台灣團體諮商研究之題材與方法之整合性分析：以2001－2012為例

A Review Study of Group Counseling Research between 2001 and 2012 in Taiwan

許智傑(Chih-Chieh Hsu)；謝政廷(Cheng-Ting Hsieh)；吳秀碧(Sophia Woo)

團體諮商 ； 團體研究 ； 文獻回顧分析 ； group counseling ； group research ； literature review study

臺灣諮商心理學報

2卷2期（2014 / 09 / 01）

49 - 75

繁體中文

本研究旨在針對2001－2012年期間台灣團體諮商研究的研究題材與研究方法進行整合性分析探究。研究者在「台灣博碩士論文系統網」、「台灣期刊論文索引系統」兩個資料庫，以「團體諮商」、「團體領導者」、「諮商團體」三個關鍵字，搜尋與團體諮商相關的研究或論文作為研究分析之資料。為使研究資料能更貼近研究目的、回應研究問題，研究者設定三項排除條件：（1）論文或研究出版時間早於2001年，以及晚於2012年；（2）內容屬於團體治療或團體心理治療主題；（3）非實徵研究型的文獻回顧或文獻論述文章。只要符合其中一項，即將該篇文獻排除在本研究以外。經篩選後，共得124篇團體諮商研究作為本研究的分析資料。研究者結合共識質化研究的分析方法，針對124篇團體諮商的研究進行文獻的整合性分析。研究結果的發現共可分成兩部份：（1）在研究題材方面的發現，研究對象以團體成員為主，團體領導者次之；研究對象所屬族群，則以國小學童最多，國中生次之，老人最少；在研究主題方面，與領導相關的主題以團體諮商理論取向居多，與團體成員相關的研究主題以團體成員適應相關議題最多；（2）在研究取向方面，以效果研究最多，歷程研究次之；最後，在研究方法方面，以混合方法最多，量化研究次之，質化研究第三。詳細研究結果與研究建議則於內文中討論。

This article provides an integrative review of group counseling research conducted in Taiwan between 2001 and 2012. Particularly the main interest and focus of the study were on the topics and methodology of these research papers. Three keywords of group counseling, group leaders, and counseling group were used to conduct the search in the ＂National Digital Library of Theses and Dissertations in Taiwan＂ and ＂PerioPath Index to Taiwan Periodical Literature System.＂ In addition, three exclusion criteria were set to screen the identified research articles. A total number of 124 research papers were selected and analyzed, and the percentages of each purposeful category were calculated. The results indicated that the most frequent participants in these researches were group members and then group leaders. Among age levels of research participants, elementary school children were the biggest group examined followed by junior high school students, and then seniors. Research topics focused mostly on theories of group counseling. The most popular research method applied in these group counseling research papers was mixed-method with quantitative research being the second, and qualitative research being the least popular. In addition, there were far more the outcome research papers than process research papers. According to these findings, detailed results and suggestions for further research are discussed.

