腦中的自由意志？對來自認知神經科學之實徵證據的擷選回顧

Free Will in the Brain? A Selective Review of the Empirical Evidence From Cognitive Neuroscience

10.3966/207466012018121002001

吳嫻(Denise Hsien Wu)

主觀意識 ； 自我控制 ； 腦電波研究 ； 準備電位 ； 功能性核磁共振造影 ； subjective consciousness ； self control ； electrophysiological research ； readiness potentials ； functional magnetic resonance imaging

生命教育研究

10卷2期（2018 / 12 / 01）

1 - 27

繁體中文

普羅大眾相信人類有自由意志，但透過測量大腦活動來了解人類功能和機制的認知神經科學研究顯示，在受試者任意進行抬手、自由決定以哪隻手按鍵或進行加法或減法運算時，先觀察到和後續行為相關之生理訊號，接著受試者才意識到其動作意圖，最後觀察到受試者之外顯行為；此種結果似乎強烈挑戰自由意志的存在。本文介紹相關研究之數個經典實驗，指出其實驗假設的內部矛盾、其實驗派典的潛在問題和侷限，並澄清其結果的意涵，再進一步根據人類記憶等其他認知範疇中的行為表現，提出「自由意志的運作並非單一歷程，包含難以意識到的內隱意志和可清楚意識到的外顯意志」。本文根據對科學實徵證據的擷選回顧，闡述即使我們相信人類所有認知功能（包括自由意志）都奠基於神經元活動，目前的腦科學研究仍尚未提供自由意志如何運作的直接證據，也未推翻自由意志的存在。

It is generally believed that people have free will, according to which we can freely choose and control our own behaviors. However, such belief is strongly challenged by empirical evidence from cognitive neuroscience, which investigates human cognitive functions and their neuronal mechanisms through measuring brain activities. Specifically, research has shown that when people spontaneously move their hands, freely choose to move their right or left hand, or freely decide to perform addition or subtraction, the neuronal signals that are relevant to the following behaviors are first observed, followed by participants' subjective awareness of the intention to act, and then the explicit behaviors are observed. Such findings seem to be directly against the existence of free will. To better understand functional and neural mechanisms of free will in the brain, several classic studies addressing this issue via cognitive neuroscience methods are reviewed in the present article. The theoretical assumptions, experimental procedures, and behavioral and neuroimaging results of these experiments are introduced. The results and their implications are described and discussed. Critically, the inconsistency of the underlying assumptions, the problems of the paradigms, and the limitations of the findings of these experiments are highlighted and elaborated. It is further proposed that, similar to behaviors in other cognitive domains such as memory, the functioning of free will may not be a unitary process but encompassing the implicit phase that is unaware of and the explicit phase that is clearly aware of by an agent. Based on the selective review of the studies in cognitive neuroscience, it is concluded that despite the belief that all human behaviors are supported by neural activities in the brain, the present evidence has not elucidated the operations of free will in the brain, nor has it overthrown the existence of free will of human beings.

