Qualitative Approaches to Evaluating Social Media Influencers: A case-based LITERATURE review

10.7903/ijecs.2025

Kangmin Cho；Kichang Jung；Michele Lee；Yena Lee；Jaewon Park；Neal Dreamson

influencer ； qualitative evaluation ； social media ； marketing strategy ； social marketing

International Journal of Electronic Commerce Studies

13卷2期（2022 / 06 / 01）

119 - 136

英文

With the age of the Internet upon us, many marketing strategies have come to focus on social media influencers. Current research about social media influencers conveys the quantitative values of influencers' capacity, but the numbers are readily manipulated with automated bots and other methods. Therefore, in this case-based literature review, we aim to demonstrate the legitimacy to evaluate influencers' performance from qualitative perspectives. We found ten qualitative factors, such as credibility, appearance, connectedness, and so on, from a review of relevant 37 journal articles identified from keywords searching on academic databases. Then, we redefined and remapped the factors by thematically reviewing 39 promotion video clips from 13 popular social media influencers in lifestyle, which results in 52 indicators. We semantically and systematically classified the indicators with three larger qualitative themes and nine sub-themes: (a) credibility: expertise, trustworthiness, and quality content, (b) engagement: interpersonal interaction, quality presentation, and personal branding; (c) connectivity: participatory activities, collaborating with others, and socially networking. For qualitative approaches to social media influencers, we articulated applicable analysis methods to each sub-theme. In this study, we demonstrated the potential of an alternative to existing quantitative evaluation methods that marketers could consider it in their recruitment and evaluation of social media influencers to find the right social media influencers.