1. 王麗斐,林淑君(2010)。國內諮商與心理治療質性研究之研究方法與研究題材之初步性整合分析。教育心理學報，41(4)，799-822。
   連結：
2. 吳秀碧,許育光(2012)。團體領導能力量表之編製與信、效度建構。中華輔導與諮商學報，32，1-31。
   連結：
3. 宋曜廷,潘佩妤(2010)。混合教育在教育研究的應用。教育科學研究期刊，55(4)，97-130。
   連結：
4. Association for specialist in group work [ASGW] (2000). Professional standards for the training of group workers [Online]. Retrieved Jun 11, 2013 from the World Wide Web: http://asgw.org/pdf/training_standards.pdf
5. Bachelor, A.(1988).How clients perceive therapist empathy: A content analysis of “received” empathy.Psychotherapy,25,227-240.
6. Baggerly, J.,Abugideiri, S. E.(2010).Grief counseling for Muslim preschool and elementary school children.Journal of Multicultural Counseling and Development,38(2),112-124.
7. Balkin, R. S.,Miller, J.,Ricard, R. J.,Garcia, R.,Lancaster, C.(2011).Assessing factors in adolescent adjustment as precursors to recidivism in court-referred youth.Measurement and Evaluation in Counseling and Development,44(1),52-59.
8. Barker, C.(1985).Interpersonal process recall in clinical training and research.New developments in clinical psychotherapy,Chichester:
9. Berzon, B.,Pious, C.,Farson, R. E.(1963).The therapeutic event in group psychotherapy: A study of subjective reports by group members.Journal of Individual psychology,19,204-212.
10. Bloch, S.,Reibtein, J.,Crouch, E.,Holroyd, P.,Themen, J.(1979).A method for the study of therapeutic factors in group psychotherapy.British Journal of Psychiarty,134,257-263.
11. Bostick, D.,Anderson, R.(2009).Evaluating a small-group counseling program- A model for program planning and improvement in the elementary setting.Professional School Counseling,12(6),428-433.
12. Brannen, J.,Collard, J.(1982).Marriages in trouble: The process of seeking help.London:Tavistock.
13. Burlingame, G. M.,Fuhriman, A. J.,Johnson, J.(2004).Process and outcome in group counseling and psychotherapy: A perspective.Handbook of group counseling and psychotherapy,CA:
14. Burlingame, G. M.,Fuhriman, A. J.,Johnson, J.(2004).Current status and future directions of group therapy research.Handbook of group counseling and psychotherapy,CA:
15. Burlingame, G. M.,MacKenzie, K. R.,Strauss, B.(2004).Small group treatment: Evidence for effectiveness and mechanisms of change.Bergin & Garfield’s handbook of psychotherapy and behavior change,NY:
16. Butterfield, L. D.,Borgen, W. A.,Amundson, N. E.,Maglio, A. T.(2005).Fifty years of the critical incindent technique: 1954-2004 and beyond.Qualitative Research,5(4),475-497.
17. Corey, M. S.,Corey, G.,Corey, C.(2010).Groups: Process and practice.CA:Brooks/Cole.
18. Crespi, T. D.(2009).Group counseling in the schools: Legal, ethical, and treatment issues in school practice.Psychology in the Schools,46(3),273-280.
19. Dale, P.,Allen, J.,Measor, L.(1998).Counselling adults who were abused as children: Clients' perceptions of efficacy, client–counsellor communication, and dissatisfaction.British Journal of Guidance & Counselling,26(2),141-157.
20. Delucia-Waack, J. L.,Gellman, R. A.(2007).The efficacy of using music in children of divorce groups: Impact on anxiety, depression, and irrational beliefs about divorce.Group Dynamics: Theory, Research, and Practice,11(4),272-282.
21. DeLucia-Waack, J. L.,Kalodner, C. R.(2005).Contemporary issues in group practice.Handbook of group practice and research,CA:
22. DeRosier, M. E.(2004).Building relationships and combating bullying: Effectiveness of a school-based social skills group intervention.Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology,33(1),196-201.
23. Elliott, R.(1986).Interpersonal process recall (IPR) as a psychotherapy process research method.The psychotherapeutic process: A research handbook,NY:
24. Elliott, R.,Shapiro, D. A.(1992).Client and therapist as analysis of significant events.Psychotherapy process research: Paradigmatic and narrative approaches,Lodon:
25. Flanagan, J. C.(1954).The critical incident technique.Psychological Bulletin,51(4),327-358.
26. Frommer, J.,Langenbach, M.,Streeck, U.(2004).Qualitative psychotherapy research in German-speaking countries.Psychotherapy Research,14(1),57-75.
