题名

表現本位教育實習成績評量制度之建構及其試辦成果分析

并列篇名

Outcomes of the Application of Performance-Based Assessment System for Educational Practicums

DOI

10.6209/JORIES.202103_66(1).0001

作者

黃嘉莉(Jia-Li Huang)；武佳瀅(Chia-Ying Wu)

关键词

表現本位評量 ； 師資培育 ； 教育實習 ； 臨床表現評量 ； performance-based assessment ； teacher education ； educational practicum ； clinic performance assessment

期刊名称

教育科學研究期刊

卷期/出版年月

66卷1期（2021 / 03 / 01）

页次

1 - 38

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

因應2017年《師資培育法》調整先考試後實習，讓教育實習成績成為取得教師證書的重要依據。本研究基於國際趨勢與相關研究，建構以表現為本的實習成績評量制度，並蒐集利害關係人意見，以瞭解制度試辦的成效。本研究建構評量制度後經過試辦，回收實習學生330份、實習輔導教師255份、實習指導教師41份問卷後，運用SPSS 22軟體進行統計描述分析與質化編碼。本研究發現在表現評量任務的設計上，能讓利害關係人對教育實習歷程有整體性認識、促使實習輔導教師瞭解幫助實習學生方法、促進互動並增進實習輔導教師自我反思，以及減輕革新成績評量負擔的效果；在表現評量任務設計上，能精進實習學生專業教學能力，但任務表單的設計仍有調整的空間；在表現評量方法上，能讓評量實習學生表現更為客觀與具有共識。
英文摘要

