眼球追蹤技術在幾何教育的應用與限制

Applications and Limitations of Eye Tracking in Geometry Education

10.6278/tjme.201910_6(2).001

吳昭容(Chao-Jung Wu)

問題解決 ； 眼動 ； 眼動楷模 ； 幾何閱讀 ； problem solving ； eye movements ； EMME ； geometry reading

臺灣數學教育期刊

6卷2期（2019 / 10 / 01）

1 - 25

繁體中文

幾何是高度依賴視覺的學科。了解人們在幾何任務中如何運用視覺資訊，將有助於幾何教育。本文首先簡介了眼球追蹤技術的原理與指標，其次說明15篇幾何眼動文獻的搜尋方式，接著將期刊論文分成四個主題加以回顧，包括幾何解題與論證、閱讀與學習、口語解碼與媒體設計，以及眼動楷模。每篇文獻回顧了研究法、認知作業與材料、實驗程序，以及研究發現。本文在最後的結論與建議一節，除了從受試者特性、認知作業、幾何材料、眼動儀型態，與眼動指標的選擇來總結這些文獻，也指出眼球追蹤技術目前應用在幾何教育上的限制與突破的方式，同時也展望幾何眼動研究未來值得探究的主題。

Geometry is a highly visual discipline. Understanding how people process visual information when performing geometric tasks would be beneficial for geometry education. This article first introduces the principles and indicators of eye-tracking techniques, and then describes the procedures of paper selection and screening. The third to sixth sections reviews four topics from fifteen papers on geometry education using eye tracking, including problem solving and argumentation, reading and learning, lexical decoding and media design, and EMME. The research design, cognitive tasks and materials, procedures, and results involved in each study are reviewed. The conclusions and implications are summarized under three aspects. First, we summarize these studies by the characteristics of participants, cognitive tasks, geometric materials, eye-tracking devices, and eye-tracking indicators. Second, we identify the limits of eye tracking in geometry education and possible future breakthroughs. Third, future eye tracking research topics are discussed.

