探討中醫師對針灸治療病人安全之認知、態度及預防措施

Investigating the Factors Related to Perception, Attitude, and Prevention Mehtods of Acupuncture Patients’ Safety among Traditional Chinese Medical Doctors

顏素美(Suh-May Yen)；龔佩珍(Pei-Tseng Kun)；葉麗月(Li-Yueh Yeh)；黃宣穎(Hsuan-Ying Huang)；蔡文正(Wen-Chen Tsai)

中醫師 ； 病人安全 ； 認知 ； 態度 ； 預防措施 ； Traditional Chinese medical doctors ； Patients' safety ； Perception ； Attitude ； Prevention methods

醫學與健康期刊

5卷1期（2016 / 03 / 01）

35 - 51

繁體中文

目的：暸解中醫師對針灸治療病人安全的認知、態度、預防措施及其相關因素。方法：以台灣所有執業中醫師(N=5,099)為研究對象。藉結構式問卷進行橫斷面研究。除描述性分析與變異數分析外，並運用複迴歸分析影響中醫師對針灸治療病人安全之認知、態度與預防措施之相關因素。結果：共回收有效問卷1,424份(回收率27.9%)。中醫師平均年齡48.7歲，男女比率3:1，認知平均答對95.8%。態度和預防措施平均得分皆為4.72(滿分為5分)，複迴歸分析顯示影響認知的因素為「取得資格方式」和「平均每診看診人次」。影響態度的因素為「年齡」、「執業年資」、「職稱」、「本身曾遭遇醫療異常經驗」、「參與病人安全教育時數」和「對病人安全之認知」。影響預防措施的因素為「機構位置」和「對病人安全之態度」。結論中醫師對針灸治療病人安全具高程度的認知，中上程度的態度和預防措施。中醫師年齡越大及參與安全教育時數越多，針灸治療病人安全態度越正面。認知會正向影響態度，態度會正向影響對異常事件之預防措施。

Objectives. The aim of this study was to clarify factors related to traditional Chinese doctors' perception, attitude, and prevention methods for better safety in the care of patients receiving acupuncture therapy. Methods. The target subjects were all Taiwanese doctors practicing traditional Chinese medicine (N=5,099). A cross-sectional analysis was performed using structured questionnaire. In addition to descriptive and variant analyses, multiple regression analysis was used to evaluate the possible factors influencing traditional Chinese doctors’ perception, attitude, and prevention activities related to patient safety. Results. Total 1,424 valid questionnaires were collected (the participation rate was 27.9%). The average age of the enrolled traditional Chinese doctors was 48.7 years old. The ratio of male to female was three to one. 95.8% of the questions related to perception were answered correctly. The mean attitude score was 4.72 (the total score was 5). The mean their precaution score was 4.72 (the total score was 5). The multiple regression analysis revealed that the factors affecting perception were “the way they were certified＂ and ＂the mean outpatient number per visit＂. The factors influencing attitude included ＂age＂, ＂seniority＂, ＂professional title＂, ＂personal experience of abnormal medical events＂, ＂number of hours of attending patient safety education program＂ and ＂perception of patient safety＂. The factors impacting prevention methods included ＂location of the institute＂ and ＂attitude toward patient safety＂. Conclusion. Generally, the older the traditional Chinese doctors and the more hours of safety education programs they attended, the more positive the doctor’s attitude toward acupuncture patient safety. Their perceptions positively affected their attitudes toward methods of preventing abnormal events.