This study aimed to design a new performance-based assessment system for educational practicums to replace the high-risk assessment included in the Teacher Education Act, amended in 2017. Data were collected from stakeholders' opinions, including 330 student teachers, 255 cooperating teachers, and 41 teacher educators through descriptive statistics. The results demonstrated that the newly developed system allows stakeholders to understand the whole educational practicum process, allows participating teachers to better understand the ways they can help student teachers, facilitates stakeholder interactions, stimulates participating teachers' reflections, and reduces the burden due to previous reforms to the education practicum assessment system. Second, the tasks can promote student teachers' professional competence, but must be adjusted for tasks that are too cumbersome. Third, the use of performance-based assessment methods can make the outcome of assessments more objective and reach a consensus. This research developed an original performance evaluation system that parallels international trends and conforms to the characteristics of educational practicum situated learning. This research also provides additional design ideas and evidence for the transformation of the educational practicum system in Taiwan as a basis for granting teacher certificates.
主题分类 社會科學 > 教育學
参考文献
  1. 朱苑瑜, Y.-Y.,葉玉珠, Y.-C.(2003)。實習教師信念改變的影響因素之探討。師大學報：教育類，48(1)，41-65。
    連結：
  2. 林明地, M.-D.(2009)。近年來我國教育政策的關鍵問題與可能對策。學校行政，60，1-9。
    連結：
  3. 符碧真, B.-J.(2018)。素養導向國教新課綱的師資培育：國立臺灣大學「探究式─素養導向的師資培育」理想芻議。教育科學研究期刊，63(4)，59-87。
    連結：
  4. 符碧真, B.-J.,黃源河, Y.-R.(2016)。實地學習：銜接師資培育理論與實務的藥方？。教育科學研究期刊，61(2)，57-84。
    連結：
  5. 黃凱旻, K.-M.,金鈐, C.(2003)。一個輔導中學數學實習教師教學概念轉變的行動研究。師大學報：科學教育類，48(1)，23-46。
    連結：
  6. 黃嘉莉, J.-L.(2019)。師資養成公費制度之歷史探究。教育科學研究期刊，64(2)，99-129。
    連結：
  7. 黃嘉莉, J.-L.(2013)。我國教育實習制度設計之結構邏輯分析。教育研究與發展，9(3)，115-142。
    連結：
  8. 黃嘉莉, J.-L.(2012)。美國加州檢核職前教師表現制度之研究。教育研究與發展期刊，8(1)，93-123。
    連結：
  9. 黃嘉莉, J.-L.,武佳瀅, C.-Y.(2015)。我國教育實習學生知覺教師專業知能習得、運用與重要之研究。教育科學研究期刊，60(2)，1-32。
    連結：
  10. 黃嘉莉, J.-L.,陳學志, H.-C.,王俊斌, C.-P.,洪仁進, J.-C.(2020)。師資職前教師專業素養與課程基準之建構及其運用。教育科學研究期刊，65(2)，1-35。
    連結：
  11. 鄭聖襦, S.-R.,靳知勤, C.-C.(2007)。國中科學實習輔導教師之輔導策略、輔導障礙來源及其專業成長。科學教育學刊，15(2)，145-168。
    連結：
  12. Bartell, C. A.(1995).Shaping teacher induction policy in California.Teacher Education Quarterly,22(4),27-43.
  13. Bastian, K. C.,Lys, D.,Pan, Y.(2018).A framework for improvement: Analyzing performance-assessment scores for evidence-based teacher preparation program reforms.Journal of Teacher Education,69(5),448-462.
  14. Boursicot, K.,Etheridge, L.,Setna, Z.,Sturrock, A.,Ker, J.,Smee, S.,Sambandam, E.(2011).Performance in assessment: Consensus statement and recommendation from the Ottawa conference.Medical Teacher,33(5),370-383.
  15. Brookhart, S. M.(1999).Response to Delandshere and Petrosky’s "Assessment of complex performances: Limitations of key measurement assumptions".Educational Researcher,28(3),25-28.
  16. Brown, J. S.,Collins, A.,Duguid, P.(1989).Situated cognition and the culture of learning.Educational Researcher,18(1),32-42.
  17. Brownstein, E. M.,Horvath, L.(2016).Next generation science standards and edTPA: Evidence of science and engineering practices.Electronic Journal of Science Education,20(4),44-62.
  18. Burton, A.(1977).Competency-based teacher education in the U.S.A..Compare,7(1),31-39.
  19. Chizhik, E. W.,Chizhik, A. W.,Close, C.,Gallego, M.(2017).SMILE (shared mentoring in instructional learning environments): Effectiveness of a lesson-study approach to student-teaching supervision on a teacher-education performance assessment.Teacher Education Quarterly,44(2),27-47.
