運用早期回憶探討憂鬱症患者之依附風格

Using Early Recollections to Explore the Attachment Styles of Depressive Patient

陳偉任(Wei-Jen Chen)；陳璿丞(Hsuan-Cheng Chen)；徐瑋澤(Wei-Tse Hsu)；陳冠旭(Kauan-Hsu Chen)

早期回憶 ； 生命風格 ； 依附關係 ； 憂鬱症 ； early recollection ； life style ； attachment style ； depressive disorder

臺灣諮商心理學報

7卷1期（2019 / 11 / 01）

35 - 48

繁體中文

本研究旨在運用阿德勒個體心學中的早期回憶來理解憂鬱症患者的生命風格，進一步探討臨床實務工作上，是否能藉由早期回憶所顯示的生命風格來反映憂鬱症患者依附風格的差異？研究共邀請80位研究個案參與本研究，研究參與者除了接受早期回憶相關的評估外，同時也填寫了人際依附風格量表。將「早期回憶」收集的相關資料，將生命風格以「感受到歸屬感有無」、「感受自我的意象是正向或負向」以及「感受他人的意象是正向或負向」加以分類，並透過運用獨立樣本t檢定比較兩者之差異。研究結果發現，透過早期回憶過程將生命風格分類，「感受到歸屬感」、「感受自我意象是正向」、「感受他人意象是正向」組比起「沒有感受到歸屬感」、「感受自我意象是負向」、「感受他人意象是負向」組，在安全、焦慮、與逃避依附風格分量表有顯著的不同。期待經由本研究這樣的探討與研究結果的發現，能提供臨床實務工作者除了在客觀自陳式量表的測驗外，另外一個評估憂鬱症獨特生命經驗的方法。

The purpose of this study was to use early recollections to understand the life style of depressive patients, and to explore whether the life style indicated by early recollections can effectively distinguish the differences of patients' attachment styles. Eighty participants were invited to participate in this study who were asked to complete the Attachment Style Questionnaire as well as the assessment for early recollections. Based on the early recollection data, participants' life styles were classified by sorting into groups of ＂sense of belongingness vs. not＂, ＂positive vs. negative self-image＂, and ＂positive vs. negative image of other＂. Independent sample t tests were used for analysis. The findings indicated significant differences in attachment security, anxiety, and avoidance scores between the positive vs. negative groups of all three life style dimensions. The researchers hope that the exploration and findings of the current study offer therapists who work with depressive patients another option to assess the unique life experiences of the depressive patients in addition to using objective, self-report scales.

1. Abramson, Z.(2015).The meaning of neurosis according to Adler.The Journal of Individual Psychology,71(4),426-439.
2. Adler, A.(2013).Understanding human nature (psychology revivals).London:Routledge.
3. Akdogan, R.,Aydın, M.,Eken, H.(2018).Understanding the contribution of abnormal inferiority feelings on insecure attachment through gender and culture: A study of university students seeking psychological support.The Journal of Individual Psychology,74(1),96-116.
4. Allers, C. T.,White, J.,Hornbuckle, D.(1992).Early recollections: Detecting depression in college students.Individual Psychology: Journal of Adlerian Theory, Research & Practice,48(3),324-329.
5. Bartholomew, K.,Horowitz, L. M.(1991).Attachment styles among young adults: A test of a four-category model.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,61(2),226.
6. Bruhn, A. R.(1985).Using early memories as a projective technique - the cognitive perceptual method.Journal of Personality Assessment,49(6),587-597.
7. Carnelley, K. B.,Pietromonaco, P. R.,Jaffe, K.(1994).Depression, working models of others, and relationship functioning.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,66(1),127.
8. Clark, A. J.(2001).Early recollections: A humanistic assessment in counseling.The Journal of Humanistic Counseling,40(1),96-104.
9. Demuth, P. W.,Bruhn, A. R.(1997).The use of the early memories procedure in a psychotherapy group of substance abusers.International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology,41(1),24-35.
10. Fung, T. Y.,Webster, R.(2018).Perceived social support, social interest, and mental Health:Testing a mediator model.The Journal of Individual Psychology,74(2),157-171.
11. Goodwin, R. D.,Jacobi, F.,Bittner, A.,Wittchen, H.-U.(2006).Epidemiology of Mood Disorders.The American Psychiatric Publishing textbook of mood disorders,Arlington, VA, US:
12. Ikeda, M.,Hayashi, M.,Kamibeppu, K.(2014).The relationship between attachment style and postpartum depression.Attachment & Human Development,16(6),557-572.
13. Kern, R. M.,Belangee, S. E.,Eckstein, D.(2004).Early Recollections: A Guide for Practitioners.Journal of Individual Psychology,60(2),132-140.
14. Kopp, R.,Eckstein, D.(2004).Using early memory metaphors and client-generated metaphors in Adlerian therapy.Journal of Individual Psychology,60(2),163-174.
15. Lépine, J.-P.,Briley, M.(2011).The increasing burden of depression.Neuropsychiatric Disease and Treatment,7,3-7.
16. Manaster, G. J.,Berra, S.,Mays, M.(2001).Manaster-perryman early recollections scoring manual: Findings and summary.Journal of Individual Psychology,57(4),413-419.
17. Murray, C. J.,Vos, T.,Lozano, R.,Naghavi, M.,Flaxman, A. D.,Michaud, C.,Abdalla, S.(2013).Disability-adjusted life years for 291 diseases and injuries in 21 regions, 1990-2010: A systematic analysis for the global burden of disease Study 2010.The Lancet,380,2197-2223.
18. Peluso, P. R.,Peluso, J. P.,White, J. F.,Kern, R. M.(2004).A comparison of attachment theory and individual psychology: A review of the literature.Journal of Counseling & Development,82(2),139-145.
19. Rouillon, F.(2008).Epidemiology of mood disorders.La Revue Du Praticien,58(4),361-365.
20. Shifron, R.(2010).Adler’s need to belong as the key for mental health.Journal of Individual Psychology,66(1),10-29.
21. Tobin, D.,Wardi-Zonna, K.,Yezzi-Shareef, A. M.(2007).Early recollections of children and adolescents diagnosed with reactive attachment disorder.Journal of Individual Psychology,63(1),86-95.
22. Zuroff, D. C.,Fitzpatrick, D. K.(1995).Depressive personality styles: Implications for adult attachment.Personality and Individual Differences,18(2),253-265.
23. 王慶福(1995)。彰化縣，國立彰化師範大學。