我國大學校院經濟弱勢學生協助就學措施之研究

Taiwan's Aid Systems for Economically Underprivileged Students in Higher Education

10.6209/JORIES.202203_67(1).0005

許添明(Tian-Ming Sheu)；董馨梅(Hsin-Mei Tung)；商雅雯(Ya-Wen Shang)

高等教育 ； 經濟弱勢學生 ； 獎助學金制度 ； higher education ； economically underprivileged students ； student aid system

教育科學研究期刊

67卷1期（2022 / 03 / 01）

123 - 158

繁體中文

我國政府為降低經濟弱勢學生因家庭背景影響其求學意願，提供多項協助措施，但研究仍指出有高比例的大專校院弱勢學生仰賴工讀填補就學所需，且繁瑣的獎學金申請程序降低弱勢學生申請意願。本研究以實際受助者觀點，邀請14位低收入、中低收入學生，以及教育部擴大就學照顧的「大專校院弱勢學生助學計畫」適用學生，進行兩場焦點團體訪談，探討我國政府提供給不同類型經濟弱勢生的各項協助措施是否足夠就學所需，以及其配套是否確實有助於降低經濟弱勢學生就學阻礙。研究結果發現，公立大專校院低收入生獲得的就學資源足夠其所需，私立大專校院低收入學生仍稍有不足，但中低收入學生與「大專校院弱勢學生助學計畫」適用學生獲得的資源卻遠不足以填補就學所需缺口；工讀措施名稱混淆，內涵又與學生學習衝突；且多項協助措施申請辦法不易理解，也未能有效傳播，導致有需要的學生及家長，申辦過程阻礙重重。本研究依據上述研究發現提供政策建議。

Research Motivation and Purpose: The Taiwanese government has developed numerous financial aid measures to reduce the burden of higher education expenses for economically disadvantaged students. However, a large majority of economically disadvantaged university students continue to raise their education expenses through work-study opportunities. Furthermore, the complicated scholarship application process discourages students from applying for available scholarships, suggesting that the resources and measures aimed at supporting disadvantage students are inadequate. To address the dearth of information in this area, this study invited economically disadvantaged students who had received government assistance during their studies to participate in focus groups. This study aimed to (1) investigate whether the support measures offered by the government to students from low-income and lower-middle-income families and to students receiving funding from the Financial Aid Project for Economically Disadvantaged Students in Higher Education are sufficient to assist these students in their studies and (2) identify obstacles to the practical application of these support measures. Literature Review: Reflecting the research goals, the literature review discusses relevant theoretical research in the field of student financial aid. It includes a discussion of the advantages and disadvantages of educational assistance measures and the current efforts by the Taiwanese government to assist economically disadvantaged students with their educational expenses, as well as related problems and responses. The literature reveals that scholarships are the most direct method of reducing student financial burdens and that work-study programs that address both educational expenses and the student's future development offer long-term benefits. Taiwan has expanded the number of recipients of funding from the Financial Aid Project for Economically Disadvantaged Students in Higher Education and has worked to strengthen work-study programs to ensure a connection between the work done and the student's studies. However, the literature demonstrates that insufficient scholarships and work-study opportunities result in most students still choosing to work off-campus. Methodology: This study was based on a consideration of schooling needs and support measures for a wide range of students enrolled in different types of universities. Fourteen students studying at four higher education institutions-public and private universities and public and private science and technology universities-were invited to participate. Each student came from a low-income or lower-middle-income family or was receiving funding from the Financial Aid Project for Economically Disadvantaged Students in Higher Education. This study investigated the channels and quotas for financial aid opportunities that are purportedly available to economically disadvantaged students and explored each interviewee's actual experiences regarding the availability of such resources, as well as the barriers to entry created by the operational nature of financial assistance measures. Research Results: The results reveal that low-income students in both public and private universities can reduce the financial burden of higher education without applying for additional loans by accessing various government scholarships and stipends. However, students from lower-middle-income families who receive funding from the Financial Aid Project for Economically Disadvantaged Students in Higher Education are still unable to acquire their schooling expenses through government scholarships and stipends, highlighting the ineffectiveness of existing financial aid measures for the most economically disadvantaged students. In addition, information regarding financial assistance is still not sufficiently updated or relayed to the students and families who need it the most. Even if parents and students receive the necessary information, the confusion caused by the names and qualifications of the different measures and the unfriendly and cumbersome nature of the application process reduces willingness to apply. Discussion and Research Suggestions: To support economically disadvantaged students starting or finishing their tertiary education, the author suggests the following: (1) The number of scholarships and amount of aid available to students from lower-middle-income families and students under the Financial Aid Project for Economically Disadvantaged Students in Higher Education should be increased. (2) Work-study programs should be implemented with a focus on the student's current studies or future career, and the labeling of the assistance measures should be standardized to help students distinguish their available options. (3) Finally, the updating and circulation of financial aid-related information should be improved. This study offers the Ministry of Education and universities a summary table of scholarships, the materials and deadlines for applications, and a point of contact that students and their families can access easily.

