發展數位教材輔助學生學習之研究—以科大學生之統計教學課程為例

Developing Digital Multimedia Educational Materials in an Introductory Statistics Course at a University of Science and Technology

10.6278/tjme.20140904.002

楊玲惠(Ling-Hui Yang)；翁頂升(Ting-Sheng Weng)；楊德清(Der-Ching Yang)

統計態度 ； 統計焦慮 ； 數位教材 ； attitudes towards statistics ； statistics anxiety ； digital teaching materials

臺灣數學教育期刊

2卷1期（2015 / 04 / 01）

1 - 22

繁體中文

本研究透過課程分析進行數位教材之設計與實施，改進教學歷程及評估教學成效。開發之數位教材內容以敘述統計與機率兩單元為主，以Flash CS6製作動畫影片，其設計理念藉由動畫帶引統計運算流程與步驟，以及正式的符號，依對應之圖形呈現統計量大小意涵與其資料分佈之特徵，強化學習者在這三者之間的串聯，讓統計思考在統計教學過程中建立，以達成資料、圖形與資訊的聯結進而訓練其批判能力。依學期初前測與期末後測之統計學習態度及統計焦慮調查，資料顯示學習者在學習過程中，在情意（affect）、價值（value）、困難感（difficulty）與認知能力（cognitive competence）四個面向有顯著提升；在統計焦慮層面，學習焦慮（learning anxiety）、考試焦慮（examination anxiety）和解讀焦慮（interpretationanxiety）下降程度具有顯著成效。根據PLS分析，驗證統計焦慮對統計學習態度有顯著負向之影響效果，統計學習態度對學習績效有顯著正向之影響效果；但經由教學歷程中數位教材之應用，學習者在統計焦慮與學習績效之關係而言，前測資料驗證統計焦慮對學習績效有顯著負向之影響效果，但後測資料顯示，統計焦慮對學習績效並不具負向影響效果。

This study involved developing digital multimedia materials and assessing their influence on students' attitudes and anxiety towards statistics in a statistics course at a University of Science and Technology. Digital teaching materials were developed for Descriptive Statistics and Probability courses, they featured graphical and visualization techniques to assist students in analyzing data, thinking about statistical ideas, and focusing on the interpretation of results and the understanding of concepts. We assessed students' attitudes and anxiety when they began the course and after they had completed it. Significant effects were observed in 4 attitude scales (affect, value, difficulty, and cognitive competence) and 3 anxiety scales (learning anxiety, examination anxiety, and interpretation anxiety). The difference in scores (posttest-pretest) increases in attitudes and decreases in anxiety which were attributed to using the digital multimedia educational materials. A partial least squares method was used to test the effects of students’ statistics anxiety, attitudes toward statistics, and application of digital teaching materials on their achievement in an introductory statistics course. The results of the study revealed that statistics anxiety and attitudes towards statistics were the most accurate predictors of students' achievement in statistics at the beginning of the course. Nevertheless, the analysis indicated that only students' attitudes were a critical factor, directly affecting directly their achievements at the ending of the course. In addition, statistics anxiety exerted an indirect effect on the achievements in statistics by influencing the attitudes of the students towards statistics anxiety. This paper presents a discussion of the implications of these findings for teaching and learning statistics.

