異常報酬、公司治理與私募股權折價之關係

A Research of Relationship among Abnormal Return, Corporate Governance and the Discount of Private Equity Placements

林嘉慧(Jia-Hui Lin)；王政翰(Cheng-Han Wang)；顏盟峯(Meng-Feng Yen)

私募股權 ； 股權折價幅度 ； 長短期報酬 ； 異常報酬 ； 公司治理 ； Private equity placement ； Discount of the equity ； Short-run and long-run returns ； Abnormal return ； Corporate governance

會計審計論叢

10卷1期（2020 / 06 / 01）

79 - 120

繁體中文

本研究以臺灣2005年至2015年間319家實施私募之公司為研究樣本，首先探討私募宣佈後之短期及長期報酬是否存在異常報酬現象；其次探討異常報酬、公司治理與私募股權折價之關係。研究結果顯示，私募後存在短期正向異常報酬；而長期則存在負向異常報酬。研究亦發現私募公告前六個月平均異常報酬愈高時，對私募公司愈有利，則折價幅度愈小；當我們同時考慮異常報酬與公司治理變數時，研究結果發現當大股東質押比率愈高，投資人傾向支付較低之價格，折價幅度愈大；外部監察人席次比率愈高，折價幅度愈小（僅限於股東會決議日前5日）；法人持股率愈高，折價幅度愈小（僅限於私募定價後5日與10日）。

In this study, we set out to examine whether there are short-run and long-run abnormal returns following public announcements of 319 private equity placements Taiwan during the 2005-2015 period. We analyzed the relationships among the abnormal return, corporate governance and the discount of private equity placements. We found positive abnormal returns in the short-run period around the announcement of a private placement but negative abnormal returns in the relatively long-run period following the announcement of a private placement. A higher average of monthly abnormal returns over the six months prior to the announcement of a private placement is related to a smaller price discount. When controlling for 6-month abnormal return prior to the private placement and corporate governance variables, a higher collateralized ratio by block shareholders would have a larger discount of the equity. A higher ratio of external supervisor seats over all supervisor seats resulted in a smaller price discount (the 5-th day before the shareholders' meeting date). Finally, a higher ratio of institutional ownership was related to a smaller discount (closing price on the 5-th and 10-day after the pricing date).

