: An Empirical Analysis of the Role of its Economic, Social and Environmental Dimensions on the Association between Capabilities and Performance.Journal of Business Ethics,115(2),383-402.
37. Vazquez-Brust, D.A.,Liston-Heyes, C.,Plaza-Ubeda, J.A.,Burgos-Jimenez, J.(2010).Stakeholders Pressures and Strategic Prioritisation: An Empirical Analysis of Environmental Responses in Argentinean Firms.Journal of Business Ethics,91(S2),171-192.
38. Walley, N.,Whitehead, B.(1994).It’s Not Easy Being Green.Harvard Business Review,72(3),46-52.
39. Walls, J. L.,Berrone, P.,Phan, P. H.(2012).Corporate Governance and Environmental Performance: Is There Really a Link?.Strategic Management Journal,33(8),885-913.
40. Winn, S. F.,Roome, N. J.(1993).R&D Management Responses to the Environment: Current Theory and Implications to Practice and Research.R&D Management,23(2),147-160.
41. Wiseman, J.(1982).An Evaluation of Environmental Disclosures Made in Corporate Annual Reports.Journal of Accounting, Organizations and society,7(1),53-63.
42. 王雅芳(2013)。國立高雄應用科技大學國際企業研究所。
43. 林清河(2006)。策略管理。科學發展，399，12-19。
44. 高惠松,鄭品卉(2012)。集團企業特性、公司治理與社會責任績效。中華管理評論，15(3)，1-34。
45. 張麗娟,晁罡,詹芷樺(2016)。公司治理對期間報酬、經營績效之影響研究: 以臺灣「公司治理評量制度」授證公司為例。中華管理評論，19(1)，1-28。
46. 陳可欣(2005)。淡江大學會計研究所。
47. 陳怡婷(2008)。淡江大學會計研究所。
48. 陳冠宏(2010)。亞洲大學會計與資訊研究所。
49. 程聰,謝宏明(2012)。企業外部環境、綠色經營策略與競爭優勢關係研究: 以環境效益為調節變數。科研管理，33(11)，129-136。
50. 劉思秀(2017)。國立清華大學科技管理研究所。
51. 劉錦鳳(2017)。國立彰化師範大學企業管理學系國際企業經營管理研究所。
52. 鄭伊婷,王建文(2015)。世界公司治理評鑑制度介紹。證券服務，638，25-29。

1. 鄧景宜,蔡允臻,陳明怡,阮黃雲(2020)。How Does Green Marketing Awareness Impact on Purchase Intention in the Retail Setting? The Perspective of Corporate Image。商略學報，12(2)，111-131。
2. 黃振豊,陳詩穎,孔繁華(2020)。環境策略、環境管理與企業價值－以台灣製造業為例。當代會計，21(1)，1-31。