取得中學教職的關鍵因素：運用決策樹探勘師資培育歷程

Critical Factors of Becoming Secondary School Teachers: Mining the Process of Teacher Education by Decision Trees

10.6209/JORIES.2017.62(2).04

黃嘉莉(Jia-Li Huang)；葉怡芬(Yi-Fen Yeh)；許瑛玿(Ying-Shao Hsu)；曾元顯(Yuen-Hsien Tseng)

決策樹 ； 教師證書 ； 教職 ； 學科教學知識 ； decision tree ； pedagogical content knowledge ； teacher certificate ； teacher job

教育科學研究期刊

62卷2期（2017 / 06 / 01）

89 - 123

繁體中文

本研究旨在透過大量的教育數據，運用資料探勘技術中的決策樹演算法，分析師資生於現行的師資培育歷程中，取得中學教師資格與取得正式教職的關鍵因素，以作為改進師資培育的參考。本研究以一所傳統師範體系的綜合大學2003~2010 年入學的師資生為對象，運用開源碼軟體Weka分類演算法中的決策樹，針對每位師資生經歷5 年培育歷程中修課與培訓的數據，進行資料探勘，用以瞭解取得教師證書與正式教職的關鍵因素。本研究主要結果為：一、三個主要學院（文、理、教育學院）的師資生取得教職所需年限有別（特別是理學院差異較大）；二、取得教師證書的關鍵因素是教育專業知識，而取得正式教職的關鍵因素則為專門知識與學科教學知識。此外，師資生拓展多元經驗亦有機會取得教職，且目前結果顯示教育實習成績並非是取得教師證書與教師工作的關鍵因素。本研究再以各類文獻驗證上述部分結果，提供師資培育較佳作法的參考建議。

This study aimed to identify the critical factors leading teacher students to successfully receive teacher certificates and become secondary school teachers by mining vast educational data using decision trees in order to provide actionable suggestions to improve teacher education. The five-year learning evidence of the teacher students enrolled during 2003-2010 school years from a normal university in Taiwan was collected and then analyzed with the open source data mining software Weka by use of its decision tree algorithms. The major findings include: (1) Years spent to receive a teacher job were different among the three major colleges, namely colleges of Education, Liberal Arts, and Science; (2) Education knowledge is the critical predictor to receive a teacher certificate, while pedagogical content knowledge and content knowledge play the most critical roles to obtain a teacher job. In addition, more practical experiences were also useful to obtain a teacher job, and the score of education practicum was an ineffective predictor, as the current result shows. This study verifies part of the findings with previous work to provide solid suggestions for better teacher education practice.

