中晚明儒者友誼研究

Review of Scholarship on Confucian Friendship in the Mid- and Late- Ming China

10.6672/shiyuan.2017.29.05

詹前倬(Chan, Chien-Cho)

友誼 ； 友道 ； 友倫 ； 明代 ； 儒學 ； Male Friendship ； Ming China ； Confucianism

史原

復刊8期=29期（2017 / 09 / 01）

227 - 251

繁體中文

處於開展階段的中國友誼研究中，中晚明是較受矚目的一個時段。係因「尚友」風氣自陽明學興起以後，至晚明興盛一時，不少儒者對此有新穎之見解。儒者為此時期主要關注的對象，他們的言說與實踐都受到細膩的檢視。部分學者已有研究，然綜述整理或討論尚屬稀缺，僅見英文學界黃衛總（Martin W. Huang）為「明代的男性友誼」（Male Friendship in Ming China）專號寫的導論，著重於背景說明，並突出專號文章之貢獻。中文學界則尚無專文回顧。本文梳理前輩學人對中晚明儒者友誼的研究，將成果依據研究取徑分為四階段，以便說明此一研究的發展，並提出個人對友誼研究未來發展的淺見。

As an emerging field of research, studies of male friendship in China primarily focus in the friendship among Confucian scholars in the mid- and late- Ming periods, since the advocacy of friendship was initially flourished under the influence of Yangming school and reached its peak by the late Ming. A few studies have examined, yet few comprehensively reviewed Confucian scholars' discourses and practices regarding friendship at that time, except for Martin W. Huang's introduction to Male Friendship in Ming China (2007). This paper reviews the development of current scholarship according to four different themes/approaches. The focus has shifted from the definition and interpretation of friendship within Confucianism to the actual practice of friendship. In conclusion, this paper suggests several potential directions for future research in this area.

1. 朱偉誠(2015)。西方友誼研究及其在地用處初探。台灣社會研究季刊，99，1-77。
   連結：
2. 何宇軒(2013)。方興未艾：學術界的中國男性史研究。漢學研究通訊，32(4)，1-10。
   連結：
3. 何宇軒(2015)。中國男性史研究論著目錄。書目季刊，49(2)，105-121。
   連結：
4. 盧嘉琪(2012)。走過十五載的《男女》。近代中國婦女史研究，20，229-246。
   連結：
5. Besio, Kimberly(2007).A Friendship of Metal and Stone: Representations of Fan Juqing and Zhang Yuanbo in the Ming Dynasty.Nan Nü: Men, Women, and Gender in China,9(1),111-145.
6. Clunas, Craig(2004).Elegant Debts: The Social Art of Wen Zhengming.Honolulu:University of Hawai'i Press.
7. De Bary, William Theodore(1970).Individualism and Humanitarianism in Late Ming Thought.Self and Society in Ming Thought,New York:
8. De Vos, George A.(ed.),Sofue, Takao(ed.)(1984).Religion & the Family in East Asia.Berkeley:University of California Press.
9. Gerritsen, Anne(2007).Friendship through Fourteenth-Century Fissures: Dai Liang, Wu Sidao and Ding Henian.Nan Nü,9(1),34-69.
10. Hinsch, Bret(1992).Passions of the Cut Sleeve: The Male Homosexual Tradition in China.Berkeley:University of California Press.
11. Huang, Martin W.(2007).Male Friendship and Jiangxue (Philosophical Debates) in Sixteenth-Century China.Nan Nü,9(1),146-178.
12. Huang, Martin W.(2007).Male Friendship in Ming China: An Introduction.Nan Nü,9(1),2-33.
13. Huang, Martin W.(2013).Male-Male Sexual Bonding and Male Friendship in Late Imperial China.Journal of the History of Sexuality,22(2),312-331.
14. Kutcher, Norman(2000).The Fifth Relationship: Dangerous Friendships in the Confucian Context.The American Historical Review,105(5),1615-1629.
15. Lam, Joseph S. C.(2007).Music and Male Bonding in Ming China.Nan Nü,9(1),70-110.
16. Leaman, Oliver(ed.)(1996).Friendship East and West: Philosophical perspectives.Richmond:Curzon Press.
17. McDermott, Joseph P.(1992)。Friendship and Its Friends in the Late Ming..。近世家族與政治比較歷史論文集，臺北:
18. Ricci、 Matteo,Billings, Timothy(trans.)(2009).On Friendship: One Hundred Maxims for a Chinese Prince.New York:Columbia University Press.
19. Shields, Anna(2015).One Who Knows Me: Friendship and Literary Culture in Mid-Tang China.Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press.
20. Vervoorn, Aat(2004).Friendship in Ancient China.East Asian History,27,1-32.
21. Vitiello, Giovanni(2011).The Libertine's Friend: Homosexuality and Masculinity in Late Imperial China.Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
22. Wei-Ming, Tu(1979).Ultimate Self-Transformation as a Communal Act: Comments on Modes of Self-Cultivation in Traditional China.Journal of Chinese Philosophy,6,237-246.
23. 呂妙芬(2006)。陽明學士人社群：歷史、思想與實踐。北京:新星出版社。
24. 張藝曦(1998)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。臺北，國立臺灣大學歷史學系。
25. 郭齊勇編、鄭文龍編(2002)。杜維明文集。武漢:武漢出版社。
26. 陳雯怡(2013)。「承道」論述與「求道」傳記︰宋代「師友淵源」概念的發展與表現。近世中國之變與不變，臺北:
27. 陳翠英(2011)。疆界內外─《聊齋誌異》的同性情愛。文與哲，19，317-350。
28. 黃宗羲編(1977)。明文海。臺北:商務印書館。
29. 蔡淑閔(2005)。博士論文(博士論文)。臺北，國立政治大學中國文學研究所。
30. 鄧志峰(2004)。王學與晚明的師道復興運動。北京:社會科學文獻出版社。
31. 魏月萍(2016)。君師道合：晚明儒者的三教合一論述。臺北:聯經出版公司。