题名

台灣會計學術單位期刊著作表現之再檢測

并列篇名

A Reexamination of the Contributions to Referred Journals by Taiwanese Accounting Institutions

DOI

10.6538/TAR.2016.1201.04

作者

吳安妮(An-Ne Wu)；王泰昌(Tay-Chang Wang)；彭火樹(Huo-Shu Peng)；陳美惠(Mei-Hui Chen)

关键词

會計教育 ； 研究生產力 ； 期刊著作表現 ； accounting education ； publication productivity ； journal publication

期刊名称

中華會計學刊

卷期/出版年月

12卷1期（2016 / 07 / 01）

页次

115 - 192

内容语文

繁體中文;英文
中文摘要

延續吳安妮、王泰昌與彭火樹 (2004) 分析國內大學院校會計系所專任教師於1992 ~ 2001 年（比較期）在國內外期刊之著作表現，本研究探討2002 ~ 2010年（再檢測期），並分析此兩段期間國內會計系所期刊著作表現之差異。研究結果顯示，各系所教師平均每人每年之期刊著作表現，再檢測期平均優於比較期；並證實會計系所教師特性（發表論文的共同作者人數、教職經驗及性別）與國內、外學術期刊發表篇數具關聯性。此外，各系所著作發表集中於少數人的現象亦有所改善。本研究之結果可供教師個人生涯規劃、各系所訂定績效考核及未來發展方向之參考，並有助於教育主管當局分配其有限資源及決定獎勵補助決策之參考，社會大眾亦可較客觀的衡量各系所的學術聲望及決定其捐款對象。
英文摘要