1. 張旭華、呂鑌洧(2007)。整合二維品質模式與品質機能展開應用於高等技職教育服務之實證研究。品質學報，14(4)，405-421。
   連結：
2. 郭國禎、駱芳美(2011)。統計焦慮量表信度與效度考驗。輔導與諮商學報，33(1)，23-38。
   連結：
3. 楊玲惠、何光明、周鉦凱(2012)。技術校院餐飲管理系教育品質屬性之個案研究－Kano 二維品質模式與IPA 方法的應用分析。技術及職業教育學報，5(1)，1-39。
   連結：
4. 劉明盛(2008)。應用Kano 模式探討大學教育品質―以某科技大學為例。品質學報，15(1)，39-61。
   連結：
5. Schield, M. (2009). Assessing statistical literacy and attitudes following a second course of business statistics. Retrieved from http://www.StatLit.org/pdf/2009PhelpsASA6up.pdf
6. Babić-Hodović, V.,Mehić, E.(2004).Quality dimensional analysis: A basis for marketing strategy of higher educational institutions..Zagreb International Review of Economics and Business,1,171-187.
7. Carlson, K. A.,Winquist, J. R.(2011).Evaluating an active learning approach to teaching introductory statistics: A classroom workbook approach.Journal of Statistics Education,19(1),1-23.
8. Chance, B.,Ben-Zvi, D.,Garfield, J.,Medina, E.(2007).The role of technology in improving student learning of statistics.Technology Innovations in Statistics Education Journal,1(1),1-26.
9. Chen, S. C.,Hsu, C. W.,Lin, H. C.,Chou, H. Y.(2010).The evaluation and using intention for digital teaching materials of Penghu basalt.International Journal of Management & Information Systems,14(5),141-146.
10. Chiesi, F.,Primi, C.(2009).Assessing statistics attitudes among college students: Psychometric properties of the Italian version of the Survey of Attitudes toward Statistics (SATS).Learning and Individual Differences,19(2),309-313.
11. Chin, W. W.(1998).Issues and opinion on structural equation modeling.Management Information Systems Quarterly,22(1),7-16.
12. Clark, R. C.,Mayer, R. E.(2008).E-learning and the science of instruction: Proven guidelines for consumers and designers of multimedia learning.San Francisco, CA:Pfeiffer.
13. Cruise, R. J.,Cash, R. W.,Bolton, D. L.(1985).Development and validation of an instrument to measure statistical anxiety.the annual meeting of the Statistical Education Section,Chicago, IL.:
14. DeVaney, T. A.(2010).Anxiety and attitude of graduate students in on-campus vs. online statistics courses.Journal of Statistics Education,18(1),1-15.
15. Evans, B.(2007).Student attitudes, conceptions, and achievement in introductory undergraduate college statistics.The Mathematics Educator,17(2),24-30.
16. Finney, S. J.,Schraw, G.(2003).Self-efficacy beliefs in college statistics courses.Contemporary Educational Psychology,28(2),161-186.
17. Fitzgerald, S. M.(1997).Toledo, OH,University of Toledo.
18. Fitzgerald, S. M., Jurs, S. J.,Hudson, L. M.(1996).A model predicting statistics achievement among graduate students.College Student Journal,30(3),361-366.
19. Fornell, C.,Larcker, D. F.(1981).Evaluating structural equation models with unobservable variables and measurement error.Journal of Marketing Research,18(1),39-50.
20. Gal, I.(2002).Adults' statistical literacy: Meanings, components, responsibilities.International Statistical Review,70(1),1-25.
21. Gal, I.(Ed.),Garfield, J. B.(Ed.)(1997).The assessment challenge in statistics education.Amsterdam, the Netherlands:IOS Press.
22. Gal, I.(Ed.),Garfield, J. B.(Ed.)(1997).The Assessment Challenge in Statistics Education.Amsterdam,the Netherlands:IOS Press.
23. Giller, S.,Barker, P.(2006).An evolving methodology for managing multimedia courseware production.Innovations in Education and Teaching International,43(3),303-312.
24. Harlow, L. L.,Burkholder, G. J.,Morrow, J. A.(2002).Evaluating attitudes, skill, and performance in a learning-enhanced quantitative methods course: A structural modeling approach.Structural Equation Modeling: A Multidisciplinary Journal,9(3),413-430.
25. Hsu, M. K.,Wang, S. W.,Chiu, K. K. S.(2008).Influence of attitude, anxiety and self-efficacy toward statistics and technology on statistical package software usage behavior.Proceedings of the 2008 Southwest Decision Sciences Institute Annual Conference,Houston, TX:
26. Lalayants, M.(2012).Overcoming graduate students' negative perceptions of statistics.Journal of Teaching in Social Work,32(4),356-375.
