運用重要－表現分析法探討老人福利機構服務品質－以中部某養護中心為例

Applying Importance-Performance Analysis as a Service Quality Measure in Welfare Institutions for the Elderly-A Case Study of a Long-term Care Institution in Central Taiwan

梁亞文(Yia-Wun Liang)；蘇湘怡(Siang-Yi Su)；楊凱蓁(Kai-Chen Yang)；廖虔珮(Chien-Pei Liao)；葉建鑫(Jian-Sin Ye)

長期照護機構 ； 服務品質 ； 重要－表現分析法 ； Long-term care institution ； Service quality ； Importance-performance analysis

醫學與健康期刊

5卷1期（2016 / 03 / 01）

67 - 84

繁體中文

目的：本研究旨在探討中部某養護中心住民的服務重視度及滿意度，提供管理者擬定服務品質改善項目優先順序參考。方法：本研究為一橫斷性研究，以結構式問卷調查住民對機構環境設施、服務項目的重視度及滿意度。統計分析先以t檢定檢視住民對服務的重視度與滿意度間是否存在顯著差異，再以「重要－表現分析法」探討重視度高滿意度低的服務項目。結果：住民在九個服務構面中有6個構面的重視度與滿意度達顯著差異；96個服務項目中有55個項目之重視度顯著高於滿意度；19個項目須優先改善。結論：機構可增設地板求助鈴或導入高科技智能手環，裨益住民主動求援，機構照顧應避免「全控機構」式的理念，朝「住民為中心」的服務模式努力，人力可採外聘、內留雙軌方式，充足照服員人力，另，可考慮賦權照服員使其具有較高的工作控制，提升專業形象，提高留任意願。此外，藉由團體規範、多元團隊服務，發展具機構特色的服務模式，提供適當且具經濟效益的服務。

Objectives. This study aimes to explore the residents' perceptions of importance and their perceived performance with regards to the services provided by a senior caring center in central Taiwan area. The study results will provide useful information for the managers to prioritize the services that require quality improvement. Methods. This is a cross-sectional study using structured questionnaire to collect data through measuring the senior center services quality based on two dimensions: institution-environment facilities and service items. The t-test was used to test the difference between the residents' perceptions of importance and their perceived performance of the provided services. The importance performance analysis was adopted to explore the satisfaction items for further improvement. Results. Residents' perceived importance for six service dimensions and 55 service items were found significantly higher than their perceived performance. Nineteen service items were identified as the first priority needed to be improved immediately. Conclusion. We suggest the senior caring center to install the floor emergency bell and provide the high-tech monitoring devices for the detection of emergent situations occurred for the residents. A culture change from an institutional model of care to a more individualized, resident-oriented practice that embraces choice and autonomy for residents and caregivers is highly suggested. The number of nursing assistants can be maintained through recruitments and retentions; in addition, empowering nursing assistants to have more job control and promote their professional images may increase their willingness of retention. Finally, developing an institutional features service model based on group norms and multidiscipline is expected to be able to provide high-quality services.

1. 蔡淑鳳、陳文意、林育秀、梁亞文(2013)。台灣地區長期照護機構女性照顧服務員工作壓力源與工作適應、離職意願之研究。台灣衛誌，32，476-90。
   連結：
2. Jeon YH: Breaking down professional barriers in aged care. Australian Ageing genda: Opinion, Feb 11. Available at: www.australi anageingagenda.com.au. Accessed November 26, 2014.
3. Bartlett, H,Boldy, D(2001).Approaches to improving quality in nursing and residential homes: Recent developments in Australia and their relevance to the UK.Quality in Ageing,2,2-14.
4. Chang, SC,Shiu, MN,Chen, HT,Ng, YY,Lin, LC,Wu, SC(2015).Evaluation of care quality for disabled older patients living at home and in institutions.J Clin Nurs
5. ECSWPR(2010).,Vienna:European Centre for Social Welfare Policy and Research.
6. Francis, J,Netten, A(2004).Raising the quality of home care: a study of srvice users' views.Social Policy & Administration,38,290-305.
7. Gaster, L,Squires, A(2003).Providing quality in public sector: A practical approach to improving public services.Maidenhead:Open University Press.
8. Gibb, H,Freeman, M,Ballantyne, A,Corlis, M(2015).Team care: development and evaluation of an evidence based model for supporting safer, quality care delivery to residents in aged care facilities.Agening International,2,1-22.
9. Gibb, HJ(2013).An environmental scan of an aged care workplace using the PARiHS model: assessing preparedness for change.Journal of Nursing Management,21,293-303.
10. Giorgio, LD,Filippini, M,Masiero, G(2016).Is higher nursing home quality more costly?.Eur J Health Econ,17(8),1011-1026.
11. Goffman, E(1961).Asylums: Essays on the social situation of mental patients and other inmates.New York:Doubleday Anchor.
12. Helsedirektoratet(2013).Statusrapport fra arbeidsgruppen for pleie og omsorgStatusrapport fra arbeidsgruppen for pleie og omsorg,未出版
13. Hjaltadottir, I,Ekwall, AK,Nyberg, P,Hallberg, IR(2012).Quality of care in Icelandic nursing homes measured with Minimum Data Set quality indicators: retrospective analysis of nursing home data over 7 years.Int J Nurs Stud,49,1342-53.
14. Hoare, RJ,Butcher, K(2007).Do Chinese cultural values affect customer satisfaction/loyalty?.Int J Contemp Hosp Manag,20,156-71.
15. Jones, K,Fowles, AJ(1998).Understanding Health and Social Care-An Introductory Reader.London:SAGE.
16. Kjøs, BØ,Havig, AK(2016).An examination of quality of care in Norwegian nursing homes-a change to more activities?.Scand J Caring Sci,30(2),330-9.
17. Kulmala, J,Nykanen, I,Manty, M,Hartikainen, S(2014).Association between frailty and dementia: A population-based study.Gerontology,60,16-21.
18. Martin, V,Henderson, E(2001).Managing in Health and Social Care.London:Routledge.
19. Meyer, J,Owen, T(2007).Guest editorial: my home life programme.Int J Older People Nurs,2,239-40.
20. Milulić, J,Prebežac, D(2008).Prioritizing improvment of service attributes using impact range-performance analysis and impact-asymmetry analysis.Managing Service Quality,18,559-76.
21. Moullin, M(2002).Delivering excellence in health and social care.Maidenhead:Open University Press.
22. Nakrem, S(2015).Understanding organizational and cultural premises for quality of care in nursing homes: an ethnographic study.BMC health services research,15,508.
23. Nakrem, S,Vinsnes, AG,Harkless, GE,Paulsen, B,Seim, A(2009).Nursing sensitive quality indicators for nursing home care: International review of literature, policy and practice.Int J Nurs Stud,33,469-78.
24. Saga, S,Vinsnes, AG,Mørkved, S,Norton, C,Seim, A(2015).What characteristics predispose to continence in nursing home residents?: A population-based cross-sectional study.Neurourology and Urodynamics,34,362-7.
25. Sargent, L,Harley, B,Allen, B(2008).Report for the ANF Victoria BranchReport for the ANF Victoria Branch,Faculty of Economics and Commerce, University of Melbourne.
26. Spilsbury, K,Hewitt, C,Stirk, L,Bowman, C(2011).The relationship between nurse staffing and quality of care in nursing homes: a systematic review.Int J Nurs Stud,48,732-50.
27. Stone, IR(2006).Handbook of Aging and the Social Sciences.San Diego:Academic Press.
28. Tanuseputro, P,Chalifoux, M,Bennett, C(2015).Hospitalization and mortality rates in long-term care facilities: does for-profit status matter?.J Am Med Dir Assoc,16,874-83.
29. Watson, D(2003).The development of total quality management in the personal social service: realities, limitations and opportunities with the modernising agenda?.Local Government Studies,29,33-50.
30. Wilson, D,Truman, C(2005).Comparing the health services utilization of long-termcare residents, home-care recipients, and the well older.Can J Nurs Res,37,138-54.
31. Young, C,van de Glind, EMM,Quinn, TJ(2012).At-home versus institutional long term-care for chronic functionally dependent older people.The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews,6,CD009844.
32. Zeithaml, VA,Berry, LL,Parasuraman, A(1996).The behavioral consequences of service quality.Journal of Marketing,60,31-46.
33. 王文良、盧一帆、張宏哲、劉安琪(2006)。利用PZB與FAHP於養護機構服務品質評估之研究。健康管理學刊，4，103-30。
34. 王順治(2013)。,台北=Taipei:內政部=Ministry of the Interior。
35. 王潔媛(2013)。長期照護機構服務品質與發展趨勢之探討。社區發展季刊，141，173-86。
36. 邱泯科、徐伊玲(2005)。老人居家照顧服務員考訓現狀與工作困境之探討。社區發展，110，284-300。
37. 張金釵(2005)。Changhua，彰化師範大學商業教育學系=Department of Finance, National Changhua University。
38. 陳鳳音(2002)。臺北=Taipei，國立臺灣大學衛生政策與管理研究所=Institute of Health Policy and Management, National Taiwan University。
39. 曾馨慧(2009)。台中=Taichung，中山醫學大學醫療產業科技管理學系=Department of Health Policy and Management, Chung Shan Medical University。
40. 游麗裡(2000)。嘉義=Chayi，中正大學社會福利研究所=Department of the Social Welfare。
41. 黃源協、陳伶珠、童伊迪(2004)。個案管理與照顧管理。臺北=Taipei:雙葉出版社=Yeh Yeh Book Gallery。
42. 楊培珊、王潔媛、林明璇(2005)。推動小型老人養護機構社工服務方案經驗分析。社區發展季刊，110，321-39。
43. 簡秀美(2006)。台中=Taichung，亞洲大學長期照護研究所=Institute of Long-Term Care, Asia University。

1. 陳欣蘭,張育瑄(2023)。居家機構應用自立支援照顧於失能個案效益之研究。管理資訊計算，12(1)，25-36。