  20. Cobb, P.,McClain, K.,de Silva Lamberg, T.,Dean, C.(2003).Situating teachers’ instructional practices in the institutional setting of the school and district.Educational Researcher,32(6),13-24.
  21. Cochran-Smith, M.,Lytle, S. L.(1999).Relationships of knowledge and practice: Teacher learning in communities.Review of Research in Education,24(1),249-305.
  22. Darling-Hammond, L.(1994).Performance-based assessment and educational equity.Harvard Educational Review,64(1),5-31.
  23. Darling-Hammond, L.(2001).Teacher testing and the improvement of practice.Teaching Education,12(1),11-34.
  24. Darling-Hammond, L.(2008).Reshaping teaching policy, preparation, and practice: Influences of the national board for professional teaching standards.Assessing teachers for professional certification: The first decade of the National Board for Professional Teaching Standards
  25. Darling-Hammond, L.,Snyder, J.(2000).Authentic assessment of teaching in context.Teaching and Teacher Education,16(5-6),523-545.
  26. Educative Teacher Performance Assessment(2018).Educative assessment & meaningful support: 2017 edTPA administrative report.
  27. Elam, S.(1972).Performance-based teacher education: What is the state of the art?.Quest,18(1),14-19.
  28. Epstein, R. M.,Hundert, E. M.(2002).Defining and assessing professional competence.JAMA,287(2),226-235.
  29. Ericsson, K. A.,Charness, N.(1994).Expert performance: Its structure and acquisition.American Psychologist,49(8),725-747.
  30. Ginsburg, L. R.,Tregunno, D.,Norton, P. G.,Smee, S.,de Vries, I.,Sebok, S. S.,VanDenKerkhof, E. G.,Luctkar-Flude, M.,Medves, J.(2015).Development and testing of an objective structured clinical exam (OSCE) to assess socio-cultural dimensions of patient safety competency.BMJ Quality & Safety,24(3),188-194.
  31. Grossman, P.,Pupik Dean, C. G.(2019).Negotiating a common language and shared understanding about core practices: The case of discussion.Teaching and Teacher Education,80,157-166.
  32. Guaglianone, C. L.,Payne, M.,Kinsey, G. W.,Chiero, R.(2009).Teaching performance assessment: A comparative study of implementation and impact amongst California State University Campuses.Issues in Teacher Education,18(1),129-148.
  33. Hafner, A. L.,Maxie, A.(2006).Looking at answers about reform: Findings from the SB 2042 implementation study.Issues in Teacher Education,15(1),85-102.
  34. Hager, P.,Gonczi, A.(1996).What is competence?.Medical Teacher,18(1),15-18.
  35. Hertzberg, H. W.(1976).Competency based teacher education: Does it have a past or a future?.Teachers College Record,78(1),1-21.
  36. Kennedy, M.(Ed.)(2010).Teacher assessment and the quest for teacher quality.John Wiley & Sons.
  37. Khan, K.,Ramachandran, S.(2012).Conceptual framework for performance assessment: Competency, competence and performance in the context of assessments in healthcare-Deciphering the terminology.Medical Teacher,34(11),920-928.
  38. Kohler, F.,Henning, J. E.,Usma-Wilches, J.(2008).Preparing preservice teachers to make instructional decisions: An examination of data from the teacher work sample.Teaching and Teacher Education,24(8),2108-2117.
  39. Lampert, M.(2010).Learning teaching in, from, and for practice: What do we mean?.Journal of Teacher Education,61(1-2),21-34.
  40. Lave, J.,Wenger, E.(1991).Situated learning: Legitimate peripheral participation.Cambridge University Press.
  41. Lawrence, J. E. S.,Cook, T. J.(1982).Designing program evaluations with the help of stakeholders.Journal of Policy Analysis and Management,2(1),120-123.
