興櫃股票公允價值估價模型探討

A Study on Fair Value Pricing Models of Emerging Stock

陳怡凱(Yi-Kai Chen)；高蘭芬(Lan-Feng Kao)；陳安琳(Anlin Chen)；林玫均(Mei-Chun Lin)

Fair Value ； Emerging Stock ； IFRS ； Liquidity Discount

兩岸金融季刊

5卷3期（2017 / 09 / 01）

113 - 158

繁體中文

自2013年台灣開始要求上市櫃公司採用國際財務報導準則(IFRS)，過去興櫃股票只需使用成本法入帳，故衡量興櫃股票公允價值成為IFRS啟用後企業首當其衝面臨的問題。興櫃股票缺乏流動性，且公司資訊透明度不似上市櫃公司高，過去常用的評價模型無法衡量興櫃公司的公允價格。本研究參考Silber(1991)設計出流動性折價後模型，衡量出興櫃公允價值，接著和三種價格做比較：第一種為興櫃收盤價；第二種為券商簡易衡量模型；第三種為證期會承銷價公式。研究結果發現流動性折價幅度確實跟公司獲利能力和私募規模有顯著相關。模型驗證階段，使用Theil's U值去判斷其適用性，這三種價格和所計算出來的理論價格相比，研究結果證實有些興櫃股票價格有過於高估現象。

Taiwan Stock Exchange (TSE) adopts International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) in 2013. In the past, firms used historical costs as the fair value in the financial statement. Therefore, measuring the fair value of emerging stock becomes the most important issue after adopting IFRS. Unlike the listed companies, the emerging stock is illiquid and the financial information is less prevailed. The closing price of the emerging stock might be manipulated. Therefore, the models commonly used for the listed stocks might not be appropriate for assessing the fair value of the emerging stock. Referring Silber (1991), this study employs available publicly accounting and market data and develop a liquidity discount model to evaluation the fair price of the emerging stocks. The calculated fair price is compared with the prices commonly used in the market. Three commonly used fair prices are the closing price of emerging stock, the average monthly price used by security dealers, and the underwriting price developed by the Securities and Futures Institute (SFI). The results show that the liquidity discount is significantly associated with the company profitability and the scale of the private placement. Furthermore, this study employs Theil's U to verify the fair price developed by the liquidity discount model. The results show the some emerging stock prices are overvalued.

1. 朱心蘅、陳怡諠、邱惠貞(2010)。興櫃市場首次公開發行超額報酬與資訊揭露效果之探討。台灣金融財務季刊，11(1)，69-92。
   連結：
2. 吳清在、林惠芬(2011)。申請初次上市（櫃）前股價異常報酬之探討。管理學報，28(2)，145-170。
   連結：
3. 崔可欣、廖恆毅(2007)。台灣新上市股票評價研究－比較乘數法之應用。輔仁管理評論，14(1)，1-26。
   連結：
4. Chen, Z., and P. Xiong (2001), “Discounts on illiquid stocks: Evidence from china,” Available at SSRN 286169
5. Bajaj, M., D. Denis, S. Ferris, and A. Sarin (2001), “Firm value and marketability discounts,” Available at SSRN 262198.
6. Block, F. E.(1995).A study of the price to book relationship.Financial Analysts Journal,51(1),63-73.
7. Comment, R.(2012).Revisiting the Illiquidity Discount for Private Companies: A New (and "Skeptical") Restricted-Stock Study.Journal of Applied Corporate Finance,24(1),80-90.
8. Damodaran, A.(2012).Investment Valuation: Tools and Techniques for Determining the Value of Any Asset.Wiley.
9. Emory, J. D., Sr.,Dengel F. R., III,Emory, J. D., Jr.(2000).The value of marketability as illustrated in initial public offerings of Dot-Com companies: May 1997 through March 2000.Business Valuation Review,19(3),111-121.
10. Gelman, M.(1972).An economist-financial analyst's approach to valuing stock of a closely held company.Journal of Taxation,36(6),353-354.
11. Kaplan, S. N.,Ruback, R. S.(1995).The valuation of cash flow forecasts: An empirical analysis.The Journal of Finance,50(4),1059-1093.
12. Kim, M.,Ritter, J. R.(1999).Valuing IPOs.Journal of Financial Economics,53(3),409-437.
13. Maher, J. M.(1976).Discounts for lack of marketability for closely held business interests.Taxes,54,562.
14. Mercer, Z. C.(2001).Quantifying marketability discounts: Developing and supporting marketability discounts in the appraisal of closely held business interests.Peabody.
15. Moroney, R. E.(1973).Most courts overvalue closely held stocks.Taxes,51,144-156.
16. Pratt, S. P.,Reilly, R. F.,Schweihs, R. P.(2000).Valuing a business.McGraw-Hill.
17. Reilly, R.,Rotkowski, A.(2007).Discount for lack of marketability: Update on current studies and analysis of current controversies.The Tax Lawyer,61(1),241-286.
18. Silber, W. L.(1991).Discounts on Restricted Stock: The impact of illiquidity on stock prices.Financial Analysts Journal,47(4),60-64.
19. Theil, H.,Beerens, G.,Tilanus, C. B.,De Leeuw, C.(1966).Applied Economic Forecasting.North-Holland Publishing Company Amsterdam.
20. Trout, R. R.(1977).Estimation of the discount associated with the transfer of restricted securities.Taxes,55,381-384.
21. 安侯建業會計師事務所編譯(2010)。洞悉IFRS-KMPG觀點。
22. 吳啟銘(2001)。企業評價─個案實證分析。智勝出版。
23. 吳欽杉(2004)。行政院國家科學委員會專題研究計畫成果報告行政院國家科學委員會專題研究計畫成果報告,未出版
24. 吳雅雯(2012)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立台灣大學會計研究所。
25. 林家生(2012)。興櫃股票市場制度十週年之回顧與展望─專訪櫃買中心吳總經理裕群。證券櫃檯雙月刊，157，10-12。
26. 張千雲、周建新(2008)。興櫃市場新制對初次上市（櫃）股票短期折價行為之再探討。修平學報，16，79-94。
27. 陳怡靜(2003)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立中山大學財務管理研究所。
28. 陳樹(2012)。櫃買中心龍年新展望－興櫃市場十週年慶回顧與前瞻。證券櫃檯雙月刊，157，6-9。
29. 陳勸仁(2002)。未上市（櫃）股票交易之探討。玉山銀行雙月刊文集，56
30. 黃金澤(2011)。談公允價值衡量新基準。資誠通訊月刊，254，7-25。
31. 蔡彥卿(2011)。臺灣證券交易所股份有限公司財團法人中華民國證券櫃檯買賣中心100年研究計畫期末報告臺灣證券交易所股份有限公司財團法人中華民國證券櫃檯買賣中心100年研究計畫期末報告,未出版
32. 興櫃股票市場(2009)。證券櫃檯買賣中心15週年紀念特刊。
33. 賴建成(2008)。興櫃初期與興櫃轉上市櫃初期股票異常報酬之研究。遠東學報，25(4)，617-630。