1. 吳淑禎（2018）。生涯韌力：大學青年的生涯逆境知覺及其因應策略之研究。教育科學研究期刊，63（3），197-230。【Wu, S.-C. (2018). Career resilience: Career adversities and the effects of coping strategies on higher education students’ career path. Journal of Research in Education Sciences, 63(3), 197-230. 】
   連結：
2. 沈暉智、林明仁（2019）。論家戶所得與資產對子女教育之影響─以1993-1995出生世代及其父母稅務資料為例。經濟論文叢刊，47（3），393-453。【Shen, H.-C., & Lin, M.-J. (2019). Education opportunity inequality across income in Taiwan. Taiwan Economic Review, 47(3), 393-453. 】
   連結：
3. 胡詠翔、俞慧芸（2020）。以教育大數據分析驅動入學管理機制開設新生銜接課程提升就學穩定度之研究。教育科學研究期刊，65（4），31-63。 【Hu, Y.-H., & Yu, H.-Y. (2020). Improving retention rate through educational data mining: The design of placement program for newly enrolled students. Journal of Research in Education Sciences, 65(4), 31-63. 】
   連結：
4. 郭姿妤（2015）。父母移轉金、打工行為與學業成績之研究（未出版碩士論文）。國立臺灣大學。 【Kao, T.-Y. (2015). The analysis of parental transfer, part-time work behaviors, and academic performances of college students [Unpublished master’s thesis]. National Taiwan University. 】
   連結：
5. 鄭英耀、方德隆、莊勝義、陳利銘、劉敏如（2015）。大學經濟弱勢學生入學及就學扶助政策分析與建議。教育科學研究期刊，60（4），1-19。【Cheng, Y.-Y., Fang, D.-L., Chuang, S.-Y., Chen, L.-M., & Liu, M.-J. (2015). Expanding access to and participation in higher education for low-SES students: Policy analysis and suggestions. Journal of Research in Education Sciences, 60(4), 1-19. 】
   連結：
6. 駱明慶（2004）。升學機會與家庭背景。經濟論文叢刊，32（4），417-445。 【Luoh, M.-C. (2004). Educational opportunities and family background in Taiwan. Taiwan Economic Review, 32(4), 417-445. 】
   連結：
7. Cabrera, A. F., Stampen, J. O., & Hansen, W. L. (1990). Exploring the effects of ability to pay on persistence in college. The Review of Higher Education, 13(3), 303-336.
   連結：
8. Chen, R. (2008). Financial aid and student dropout in higher education: A heterogeneous research approach. Higher Education: Handbook of Theory and Research, 23, 209-239.
   連結：
9. Dowd, A. C., & Coury, T. (2006). The effect of loans on the persistence and attainment of community college students. Research in Higher Education, 47(1), 33-62.
   連結：
10. Goldrick-Rab, S., Harris, D. N., & Trostel, P. A. (2009). Why financial aid matters (or does not) for college success: Toward a new interdisciplinary perspective. Higher Education: Handbook of Theory and Research, 24, 1-45.
    連結：
11. Kelchen, R. (2015). Campus-based financial aid programs: Trends and alternative allocation strategies. Educational Policy, 31(4), 448-480.
    連結：
12. Malcom, L. E., & Dowd, A. C. (2012). The impact of undergraduate debt on the graduate school enrollment of STEM baccalaureates. The Review of Higher Education, 35(2), 265-305.
    連結：
13. McDonough, P. M., & Calderone, S. (2006). The meaning of money: Perceptual differences between college counselors and low-income families about college costs and financial aid. American Behavioral Scientist, 49(12), 1703-1718.
    連結：
14. Mendoza, P., Mendez, J. P., & Malcolm, Z. (2009). Financial aid and persistence in community colleges: Assessing the effectiveness of federal and state financial aid program in Oklahoma. Community College Review, 37(2), 112-135.
    連結：
15. Morgan, D. L. (1988). Focus groups as qualitative research. Sage.
    連結：
16. B405Development. (2018). Education at a glance 2018: OECD indicators. Author.
    連結：
17. Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development. (2020). Education at a glance 2020: OECD indicators. Author.
    連結：
18. Paulsen, M. B., & St. John, E. P. (2002). Social class and college costs: Examining the financial nexus between college choice and persistence. The Journal of Higher Education, 73(2), 189-236.
    連結：
19. Sackett, P. R., Kuncel, N. R., Beatty, A. S., Rigdon, J. L., Shen, W., & Kiger, T. B. (2012). The role of socioeconomic status in SAT-grade relationships and in college admissions decisions. Psychological Science, 23(9), 1000-1007.
    連結：
20. Schneider, A. (2010). Redistributive taxation vs. education subsidies: Fostering equality and social mobility in an intergenerational model. Economics of Education Review, 29(4), 597-605.
    連結：
21. Scott-Clayton, J., & Minaya, V. (2016). Should student employment be subsidized? Conditional counterfactuals and the outcomes of work-study participation. Economics of Education Review, 52, 1-46.
    連結：
22. Smith, L. (2011). Experiential “hot” knowledge and its influence on low-SES students’ capacities to aspire to higher education. Critical Studies in Education, 52(2), 165-177.
    連結：
23. Tekleselassie, A. A., & Johnstone, D. B. (2004). Means testing: The dilemma of targeting subsidies in African higher education. Journal of Higher Education in Africa / Revue de l’enseignement supérieur en Afrique, 2(2), 135-158.
    連結：
24. 王如哲、楊瑩、劉秀曦、張珍瑋、黃家凱（2014）。我國推動經濟弱勢學生之人才培育政策分析與發展。臺灣經濟論衡，12（2），61-83。【Wang, R.-J., Yang, Y., Liou, S.-S., Chang, C.-W., & Huang, C.-K. (2014). Analysis and development of Taiwan’s policies to promote talent cultivation of economically disadvantaged students. Taiwan Economic Forum, 12(2), 61-83.】
25. 行政院（2018）。推動兒童及少年未來教育與發展帳戶—協助弱勢孩童自立脫貧。https://www. ey.gov.tw/Page/5A8A0CB5B41DA11E/52d1abd9-87f2-4863-b745-7ab2510b6d67 【Executive Yuan. (2018). The accounts for promoting future education and development of children and adolescents-assist disadvantaged children to be independent and away from poverty. https://www.ey.gov.tw/　Page/5A8A0CB5B41DA11E/52d1abd9-87f2-4863-b745-7ab2510b6d67】
26. 行政院主計總處（2019）。家庭收支調查報告。https://win.dgbas.gov.tw/fies/a11.asp?year=108 【Directorate General of Budget, Accounting and Statistics of Executive Yuan. (2019). Report on the survey of family income & expenditure. https://win.dgbas.gov.tw/fies/a11.asp?year=108】
27. 低收入生及中低收入生就讀高級中等以上學校學雜費減免辦法（2016）。 【Regulations for Tuition Fees Exemption of the Upper Secondary and Higher Education (2016).】
28. 李高英（2015）。大專校院學雜費爭議及其相關問題之研析（上）。立法院國會月刊，43（2），90-124。 【Li, K.-Y. (2015). An analysis of the depute and related issue about higher education tuition fees. Congress Monthly, 43(2), 90-124.】
29. 沈美真、吳豐山（2010）。大專校院弱勢學生助學計畫調查報告（0990800582）。監察院。 【Shen, M.-C., & Wu, F.-S. (2010). Report of the financial aid project for economically disadvantaged university students (0990800582). Control Yuan.】
30. 林效荷（2014）。近年各級學生輟學及休退學概況分析。https://stats.moe.gov.tw/files/analysis/103_　all_dropout.pdf 【Lin, H.-H. (2014). An analysis of dropouts, suspended or withdrawn students at all levels of schools in recent years. https://stats.moe.gov.tw/files/analysis/103_all_dropout.pdf】
31. 社會救助法（2020）。 【The Social Asistance’s Act (2020).】
32. 洪伯勳（2015）。製造低收入戶。群學。 【Hung, H.-H. (2015). Manufacturing low-income families. Socio.】
33. 財團法人台灣兒童暨家庭扶助基金會（2014）。大專生工讀狀況調查分析報告。作者。 【Taiwan Fun for Children and Families. (2014). The survey report on work-study conditions of college students. Author.】
34. 高級中等以上學校學生就學貸款作業要點（2017）。 【Working Guidelines for the Upper Secondary and Higher Education Student Loan (2017).】
35. 高等教育深耕計畫（2017）。 【Higher Education Sprout Project (2017).】