Wu, Wang, and Peng (2004) have analyzed the publication productivity of accounting departments in Taiwanese colleges and universities from 1992 to 2001. Our study extends the analysis to 2010. We compare the data of the ＂re-testing period,＂ 2002 ~ 2010, to that of the ＂comparative period,＂ 1992 to 2001. The comparison shows that, on average, the publication productivity in the re-testing period was higher than that of the comparative period. Moreover, we find publication productivity to be associated with the faculties'demographic characteristics, such as co-authorship, teaching experience, and gender. Also of note is that the centralization of scholars involved in research activity (measured by Gini coefficient) improved over the re-testing period. The findings of this study can be used by faculties in career planning, by universities in departmental performance evaluations, by educational authorities in resource allocation decisions, and by the public in funding considerations.
主题分类 社會科學 > 財金及會計學
参考文献
  1. 吳安妮、王泰昌、彭火樹(2004)。台灣會計學術單位期刊著作表現之研究。證券市場發展季刊，16(1)，1-52。
    連結：
  2. 俞明德、沈仰斌、蔡湘萍(2011)。台灣財金系所期刊著作表現之研究：2003～2008。財務金融學刊，19(1)，97-133。
    連結：
  3. 戚樹誠、洪世章、廖苑君、陳彥君(2004)。台灣管理學術單位在組織與管理領域之國際學術期刊上發表狀況研究。台灣管理學刊，4(1)，1-24。
    連結：
  4. 曹添旺、管中閔、郭炳伸、張峰嘉、陳致綱(2006)。經濟學術期刊的分等與台灣各經濟學系所的學術表現。經濟論文，34(3)，391-433。
    連結：
  5. 曹添旺、賴景昌、張峰嘉(2002)。台灣經濟學術單位在EconLit 資料庫的學術表現。經濟論文，30(2)，115-152。
    連結：
  6. 黃三益、賴香菊、梁定澎、孫培真(2002)。台灣資訊管理學術單位在學術期刊上的發表狀況之研究。資訊管理學報，9(1)，217-239。
    連結：
  7. 賴香菊、黃三益、梁定澎、洪新原、吳祥麟(2011)。台灣資訊管理學術單位學術期刊發表狀況。資訊管理學報，18(3)，175-196。
    連結：
  8. Heck, J. L. 2009. “Most prolific authors in the accounting literature over the past halfcentury: 1959-2008.” Working paper. Saint Joseph's University
  9. 教育部，2003，教育部針對報載2002 年SSCI、SCI、EI論文篇數統計提出說明，教育部。檢索於2003 年10 月30 日，http://www.edu.tw/university/importance/921030-1.htm
  10. Allen, M.(1996).Research productivity and positive teaching evaluations: Examining the relationship through meta-analysis.Journal of the Association for Communication Administration,2,77-96.
  11. Andrew, W. T.,McKenzie, P. B.(1978).Leading accounting departments revisited.The Accounting Review,53(1),135-138.
  12. Ballas, A.,Theoharakis, V.(2003).Exploring diversity in accounting through faculty journal perceptions.Contemporary Accounting Research,20(4),619-644.
  13. Barney, J.(1991).Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage.Journal of Management,17(1),99-120.
  14. Bazley, J. D.,Nikolai, L. A.(1975).A comparison of published accounting research and qualities of accounting faculty and doctoral programs.The Accounting Review,50(3),605-610.
  15. Bean, D. F.,Bernardi, R. A.(2005).Estimating the ratings of journals omitted in prior quality ratings.Advances in Accounting Education,7,109-127.
  16. Beattie, V.,Goodacre, A.(2006).A new method for ranking academic journals in accounting and finance.Accounting and Business Research,36(2),65-91.
  17. Bonner, S. E.,Hesford, J. W.,Van der Stede, W. A.,Young, S. M.(2006).The most influential journals in academic accounting.Accounting, Organizations and Society,31(7),663-685.
  18. Boyer, E. L.(1990).Scholarship reconsidered: Priorities of the professorate.Princeton, NJ:Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching.
  19. Brown, L. D.,Huefner, R. J.(1994).The familiarity with and perceived quality of accounting journals: Views of senior accounting faculty in leading US MBA programs.Contemporary Accounting Research,11(1),223-250.
  20. Brown, L. D.,Laksmana, I.(2004).Ranking accounting Ph.D. programs and faculties using social science research network downloads.Review of Quantitative Finance and Accounting,22(3),249-266.
  21. Brownell, P.,Godfrey, J.(1993).Professorial rankings of Australian Accounting Departments.The Australian Economic Review,26(4),77-87.
  22. Bublitz, B.,Kee, R.(1984).Measures of research productivity.Issues in Accounting Education,1,39-60.