1. Ahrens, P.(2018).Qualitative network analysis: A useful tool for investigating policy networks in transnational settings?.Methodological Innovations,11(1)
2. A. Akhtar. (2019, Oct. 8). 11 scientific reasons why attractive people are more successful in life. Insider [Online]. Available at:https://www.businessinsider.com/beautiful-people-make-more-money-2014-11
3. Almeida, F.,Faria, D.,Queirós, A.(2017).Strengths and limitations of qualitative and quantitative research methods.European Journal of Education Studies,3(9),369-387.
4. Almström, J.,Egertz, L.,Truong, B.(2019).Jönköping University.
5. Balaban, D.,Mustățea, M.(2019).Users’ perspective on the credibility of social media influencers in Romania and Germany.Romanian Journal of Communication and Public Relations,21(1),31-46.
6. Bauer, J.K.(2020).Portland State University.
7. G. Bergstrom. (2020, Sep. 12). What Are Opinion Leaders? The Balance Small Business [Online]. Available at: https://www.thebalancesmb.com/who-are-opinion-leaders-and-why-do-they-matter-2295976
8. Bian, X.,Moutinho, L.(2011).The Role of Brand Image, Product Involvement, and Knowledge in Explaining Consumer Purchase Behaviour of Counterfeit: Direct and Indirect Effects.European Journal of Marketing,45(1/2),191-216.
9. Braun, V.,Clarke, V.(2006).Using thematic analysis in psychology.Qualitative Research in Psychology,3(2),77-101.
10. Bullock L (2018, January 09). How to evaluate and partner with social media influencers. Social Media Examiner [Online]. Available at: https://www.socialmediaexaminer.com/partner-social-media-influencers/
11. Casaló, L.,Flavián, C.,Ibáñez-Sánchez, S.(2020).Influencers on Instagram: Antecedents and consequences of opinion leadership.Journal of Business Research,117,510-519.
12. Cho, E.,Son, J.(2019).The effect of social connectedness on consumer adoption of social commerce apparel shopping.Fashion and Textiles,6,14.
13. D’Alessandro, S.,Chitty, B.(2011).Real or relevant beauty? Body shape and endorser effects on brand attitude and body image.Psychology & Marketing,28(8),843-878.
14. Damásio, M.J.,Dia, P.,Andrade, J.G.(2012).The PR pyramid: Social media and the new role of public relations in organizations.Revista internacional de relaciones públicas,2(4),11-30.
15. Enke, N.,Borchers, N.S.(2019).Social media influencers in strategic communication: A conceptual framework for strategic social media influencer communication.International Journal of Strategic Communication,13(4),261-277.
16. Freberg, K.,Graham, K.,Mcgaughey, K.,Freberg, L.A.(2011).Who are the social media influencers? A study of public perceptions of personality.Public Relations Review,37(1),90-92.
17. Ginevičius, R.,Podvezko, V.,Ginevičius, A.(2017).Quantitative Evaluation of Enterprise Marketing Activities.Journal of Business Economics and Management,14(1),200-212.
18. Glucksman, M.(2017).The rise of social media influencer marketing on lifestyle branding: A case study of Lucie Fink.Elon Journal of Undergraduate Research in Communications,8(2),77-87.
19. Gorbatov, S.,Khapova, S.N.,Lysova, E.I.(2019).Get noticed to get ahead: The impact of personal branding on career success.Front Psychology,9
20. Hanna, R.,Rohm, R.,Crittenden, V.(2011).We’re all connected: The power of the social media ecosystem.Business Horizons,54(3),265-273.
21. Harris, L.C.,Goode, M.M.H.(2010).Online servicescapes, trust, and purchase intentions.Journal of Services Marketing,24(2-3),230-243.
22. Hassan, S.H.,Teo, S.Z.,Ramayah, T.,Al-Kumaim, N.H.(2021).The credibility of social media beauty gurus in young millennials’ cosmetic product choice.Plos one,16(3)
23. Hsieh, H.F.,Shannon, S.E.(2005).Three approaches to qualitative content analysis.Qualitative Health Research,15(9),1277-1288.
24. Jang, H.S.,Yoh, E.(2020).Perceptions of male and female consumers in their 20s and 30s on the 3D virtual influencer.The Research Journal of the Costume Culture,28(4),446-462.
25. Jarrar, Y.,Awobamise, A.O.,Aderibigbe, A.A.(2020).Effecrtiveness of influencer marketing vs social media sponsored advertising.Utopía y Praxis Latinoamericana,25(12),40-54.
26. Jin, S.V.,Muqaddam, A.,Ryu, E.(2019).Instafamous and social media influencer marketing.Marketing Intelligence & Planning,37(5),567-579.
27. Jun, S.,Yi, J.(2020).What makes followers loyal? The role of influencer interactivity in building influencer brand equity.Journal of Product & Brand Management,29(6),803-814.
28. Kádeková, Z.,Holienčinová, M.(2018).Influencer marketing as a modern phenomenon creating a new frontier of virtual opportunities.Communication Today,9,90-105.
29. Kaplan, A.,Haenlein, M.(2010).Users of the World, Unite! The Challenges and Opportunities of Social Media.Business Horizons,53(1),59-68.
30. S. Kemp. (2020, Jan. 30). Digital 2020: Global Digital Overview. Datareportal [Online]. Available at: https://datareportal.com/reports/digital-2020-global-digital-overview