27. Fuhriman, A.,Burlingame, G. M.(1999).Does group psychotherapy work?.A guide to starting psychotherapy groups,CA:
28. Gazda, G. M.(1989).Group counseling: A developmental approach.MA:Allyn & Bacon.
29. Gazda, G. M.,Ginter, E. J.,Horne, A. M.(2001).Group counseling and group psychotherapy: Theory and application.MA:Allyn & Bacon.
30. Grenz, S.(2011).Review of Helping at-risk students: A group counseling approach for grades 6-9 (2nd edition).School Social Work Journal,35(2),101-102.
31. Hagborg, W. J.(1991).Group counseling with adolescent special education students: Challenges and useful procedures.Adolescence,26(103),557-563.
32. Hill, C. E.,Corbett, M. M.(1993).A perspective on the history of process and outcome research in counseling psychology.Journal of Counseling Psychology,40(1),3-24.
33. Hill, C. E.,Thompson, B. J.,Williams, E. N.(1997).A guide to conducting consensual qualitative research.The Counseling Psychologist,25(4),517-572.
34. Hill, C.,Knox, S.,Thompson, B.,Williams, E.,Hess, S.,Ladany, N.(2005).Consensual qualitative research : An update.Journal of Counseling Psychology,52(2),196-205.
35. Hoag, M. J.,Burlingame, G. M.(1997).Evaluating the effectiveness of child and adolescent group treatment: A meta-analysis review.Journal of Clinical Child Psychology,26,234-246.
36. Holmes, S. E.,Kivlighan, D. M.(2000).Comparison of therapeutic factors in group and individual threatment processes.Journal of Counseling Psychology,47,478-484.
37. Horne, A. M.,Stoddard, J. L.,Christopher, D. B.(2007).Goup approaches to reducing aggression and bullying in school.Group Dynamics: Theory, Research, and Practice,11(4),262-271.
38. Iliceto, P.,Fino, E.,Pasquariello, S.,Di Paola, M. E.,Enea, D.(2013).Predictors of success in smoking cessation among Italian adults motivated to quit.Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment,44(5),534-540.
39. Johnson, R. B.,Onwuegbuzie, A. J.(2004).Mixed methods research: A research paradigm whose time has come.Educational Researcher,33(7),14-26.
40. Kagan, N.(1980).Influencing human interaction: 18 years with IPR.Psychotherapy supervision: Theory, research, and practice,Chichester:
41. Kagan, N.(1984).Interpersonal process recall: Basic methods and recent research.Teaching psychological skills,CA:
42. Kirschenbaum, D. S.,Gierut, K.(2013).Treatment of childhood and adolescent obesity: An integrative review of recent recommendations from five expert groups.Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology,81(2),347-360.
43. Lietaer, G.(1992).Helping and hindering processes in client-centered/experiential psychotherapy: A content analysis of client and therapist postsession perceptions.Psychotherapy process research: Paradigmatic and narrative approaches,London:
44. Llewelyn, S. P.,Elliott, R.,Shapiro, D. A.,Hardy, G.,Firth-Cozens, J.(1988).Client perceptions of significant events in prescriptive and exploratory period of individual therapy.British Journal of Clinical Psychotherapy,27,105-114.
45. Malott, K. M.,Paone, T. R.,Humphreys, K.,Martinez, T.(2010).Use of group counseling to address ethnic identity development: Application with adolescents of Mexican descent.Professional School Counseling,13(5),257-267.
46. Maluccio, A.(1979).Learning from clients: Interpersonal helping as viewed by clients and social workers.NY:Free Press.
47. Markus, H. E.,King, D. A.(2003).A survey of group psychotherapy training during predoctoral psychology internship.Professional Psychotherapy: Research and Practice,34(2),203-209.
48. Martin, J.,Stelmazonek, K.(1988).Participants identification and recall of important events in counseling.Journal of Counseling Psychology,35(4),385-390.
49. Mayer, J.,Timms, N.(1970).The clients speaks: Working-Class impression of casework.London:Routledge and Kegan Paul.
50. McLeod, J.(2003).Qualitative research methods in counseling psychology.Handbook of counseling psychology,London:
51. Morrow, J. B.,Dallo, F. J.,Julka, M.(2010).Community-based colorectal cancer screening trials with multi-ethnic groups: A systematic review.Journal of Community Health: The Publication for Health Promotion and Disease Prevention,35(6),592-601.