  23. Buchheit, S.,Collins, A. B.,Collins, D. L.(2001).Intra-institutional factors that influence accounting research productivity.The Journal of Applied Business Research,17(2),17-32.
  24. Buchheit, S.,Collins, D.,Reitenga, A.(2002).A cross-discipline comparison of top-tier academic journal publication rates: 1997-1999.Journal of Accounting Education,20(2),123-130.
  25. Burke, D.(1988).A new academic marketplace.Westport, CT:Greenwood Press.
  26. Campbell, D. R.,Morgan, R. G.(1987).Publication activity of promoted accounting faculty.Issues in Accounting Education,2(1),28-43.
  27. Caplow, T.,McGee, R. J.(1958).The academic marketplace.New York, NY:Basic Books.
  28. Cargile, B. R.,Bublitz, B.(1986).Factors contributing to published research by accounting faculties.The Accounting Review,61(1),158-178.
  29. Chan, K. C.,Chan, K. C.,Seow, G. S.,Tam, K.(2009).Ranking accounting journals using dissertation citation analysis: A research note.Accounting, Organizations and Society,34(6-7),875-885.
  30. Chan, K. C.,Chen, C. R.,Cheng, L. T. W.(2005).Ranking research productivity in accounting for Asia-Pacific Universities.Review of Quantitative Finance and Accounting,24(1),47-64.
  31. Chan, K. C.,Liano, K.(2009).Threshold citation analysis of influential articles, journals, institutions and researchers in accounting.Accounting and Finance,49(1),59-74.
  32. Chen, Y.,Gupta, A.,Hoshower, L.(2006).Factors the motivate business faculty to conduct research: An expectancy theory analysis.Journal of Education for Business,81(4),179-189.
  33. Chow, C. W.,Harrison, P.(1998).Factors contributing to success in research and publications: Insights of 'influential' accounting authors.Journal of Accounting Education,16(3-4),463-472.
  34. Chung, K. H.,Pak, H. S.,Cox, R. A. K.(1992).Patterns of research output in the accounting literature: A study of the bibliometric distributions.Abacus,28(2),168-185.
  35. Clark, B. R.(1995).Places of inquiry: Research and advanced education in modern universities.Berkeley, CA:University of California Press.
  36. Clemente, F.,Sturgis, R. B.(1974).Quality of department of doctoral training and research productivity.Sociology of Education,47(2),287-299.
  37. Coyne, J. G.,Summers, S. L.,Williams, B.,Wood, D. A.(2010).Accounting program research rankings by topical area and methodology.Issues in Accounting Education,25(4),631-654.
  38. Danielson, M. G.,Heck, J. L.(2010).Giving credit where credit is due: Summary analysis of the most prolific authors in 15 high-impact accounting journals.Advances in Accounting: Incorporating Advances in International Accounting,26(2),195-206.
  39. Diamond, A. M.(1986).The life-cycle research productivity of mathematicians and scientists.Journal of Gerontology,41(4),520-525.
  40. Dwyer, P. D.(1994).Gender differences in the scholarly activities of accounting academics: An empirical investigation.Issues in Accounting Education,9(2),231-346.
  41. Dyckman, T. R.,Zeff, S. A.(1984).Two decades of the journal of accounting research.Journal of Accounting Research,22(1),225-297.
  42. Dyl, E. A.,Lilly, M. S.(1985).A note on institutional contributions to the accounting literature.Accounting, Organizations and Society,10(2),171-175.
  43. Englebrecht, T. D.,Iyer, G. S.,Patterson, D. M.(1994).An empirical investigation of the publication productivity of promoted accounting faculty.Accounting Horizons,8(1),45-68.
  44. Everett, J. O.,Klamm, B.,Stoltzfus, R.(2004).Developing benchmark for evaluating publication records at doctoral programs in accounting.Journal of Accounting Education,22(3),229-252.
  45. Fogarty, T. J.,Ruhl, J. M.(1996).The stratification of academic accounting in the U.S.: The role of doctoral funding grants.Critical Perspectives on Accounting,7(5),509-528.