1. Chen, A.,Chen, R. C. Y.,Pan, K. L.(2002).The performance of initial public offerings conditioning on issue information: The case of Taiwan.Asia Pacific Management Review,7(2),167-190.
   連結：
2. Lew, J. F.,Wu, S. J.(2013).Controlling shareholders and earnings informativeness: Evidence from Taiwan.Asia Pacific Management Review,18(1),93-124.
   連結：
3. Lew, J. F.,Wu, S. J.(2013).Controlling shareholders and earnings informativeness: Evidence from Taiwan.Asia Pacific Management Review,18(1),93-124.
   連結：
4. Tang, H. W.(2016).Earnings management, investor type, and firm performance of private placements.Journal of Financial Studies,24(1),55-102.
   連結：
5. Tang, H. W.(2016).Earnings management, investor type, and firm performance of private placements.Journal of Financial Studies,24(1),55-102.
   連結：
6. 林宛瑩, Wan-Ying,許崇源, Chung-Yuan(2008)。台灣集團企業之控股型態及公司治理衡量指標之研究與建議。交大管理學報，28(1)，269-312。
   連結：
7. 洪振虔, Chen-Chein,吳欽杉, Chin-Shun,陳安琳, An-Lin(2002)。非理性投資行為對新上市股票價格績效之影響。管理評論，21(2)，53-79。
   連結：
8. 高蘭芬, Lan-Feng,盧正壽, Cheng-Shou,黃冠智, Kuan-Chih,陳安琳, An-Lin(2012)。公司治理、公司績效與投資策略。中山管理評論，20(3)，851-880。
   連結：
9. 張琬喻, Woan-Yuh,蔡明秀, Min-Shiou,郭一帆, Yi-Fan(2010)。股權私募宣告效果與股權結構變動－以台灣上市上櫃公司為例。財務金融學刊，18(1)，91-136。
   連結：
10. 張瑞當, Ruey-Dang,沈文華, Wen-Hua,黃怡翔, Yi-Hsiang(2011)。宣告效果、股價報酬與盈餘管理：我國企業私募股權之研究。中華會計學刊，7(1)，21-60。
    連結：
11. 陳安琳, An-Lin(2001)。各種衡量模型下新上市公司股票之長期報酬。財務金融學刊，9(3)，1-20。
    連結：
12. 陳維慈, Wei-Tzu,劉啟群, Chi-Chun,張儒欣, Ju-Hsin(2012)。股權私募之折價因素：資訊假說之再檢視。證券市場發展季刊，24(2)，49-86。
    連結：
13. 陳錦村, Jing-Twen,吳有山, Yu-Shan,廖婉惠, Wan-Hui(2011)。金融機構私募股權及其折溢價研究。台灣金融財務季刊，12(1)，1-40。
    連結：
14. 曾玉琦, Yee-Chy,張瑞當, Ruey-Dang,董瑞瑄, Jui-Hsuan(2012)。私募股權公司之特性與折溢價幅度之探討。臺灣管理學刊，12(1)，1-25。
    連結：
15. 黃志仁, Chih-Jen,廖彩伶, Tsai-Ling,陳于格, Yu-Ke(2009)。現金增資之盈餘管理行為：裁決性應計項目與業外損益之整合性決策。當代會計，10(1)，63-98。
    連結：
16. 歐陽豪, Yang-Hou(2009)。外部公司治理機制、相對績效與金融機構總經理更迭關聯之實證研究。臺灣金融財務季刊，10(1)，29-80。
    連結：
17. 賴秀卿, Syou-Ching,李宏志, Hung-Chih,何威德, Wei-Te(2014)。募股權與公司經營績效：應募人類型與私募溢折價之影響。證券市場發展季刊，26(4)，39-82。
    連結：
18. Barclay, M. J.,Holderness, C. G.,Sheehan, D. P.(2007).Private placements and managerial entrenchment.Journal of Corporate Finance,13(4),461-484.
19. Barton, J.(2001).Does the use of financial derivatives affect earnings management decisions?.The Accounting Review,76(1),1-26.
20. Beasley, M. S.(1996).An empirical analysis of the relation between the board of director composition and financial statement fraud.The Accounting Review,71(4),443-465.
21. Brophy, D. J., P. P. Ouimet, and C. Sialm. 2004. PIPE dreams? The performance of companies issuing equity privately. Working Paper, University of Michigan.
22. Brown, S. J.,Warner, J. B.(1985).Using daily stock returns: The case of event studies.Journal of Financial Economics,14(1),3-31.
23. Chen, A. S.,Cheng, L.Y.,Cheng, K. F.,Chih, S. W.(2010).Earnings management, market discounts and the performance of private equity placements.Journal of Banking and Finance,34(8),1922-1932.
24. Chen, L. H.,Dyl, E. A.,Jiang, G. J.,Juneja, J. A.(2015).Risk, illiquidity or marketability: What matters for the discounts on private equity placements?.Journal of Banking and Finance,57,41-50.
25. Chou, D. W.,Gombola, M.,Liu, F. Y.(2010).Earnings management and long-run stock performance following private equity placements.Review of Quantitative Finance and Accounting,34(2),225-245.
26. Claessens, S.,Djankov, S.,Fan, J. P. H.,Lang, L. H. P.(2002).Disentangling the incentive and entrenchment effects of large shareholdings.Journal of Finance,57(6),2741-2771.
27. Claessens, S.,Djankov, S.,Lang, L. H. P.(2000).The separation of ownership and control in East Asian corporations.Journal of Financial Economics,58(1-2),81-112.
28. Cremers, K. J. M.,Nair, V. B.(2005).Governance mechanisms and equity prices.Journal of Finance,60(6),2859-2894.
29. Cronqvist, H.,Nilsson, M.(2003).Agency costs of controlling minority shareholders.Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,38(4),695-719.
30. Dann, L. Y.,DeAngelo, H.(1988).Corporate financial policy and corporate control: A study of defensive adjustments in asset and ownership structure.Journal of Financial Economics,20,87-127.
31. Dechow, P. M.,Sloan, R. G.,Sweeney, A. P.(1995).Detecting earnings management.The Accounting Review,70(2),193-225.
32. Dechow, P. M.,Sloan, R. G.,Sweeney, A. P.(1996).Causes and consequences of earnings manipulation: An analysis of firms subject to enforcement actions by the SEC.Contemporary Accounting Research,13(1),1-36.
33. Edwards, J. S. S., and A. J. Weichenrieder. 1999. Ownership concentration and share valuation: Evidence from Germany. Working paper, University of Cambridge and Goethe University Frankfurt.
34. Fama, E. F.,French, K. R.(1993).Common risk factors in the returns on stocks and bonds.Journal of Financial Economics,33(1),3-56.
35. Fama, E. F.,Jensen, M. C.(1983).Separation of ownership and control.The Journal of Law and Economics,26(2),301-325.
36. Gao, L.,Kling, G.(2008).Corporate governance and tunneling: Empirical evidence from China.Pacific-Basin Finance Journal,16(5),591-605.