52. Nakimuli-Mpungu, E.,Okello, J.,Kinyanda, E.,Alderman, S.,Nakku, J.,Alderman, J. S.,Pavia, A.,Adaku, Alex,Allden, K.,Musisi, Seggane(2013).The impact of group counseling on depression, post-traumatic stress and function outcomes: A prospective comparison study in the Peter C. Alderman trauma clinics in northern Uganda.Journal of Affective Disorders,151(1),78-84.
53. Paone, T. R.,Packman, J.,Maddux, C.,Rothman, T.(2008).A school-based group activity therapy intervention with at-risk high school students as it relates to their moral reasoning.International Journal of Play Therapy,17(2),122-137.
54. Piper, W. E.,Ogrodniczuk, J. S.(2004).Brief group therapy.Handbook of group counseling and psychotherapy,CA:
55. Rennie, D. L.(2004).Anglo-North American qualitative counseling and psychotherapy research.Psychotherapy Research,14(1),37-55.
56. Richardson, B. G.,Surmitis, K. A.,Hyldahl, R. S.(2012).Minimizing social contagion in adolescents who self-injure: Considerations for group work, residential treatment, and the internet.Journal of Mental Health Counseling,34(2),121-132.
57. Rogers, C. R. (1942). Counseling and psychotherapy. MA: Houghton Miflin.
58. Rosenblum, A.,Magura, S.,Kayman, D. J.,Deborah, J.,Fong, C.(2005).Motivationally enhanced group counseling for substance users in a soup kitchen: A randomized clinical trial.Drug and Alcohol Dependence,80(1),91-103.
59. Rosselet, J. G.,Stauffer, S. D.(2013).Using group role-playing games with gifted children and adolescents: A psychosocial intervention model.International Journal of Play Therapy,22(4),173-192.
60. Shechtman, Z.(2007).How does group process research inform leaders of counseling and psychotherapy groups?.Group Dynamic: Theory, Research and Practice,11(4),293-304.
61. Shechtman, Z.(2004).Group counseling/ psychotherapy with children.The Group Worker,32(3),7-9.
62. Shechtman, Z.,Gilat, I.(2005).The effectiveness of counseling groups in reducing stress of parents of children with learning disabilities.Group Dynamics: Theory, Research, and Practice,9(4),275-286.
63. Shechtman, Z.,Ifargan, M.(2009).School-based integrated and segregated interventions to reduce aggression.Aggressive Behavior,35(4),342-356.
64. Steen, S.,Kaffenberger, C. J.(2007).Integrating academic interventions into small group counseling in elementary school.Professional School Counseling,10(5),516-519.
65. Stockton, R.,Morran, D. K.,Krieger, K.(2004).An overview of current research and best practices for training beginning group leaders.Handbook of Group Counseling and Psychotherap,CA:
66. Tanner-Smith, E. E.,Jo Wilson, S.,Lipsey, M. W.(2013).The comparative effectiveness of outpatient treatment for adolescent substance abuse: A meta-analysis.Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment,44(2),145-158.
67. Tashakkori, A.,Teddlie, C.(2003).Handbook of mixed methods in social and behavioral research.CA:Sage.
68. Thompson, E. H.,Trice-Black, S.(2012).School-based group interventions for children exposed to domestic violence.Journal of Family Violence,27(3),233-241.
69. Timms, N.,Blampied, A.(1985).Intervention in marriage: The experience of counselors and their clients.University of Sheffield: Joint Unit for Social Services Research.
70. Ueda, Y.,Tsuda, A.(2013).Differential outcomes of skill training, group counseling, and individual cognitive therapy for persons with acquired visual impairment.Japanese Psychological Research,55(3),229-240.
71. Webb, L. D.,Myrick, R. D.(2003).Goup Counseling Intervention for Children with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder.Professional School Counseling,7(2),108-115.
72. Yalom, I. D.(2005).Theory and practice of group psychotherapy.NY:Basic Books.
73. Zinck, K.,Littrell, J. M.(2000).Action research shows group counseling effective with at-risk adolescent girls.Professional School Counseling,4(1),50-59.
74. 吳秀碧(1998).團體諮商實務.高雄市:復文.
75. 吳武典,張德聰,洪有義(2010).團體輔導.台北市:心理.
76. 連廷誥（譯）,連廷嘉（譯）,連秀鸞（譯）,McLeod, J.(2006).認識諮商研究.台北市:心理.
77. 程小蘋（譯）,黃慧涵（譯）,劉安真（譯）,梁淑娟（譯）,Jacobs, E. E.,Harvill, R. L.,Masson, R. L.(2007).團體諮商策略與技巧.台北市:五南.

1. 李明峰(2017)。台灣諮商督導研究主題與方法之分析─以2000～2015年為例。諮商心理與復健諮商學報，30，97-119。
2. 蘇俊濠(2019)。比昂精神分析團體理論之探究：三個或更多團體基本假設？。中華心理衛生學刊，32(4)，439-463。