31. S. Kemp. (2017, Jan. 24). Digital in 2017: Global Overview. We are social [Online]. Available at: https://wearesocial.com/special-reports/digital-in-2017-global-overview
32. Khalid, N.L.,Jayasainan, S.Y.,Hassim, N.(2018).Social Media Influencers -Shaping consumption culture among Malaysian youth.SHS Web of Conferences,53(2),1-12.
33. Ki, C.W.C.,Kim, Y.K.(2019).The mechanism by which social media influencers persuade consumers: The role of consumers’ desire to mimic.Psychology & marketing,36(10),905-922.
34. C.M. Kim. (2016, Mar. 4). Four ways to gain credibility in social media.Institute for Public Relations [Online]. Available at: https://instituteforpr.org/four-ways-to-gain-credibility-in-social-media/
35. Lim, B.C.,Cheung, C.M.Y.(2014).Word-of-Mouth: The use of source expertise in the evaluation of familiar and unfamiliar brands.Asia Pacific Journal of Marketing and Logistics,26(1),39-53.
36. Lim, X.J.,Radzol, A.R.M.,Cheah, J.H.,Hashim, A.,Wong, M.W.(2019).The impact of social media influencers on purchase intention and the mediation effect of customer attitude.Asian Journal of Business Research,7(2),19-36.
37. McQuarrie, E.F.,Miller, J.,Phillips, B.J.(2013).The Megaphone effect: Taste and audience in fashion blogging.Journal of Consumer Research,40(1),136-158.
38. B. Miller. (2020, Jan. 24). 15 advantages and disadvantages of quantitative research. Green Garage [Online]. Available at: https://greengarageblog.org/15-advantages-and-disadvantages-of-quantitative-research
39. Nielsen, M.F.(1994).The method of qualitative interaction analysis.Proceedings of the XIVth Scandinavian Conference of Linguistics and the VIIIth Conference of Nordic and General Linguistics,Reykjavík:
40. Noble, D.,Letsky, M.(2003).,Information Superiority Working Group.
41. P. Pavliscak. (2014, June 2). Choosing the right metrics for user experience. UX matters [Online]. Available at:https://www.uxmatters.com/mt/archives/2014/06/choosing-the-right-metrics-for-user-experience.php
42. Rahman, M.s.(2016).The advantages and disadvantages of using qualitative and quantitative approaches and methods in language “testing and assessment” research: A literature review.Journal of Education and Learning,6(1),102-112.
43. Ramey, K.E.,Champion, D.N.,Dyer, E.B.,Keifert, D.T.,Krist, C.,Meyerhoff, P.,Villanosa, K.,Hilppö, J.(2016).Qualitative analysis of video data: Standards and heuristics.12th International Conference of the Learning Sciences, ICLS 2016: Transforming Learning, Empowering Learners, Proceedings,International Society of the Learning Sciences (ISLS),Singapore:
44. Ruiz-Gomez, A.(2019).Digital fame and fortune in the age of social media: A classification of social media influencers.International Journal of Communication Research,19(19),8-29.
45. Ryu, E.A.,Han, E.K.(2021).Social media influencers’ reputation: Developing and validating a multidimensional scale.Sustainability,13(2),631-649.
46. Sekhon, H.,Ennew, E.,Kharouf, H.,Devlin, J.(2014).Trustworthiness and trust: Influences and implications.Journal of Marketing Management,30(3-4),409-430.
47. J. Sidnell. (2016, Mar. 03). Conversation Analysis. Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Linguistics. [Online]. Available at: https://oxfordre.com/linguistics/view/10.1093/acrefore/9780199384655.001.0001/acrefore-9780199384655-e-40?mediaType=Article
48. Sokolova, K.,Kefi, H.(2020).Instagram and YouTube bloggers promote it, why should I buy? How credibility and parasocial interaction influence purchase intentions.Journal of Retailing and Consumer Service,53
49. van Dijck, J.,Poell, T.(2013).Understanding social media logic.Media and Communication,1(1),2-14.
50. van Driel, L.,Dumitrica, D.(2020).Selling brands while staying “Authentic”: The professionalization of Instagram influencers.Convergence,27(1),66-84.
51. Villi, M.,Matikainen, J.(2016).Participation in social media: Studying explicit and implicit forms of participation in communicative social networks.Media and Communication,4(4),109-117.
52. Vodka, J.,Cakanova, L.,Pekar, M.,Novysedlak, M.(2019).Influencer marketing as a modern phenomenon in reputation management.Managing Global Transitions,17(3),211-220.
53. Wiedmann, K.P.,von Mettenheim, W.(2020).Attractiveness, trustworthiness and expertise – social influencers’ winning formula?.Journal of Product & Brand Management
54. Wielki, J.(2020).Analysis of the role of digital influencers and their impact on the functioning of the contemporary on-line promotional system and its sustainable development.Sustainability,127,1-20.
55. Xiao, M.,Wang, R.,Chan-Olmsted, S.(2018).Factors affecting YouTube influencer marketing credibility: a heuristic-systematic model.Journal of media business studies,15(3),188-213.
56. Yuan, S.,Lou, C.(2020).How social media influencers foster relationships with followers: The roles of source credibility and fairness in parasocial relationship and product interest.Journal of Interactive Advertising,20(2),133-147.