  42. Lindsey, M.(1973).Performance-based teacher education: Examination of a slogan.Journal for Teacher Education,24(3),180-186.
  43. Linn, R. L.,Gronlund, N. E.(2000).Measurement and assessment in teaching.Prentice-Hall.
  44. Little, J. W.(2002).Locating learning in teachers’ communities of practice: Opening up problems of analysis in records of everyday work.Teaching and Teacher Education,18(8),917-946.
  45. Lunsford, A.,Warner, W. J.,Park, T. D.,Morgan, J. E.(2016).Agricultural education teacher candidates’ perceptions of the edTPA.Career and Technical Education Research,41(3),213-225.
  46. Messick, S.(1994).The interplay of evidence and consequences in the validation of performance assessments.Educational Researcher,23(2),13-23.
  47. Meuwissen, K. W.,Choppin, J. M.(2015).Preservice teachers’ adaptations to tensions associated with the edTPA during its early implementation in New York and Washington States.Education Policy Analysis Archives,23(103),1-25.
  48. Miller, G. E.(1990).The assessment of clinical skills/competence/performance.Academic Medicine,65(9),S63-S67.
  49. Miller, R. L.,Brickman, P.,Bolen, D.(1975).Attribution versus persuasion as a means for modifying behavior.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,31(3),430-441.
  50. Orey, M. A.,Nelson, W. A.(1997).The impact of situated cognition: Instructional design paradigms in Transition.Instructional development paradigms
  51. Panzarella, K. J.,Manyon, A. T.(2007).A model for integrated assessment of clinical competence.Journal of Allied Health,36(3),157-164.
  52. Parkes, K. A.,Powell, S. R.(2015).Is the edTPA the right choice for evaluating teacher readiness?.Arts Education Policy Review,116(2),103-113.
  53. Patton, J. Q.(2005).Meat sharing for coalitional support.Evolution and Human Behavior,26(2),137-157.
  54. Pring, R.(2004).Teaching and the good teacher.Education and the good society
  55. Rennert-Ariev, P.(2005).A theoretical model for the authentic assessment of teaching.Practical Assessment, Research & Evaluation,10(2),1-11.
  56. Resnick, L. B.(1987).Education and learning to think.National Academy Press.
  57. Rethans, J.-J.,Norcini, J. J.,Barón-Maldonado, M.,Blackmore, D.,Jolly, B. C.,LaDuca, T.,Lew, S.,Page, G. G.,Southgate, L. H.(2002).The relationship between competence and performance: Implications for assessing practice performance.Medical Education,36(10),901-909.
  58. Rozelle, J. J.,Wilson, S. M.(2012).Opening the black box of field experiences: How cooperating teachers’ beliefs and practices shape student teachers’ beliefs and practices.Teaching and Teacher Education,28(8),1196-1205.
  59. Sandholtz, J. H.,Shea, L. M.(2015).Examining the extremes: High and low performance on a teaching performance assessment for licensure.Teacher Education Quarterly,42(2),17-42.
  60. Selvester, P. M.,Summers, D.,Williams, E. F.(2006).Costs and benefits of accountability: A case study of credential candidates’ performance assessment.Issues in Teacher Education,15(1),21-36.
  61. Shepard, L. A.(2000).The role of assessment in a learning culture.Educational Researcher,29(7),4-14.
  62. Shulman, J. H.(Ed.)(1992).Case methods in teacher education.Teacher College Press.
  63. Shulman, L. S.(1975).Teaching as clinical information processing.NIE Conference on studies in teaching (Panel 6)
  64. Shulman, L. S.(1988).A union of insufficiencies: Strategies for teacher assessment in a period of education reform.Educational Leadership,46(3),36-41.
  65. Shulman, L. S.(1987).Knowledge and teaching: Foundations of the new reform.Harvard Educational Review,57(1),1-23.