1. 朱苑瑜、葉玉珠(2003)。實習教師信念改變的影響因素之探討。師大學報：教育類，48(1)，41-66。
   連結：
2. 周愚文、洪仁進、吳淑禎(2010)。國立臺灣師範大學學生對師資培育課程修習認知與意願之調查研究。中等教育，61(4)，40-59。
   連結：
3. 張其祿(2003)。美國醫療管制政策之政治經濟分析。歐美研究，33(1)，1-55。
   連結：
4. 郭淑芳(2013)。我國師資培育數量規劃政策實施之效能分析。測驗統計年刊，21，61-86。
   連結：
5. 黃凱旻、金鈐(2003)。一個輔導中學數學實習教師教學概念轉變的行動研究。師大學報：科學教育類，48(1)，23-46。
   連結：
6. 黃嘉莉(2016)。第一期卓越師資培育獎學金學生教學準備度之研究。教育研究與發展期刊，12(1)，1-38。
   連結：
7. 黃嘉莉、武佳瀅(2015)。我國教育實習學生知覺教師專業知能習得、運用與重要之研究。教育研究與發展期刊，60(2)，1-32。
   連結：
8. 王麗雲、張民杰、張素貞（2013）。100 學年度大三／四技三師資生調查描述性分析報告。取自https://teacher.edu.tw/web/file/report/hedu_100junior_p.pdf【Wang, L.-Y., Chang, M.-C., & Chang, S.-C. (2013). A descriptive analysis for year 3 student teachers in 100 academic semester. Retrieved from https://teacher.edu.tw/web/file/report/hedu_100junior_p.pdf】
9. American Association of Colleges for Teacher Education. (2013). edTPA. Retrieved from http://edtpa.aacte.org/
10. Robinson, S. (2013, November 8). AACTE Celebrates Official Launch of edTPA. Retrieved from http://edprepmatters.net/2013/11/announcing-edtpa-field-test-results-recommended-passing-sco re/
11. Alexander, R. J.(Ed.),Craft, M.(Ed.),Lynch, J.(Ed.)(1984).Change in teacher education: Context and provision since Robbins.London, UK:Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
12. Ball, D. L.,Forzani, F. M.(2009).The work of teaching and the challenge for teacher education.Journal of Teacher Education,60(5),497-511.
13. Bandura, A.(1977).Self-efficacy: Toward a unifying theory of behavior change.Psychological Review,84(2),191-215.
14. Bastick, T.(2000).Why teacher trainees choose the teaching profession: Comparing trainees in metropolitan and developing countries.International Review of Education,46(3-4),343-349.
15. Begle, E. G.(1979).Critical variables in mathematics education.Washington, DC:Mathematical Association of American and National Council of Teachers of Mathematics.
16. Brown, J. S.,Collins, A.,Duguid, P.(1989).Situated cognition and the culture of learning.Educational Researcher,18(1),32-42.
17. Calderhead, J.(Ed.)(1987).Exploring teachers' thinking.New York, NY:Taylor and Francis.
18. Carver, C. L.,Feiman-Nemser, S.(2009).Using policy to improve teacher induction: Critical elements and missing pieces.Educational Policy,23(2),295-328.
19. Cochran-Smith, M.(2001).Constructing outcomes in teacher education: Policy, practice and pitfalls.Educational Policy Analysis Archives,9(11),1-56.
20. Darling-Hammond, L.(2006).Constructing 21st-century teacher education.Journal of Teacher Education,57(3),300-314.
21. Darling-Hammond, L.(2001).Teacher testing and the improvement of practice.Teaching Education,12(1),11-34.
22. Darling-Hammond, L.(2000).Teacher quality and student achievement: A review of state policy evidence.Educational Policy Analysis Archives,8(1),1-44.
23. Darling-Hammond, L.(2013).Getting teacher evaluation right: What really matters for effectiveness and improvement.New York, NY:Teacher College.
24. Darling-Hammond, L.,Snyder, J.(2000).Authentic assessment of teaching in context.Teaching and Teacher Education,16(5-6),523-545.
25. Dills, C. R.(Ed.),Romiszowski, A. J.(Ed.)(1997).Instructional development paradigms.Englewood Cliffs, NJ:Educational Technology.
26. Dodl, N. R.(1973).Selecting competency outcomes for teacher education.Journal of Teacher Education,24(3),194-199.
27. Druva, C. A.,Anderson, R. D.(1983).Science teacher characteristics by teacher behavior and by student outcome: A meta-analysis of research.Journal of Research in Science Teaching,20(5),467-479.
28. Elam, S.(1971).Performance based teacher education: What is the state of the art?.Washington, DC:American Association of Colleges for Teacher Education.
