新式腳踝護具對腳踝扭傷運動員之平衡表現與疼痛的影響

The Effect of a Novel Ankle Brace on Balance and Pain for Athletes with Ankle Sprain History

10.3966/207332672017121402004

張曉昀(Hsuai-Yun Chang)；江宛臻(Wan-Zhen Jiang)

腳踝傷害 ； 姿勢控制 ； 護具 ； ankle injury ； posture control ； brace

華人運動生物力學期刊

14卷2期（2017 / 12 / 01）

22 - 29

繁體中文

目的：本研究之目的是利用一個倒L型的墊子固定在腳踝護具內裡、並用外部綁帶綁定遠端腓骨頭做為固定，以及使用這個新式的腳踝護具，針對腳踝曾經扭傷的運動員進行靜態、動態平衡及腳踝疼痛評估。方法：以24名大學業餘運動員(12名男性、12名女性)作為受測者，測試項目包括靜態、動態平衡測試及疼痛評估，先使用獨立樣本t考驗分析控制組與護具組第一次測試的數據；再以相依樣本t考驗分析護具組介入新式護具穿著之前後兩次的數據的差異。結果：結果發現護具組在穿著新式護具後在開眼狀態的靜態平衡晃動面積明顯較未穿著時大，但是晃動軌跡並未有明顯改變；然而在動態平衡的平衡誤差在穿著新式護具後顯著小於未穿著新式護具時，因此也導致整體性的總動態平衡誤差變少，另外在動態活動時的疼痛指數在有無穿著新式護具之間並無差別。結論：穿著新式護具可改善腳踝扭傷運動員整體動態平衡的能力，但是對於維持靜態姿勢的平衡並未有明顯改變，且對於動態活動時的疼痛指數並無改善之效果。

Purpose: The purpose of this study was designed a reverse L pad at inside lining of a novel ankle brace with an outside elastic belt to fibular head fixed and to determine the effect of a novel ankle brace on static and dynamic balance and pain while movements. Methods: Twenty- four amateur collegiate athletes (12 Males and 12 female) were recruited to participate this study and divided into control and brace group. The measured outcomes were static and dynamic balance and pain condition while movements. The independed t test was used to analyze the values of the measured outcomes variables between the control and brace group firstly. Then, the paired-t test was used to analyze the values of the measured outcomes variables between the with-wearing and without wearing for brace group secondly. Results: The results was found that the sway area in open eye condition of the static balance with wearing a novel ankle brace significantly more wide than without wearing brace, but the sway path length have no significantly changed. Also, there were showed the decreased in the dynamic balance error with wearing a novel ankle brace of the brace groups than without wearing brace. The results indicated that the total dynamic balance scores decreased when wearing a novel ankle brace of the brace groups. The pain scale while movements had no significantly difference between wearing or non-wearing a novel brace in brace group. Conclusions: Wearing a novel ankle brace can enhance the dynamic balance for athletes with ankles sprain history. However, it cannot alter the static balance and pain condition while dynamic movements.