1. Balaguer, M.(2014).Free will.Cambridge, MA:MIT Press.
2. Baumeister, R. F.,Masicampo, E. J.,DeWall, C. N.(2009).Prosocial benefits of feeling free: Disbelief in free will increases aggression and reduces helpfulness.Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin,35(2),260-268.
3. Baumeister, R. F.,Masicampo, E. J.,Vohs, K. D.(2011).Do conscious thoughts cause behavior?.Annual Review of Psychology,62,331-361.
4. Bode, S.,He, A. H.. Soon, C. S.,Trampel, R.,Turner, R.,Haynes, J.-D.(2011).Tracking the unconscious generation of free decisions using ultra-high field fMRI.PLoS One,6(6),e21612.
5. Bode, S.,Murawski, C.,Soon, C. S.,Bode, P.,Stahl, J.,Smith, P. L.(2014).Demystifying "'free will"': The role of contextual information and evidence accumulation for predictive brain activity.Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews,47,636-645.
6. Brass, M.,Lynn, M. T.,Dcmanet, J.,Rigoni, D.(2013).Imaging volition: What the brain can tell us about the will.Experimental Brain Research,229(3),301-312.
7. Chang, E.,Ro. T(2007).Maintenance of visual stability in the human posterior parietal cortex.Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience,79(2),266-274.
8. Colas, J. T.,Hsieh, P.-J.(2014).Pre-existing brain states predict aesthetic judgments.Human Brain Mapping,35(7),2924-2934.
9. Ebert, J. P.,Wegner D. M.(2011).Mistaking randomness for free will.Consciousness and Cognition,20(3),965-971.
10. Fried, I.,Mukamel, R.,Kreiman, G.(2011).Internally generated preactivation of single neurons in human medial frontal cortex predicts volition.Neuron,69(3),548-562.
11. Glannon, W.(2011).Brain, body, and mind: Neuroethics with a human face.New York, NY:Oxford University Press.
12. Greene, J..,Cohen, J.(2004).For the law. neuroscience changes nothing and everything.Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences,359(1451),1775-1785.
13. Haggard, P, & Eimer, M.(1999).On the relation between brain potentials and the awareness of voluntary movements.Experimental Brain Research,126(1),128-133.
14. Haggard, P.(2008).Human volition: Towards a neuroscience of will.Nature Reviews Neuroscience,9(12),934-946.
15. Haggard, P.,Lau, H.(2013).What is volition?.Experimental Brain Research,229(3),285-287.
16. Hsieh, P.-J.,Colas, J. T.,Kanwisher, N. G.(2012).Prc-stimulus pattern of activity in the fusiform face area predicts face percepts during binocular rivalry.Neuropsychologia,50(4),522-529.
17. Hung, Y.-H.,Hung, D.-L.,Tzeng, O. J.-L.,Wu, D.-H.(2008).Flexible spatial mapping of different notations of numbers in Chinese readers.Cognition,106(3),1441-1450.
18. Jo, H. G.,Hinterberger, T.,Wittmann, M.,Borghardt, T. L.,Schmidt, S.(2013).Spontaneous EEG fluctuations determine the readiness potential: Is preconscious brain activation a preparation process to move?.Experimental Brain Research,231(4),495-500.
19. Kane, R.(1996).The significance of free will.New York, NY:Oxford University Press.
20. Libet, B.(1985).Unconscious cerebral initiative and the role of conscious will in voluntary action.The Behavioral and Brain Sciences,8(4),529-539.
21. Libet, B.(1985).Tlieory and evidence relating cerebral processes to conscious will.The Behavioral and Brain Sciences,8(4),558-566.
22. Libet, B.,Gleason, C. A.,Wright, E. W., Jr.,Pearl, D. K.(1983).Time of conscious intention to act in relation to onset of cerebral activity (readiness-potential). The unconscious initiation of a freely voluntary act.Brain,106(3),623-642.
23. Mele, A.(2013).Free will and neuroscience.Philosophic Exchange,43(1),1-17.
24. Mobbs, D.,Lau, H. C.,Jones, O. D..,Frith, C. D.(2007).Law, responsibility, and the brain.PLoS Biology,5(4),e103.
25. Nahmias, E.,Morris, S.,Nadelhoffer, T.,Turner, J.(2005).Surveying freedom: Folk intuitions about free will and moral responsibility.Philosophical Psychology,18(5),561-584.
26. Nahmias, E.,Shepard, J.,Reuter, S.(2014).It's OK if 'my brain made me do it': People's intuitions about free will and neuroscientific prediction.Cognition,133(2),502-516.
27. Nelson, R. J.(1985).Libet's dualism.The Behavioral and Brain Sciences,8(4),550.
28. Nichols, S.(2011).Experimental philosophy and the problem of free will.Science,331(6023),1401-1403.
29. Nichols, S.(2004).The folk psychology of free will: Fits and starts.Mind and Language,19(5),473-502.
30. Nichols, S.(2006).Folk intuitions on free will.Journal of Cognition and Culture,6(1),57-86.
31. Nichols, S.,Knobe, J.(2007).Moral responsibility and determinism: The cognitive science of folk intuitions.Noûs,41(4),663-685.
32. O'Connor, T. (2014). Free will. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Retrieved from http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2014/entries/freewill/
33. Rigoni, D.,Kühn, S.. Sartori, G.,Brass, M.(2011).Inducing disbelief in free will alters brain correlates of prcconscious motor preparation: The brain minds whether we believe in free will or not.Psychological Science,22(5),613-618.
34. Roskies, A. L.(2006).Neuroscientific challenges to free will and responsibility.Trends in Cognitive Sciences,10(9),419-423.
35. Roskies, A. L.(2010).How does neuroscience affect our conception of volition?.Annual Review of Neuroscience,33,109-130.
36. Sarkissian, H.,Chatterjee, A.,De Brigard, F.,Knobe, J.,Nichols, S.,Sirker, S.(2010).Is belief in free will a cultural universal?.Mind & Language,25(3),346-358.
37. Schurger, A.,Sitt, J. D.,Dehaene, S.(2012).An accumulator model for spontaneous neural activity prior to self-initiated movement.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,109(42),E2904-E2913.
38. Shariff, A. F.,Greene, J. D.,Karremans, J. C.,Luguri, J. B.,Clark, C. J.,Schooler, J. W.,Vohs, K. D.(2014).Free will and punishment: A mechanistic view of human nature reduces retribution.Psychological Science,25(8),1563-1570.
39. SharifF, A. F.,Vohs, K. D.(2014).The world without free will.Scientific American,310(6),76-79.
40. Sinnott-Armstrong, W.(Ed.)(2014).Moral psychology: Freedom and responsibility.Cambridge, MA:MIT Press.
41. Sinnott-Armstrong, W.(Ed.),Nadel, L.(Ed.)(2010).Conscious will and responsibility: A tribute to Benjamin Libet.New York, NY:Oxford University Press.
42. Soon, C. S..,Allefeld, C.,Bogler, C.,Heinzle, J.,Haynes, J.-D.(2014).Predictive brain signals best predict upcoming and not previous choices.Frontiers in Psychology,5,406.
43. Soon, C. S.,Brass, M.,Heinze, H.-J.,Haynes, J.-D.(2008).Unconscious determinants of free decisions in the human brain.Nature Neuroscience,11(5),543-545.
44. Soon, C. S.,He, A. H.,Bode, S.,Haynes, J.-D.(2013).Predicting free choices for abstract intentions.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,110(15),6217-6222.
45. Vohs, K. D.,Schooler, J. W.(2008).The value of believing in free will encouraging a belief in determinism increases cheating.Psychological Science,19(1),49-54.
46. Wegner, D.(2002).The illusion of conscious will.Cambridge, MA:MIT Press.
47. Wilson, B. A.,Baddeley, A. D.,Kapur, N.(1995).Dense amnesia in a professional musician following herpes simplex virus encephalitis.Journal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology,17(5),668-681.
48. Wood. C. C.(1985).Pardon, your dualism is showing.The Behavioral and Brain Sciences,8(4),557.
49. Wu, D.-H.,Morganti, A.,Chattcijee, A.(2008).Neural substrates of processing path and manner information of a moving event.Neuropsychologia,46(2),704-713.