Counter Disaster Measures for People with Functional Needs in Times of Disaster in Japan: Achievements and Challenges before and after the Great East Japan Earthquake and Tsunami Disaster

10.6149/JDM.2012.0101.02

Shigeo Tatsukih；Nicolle Comafay

People with functional needs in times of disaster ； Counter-disaster measures ； Maximum probable event ； Maximum possible event ； Mapping vulnerability

災害防救科技與管理學刊

1卷1期（2012 / 03 / 01）

35 - 61

英文

This paper reports, first, the achievements to counter disaster measures for People with Functional Needs in Times of Disaster (PFND) in Japan since 2004, second, the newfound challenges following the 2011 Great East Japan Earthquake and, finally possible solutions to address these issues. First, a case study conducted at Hyogo ward, Kobe city was presented as an attempt to propose a standardized method of identifying and locating individual PFND based on person-in-environment model of vulnerability. After the 2011 earthquake and tsunami disasters, newfound challenges were observed: Those were (1) identifying people at risk; (2) assigning specially designated shelters for PFND; (3) utilizing the information on PFND. Identifying people at risk relied on the current hazard estimation process which is based on the maximum probable event (MP(subscript r)E) framework. It was found, however, that there is a need to re-think this and shift to the maximum possible event (MP(subscript o)E) framework. The need for shelters and temporary housing units that can respond to individualized needs of PFND arose following the earthquake. However, due to lack of pre-planning in some municipalities, their provisions were neither systematic nor universal. Meanwhile, lack of understanding of the legal framework influenced the reluctance of many local government administrators not to share their PFND registry to Non-governmental Organization (NGO) or self-help organizations. Since a majority of people with disabilities, one large category of PFND, chose not to seek assistance from the evacuation shelters, they became invisible and the local administrators were unaware of their specific needs. To address these issues, the following were proposed; (1) a shift from MP(subscript r)E to MP(subscript o)E framework which calls for the involvement of all stakeholders; (2) developing a more detailed guidelines for specially designated shelter and temporary housing operations; and (3) public education on the use of personal information of PFND during a disaster period.

1. Aoki, K. 2011. Miyagi prefecture, west Tokyo city elderly center kirara. Report on supporting a specially designated shelter in Kesennuma city, Retrieved October 1, 2011, from www.toshinkai.or.jp/image/C8EFBAD2C3CFC7C9B8AFCAF3B9F0.pdf (in Japanese)
2. Committee on Evacuation/Sheltering Assistance for People with Special Needs in Times of Disaster. 2006. Evacuation/sheltering assistance guideline for people with special needs in times of disaster, revised edition. Retrieved December 28, 2010, from http://www.bousai.go.jp/hinan_kentou/060328/hinanguide.pdf (in Japanese)
3. Committee on Disaster Information Communication and Evacuation/Sheltering Assistance for the Elderly/ Disadvantaged Population during Heavy Meteorological and Other Disasters. 2005. Evacuation/ sheltering assistance guideline for people with special needs in times of disaster. Retrieved December 28, 2010, from www.bousai.go.jp/3oukyutaisaku/youengosya/h16/pdf/no7/05_shiryou3.pdf (in Japanese)
4. The Nippon Foundation. 2011. Road Project. Retrieved March 31, 2012, from http://road.nippon-foundation.or.jp/2011/04/007-fcd1.html
5. Kobe City. 2009. Hyogo plan: Original plan. Retrieved January 5, 2011, from http://www.city.kobe.lg.jp/ward/kuyakusho/hyogo/keikaku/kukeikaku/img/all-1.pdf (in Japanese)
6. Fire and Disaster Management Agency. 2011. A research report on municipalities' counter-disaster measures for people with functional needs in times of disaster Retrieved September 26, 2011, from http://www.fdma.go.jp/neuter/topics/houdou/2307/230708_1houdou/02_houdoushiryou.pdf (in Japanese)
7. Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare. 2002. Long term care insurance in Japan. Retrieved February 5, 2012, from http://www.mhlw.go.jp/english/topics/elderly/care/index.html
8. Beck, U.,Mark, R.(Trans.)(1992).Risk society: Towards a new modernity.London:Sage.
9. Bolin, R.,Klenow, D. J.(1983).Response of the elderly to disaster: An age-stratified analysis.International Journal of Aging and Human Development,16,283-296.
10. Cohen, E. S.,Poulschock, S. W.(1977).Societal response to mass dislocation of the elderly; Implications for area agencies on aging.The Gerontologist,17,262-268.
11. Comafay, N.(2011)。Kyoto, Japan，Doshisha University。
12. Comafay, N.、Kitahama, Y.、Tobioka, K.、Tatsuki, S.(2008)。A qualitative study on how persons with special needs at times of disaster (PSND) were responded to during the 2007 Noto Hanto earthquake: From the response process of supporting organizations for elderlies in need of care。Journal of Social Safety Science，10，521-530。
13. Committee on Public Welfare and Disaster Prevention Coordination in Evacuation/Sheltering Assistance for PSND(2007)。Guidelines on countermeasures concerning people with special needs in times of disaster。Tokyo:Japan Cabinet Office。
14. Friedsam, H. J.(1960).Older persons as disaster casualties.Journal of Health and Human Behavior,1,269-273.
15. Hayashi, H.、Tamura, K.(2005)。Profiling causes of deaths at the Niigata flooding disaster on July 13, 2004。Journal of Social Safety Science，7，197-206。
16. Kailes, J. I.,Enders, A.(2007).Moving beyond "special needs:" A function-based framework for emergency management and planning.Journal of Disability Policy Studies,17,230-237.
17. Lash, S.(Ed.),Szerszynski, B.(Ed.),Wynne, B.(Ed.)(1996).Risk, environment and modernity: Towards a new ecology.London:Sage.
18. Mythen, G.(2004).Ulrich beck: A critical introduction to the risk society.London:Pluto Press.
19. Ochi, Y.、Tatsuki, S.(2007)。Conceptualizing the level of special need in times of disaster: Visualization of hazard-vulnerability interaction。Gen-sai: Disaster Reduction Management，2，90-98。
20. Pinkoski, J.(Ed.)(2008).Disaster management handbook.New York:CRC Press.
21. Tamura, K.、Hayashi, H.、Tatsuki, S.(2005)。How long-term care insurance system worked for disaster response of the elderly to the Niigata flood and the mid-Niigata prefecture earthquake。Journal of Social Safety Science，7，213-220。
22. Tatsuki, S.,Comafay, N.(2010).Evacuation and sheltering assistance planning for special needs population: Kobe disadvantaged population mapping project.Paper presented at the International Sociological Association World Congress of Sociology,Gothenburg, Sweden: