同儕意外死亡對高中生班級人際衝擊及其哀傷

The Study of Interpersonal Impact and the Grief Process on Peer Accidental Death among Senior High School Students

10.6308/JCPRC.25.04

連廷誥(Ting-Kao Lien)；連廷嘉(Ting-Chia Lien)

哀傷反應 ； 高中生 ； 人際衝擊 ； 同儕死亡 ； grief reaction ； senior high school students ； interpersonal impact ； peer death

諮商心理與復健諮商學報

25期（2013 / 05 / 01）

113 - 165

繁體中文

本研究主要目的在探討高中生在經歷同儕意外死亡事件後，所呈現的哀傷歷程，以及對班級人際的衝擊。本研究採取質性研究法，以十二位高中學生為研究對象，根據親疏關係之不同，分成三組進行焦點團體訪談，所得訪談資料經轉錄為逐字稿後，萃取核心概念，歸納得到下列的結論：1. 高中生在面對同儕意外死亡事件後，會呈現出震驚、不可置信、難過、思念、失眠、逃避、無助、尋求支持等哀傷反應，以及對其未來人生觀具正向影響。2. 因同儕意外死亡而改變了原有的班級人際關係系統，班級成員彼此的關係或次系統運作都會跟著調整，以適應新的情境。3. 高中生的哀傷反應受到支持系統、個人經驗、死者和生者的關係及學校處遇措施等因素影響，不能以單一因素解釋或預測。4. 高中生得知同學死亡消息後會馬上聯絡其好友及同學，並詢問與死者較為親近的同學。並且哀傷反應會隨著與死者不同親疏關係而有所差異，與死者較為親近者的哀傷反應較強且時間也較長。最後本研究根據上述研究結果與發現，提出對青少年實施哀傷輔導及進行相關的研究建議。

The study aims to discuss the grief process and interpersonal impacts of peer accidental death among senior high students. This qualitative research divided 12 senior high students into three focus group to interview their experience, according to their relationship with the death. The collected data was typed with the interview record. The results were as following:1. When high school students encounter incidents that cause death of their cohorts, they tend to respond in manners such as expressing shock, grief, yearning for the dead, insomnia, escape from reality, feeling of helplessness, and seek for support. Their perspective on life is also affected.2. The interpersonal relationship within the class will be altered to adapt to a new environment without the lost cohort due to accidental death.3. The grief response manner, support system, personal experience, relationship between the diseased and high school students, and how schools cope with such incidents could not be predicted or explained by a single factor.4. The grief response manner of high school students differs, which is affected by how close they are with the diseased.Based on the discoveries above, suggestions related to grief counseling will be proposed.

1. Jiang, R. S.,Chou, C. C.,Tsai, P. L.(2006).The grief reactions of nursing students related to the sudden death of a classmate.Journal of Nursing Research,14,279-284.
   連結：
2. 王純娟(2006)。哀傷或不哀傷？當西方的哀傷治療過上臺灣的宗教信仰與民俗。生死學研究，3，93-131。
   連結：
3. 王櫻芬、連廷嘉(2012)。青少年社交能力在其人際依附與心理健康間的中介角色探討分析研究。諮商與輔導學報，24，67-94。
   連結：
4. 洪雅鳳(2007)。面對驟然消逝的生命～意外死亡的班級輔導。輔導季刊，43(1)，69-72。
   連結：
5. 夏允中、越建東(2012)。以佛教的死亡本質及生命無常觀點來探討死亡恐懼。本土心理學研究，38，167-189。
   連結：
6. 黃禎貞(2002)。青少年死亡概念、失落經驗及其教育需求之研究。學校衛生，41，48-68。
   連結：
7. Balk, D. E.(1983).How teenagers cope with sibling's death: Implications for school counselors.The School Counselor,31,150-157.
8. Christ, G. H.,Siegel, K.,Christ, A. E.(2002).Adolescent Grief.Journal of The American Medical Association,288,1269-1278.
9. Corr, C. A.,Balk, D. E.(1996).Handbook of adolescent death and bereavement.New York:Springer.
10. Corr, C. A.,Nabe, C. M.,Corr, D. M.(2000).Death and dying, life and living.Pacific Grove, CA:Wedsworth.
11. Corr, R.(2008).Death, Dice, and Divination: Rethinking Religion and Play in South America.The Journal of Latin American and Caribbean Anthropology,13,2-21.
12. Geller, G.,Rushton, C.,Francomano, C.,Kolodner, K.,Bernhardt, B.(2010).Genetics professionals' experiences with grief and loss: Implications for support and training.Clinical Genetics,77,421-429.
13. Hsu, M. T.,Kahn, D. L.,Huang, C. M.(2002).No more the same: The lives of adolescents in Taiwan who have lost fathers.Family and Community Health,25,43-56.
14. Jacobs, J. R.,Bovasso, G. B.(2009).Re-Examining the long term effects of experiencing parental death in childhood on adult psychopathology.The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease,197,24-27.
15. Maranzano, V.(2005).Columbia University.
16. McFerran, K.,Roberts, M.,O''Grady, L.(2010).Music therapy with bereaved teenagers : A mixed methods perspective.Death studies,34,541-565.
17. Metel, M.,Barnes, J.(2011).Peer-group support for bereaved children : A qualitative interview study.Child and Adolescent Mental Health,16,201-207.
18. O''Brien, J. M.,Goodenow, C.,Espin O.(1991).Adolescents' reactions to the death of a peer.Adolescence,102,431-441.
19. Packman, W.,Horsley, H.,Davies, B.,Kramer, R.(2006).Sibling bereavement and continuing bonds.Death Studies,30,817-841.
20. Parrish, C. P.,Zeman, J.(2011).Relations among sadness regulation, peer acceptance, and social functioning in early adolescence: The role of gender.Social Development,20,135-153.
21. Rowling, L.(2003).Grief in school communities: Effective support strategies.Philadephia, PA:Open University Press.
22. Schonfeld, D. J.,Shaughnessy, M. F.(2011).An interview with David Schonfeld : The educator's role in helping children with grief.North American Journal of Psychology,13,278-280.
23. Seraty-seib, H. L.,Taub, D. J.(2008).Training faculty memberts and resident assistants to respond to bereaved students.New Direction for Student Services,121,51-62.
24. Stroebe, M. S.(Ed.),Hansson, R. O.(Ed.),Stroebe, W.(Ed.),Schut, H.(Ed.)(2001).Handbook of bereavement research: Consequences, coping, and care.Washington, DC:American Psychological Association.
25. Tyrka, A. R.,Wier, L.,Price, L.H.,Ross, N.S.,Carpenter, L. L.(2008).Childhood parental loss and adult psychopathology: Effects of loss characteristics and contextual factors.International Journal of Psychiatry Medicine,38,329-344.
26. Williams, A. L.,Merten, M. J.(2009).Adolescent's online social networking following the death of a peer.Journal of Adolescent Research,24,67-90.
27. 呂羿慧(2011)。青少年面對死亡事件之失落反應與因應。諮商與輔導，301，10-13。
28. 巫志忠(2008)。喪失手足青少年之悲傷調適與輔導。諮商與輔導，275，40-42。
29. 洪雅鳳(1999)。在悲傷中學習成長─學生自殺的班級輔導。諮商與輔導，158，43-45。
30. 高淑清(2008)。質性研究的18 堂課：首航初探之旅。高雄:麗文。
31. 張淑美(1996)。死亡學與死亡教育。高雄:復文。
32. 陳秉華校閱、許維素校閱(2006)。焦點解決諮商的多元應用。臺北:張老師文化。
33. 賴穎萱、林姵瑩(2010)。國小中年級生參與「悲」不再「傷」課程的轉變歷程。生命教育與健康促進學術論文研討會
34. 聶慧文(2004)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。新竹，國立交通大學。
35. 蘇絢慧(2003)。請容許我悲傷。臺北:張老師。