  46. Fogarty, T. J.,Ruhl, J. M.(1997).Institutional antecedents of accounting faculty research productivity: A LISREL study of the 'best and brightest'.Issues in Accounting Education,12(1),27-48.
  47. Fox, M. F.(1992).Research, teaching, and publication productivity: Mutuality versus competition in academia.Sociology of Education,65(4),293-305.
  48. Gordon, G.,Marquis, S.(1966).Freedom, visibility of consequences, and scientific innovation.The American Journal of Sociology,72(2),195-202.
  49. Hagerman, R. L.,Hagerman, C. M.(1989).Research promotion standards at selected accounting programs.Issues in Accounting Education,4(2),265-279.
  50. Hancock, T.,Lane, J.,Ray, R.,Glennon, D.(1992).Factors influencing academic research productivity: A survey of management scientists.Interfaces,22(5),26-38.
  51. Hasselback, J. R.,Reinstein, A.(1995).A proposal for measuring the scholarly productivity of accounting faculty.Issues in Accounting Education,10(2),269-306.
  52. Hasselback, J. R.,Reinstein, A.(1995).Assessing accounting doctoral programs by their graduates' research productivity.Advances in Accounting,13,61-86.
  53. Heck, J. L.,Jensen, R. E.,Cooley, P. L.(1990).An analysis of contributors to accounting journals, Part I: The aggregate performances.The International Journal of Accounting,25,202-217.
  54. Heck, J. L.,Jensen, R. E.,Cooley, P. L.(1991).An analysis of contributors to accounting journals, Part II: The individual academic accounting journals.The International Journal of Accounting,26,1-17.
  55. Herron, T. L.,Hall, T. W.(2004).Faculty perceptions of journals: Quality and publishing feasibility.Journal of Accounting Education,22(3),175-210.
  56. Jacobs, F. A.,Hartgraves, A. L.,Beard, L. H.(1986).Publication productivity of doctoral alumni: A time adjusted model.The Accounting Review,61(1),179-187.
  57. Jones, J. E.,Preusz, G. C.(1993).Attitudinal factors associated with individual faculty research productivity in academic dentistry.Perceptual and Motor Skills,76(2),1191-1198.
  58. Kim, S.(2003).The impact of research productivity on early retirement of university professors.Industrial Relations: A Journal of Economy and Society,42(1),106-125.
  59. Kirkpatrick, S. A.,Locke, E. A.(1992).The development of measures of faculty scholarship.Group & Organization Management,17(1),5-23.
  60. Koch, B. S.,Merino, B. D.,Berman, N. D.(1983).Publishing patterns of doctoral graduates: A preference for perishing.Proceedings, Doctoral Programs in Accounting Conference, American Accounting Association
  61. Long, J. S.(1978).Productivity and academic position in the scientific career.American Sociological Review,43(6),889-908.
  62. Lowe, A.,Locke, J.(2005).Perceptions of journal quality and research paradigm: Results of a web-based survey of British accounting academics.Accounting, Organizations and Society,30(1),81-98.
  63. Lowensohn, S.,Samelson, D. P.(2006).An examination of faculty perceptions of academic journal quality within five specialized areas of accounting research.Issues in Accounting Education,21(3),219-239.
  64. Mathieu, R.,McConomy, B. J.(2003).Productivity in "top-ten" academic accounting journals by researchers at Canadian universities.Canadian Accounting Perspectives,2(1),43-76.
  65. Milburn, L.-A. S.,Brown, R. D.(2003).The relationship of age, gender, and education to research productivity in landscape architecture faculty in North America.Landscape Journal,22(1),54-62.
  66. Milne, R. A.,Vent, G. A.(1987).Publication productivity: A comparison of accounting faculty members promoted in 1981 and 1984.Issues in Accounting Education,2(1),94-102.
  67. Moizer, P.(2009).Publishing in accounting journals: A fair game?.Accounting, Organizations and Society,34(2),285-304.
  68. Moore, L. J.,Taylor, B. W.(1980).A study of institutional publications in Business-Related Academic Journals 1972-1978.Quarterly Review of Economics and Business,20(Spring),87-97.