1. 鍾其祥、高森永、白璐、簡戊鑑(2010)。臺灣地區住院醫療疏失案件流行病學分析：以2007年為例。醫務管理期刊，11，59-74。
   連結：
2. 中央健康保險署：中醫門診總額針灸標準作業程序醫療品質提升計畫實施方案。http://www.nhi.gov.tw/resource/bulletin/703_W0940041252-A1.DOC。引用01/01/2014。National Health Insurance Administration, Ministry of Health and Welfare: Available at: http://www.nhi.gov.tw/resource/bulletin/703_W0940041252-A1.DOC. Accessed Jan 1, 2014. [In Chinese]
3. 衛生福利部：2008-2009年度醫院推動醫療品質及病人安全工作年度目標及策略。http://ttw3.mmh.org.tw/safe/download/safe_2c.pdf。引用01/01/2014。Ministry of Health and Welfare: Available at: http://ttw3.mmh.org.tw/safe/download/safe_2c.pdf. Accessed Jan 1, 2014. [In Chinese]
4. Brennan, TA,Leape, LL,Laird, NM(1991).Incidence of adverse events and negligence in hospitalized patients. Results of the Harvard Medical Practice Study I..N Engl J Med,324,370-6.
5. Carron, H,Epstein, BS,Grand, B(1974).Complications of acupuncture.JAMA,228,1552-4.
6. Cooper, JB,Gaba, DM,Liang, B,Woods, D,Blum, LN(2000).The national patient safety Foundation agenda for research and development in patient safety.Med Gen Med,2,E38.
7. Ernst, E,White, AR(2001).Prospective studies of the safety of acupuncture: a systematic review.Am J Med,110,481-5.
8. Ernst, G,Strzyz, H,Hagmeister, H(2003).Incidence of adverse effects during acupuncture therapy-a multicentre survey.Complement Ther Med,11,93-7.
9. Fisher, P,Ward, A(1994).Complementary medicine in Europe.BMJ,309,107-11.
10. Flotta, D,Rizza, P,Bianco, A,Pileggi, C,Pavia, M(2012).Patient safety and medical errors: knowledge, attitudes and behavior among Italian hospital physicians.Int J Qual Health Care,24,258-65.
11. Goldberg, I(1973).Pneumothorax associated with acupuncture.Med J Aust,1,941-2.
12. Hamilton, JD,Gibberd, RW,Harrison, BT(2014).After the Quality in Australian Health Care Study, what happened?.Med J Aust,201,23.
13. Leape, LL,Brennan, TA,Laird, N,(1991).The nature of adverse events in hospitalized patients. Results of the Harvard Medical Practice Study II.N Engl J Med,324,377-84.
14. Niggemann, B,Gruber, C(2003).Side-effects of complementary and alternative medicine.Allergy,58,707-16.
15. Norheim, AJ(1996).Adverse effects of acupuncture: a study of the literature for the years 1981-1994.J Altern Complement Med,2,291-7.
16. Norheim, AJ,Fonnebo, V(2000).A survey of acupuncture patients: results from a questionnaire among a random sample in the general population in Norway.Complement Ther Med,8,187-92.
17. Ritter, HG,Tarala, R(1978).Pneumothorax after acupuncture.Br Med J,2,602-3.
18. Schiøler, T,Lipczak, H,Pedersen, BL(2001).Incidence of adverse events in hospitals. A retrospective study of medical records.Ugeskr Laeger,163,5370-8.
19. Thomas, EJ,Studdert, DM,Burstin, HR(2000).Incidence and types of adverse events and negligent care in Utah and Colorado.Med Care,38,261-71.
20. Vilke, GM,Wulfert, EA(1997).Case reports of two patients with pneumothorax following acupuncture.J Emerg Med,15,155-7.
21. Vincent, C,Neale, G,Woloshynowych, M(2001).Adverse events in British hospitals: preliminary retrospective record review.BMJ,322,517-9.
22. Waldman, I(1974).Letter: Pneumothorax from acupuncture.N Engl J Med,290,633.
23. Yamashita, H,Tsukayama, H,White, AR,Tanno, Y,Sugishita, C,Ernst, E(2001).Systematic review of adverse events following acupuncture: the Japanese literature.Complement Ther Med,9,98-104.
24. 王佳敏(2008)。Taichung，中臺科技大學醫護管理研究所=Central Taiwan University of Science and Technology。
25. 吳永隆、張嘉晃、吳宛庭、鄭嘉惠、王拔群、侯紹敏(2009)。急診護理人員病人安全文化─以某醫學中心為例。輔仁醫學期刊，7，17-27。
26. 呂旻芬、戴芳楟、黃芷苓(2011)。醫院員工對病人安全通報態度之研究。護理暨健康照護研究，7，207-14。
27. 李珊、盧玉(2002)。針灸教學宜加強針刺意外的教育。現代中醫藥，4，48-9。
28. 張必正(2003)。臺北=Taipei，國立臺灣大學醫療機構管理研究所=National Taiwan University。
29. 張瓊文、陳熹陽、周洋(2009)。臨床醫生對病人安全的認知現狀調查與分析。中國循證醫學雜誌，9，26-9。
30. 梁惠玉(2005)。Hualien，慈濟大學護理研究所=Tzu Chi University。
31. 鈕元瑛(2007)。Taipei，臺北醫學大學醫務管理學研究所=Taipei Medical University。
32. 黃英峰(2008)。Taichung，中興大學森林學系所=National Chung Hsing University。
33. 楊哲彥、楊秀儀(2004)。台灣地區中醫與西醫醫療糾紛的差異。中醫藥雜誌，15，1-15。
34. 楊鳳凰(2006)。Taichung，亞洲大學健康管理研究所=Asia University。

1. 鄧雪妹、黃淑娟、陳俐伶、郭美玲、張惠珍、李姿蓉(2019)。降低針灸治療毫針掉落發生率之改善專案。長庚護理，30(1)，40-51。
2. 蔣嘉鈴,劉淑浚,陳妤晴,佘素蓉,李合幼,呂友文(2020)。以流程再造降低慢性病房中醫針灸遺漏針發生率－某區域醫院為例。中醫藥研究論叢，23(1)，45-56。
3. 裴駿、陳巧宴、徐宗福(2016)。護理人員對疾病末期病人選擇維生醫療的知識、態度與行為之研究。醫務管理期刊，17(3)，169-187。
4. 施佳欣(2023)。台灣民眾對罕見疾病議題的知識、態度與行為之研究。醫務管理期刊，24(3)，270-291。