36. 教育部（2014）。教育，實現夢想的力量─大專校院助學措施。https://studentaff.ctu.edu.tw/var/ file/3/1003/img/104/111307626.pdf 【Ministry of Education. (2014). Education, the power to achive dreams－University students student-aided. https:// studentaff.ctu.edu.tw/var/file/3/1003/img/104/111307626.pdf】
37. 教育部（2015）。起飛計畫─啟動對弱勢學生的全程關照。https://www.edu.tw/news_Content. aspx?n=9E7AC85F1954DDA8&s=1FEB9E95590E50D8 【Ministry of Education. (2015). FLYUP project－Initiate full care for disadvantaged students. https://www.edu.tw/ news_Content.aspx?n=9E7AC85F1954DDA8&s=1FEB9E95590E50D8】
38. 教育部（2019）。大專校院弱勢學生助學計畫。https://www.edu.tw/helpdreams/cp.aspx?n=294130 B70B308624&s=A8A03607552A5F17# 【Ministry of Education. (2019). The financial aid project for economically disadvantaged university students. https://www.edu.tw/helpdreams/cp.aspx?n=294130B70B308624&s=A8A03607552A5F17#】
39. 教育部大專校院校務資訊公開平臺（2019）。學雜費減免人數─以「校」統計。https://udb. moe.edu.tw/DetailReportList/%E6%A0%A1%E5%8B%99%E9%A1%9E/MoeTuitionsFeesWavier/Index 【College and University School Affairs Information Disclosure Platform of the Ministry of Education. (2019). The number of tuition and miscellaneous fee exemptions－counted by “school”. https://udb.moe.edu.tw/Detail ReportList/%E6%A0%A1%E5%8B%99%E9%A1%9E/MoeTuitionsFeesWavier/Index】
40. 教育部高等教育司（2021）。103-107學年度高級中等以上學校學生申請就學貸款人次、人數及貸款金額。https://ws.moe.edu.tw/001/Upload/4/relfile/0/4764/e2270c3b-2f9a-458b-b582-c661 eb83aeb6.csv 【Department of Higher Education of the Ministry of Education. (2021). The count, applicant numbers and amount of the Upper Secondary and Higher Education Student Loan in Academic Years 2014-2018. https://ws.moe.edu. tw/001/Upload/4/relfile/0/4764/e2270c3b-2f9a-458b-b582-c661eb83aeb6.csv】
41. 21.      教育部統計處（2020）。各級教育學齡人口粗在學率。http://stats.moe.gov.tw/files/ebook/ Education_Statistics/109/109edu_A_2_4.xls 【Department of Statistics of the Ministry of Education. (2020). Gross enrollment ratio by educational level. http:// stats.moe.gov.tw/files/ebook/Education_Statistics/109/109edu_A_2_4.xls】
42. 教育部學產基金設置低收入生助學金實施要點（2018）。 【Directions for the Low-Income Student Aids in Education Property Foundation of the Ministry of Education (2018).】
43. 教育部辦理大學校院弱勢學生學習輔導補助計畫審查作業要點（2018）。 【Directions for Disadvantaged University Students Learning Guidance Program of the Ministry of Education (2018).】
44. 勞動部（2006）。大學生打工狀況調查統計。作者。 【Ministry of Labor (2006). Survey and statistics of college students’ part-time work. Author.】
45. 彭森明（2005，3月26日）。高等教育如何趨向公平化（研討會論文）。「台灣高等教育資料庫之建置及相關議題之探討」第一階段成果報告研討會，新竹市，臺灣。 【Peng, S.-M. (2005, March 26). How does higher education tend to be fair [Paper presentation]. “Taiwan Higher Education Data System and Its Applications” the first stage pproceedings, Hsinchu, Taiwan.】
46. 黃朝琴（2021）。學習取代工讀 助弱勢生翻轉未來。青年日報。https://tw.news.yahoo.com/%E5 %AD%B8%E7%BF%92%E5%8F%96%E4%BB%A3%E5%B7%A5%E8%AE%80-%E5%8A%A9%E5%BC%B1%E5%8B%A2%E7%94%9F%E7%BF%BB%E8%BD%89%E6%9C%AA%E4%BE%86-160000302.html?guccounter=1 【Huang, C.-C. (2021). Learning instead of working: Turning around the future of disadvantaged students. Youth Daily News. https://tw.news.yahoo.com/%E5%AD%B8%E7%BF%92%E5%8F%96%E4%BB%A3%E5%B7 %A5%E8%AE%80-%E5%8A%A9%E5%BC%B1%E5%8B%A2%E7%94%9F%E7%BF%BB%E8%BD%89%E6%9C%AA%E4%BE%86-160000302.html?guccounter=1】
47. 楊瑩、楊國賜、劉秀曦、黃家凱（2012）。台灣高等教育擴張後教育公平現況之檢視。高等教育，7（2），1-35。https://doi.org/10.3966/199254762012120702001 【Yang, Y., Yang, K.-S., Liu, H.-H., & Huang, C.-K. (2012). Examining the education equity reality after higher education expansion in Taiwan. Journal of Higher Education, 7(2), 1-35. https://doi.org/10.3966/19925476 2012120702001】
48. 劉金山（2009）。臺灣高等教育助學機制評鑑之研究：運用理論導向模式（未出版博士論文）。國立政治大學。 【Liou, C.-S. (2009). A study on evaluation of the higher education financial aid mechanism in Taiwan: Adopting a theory-driven model [Unpublished doctoral dissertation]. National Chengchi University.】
49. 衛生福利部（2019）。109年最低生活費、低收入戶及中低收入戶資格審核標準及109年度低收入戶類別條件一覽表。https://dep.mohw.gov.tw/dosaasw/cp-566-49605-103.html 【Minstry of Health and Welfare. (2019). The credentialing standards of minimum cost of living, low-income and middle-low-income in 2020 and the category list of low-income family in 2020. https://dep.mohw.gov.tw/ dosaasw/cp-566-49605-103.html】
50. 蕭霖（2015）。高等教育學費與就學貸款政策分析。復文圖書。 【Hsiao, L. (2015). Policy analysis for higher education tuition and student loan. Fu Wen Books.】
51. 賴怡芳（2014）。理想與現實之間！自行負擔費用的大學生之生活（未出版碩士論文）。靜宜大學。 【Lai, Y.-F. (2014). The dream and the reality! The life of the college students who work for their living expenses [Unpublished master’s thesis]. Providence University.】
52. 謝文瑾（2014）。高等教育學雜費之公共論述：以臺灣學生團體為例（未出版碩士論文）。國立臺灣師範大學。 【Hsieh, W.-C. (2014). A public discourse on tuition fees for higher education: A perspective of student groups in Taiwan [Unpublished master’s thesis]. National Taiwan Normal University.】
53. 魏惠娟（2004）。焦點團體。載於謝臥龍（主編），質性研究（頁273-315）。心理。 【Wei, H.-C. (2004). Focus group. In W.-L. Hsieh (Ed.), Qualitative research (pp. 273-315). Psychological.】
54. Alliance for Excellent Education. (2013). Repairing a broken system: Fixing federal student aid. https://mk0all4edorgjxiy8xf9.kinstacdn.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/RepairingBrokenSystem.pdf.
55. Becker, G. S. (1993). Human capital: A theoretical and empirical analysis, with special reference to education (3rd ed.). The University of Chicago Press.
56. Britt, S. L., Ammerman, D. A., Barrett, S. F., & Jones, S. H. (2017). Student loans, financial stress, and college student retention. Journal of Student Financial Aid, 47(1), 25-37.
57. Brown, M. (2020). College students are dropping out without cosigners: Survey & report. https:// lendedu.com/blog/college-students-dropping-out-without-cosigners
58. Campaigne, D. A., & Hossler, D. (1998). How do loans affect the educational decisions of students? In R. Fossey & M. Bateman (Eds.), Condemning students to debt (pp. 85-104). Teachers College Press.
59. Chapman, S. (2015). Student loans and the labor market: Evidence from merit aid programs. https:// cpb-us-e1.wpmucdn.com/sites.northwestern.edu/dist/7/687/files/2015/09/Download-Job-Market-Paper-PDF-274452u.pdf
60. Cofer, J., & Somers, P. (2000). A comparison of the influence of debt load on the persistence of students at public and private colleges. Journal of Student Financial Aid, 30(2), 39-58.
61. College Atlas. (2018). U.S. college dropout rate and dropout statistics. https://www.collegeatlas.org/ college-dropout.html
62. Cottom, T. C. (2017). Lower Ed: The troubling rise of for-profit colleges in the new economy. The New Press.
63. Courant, P. N., McPherson, M., & Resch, A. M. (2006). The public role in higher education. National Tax Journal, 59(2), 291-318.
64. Davidson P. (2017). Are student loans as big of a problem as people think? https://www.usatoday. com/story/money/2017/07/07/student-loans-big-problem-people-think/101842736/
65. Dynarski, S., & Scott-Clayton, J. (2008). Complexity and targeting in federal student aid: A quantitative analysis. In J. M. Poterba (Ed.), Tax policy and the economy (Vol. 22, pp. 109-150). The University of Chicago Press. https://doi.org/10.3386/w13801
66. Johnstone, D. B. (2005). Higher educational accessibility and financial viability: The role of student loans. https://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.496.5497&rep=rep1&type=pdf
