臺灣地區大專院校教師對學校評價的影響機制：學校屬性與教師分級的區隔作用

Taiwanese College Instructors' Evaluation of Their Schools: The Differences Among School Attributes and Instructor Ranks

10.6209/JORIES.2014.59(3).02

林俊瑩(Chunn-Ying Lin)；謝亞恆(Ya-Heng Hsieh)；陳成宏(Cheng-Hung Chen)

工作環境 ； 高等教育 ； 教師分級 ； 學校評價 ； 學校屬性 ； work environment ； higher education ； instructor ranks ； evaluations of the school ； school attributes

教育科學研究期刊

59卷3期（2014 / 09 / 01）

29 - 58

繁體中文

在高等教育經營環境日趨嚴苛的情形下，如何讓所屬教職員能認同於學校，並給予高評價，願意努力付出，增進學校榮譽，提高競爭力，當是高等教育經營管理重要的課題。然而，在如何促進大專院校教師對任教學校有高度正面評價的重要問題上，卻仍少有研究關注於不同職場屬性（如公／私立、綜合／科技），與教師分級制度所可能導致的差異性，並深入探討造成差異性的因素。基於此，本研究以臺灣高等教育整合資料庫的大專教師調查資料，對上述重要的研究議題進行分析。研究結果顯示：相較於私立技職院校，公立大學教師在教師聘用、專業發展、待遇福利，職場氛圍等工作環境之滿意度較低，而使其對所任教的學校評價較低。其次，公立技職教師，對於教師任用、專業發展、待遇福利等方面的滿意度都低於私立技職院校，因而對所任教學校的評價也就明顯較低。另外，教授與副教授對學校設備、人力資源、教師任用、專業發展、待遇福利與職場氛圍等，明顯比助理教授有較高的滿意度，因而對所任教的學校也就有較高的評價，而助理教授覺得學校較不夠友善，給的評價也就最低。

Managing higher education is becoming increasingly difficult. How to strengthen the identifications, evaluations, and dedications of faculties to the reputation and competitiveness of their institutions is a critical issue in managing higher education. Little research on how to promote the identification of college instructors with their institutions has focused on differences among job attributes (e.g., public/private, general/technological, and science) and instructor ranks as well as the factors contributing to the differences. This study attempted to answer these questions by using a sample of college instructors obtained from the Taiwan Integrated Postsecondary Education Database. The results showed that compared with instructors at private vocational colleges, instructors at public universities were less satisfied with employment, professional development, salary and benefits, and workplace atmosphere of their institutions and tended to assign relatively lower ratings to their schools. In addition, instructors at public vocational colleges were less satisfied with employment, professional development, and the salary and benefits of their institutions compared with their counterparts at private vocational colleges, which lead to the low rating of their institutions. Analysis of differences according to rank revealed that professors and associate professors were significantly more satisfied than assistant professors with their schools in the aspects of facilities, human resources, employment, professional development, salary and benefits, and workplace atmosphere. Thus, they assigned higher ratings to their schools. Associate professors tended to identify their schools as insufficiently friendly, and thus, their ratings of their schools were the lowest.