1. 林威秀、黎俊彥(2003)。踝內翻外翻肌力與平衡控制的相關。體育學報，34，53-64。
   連結：
2. 張曉昀、吳國輝、吳明哲(2013)。腓骨肌群肌內效貼紮與運動貼紮對踝關節基本運動表現的影響。運動教練科學，29，1-17。
   連結：
3. 鄭世賢(2009)。踝關節貼紮或護具對足踝運動機制影響之探討。大專體育，100，180-185。
   連結：
4. Brown, C.,Bowser, B.,Simpson, K. J.(2012).Movement variability during single leg jump landings in individuals with and without chronic ankle instability.Clinical Biomechanics,7(1),52-63.
5. Doherty, C.,Bleakley, C.,Hertel, J.,Caulfield, B.,Ryan, J.,Delahunt, E.(2015).Single-leg drop landing movement strategies 6 months following first-time acute lateral ankle sprain injury.Scandinavian Journal of Medicine and Science in Sports,25(6),806-17.
6. Eechaute, C.,De Ridder, R.,Maes, T.,Beckwée, D.,Swinnen, E.,Buyl, R.,Vaes, P.(2017).Evidence of a different landing strategy in subjects with chronic ankle instability.Gait and Posture,52,62-67.
7. Eechaute, C.,Vaes, P.,Duquet, W.(2009).The dynamic postural control is impaired in patients with chronic ankle instability: Reliability and validity of the multiple hop test.Clinical Journal of Sports Medicine,19(2),107-114.
8. Faraji, E.,Daneshmandi, H.,Atri, A. E.,Onvani, V.,Namjoo, F. R.(2012).Effects of prefabricated ankle orthoses on postural stability in basketball players with chronic ankle instability.Asian Journal of Sports Medicine,3(4),274-8.
9. Hertel, J.(2002).Functional anatomy, pathomechanics, and pathophysiology of lateral ankle instability.Journal of Athletic Training,37(4),364-375.
10. Hubbard, T.,Hertel, J.(2008).Anterior positional fault of the fibula after sub-acute lateral ankle sprains.Manual Therapy,13,63-67.
11. Hubbard, T.,Hertel, J.,Sherbondy, P.(2006).Fibular position in those with self-reported chronic ankle instability.The Journal of Orthopaedic and Sports Physical Therapy,36,3-9.
12. Hubbard, T.,Olmsted, L.C.,Hertel, J.,Sherbondy, P.(2005).Anterior-posterior mobility of the talus in those with chronic ankle instability.Physical Therapy in Sport,6,146-152.
13. Janssen, K. W.,van Mechelen, W.,Verhagen, E. A.(2014).Bracing superior to neuromuscular training for the prevention of self-reported recurrent ankle sprains: a three-arm randomised controlled trial.British Journal of Sports Medicine,48(16),1235-1239.
14. Kaminski, T. W.,Hertel, J.,Amendola, N.,Docherty, C. L.,Dolan, M. G.,Hopkins, J. T.,Nussbaum, E.,Poppy, W.,Richie, D.(2013).National Athletic Trainers' Association. National Athletic Trainers' Association position statement: conservative management and prevention of ankle sprains in athletes.Journal of Athletic Training,48(4),528-545.
15. Kavanagh, J.(1999).Is there a positional fault at the inferior tibiofibular joint in patients with acute or chronic ankle sprains compared to normals?.Manual Therapy,4(1),19-24.
16. Kemler, E.,van de Port, I.,Schmikli, S.,Huisstede, B.,Hoes, A.,Backx, F.(2015).Effects of soft bracing or taping on a lateral ankle sprain: a non-randomised controlled trial evaluating recurrence rates and residual symptoms at one year.Journal of Foot and Ankle Research,8,13-20.
17. McGuine, T. A.,Brooks, A.,Hetzel, S.(2011).The effect of lace-up ankle braces on injury rates in high school basketball players.The American Journal of Sports Medicine,39(9),1840-1848.
18. Mickel, T. J.,Bottoni, C. R.,Tsuji, G.,Change, K.,Baum, L.,Tokushige, K. A.(2006).Prophylactic bracing versus taping for the prevention of ankle sprains in high school athletes: a prospective, randomized trial.Foot and Ankle Surgery,45(6),360-365.
19. Nawoczenski, D.A.(Ed.),Epler, M. E.(Ed.)(1997).Orthotics in functional rehabilitation of the lower limb.Pennsylvania:W. B. Saunders Company.
20. Reiman, M. P.,Robert, C. M.(2009).Functional testing in human performance.Champaign, IL:Human Kinetics.
21. Sharpe, S. R.,Knapik, J.,Jones, B.(1997).Ankle braces effectively reduce recurrence of ankle sprains in female soccer players.Journal of Athletic Training,32(1),21-24.
22. Sitler, M.,Ryan, J.,Wheeler, B.,McBride, J.,Arciero, R.,Anderson, J.,Horodyski, M.(1994).The efficacy of a semirigid ankle stabilizer to reduce acute ankle injuries in basketball. A randomized clinical study at West Point.The American Journal of Sports Medicine,22(4),454-461.
23. Surve, I.,Schwellnus, M. P.,Noakes, T.,Lombard, C.(1994).A fivefold reduction in the incidence of recurrent ankle sprains in soccer players using Sport-Stirrup orthosis.The American Journal of Sports Medicine,22(5),601-606.
24. Tropp, H.,Askling, C.,Gillquist, J.(1985).Prevention of ankle sprains.The American Journal of Sports Medicine,13(4),259-262.
25. Wikstrom, E. A.,Fournier, K. A.,McKeon, P. O.(2010).Postural control differs between those with and without chronic ankle instability.Gait and Posture,32(1),82-6.
26. Wikstrom, E. A.,Hubbard, T. J.(2010).Talar positional fault in persons with chronic ankle instability.Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation,91(8),1267-71.
27. Wikstrom, E. A.,Tillman, M. D.,Borsa, P. A.(2005).Detection of dynamic stability deficits in subjects with functional ankle instability.Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise,37(2),169-175.
28. Wikstrom, E. A.,Tillman, M. D.,Chmielewski, T. L.,Cauraugh, J. H.,Borsa, P. A.(2007).Dynamic postural stability deficits in subjects with selfreported ankle instability.Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise,39(3),397-402.
29. 王進華、張曉昀、蔚順華(2000)。本體感覺在運動傷害處理與復健所扮演之角色。大專體育，47，66-76。
30. 張曉昀、蔚順華(1999)。肌肉疲勞對本體感覺之影響。中華體育季刊，12(5)，69-75。