67. Johnstone, D. B., & Marcucci, P. N. (2010). Financing higher education worldwide: Who pays? Who should pay? JHU Press.
68. Long, B. T. (2011). The new financial aid policies: Their impact on access and equity for low-income students? In L. M. Stulberg & S. L. Weinberg (Eds.), Diversity in American higher education: Toward a more comprehensive approach (pp. 232-246). Routledge.
69. Lynch, M., Engle, J., & Cruz, J. L. (2011). Priced out: How the wrong financial-aid policies hurt low-income students. https://edtrust.org/resource/priced-out-how-the-wrong-financial-aid- policies-hurt-low-income-students/
70. McPherson, M. S., & Schapiro, M. O. (2006). US higher education finance. In E. Hanushek & F. Welch (Eds.), Handbook of the economics of education (Vol. 2, pp. 1403-1434). Elsevier.
71. Mian, A., Rao, K., & Sufi, A. (2013). Household balance sheets, consumption, and the economic slump. https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/75a5/00894c5ffa5f9203a7e223e3a61f9eb7aa29.pdf
72. Morgan, D. L., & Krueger, R. A. (1993). When to use focus groups and why. In D. L. Morgan (Ed.), Successful focus groups: Advancing the state of the art (pp. 3-19). Sage.
73. Mundel, D. (2008). What do we know about the impact of grants to college students? In S. Baum, M. McPherson, & P. Steele (Eds.), The effectiveness of student aid policies: What the research tells us (pp. 9-38). The College Board.
74. Mundel, D., & Rice, L. D. (2008). The impact of increases in Pell grant awards on college-going among lower income youth. https://www.brookings.edu/research/the-impact-of-increases-in-pell- grant-awards-on-college-going-among-lower-income-youth/
75. National Association of Student Financial Aid Administrators. (2013). National student aid profile: Overview of 2013 federal programs. https://www.nasfaa.org/uploads/documents/2013_national_ profile.pdf
76. National Association of Student Financial Aid Administrators. (2015). National student aid profile: Overview of 2015 federal programs. http://www.nasfaa.org/uploads/documents/2015_national_ profile_2.pdf
77. National Audit Office. (2017). The higher education market. https://www.nao.org.uk/wp-content/ uploads/2017/12/The-higher-education-market.pdf
78. Sachs, J. D. (2011). The price of civilization: Reawakening American virtue and prosperity. Random House.
79. Soliz, A., & Long, B. T. (2016). Does working help or hurt college students? The effects of federal work-study participation on student outcomes (CAPSEE Working Paper). http://capseecenter.org/does-working-help-or-hurt-college-students/
80. Tanner, R. M., & Association of Public and Land-Grant Universities. (2012). Federal student aid: Access and completion. APLU.
81. The Institute for College Access & Success. (2013). Student debt and the class of 2012. Author.
82. Thomas, L. (2012). Building student engagement and belonging in higher education at a time of change. Paul Hamlyn Foundation. https://www.heacademy.ac.uk/sites/default/files/resources/What_works_final_report.pdf
83. Trow, M. (2006). Class, race, and higher education in America (UC Berkeley Working Paper). https://escholarship.org/uc/item/46n8670k
84. Wilkinson, R. (2005). Aiding students, buying students: Financial aid in America. Vanderbilt University Press.
85. Ziderman, A., & Albrecht, D. (1995). Financing universities in developing countries. The Falmer Press.

1. (2024)。大學經濟弱勢女學生的月經貧窮：影響與改善行動。學生事務與輔導，63(1)，61-82。