1. 宋玫玫、張德勝(2008)。大學校院教師對學校工作環境滿意度之研究。花蓮教育大學學報，26，155-178。
   連結：
2. 李威儀(2011)。有錢趕快撈的彈性薪資制度。臺灣社會研究季刊，82，289-294。
   連結：
3. 林忠正(2009)。懲罰怠惰、流失人才？升等續聘標準的經濟分析。經濟論文叢刊，37(3)，301-323。
   連結：
4. 林俊瑩(2010)。工作滿意度、組織承諾與離職意圖：中小學教師與其他職業之比較。教育實踐與研究，23(1)，1-30。
   連結：
5. 林政逸、楊思偉(2011)。我國公立大學教師人力資源管理之研究。臺中教育大學學報：教育類，25(2)，85-110。
   連結：
6. 張火燦、謝廷豪、劉嘉雯(2007)。員工工作滿意、組織承諾與離職意圖關係的統合分析修正模式。臺灣管理學刊，7(1)，25-42。
   連結：
7. 曾文志(2004)。學生事務專業工作人員工作滿意度相關因素之統合分析。師大學報：教育類，49(2)，161-182。
   連結：
8. 鄭燿男(2004)。國民中小學教師的組織公民行為之影響模式。師大學報：教育類，49(1)，41-62。
   連結：
9. 教育部統計處（2013）。大專院校學校數與學生數。取自http://stats.moe.gov.tw/files/important/OVERVIEW_U0Z.XLS【Department of Statistics, Ministry of Education. (2013). Sum of university and college and sum of student. Retrieved from http://stats.moe.gov.tw/files/important/OVERVIEW_U0Z.XLS】
10. 臺灣高等教育整合資料庫（2013）。93 學年度高等師生問卷調查－大專教師。取自https://srda.sinica.edu.tw/group/sciitem/3/252/D00086Q.pdf【Taiwan Integrated Postsecondary Education Database. (2013). 2004 academic year higher student questionnaire–University and college' teachers. Retrieved from https://srda.sinica.edu.tw/group/sciitem/3/252/D00086Q.pdf】
11. 大學法（2011）。【University Act (2011).】
12. Bagozzi, R. P.,Yi, Y.(1988).On the evaluation of structural equation models.Academic of Marketing Science,16(1),74-94.
13. Bozeman, B.,Gaughan, M.(2011).Job satisfaction among university faculty: Individual, work, and institutional determinants.The Journal of Higher Education,82(2),154-186.
14. Caceres, C. R.,Paparoidamis, G. N.(2007).Service quality, relationship satisfaction, trust, commitment and business-to-business loyalty.European Journal of Marketing,41(7/8),836-867.
15. Chiu, S.-F.,Chen, H.-L.(2005).Relationship between job characteristics and organizational citizenship behavior: The mediational role of job satisfaction.Social Behavior and Personality,33(6),523-540.
16. Clément, R.,Noels, K.,Deneault, B.(2001).Interethnic contact, identity, and psychological adjustments in the mediating and moderating roles of communication.Journal of Social Issues,57(3),559-578.
17. De Mours, G. R.,Abrams, D.,Retter, C.,Gunnarsdottir, S.,Ando, K.(2009).Identification as an organizational anchor: How identification and job satisfaction combine to predict turnover intention.European Journal of Social Psychology,39(4),540-557.
18. Hagner, D.(2000).Primary and secondary labor markets: Implications for vocational rehabilitation.Rehabilitation Counseling Bulletin,44(1),22-29.
19. Huang, T.-C.,Hsiao, W.-J.(2007).The causal relationship between job satisfaction and organization commitment.Social Behavior and Personality,35(9),1265-1276.
20. Iiacqua, J. A.,Schumacher, P.,Li, H. C.(1995).Factors contributing to job satisfaction in higher education.Education,116(1),51-61.
21. Karsh, B.,Booske, B. C.,Sainfort, F.(2005).Job and organizational determinants of nursing home employee commitment, job satisfaction and intent to turnover.Ergonomics,48(10),1260-1281.
22. Lacy, F. J.,Sheehan, B. A.(1997).Job satisfaction among academic staff: An international perspective.Higher Education,34(3),305-322.
23. Mamiseishvili, K.,Rosser, V. J.(2011).Examining the relationship between faculty productivity and job satisfaction.Journal of the Professoriate,5(2),100-132.
24. Melly, B.(2005).Public-private sector wage differentials in Germany: Evidence from quantile regression.Empirical Economics,30(2),505-520.
25. Sezer, A.,Faruk, K.(2010).The relation between the level of job satisfaction and types of personality in high school teachers.Australian Journal of Teacher Education,35(1),27-41.
26. Stevens, P. A.(2004).Academic salaries in the UK and US.National Institute Economic Review,190(1),104-113.
27. Truell, A. D.,Price, W. T.,Joyner, R. L.(1998).Job satisfaction among community college occupational-technical faculty.Community College Journal of Research and Practice,22(2),111-122.
28. Wadsworth, T.(2000).Labor markets, delinquency, and social control theory: An empirical assessment of the mediating process.Social Forces,78(3),1041-1066.
29. Wu, M.-T.(2005)。Research on faculty demographic variables and faculty job satisfaction: A case study of private institutes of technology in the south of Taiwan。Journal of Meiho Institute of Technology，24(2)，93-119。
30. Xu, F.,Shen, J.(2007).Research on job satisfaction of elementary and high school teachers and strategies to increase job satisfaction.Chinese Education & Society,40(5),86-96.
31. Xu, Y. J.(2008).Faculty turnover: Discipline-specific attention is warranted.Research in Higher Education,49(1),40-61.
32. 杜娟娟(2002)。教學與研究─大學教師的工作投入時間。屏東師院學報，17，135-174。
33. 林大森(2002)。高中／高職的公立／私立分流對地位取得之影響。教育與心理研究，25(1)，35-62。
34. 林生傳(2003)。教育研究法：全方位的統整與分析。臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan:心理=Psychological。
35. 林俊瑩(2011)。教師組織公民行為的跨教育階段比較分析：學前教師的特殊性與其影響機制。教育政策論壇，14(3)，155-188。
36. 陳碧祥(2001)。我國大學教師升等制度與教師專業成長及學校發展定位關係之探究。國立臺北師範學院學報，14，163-208。
37. 曾敏傑、徐毅君(2005)。勞動市場結構與失業現象的關聯。臺灣社會福利學刊，4(2)，49-96。
38. 黃芳銘(2003)。結構方程模式：理論與應用。臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan:五南=Wu-Nan Book。
39. 黃毅志(2001)。臺灣地區多元勞力市場的事業成就之比較分析。行政院國家科學委員會研究彙刊：人文及社會科學，11(4)，356-370。
40. 黃毅志(2001)。臺灣地區勞力市場分隔之探討：流動表分析。臺灣社會學刊，25，157-200。
41. 劉欣宜(2005)。全球化脈絡下大學擴充對高等教育資源分配之影響。課程研究，1(1)，85-101。

1. 陳敦源(Don-Yun Chen);賴怡樺(Yi-Hua Lai);郭昱瑩(Yu-Ying Kuo);葉馨(Hsin Yeh)(2022)。國立大專校院預算員額調控機制之研究：政策問題之建構與分析。教育科學研究期刊。67(2)。125-153。 
2. 黃娸毓(2016)。補習班英語教師專業與福利之研究。義守大學企業管理學系學位論文。2016。1-64。