37. Graham, J. R.,Harvey, C. R.,Rajgopal, S.(2005).The economic implications of corporate financial reporting.Journal of Accounting and Economics,40(1-3),3-73.
38. Harford, J.,Mansi, S. A.,Maxwell, W. F.(2008).Corporate governance and firm cash holdings in the US.Journal of Financial Economics,87(3),535-555.
39. Hertzel, M.,Lemmon, M.,Linck, J. S.,Rees, L.(2002).Long-run performance following private placements of equity.The Journal of Finance,57(6),2595-2617.
40. Hertzel, M.,Smith, R. L.(1993).Market discounts and shareholder gains for placing equity privately.The Journal of Finance,48(2),459-485.
41. Hossain, M.,Prevost, A. K.,Rao, R. P.(2001).Corporate governance in New Zealand: The effect of the 1993 companies act on the relation between board composition and firm performance.Pacific-Basin Finance Journal,9(2),119-145.
42. Jensen, M. C.,Meckling, W. H.(1976).Theory of the firm: Managerial behavior, agency costs, and ownership structure.Journal of Financial Economics,3(4),305-360.
43. Kao, L.,Chiou, J. R.,Chen, A.(2004).The agency problems, firm performance and monitoring mechanisms: The evidence from collateralized shares in Taiwan.Corporate Governance: An International Review,12(3),389-402.
44. Kim, Y.,Park, M. S.,Wier, B.(2012).Is earnings quality associated with corporate social responsibility?.The Accounting Review,87(3),761-796.
45. Kothari, S. P.,Leone, A. J.,Wasley, C. E.(2005).Performance matched discretionary accrual measures.Journal of Accounting and Economics,39(1),163-197.
46. Krishnamurthy, S.,Spindt, P.,Subramaniam, V.,Woidtke, T.(2005).Does investor identity matter in equity issues? Evidence from private placements.Journal of Financial Intermediation,14(2),210-238.
47. La Porta, R.,Lopez-de-Silanes, F.,Shleifer, A.(1999).Corporate ownership around the world.The Journal of Finance,54(2),471-517.
48. Lee, T. S.,Yeh, Y. H.(2004).Corporate governance and financial distress: Evidence from Taiwan.Corporate Governance: An International Review,12(3),378-388.
49. Lemmon, M. L.,Lins, K. V.(2003).Ownership structure, corporate governance, and firm value: Evidence from the East Asian financial crisis.The Journal of Finance,58(4),1445-1468.
50. McConnell, J. J.,Servaes, H.(1990).Additional evidence on equity ownership and corporate value.Journal of Financial Economics,27(2),595-612.
51. Morck, R.,Shleifer, A.,Vishny, R. W.(1988).Management ownership and market valuation: An empirical analysis.Journal of Financial Economics,20,293-315.
52. Myers S. C.,Majluf, N. S.(1984).Corporate financing and investment decisions when firms have information that investors do not have.Journal of Financial Economics,13(2),187-221.
53. Pagano, M.,Röell, A.(1998).The choice of stock ownership structure: Agency costs, monitoring, and the decision to go public.The Quarterly Journal of Economics,113(1),187-225.
54. Pound, J.(1988).Proxy contests and the efficiency of shareholder oversight.Journal of Financial Economics,20,237-265.
55. Rangan, S.(1998).Earnings management and the performance of seasoned equity offerings.Journal of Financial Economics,50(1),101-122.
56. Roychowdhury, S.(2006).Earnings management through real activities manipulation.Journal of Accounting and Economics,42(3),335-370.
57. Shleifer, A.,Vishny, R. W.(1986).Large shareholders and corporate control.Journal of Political Economy,94(3),461-488.
58. Shleifer, A.,Vishny, R. W.(1997).A survey of corporate governance.The Journal of Finance,52(2),737-783.
59. Skinner, D. J.,Sloan, R. G.(2002).Earnings surprises, growth expectations, and stock returns or don't let an earnings torpedo sink your portfolio.Review of Accounting Studies,7(2-3),289-312.
60. Tan, R. S. K.,Chng, P. L.,Tong, Y. H.(2002).Private placements and rights issues in Singapore.Pacific-Basin Finance Journal,10(1),29-54.
61. Volpin, P. F.(2002).Governance with poor investor protection: Evidence from top executive turnover in Italy.Journal of Financial Economics,64(1),61-90.
62. Wruck, K. H.(1989).Equity ownership concentration and firm value: Evidence from private equity financings.Journal of Financial Economics,23(1),3-28.
63. Wruck, K. H.,Wu, Y. L.(2009).Relationships, corporate governance, and performance: Evidence from private placements of common stock.Journal of Corporate Finance,15(1),30-47.
64. Wu, Y. L.(2004).The choice of equity-selling mechanisms.Journal of Financial Economics,74(1),93-119.
65. Wu, Y. L. 2000. The choice between public and private equity offerings. Working paper, National Tsing Hua University.
66. Yeh, Y. H.,Lee, T. S.,Pen, J. F.(2002).Stock returns and volatilities under market segmentation: The case of Chinese A and B shares.Review of Quantitative Finance and Accounting,18(3),239-257.
67. Yeh, Y. H.,Lee, T. S.,Woidtke, T.(2001).Family control and corporate governance: Evidence from Taiwan.International Review of Finance,2(1-2),21-48.
68. 吳炘昌, Shin-Chang,葉穎如, Ying-Ru(2009)。從私募有價證券特性談我國監理之因應對策。證卷暨期貨月刊，27(11)，22-35。
69. 陳俊合, Chun-Ho,羅國華, Kuo-Hwa,王馨晨, Hsin-Chen(2009)。人認購、公司治理結構與私募股權折價。證券市場發展季刊，21(2)，119-150。
70. 黃瀚緯, Hann-Wei,王茂昌, Mao-Chang(2017)。私募普通股的利益掠奪效果與公司治理之關聯性。評價學報，11，1-20。
71. 顧廣平, Kuang-Ping(2003)。台灣新上市股票短期與長期績效之再探討。證券市場發展季刊，15(1)，1-40。