29. Epstein, R. M.,Hundert, E. M.(2002).Defining and assessing professional competence.JAMA,287(2),226-235.
30. Fayyad, U. M.(Ed.),Piatetsky-Shapiro, G.(Ed.),Smyth, P.(Ed.),Uthurusamy, R.(Ed.)(1996).Advances in knowledge discovery and data mining.Menlo Park, CA:American Association for Artificial Intelligence.
31. Feiman-Nemser, S.(2003).What new teachers need to learn.Educational Leadership,60(8),25-29.
32. Feiman-Nemser, S.,Remillard, J.(1995).,未出版
33. Fives, H.(Ed.),Gill, M. G.(Ed.)(2014).International handbook of research on teachers' beliefs.New York, NY:Routledge.
34. Freund, Y.,Mason, L.(1999).The alternating decision tree learning algorithm.16th International Conference on Machine Learning,Bled, Slovenia:
35. Fullan, M.(Ed.)(2005).Fundamental change: International handbook of educational change.Amsterdam, The Netherlands:Springer.
36. Gess-Newsome, J.(Ed.),Lederman, N. G.(Ed.)(1999).PCK and science education.Dordrecht, The Netherlands:Kluwer Academic.
37. Goldhaber, D.,Anthony, E.(2004).,未出版
38. Graddy, E.(1991).Toward a general theory of occupational regulation.Social Science Quarterly,72(4),676-695.
39. Grossman, P.,McDonald, M.(2008).Back to the future: Directions for research in teaching and teacher education.American Educational Research Journal,45(1),184-205.
40. Haertel, E. H.(1991).New forms of teacher assessment.Review of Research in Education,17(1),3-29.
41. Hertzberg, H. W.(1976).Competency based teacher education: Does it have a past or a future?.Teachers College Record,78(1),1-21.
42. Hollins, E. R.(2011).Teacher preparation for quality teaching.Journal of Teacher Education,62(4),395-407.
43. Howsam, R. B.,Corrigan, D. C.,Denemark, G. W.(1985).Educating a profession.Washington, DC:American Association of Colleges for Teacher Education.
44. Hoy, A. W.(2000).Changes in teacher efficacy during the early years of teaching.annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association,New Orleans, LA:
45. Izumi, L. T.(Ed.),Evers, W. M.(Ed.)(2002).Teacher quality.Stanford, CA:Hoover Institution.
46. Klug, J.,Bruder, S.,Schmitz, B.(2016).Which variable predict teachers' diagnostic competence when diagnosing students' learning behavior at different stages of a teacher's career?.Teachers and Teaching: Theory and Practice,22(4),461-484.
47. Korthagen, F.(2004).In search of the essence of a good teacher: Towards a more holistic approach in teacher education.Teaching and Teacher Education,20(1),77-97.
48. Labone, E.(2004).Teacher efficacy: Maturing the construct through research in alternative paradigms.Teaching and Teacher Education,20,341-359.
49. Lave, J.,Wenger, E.(1991).Situated learning: Legitimate peripheral participation.New York, NY:Cambridge University Press.
50. Lindsey, M.(1973).Performance-based teacher education: Examination of a slogan.Journal for Teacher Education,24(3),180-186.
51. Löfström, E.,Poom-Valicks, K.,Hannula, M. S.,Mathews, S. R.(2010).Supporting emerging teacher identities: Can we identify teacher potential among students?.European Journal of Teacher Education,33(2),167-184.
52. Meijer, P. C.,de Graaf, G.,Meirink, J.(2011).Key experiences in student teachers' development.Teachers and Teaching: Theory and Practice,17(1),115-129.
53. Park, H.,Byun, S.-Y.(2015).Why some countries attract more high-ability young students to teaching: Cross-National comparisons of students' expectation of becoming a teacher.Comparative Education Review,59(3),523-549.
54. Richardson, V.(Ed.)(2001).Handbook of research on teaching.Washington, DC:American Educational Research Association.