27. Lalonde, R. N.,Gardner, R. C.(1993).Statistics as a second language? A model for predicting performance in psychology students..Canadian Journal of Behavioural Science,25(1),108-125.
28. Matzler, K.,Hinterhuber, H. H.(1998).How to make product development projects more successful by integrating Kano's model of customer satisfaction into quality function development.Technovation,18(1),25-38.
29. Mills, J. D.(2004).Students' attitudes toward statistics: Implications for future.College Student Journal,38(3),349-361.
30. Onwuegbuzie, A. J.(2004).Academic procrastination and statistics anxiety.Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education,29(1),3-19.
31. Onwuegbuzie, A. J.,DaRos, D.,Ryan, J. M.(1997).The components of statistics anxiety: A phenomenological study.Focus on Learning Problems in Mathematics,19(4),11-35.
32. Onwuegbuzie, A. J.,Slate, J. R.,Paterson, F. R. A.,Watson, M. H.,Schwartz, R. A.(2000).Factors associated with achievement in educational research courses.Research in the Schools,7(1),53-65.
33. Onwuegbuzie, A. J.,Wilson, V. A.(2003).Statistics anxiety: Nature, etiology, antecedents, effects and treatments - A comprehensive review of the literature.Teaching in Higher Education,8(2),195-209.
34. Schau, C.(2003).Students' attitudes: The "other" important outcome in statistics education.the 2003 Joint Statistical Meetings,San Francisco, CA.:
35. Schau, C.,Emmioğlu, E.(2012).Do introductory statistics courses in the United States improve students' attitudes?.Statistics Education Research Journal,11(2),86-94.
36. Schau, C.,Stevens, J.,Dauphinee, T. L.,Del Vecchio, A.(1995).The development and validation of the survey of attitudes toward statistics.Educational and Psychological Measurement,55(5),868-875.
37. Sizemore, O. J.,Lewandowski, G. W.(2009).Learning might not equal liking: Research methods course changes knowledge but not attitudes.Teaching of Psychology,36(2),90-95.
38. Suanpang, P.,Petocz, P.,Kalceff, W.(2004).Student attitudes to learning business statistics: Comparison of online and traditional methods.Educational Technology & Society,7(3),9-20.
39. Tishkovskaya, S.,Lancaster, G. A.(2012).Statistical education in the 21st century: A review of challenges, teaching innovations and strategies for reform.Journal of Statistics Education,20(2),1-56.
40. Uzuntiryaki, E.,Bilgin, I.,Geban, O.(2003).The effect of learning styles on high school students' achievement and attitudes in chemistry.the Annual Meeting of the National Association for Research in Science Teaching,Philadelphia, PA:
41. Vigil-Colet, A.,Lorenzo-Seva, U.,Condon, L.(2008).Development and validation of the statistical anxiety scale.Psicothema,20(1),174-180.
42. Williams, A. S.(2010).Statistics anxiety and instructor immediacy.Journal of Statistics Education,18(2),1-18.
43. Wise, S. L.(1985).The development and validation of a scale measuring attitudes toward statistics.Educational and Psychological Measurement,45,401-405.
44. Zanakis, S. H.,Valenzi, E. R.(1997).Student anxiety and attitudes in business statistics.Journal of Education for Business,73(1),10-16.
45. Zhang, Z.,Fan, L.(2014).Research on negative influence and strategies of multimedia education in universities.Proceedings of the 2014 International Conference on Education Reform and Modern Management (ERMM 2014),Phuket, Thailand:
46. 李永明、吳麗莎(2004)。大學擴招後的文科高等數學教學的研究與探索。上饒師範學院學報，24(3)，19-21。
47. 林曉芳、盧冠樺(2009)。統計學令研究生害怕嗎？以教育統計學的學習歷程為例。明道學術論壇，5(2)，41-61。
48. 張偉(2010)。淺談文科高等數學教學。數學學習與研究，2010(5)，16。
49. 畢建芝、段生貴、劉宇輝(2005)。概率論與數理統計教學內容和課程體系的改革與實踐。中國科技信息，2005(16)，555。
50. 郭國禎、駱芳美(2005)。統計焦慮量表的編製。第二屆統計方法學學術研會暨台灣統計方法學學會年會，臺北:
51. 劉子鍵、林怡均(2005)。以概念構圖法探究高中（職）生對「相關」概念之理解及具有之迷思概念。2005 年學習、教學與評量國際研討會，臺北:

1. 陳柏霖(2016)。整合式課程設計：關鍵學習落實在心理統計學課程。新竹教育大學教育學報，33(1)，109-140。
2. 陳敏郎(2021)。多元教學方法於基礎性專業課程之教學實踐研究。弘光學報，88，69-87。
3. 黃慧莉,尹順君(2022)。探討跨科整合數位互動教材應用於「基礎醫學總論」課程之可行性。大學教學實務與研究學刊，6(2)，1-23。
4. 賴虹霖(2021)。數位教學影音與深刻學習對學生學習成效之影響－以金融審計課程為例。商管科技季刊，22(3)，405-424。
5. 盧宏益(2020)。數理統計創新教學：資訊科技融入與數位學習網站實作之教學實踐歷程。大學教學實務與研究學刊，4(2)，97-121。
6. 錢昭萍、黃國豪、梁麗珍、李琛瑜、王羽萱(2016)。圖像式媒體融入國文教學對學習之影響－以科技大學藝術設計與非藝術設計學生為例。人文社會學報，12(4)，277-304。
7. 錢昭萍、梁麗珍(2017)。多元教學對不同學院與性別的學生學習態度與學習成效之影響—以科技大學大一國文課為例。人文社會學報，13(3)，219-249。