  66. Shulman, L. S.,Elstein, A. S.(1975).Studies of problem solving, judgment, and decision making: Implications for educational research.Review of Research in Education,3(1),3-42.
  67. Sikula, J.(Ed.)(1996).Handbook of research on teacher education.Macmillan.
  68. Soled, S. W.(Ed.)(1995).Assessment, testing, and evaluation in teacher education.Ablex.
  69. Talvitie, U.,Peltokallio, L.,Mannisto, P.(2000).Student teachers’ views about their relationships with university supervisors, cooperating teachers and peer student teachers.Scandinavian Journal of Education Research,44(1),79-88.
  70. Trent, J.,Lim, J.(2010).Teacher identity construction in school-university partnerships: Discourse and practice.Teaching and Teacher Education,26(8),1609-1618.
  71. Ulvik, M.,Smith, K.(2011).What characterises a good practicum in teacher education?.Education Inquiry,2(3),517-536.
  72. Valli, L.,Rennert-Ariev, P.(2002).New standards and assessments? Curriculum transformation in teacher education.Journal of Curriculum Studies,34(2),201-225.
  73. Walsh, K. (2001). Teacher certification reconsidered: Stumbling for quality (executive summary). https://abell.org/sites/default/files/publications/ed_cert_rejoinder_1101.pdf
  74. Wang, J.,Odell, S. J.,Schwille, S. A.(2008).Effects of teacher induction on beginning teachers’ teaching.Journal of Teacher Education,59(2),132-152.
  75. Wass, V.,der Vleuten, C. V.,Shatzer, J.,Jones, R.(2001).Assessment of clinical competence.The Lancet,357(9260),945-949.
  76. Wei, R. C.,Pecheone, R. L.(2010).Assessment for learning in preservice teacher education: Performance-based assessments.Teacher assessment and the quest for teacher quality: A handbook
  77. Wenger, E.(1998).Communities of practice: Learning, meaning, and identity.Cambridge University Press.
  78. Whitty, G.,Willmott, E.(1991).Competence-based teacher education: Approaches and issues.Cambridge Journal of Education,21(3),309-318.
  79. Wolf, K.(1991).The school teacher’s portfolio: Issues in design, implementation, and evaluation.Phi Delta Kappan,73(2),129-136.
  80. Zaltman, G.,Burger, P.(1975).Marketing research: Fundamentals and dynamics.Dryden Press.
  81. 丁志權, C.-C.(2004)。落實以學校為基地的實習輔導制度。現代教育論壇十三卷
  82. 王素芸, S.-Y.,賴光真, K.-J.(2004)。教育實習的概念分析─論我國教育實習制度及其改革。國立編譯館館刊，32(1)，48-59。
  83. 吳清山, C.-S.(2006)。臺灣教育改革的檢討與策進：1994~2006年。教育資料集刊，32，1-21。
  84. 李麗玲, L., L.,陳益興, Y.-H.,郭淑芳, S.-F.,陳盛賢, S.-H.,楊思偉, S.-W.,連啟瑞, C.-J.,黃坤龍, K.-L.(2009)。,國家教育研究院籌備處=National Academy for Educational Research Preparatory Office。
  85. 林凱胤, K.-Y.,王國華, K.-H.(2007)。實習教師經由觀摩與反思途徑擷取輔導教師內隱知識之研究。屏東教育大學學報：教育類，27，31-50。
  86. 洪志成, C.-C.(2005)。教師檢定測驗不是教師專業最後防線。現代教育論壇，12，462-477。
  87. 張佳琳（2013）。美國公布第一套全國性師資培育標準本位表現評量─edTPA。取自https://fepaper.naer.edu.tw/edm.php?edm_no=41&content_no=2180 【Chang, C.-L. (2013) The United States announced the first set of national performance evaluation standards for teacher education－edTPA. https://fepaper.naer.edu.tw/edm.php?edm_no=41&content_no=2180】
  88. 張芬芬, F.-F.(1995)。我國師範教育發展現況與評估研究。第七次全國教育會議實錄
  89. 黃嘉莉, J.-L.(2015)。從美國edTPA表現評量檢視我國師資職前培育的發展。臺灣教育評論月刊，4(4)，87-92。
  90. 楊深坑（編）, S.-K.(ed.),王秋絨（編）, C.-J.(ed.),李奉儒（編）, F.-J.(ed.)(2012).各國師資培育認證制度之比較.高等教育=Higher Education.
  91. 楊深坑, S.-K.,黃嘉莉, J.-L.(2011)。各國師資培育制度與教師素質比較分析。各國師資培育制度與教師素質之現況
  92. 葉連祺, L.-C.(2004)。中小學教師檢定方法相關課題之分析。教師檢定之理論與實務會議論文集
  93. 歐用生, Y.-S.,黃嘉雄, C.-H.(1997)。落實高級中等以下學校暨幼稚園實習教師教育實習之研究。教育研究資訊，5(5)，15-30。
  94. 賴清標（編）, C.-P.(ed.)(1997).教育實習.五南=Wu-Nan.
  95. 薛梨真, L.-C.,朱潤康, J.-K.(2007)。半年全時實習問題探究。教育研究與發展期刊，3(1)，209-238。
被引用次数
  1. 黃嘉莉,陳美如,翁暄睿(2022)。1980～2020年國際師資培育研究聚類與趨勢分析。教育科學研究期刊，67(3)，1-35。
print cancel