55. Rots, I.,Aelterman, A.,Vlerick, P.,Vermeulen, K.(2007).Teacher education, graduates' teaching commitment and entrance into the teaching profession.Teaching and Teacher Education,23(5),543-556.
56. Shulman, L. S.(1987).Knowledge and teaching: Foundations of the new reform.Harvard Educational Review,57(1),1-23.
57. Shulman, L. S.(1975).,未出版
58. Sikula, J.(Ed.)(1993).Handbook of research on teacher education.New York, NY:Macmillan.
59. Soled, S. W.(Ed.)(1995).Assessment, testing and evaluation in teacher education.Norwood, NJ:Ablex.
60. Sternberg, R. J.(Ed.),Zhang, L. F.(Ed.)(2000).Perspectives on cognitive, learning, and thinking styles.Mahwah, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
61. Tamir, P.(1991).Professional and personal knowledge of teachers and teacher educators.Teaching & Teacher Education,7(3),263-268.
62. Tschannen-Moran, M.,Hoy, A. W.(2001).Teacher efficacy: Capturing an elusive construct.Teaching and Teacher Education,7(7),783-805.
63. Tseng, Y.-H.,Lin, C.-J.,Lin, Y.-I.(2007).Text mining techniques for patent analysis.Information Processing and Management: An International Journal,43(5),1216-1247.
64. Turner-Bisset, R.(1999).The knowledge bases of the expert teacher.British Educational Research Journal,25(1),39-55.
65. Valli, L.,Rennert-Ariev, P.(2002).New standards and assessments? Curriculum transformation in teacher education.Journal of Curriculum Studies,34(2),201-225.
66. Webster, N. L.,Valeo, A.(2011).Teacher preparedness for a changing demographic of language learners.TESL Canada Journal,28(2),105-128.
67. Whitty, G.,Willmott, E.(1991).Competence-based teacher education: Approaches and issues.Cambridge Journal of Education,21(3),309-318.
68. Wideen, M.,Mayer-Smith, J.,Moon, B.(1998).A critical analysis of the research on learning to teach: Making the case for an ecological perspective on inquiry.Review of Educational Research,68(2),130-178.
69. Wilson, A. H.(1982).Cross-cultural experiential learning for teachers.Theory Into Practice,21(3),184-192.
70. Wilson, S. M.(Ed.)(2004).The wisdom of practice: Essays on teaching, learning, and learning to teach.San Francisco, CA:Jossey-Bass.
71. Witten, I. H.,Frank, E.,Hall, M. A.(2011).Data mining: Practical machine learning tools and techniques.Burlington, MA:Morgan Kaufmann.
72. Wittrock, M. C.(Ed.)(1986).Handbook of research on teaching.New York, NY:Macmillan.
73. 吳璧如(2002)。教師效能感之理論分析。教育研究資訊，10(2)，45-64。
74. 李俊湖、陳志強、陳禎祐、白博仁、陳文俊、劉淑甄、楊淑敏(2007)。少子化趨勢下臺灣師資培育之困境與省思。第106 期國小校長儲訓班專題研究彙編，新北市=New Taipei City, Taiwan:
75. 周祝瑛(2003)。誰捉弄了臺灣教改？。臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan:心理=Psychology。
76. 林新發、王秀玲、鄧珮秀(2007)。我國中小學師資培育現況、政策與展望。教育研究與發展期刊，3(1)，57-79。
77. 洪志成(2005)。教師檢定測驗不是教師專業最後防線。現代教育論壇，12，462-477。
78. 孫志麟(2001)。教師自我效能與教學行為的關係：實徵取向的分析。國立臺北師範學院學報，14，109-140。
79. 許育齡(2006)。教師效能感研究的取向及限制：邁向變動教師效能感的探究。慈濟大學教育研究學刊，2，109-137。
80. 黃嘉莉(2015)。臺灣師資培育制度市場化與專業化之回顧與省思。《師資培育法》20 年來的回顧與前瞻，臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan:
81. 黃嘉莉(2013)。標準本位師資培育理念與實踐。臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan:國立臺灣師範大學出版中心=National Taiwan Normal University Press。
82. 黃嘉莉(2015)。從美國edTPA 表現評量檢視我國師資職前培育的發展。臺灣教育評論月刊，4(4)，87-92。
83. 楊深坑編、黃嘉莉編(2011)。各國師資培育制度與教師素質現況。臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan:教育部=Ministry of Education。
84. 葉連祺(2004)。中小學教師檢定方法相關課題之分析。教師檢定之理論與實務會議論文集，臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan:
85. 薛梨真、朱潤康(2007)。半年全時實習問題探究。教育研究與發展期刊，3(1)，209-237。

1. 黃嘉莉(Jia-Li Huang);武佳瀅(Chia-Ying Wu)(2022)。Content and Language Integrated Learning for Teaching the Theoretical Language of Sociology of Education to Preservice Teachers: A Quasi-Experimental Study。教育科學研究期刊。67(2)。243-268。