  69. Neumann, R.(1996).Researching the teaching-research nexus: A critical review.Australian Journal of Education,40(1),5-18.
  70. Oler, D. K.,Oler, M. J.,Skousen, C. J.(2010).Charaterizing accounting research.Accounting Horizons,24(4),635-670.
  71. Pickerd, J.,Stephens, N. M.,Summers, S. L.,Wood, D. A.(2011).Individual accounting faculty research rankings by topical area and methodology.Issues in Accounting Education,26(3),471-505.
  72. Pierce, B.,Garven, G.(1995).Publishing international business research: A survey of leading journals.Journal of International Business Studies,26(1),69-89.
  73. Rebne, D.(1990).Determinants of individual productivity: A study of academic researchers.Institute of Industrial Relations Publications Center, UCLA.
  74. Reinstein, A.,Calderon, T. G.(2006).Examining accounting departments' rankings of the quality of accounting journals.Critical Perspectives on Accounting,17(4),457-490.
  75. Reinstein, A.,Hasselback, J. R.(1997).A literature review of articles assessing the productivity of accounting faculty members.Journal of Accounting Education,15(3),425-455.
  76. Reinstein, A.,Hasselback, J. R.,Riley, M. E.,Sinason, D. H.(2011).Pitfalls of using citation indices for making academic accounting promotion, tenure, teaching load, and merit pay decisions.Issue in Accounting Education,20(1),99-131.
  77. Rosenstreich, D.,Wooliscroft, B.(2009).Measuring the impact of accounting journals using Google Scholar and the g-index.The British Accounting Review,41(4),227-239.
  78. Stephens, N. M.,Summers, S. L.,Williams, B.,Wood, D. A.(2011).Accounting doctoral program rankings based on research productivity of program graduates.Accounting Horizons,25(1),149-181.
  79. Storer, N. W.(ed.)(1973).The Sociology of Science: Theoretical and empirical investigations.Chicago, IL:University of Chicago Press.
  80. Street, D. L.,Baril, C. P.(1994).Scholarly accomplishments in promotion and tenure decisions of accounting faculty.Journal of Accounting Education,12(2),121-139.
  81. Streuly, C. A.,Maranto, C. L.(1994).Accounting faculty research productivity and citations: Are there gender differences?.Issues in Accounting Education,9(2),247-258.
  82. Swanson, E. P.(2004).Publishing in the majors: A comparison of accounting, finance, management, and marketing.Contemporary Accounting Research,21(1),223-255.
  83. Tripathy, N.,Ganesh, G. K.(1996).Evaluation, promotion, and tenure of finance faculty: The evaluators' perspective.Financial Practice and Education,6(1),46-53.
  84. Urbancic, F. R.(1986).Publishing performance by accounting faculty: Comparisons and measures of productivity.Proceedings, 1986 Southwest Regional Meeting
  85. Williams, P. F.,Jenkins, J. G.,Ingraham, L.(2006).The winnowing away of behavioral accounting research in the U.S.: The process for anointing academic elites.Accounting, Organizations and Society,31(8),783-818.
  86. Windal, F. W.(1981).Publishing for a varied public: An empirical study.The Accounting Review,56(3),653-658.
  87. Wu, J.,Hao, Q.,Yao, M. Y. M.(2009).Ranking of academic journals in accounting, finance, and information system: Perception from the college chairpersons.International Journal of Accounting and Information Management,17(1),66-105.
  88. Zamarripa, E. J.(1995).Evaluating research productivity.SRA Journal,26(3-4),17-27.
  89. Zuckerman, H.(1970).Stratification in American science.Sociological Inquiry,40(2),235-257.
  90. 吳壽山、許和鈞、楊馥如、葉立仁(2002)。我國管理領域學術研究成果統計報告（上）—論文發表量及各校領域別的發展量效率分析。人文與社會科學簡訊，4(2)，46-73。
  91. 沈仰斌、俞明德、張峰嘉(2002)。台灣財金學術單位在財金期刊之著作表現。證券市場發展，14(3)，1-43。
  92. 林修葳、俞洪昭、李佳玲、吳清在、王泰昌(2006)。行政院國家科學委員會專題研究計畫成果報告行政院國家科學委員會專題研究計畫成果報告,未出版
  93. 陳業寧、胡星陽、張森林、盧秋玲、蔡政憲、張紹基(2011)。行政院國家科學委員會專題研究計畫成果報告行政院國家科學委員會專題研究計畫成果報告,未出版
  94. 陳聖賢、林丙輝、張士傑、盧秋玲(2005)。行政院國家科學委員會專題研究計畫成果報告行政院國家科學委員會專題研究計畫成果報告,未出版
被引用次数
  1. 黃淑玲、沈碩彬(2017)。大學教師職級、主持研發計畫數與研究產能關聯性之探討：以一所私立醫學大學為例。教育科學研究期刊，62(4)，89-115。
print cancel