1. 陳琪瑤, C. Y.,吳昭容, C. J.(2012)。幾何證明文本閱讀的眼動研究 : 圖文比重及圖示著色效果。教育實踐，25(2)，35-66。
   連結：
2. 陳學志, H. C.,彭淑玲, S. L.,曾千芝, C. C.,邱皓政, H. W.(2008)。藉由眼動追蹤儀器探討平均掃視幅度大小與創造力之關系。教育心理學報，39(S)，127-149。
   連結：
3. 陳學志, H. C.,賴惠德, H. D.,邱發忠, F. C.(2010)。眼球追蹤技術在學習與教育上的應用。教育科學研究期刊，55(4)，39-68。
   連結：
4. 簡郁芩, Y. C.,吳昭容, C. J.(2012)。以眼動型態和閱讀測則驗表現探討箭頭在科學圖文閱讀中的圖示效果。中華心理學刊，54(3)，385-402。
   連結：
5. Alemdag, E.,Cagiltay, K.(2018).A systematic review of eye tracking research on multimedia learning.Computers and Education,125,413-428.
6. Alqassab, M.,Strijbos, J. W.,Ufer, S.(2018).The impact of peer solution quality on peer-feedback provision on geometry proofs: Evidence from eye-movement analysis.Learning and Instruction,58,182-192.
7. Biedert, R.,Buscher, G.,Dengel, A.(2010).The eyebook: Using eye tracking to enhance the reading experience.Informatik-Spektrum,33(3),272-281.
8. Epelboim, J.,Suppes, P.(2001).A model of eye movements and visual working memory during problem solving in geometry.Vision Research,41(12),1561-1574.
9. Gegenfurtner, A.,Lehtinen, E.,Jarodzka, H.,Säljö, R.(2017).Effects of eye movement modeling examples on adaptive expertise in medical image diagnosis.Computers and Education,113,212-225.
10. Hannus, M.,Hyönä, J.(1999).Utilization of illustrations during learning of science textbook passages among low- and high-ability children.Contemporary Educational Psychology,24(2),95-123.
11. Hegarty, M.,Just, M. A.(1993).Constructing mental models of machines from text and diagrams.Journal of Memory and Language,32(6),717-742.
12. Holsanova, J.,Holmberg, N.,Holmqvist, K.(2009).Reading information graphics: The role of spatial contiguity and dual attentional guidance.Applied Cognitive Psychology,23(9),1215-1226.
13. Hunt, T. E.,Clark-Carter, D.,Sheffield, D.(2015).Exploring the relationship between mathematics anxiety and performance: An eye-tracking approach.Applied Cognitive Psychology,29(2),226-231.
14. Hyönä, J.(2010).The use of eye movements in the study of multimedia learning.Learning and Instruction,20(2),172-176.
15. Hyönä, J.,Lorch, R. F.,Rinck, M.(2003).Eye movement measures to study global text processing.The mind's eye: Cognitive and applied aspects of eye movement research,Amsterdam, The Netherlands:
16. Inglis, M.,Alcock, L.(2012).Expert and novice approaches to reading mathematical proofs.Journal for Research in Mathematics Education,43(4),358-390.
17. Jarodzka, H.,van Gog, T.,Dorr, M.,Scheiter, K.,Gerjets, P.(2013).Learning to see: Guiding students' attention via a model's eye movements fosters learning.Learning and Instruction,25,62-70.
18. Jian, Y. C.,Wu, C. J.(2015).Using eye tracking to investigate semantic and spatial representations of scientific diagrams during text-diagram integration.Journal of Science Education and Technology,24(1),43-55.
19. Jian, Y. C.,Wu, C. J.,Su, J. H.(2014).Learners' eye movements during construction of mechanical kinematic representations from static diagrams.Learning and Instruction,32,51-62.
20. Juhasz, B. J.,Rayner, K.(2003).Investigating the effects of a set of intercorrelated variables on eye fixation durations in reading.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition,29(6),1312-1318.
21. Just, M. A.,Carpenter, P. A.(1976).Eye fixations and cognitive processes.Cognitive Psychology,8(4),441-480.
22. Knoblich, G.,Ohlsson, S.,Raney, G. E.(2001).An eye movement study of insight problem solving.Memory and Cognition,29(7),1000-1009.
23. Kojima, T.,Matsushima, E.,Ohta, K.,Toru, M.,Han, Y. H.,Shen, Y. C.,Prilipko, L.(2001).Stability of exploratory eye movements as a marker of schizophrenia: A WHO multi-center study.Schizophrenia Research,52(3),203-213.
24. Kok, E. M.,Jarodzka, H.(2017).Before your very eyes: The value and limitations of eye tracking in medical education.Medical Education,51(1),114-122.
25. Lai, M. L.,Tsai, M. J.,Yang, F. Y.,Hsu, C. Y.,Liu, T. C.,Lee, S. W. Y.,Tsai, C. C.(2013).A review of using eye-tracking technology in exploring learning from 2000 to 2012.Educational Research Review,10,90-115.
26. Lee, W. K.,Wu, C. J.(2018).Eye movements in integrating geometric text and figure: Scanpaths and given-new effects.International Journal of Science and Mathematics Education,16(4),699-714.
27. Lilienthal, A. J.,Schindler, M.(2019).,未出版
28. Lin, J. J. H.,Lin, S. S. J.(2014).Tracking eye movements when solving geometry problems with handwriting devices.Journal of Eye Movement Research,7(1),1-15.
29. Lin, J. J. H.,Lin, S. S. J.(2018).Integrating eye trackers with handwriting tablets to discover difficulties of solving geometry problems.British Journal of Educational Technology,49(1),17-29.
30. Lin, J. J. H.,Lin, S. S. J.(2014).Cognitive load for configuration comprehension in computer- supported geometry problem solving: An eye movement perspective.International Journal of Science and Mathematics Education,12(3),605-627.
31. Molina, A. I.,Navarro, Ó.,Ortega, M.,Lacruz, M.(2018).Evaluating multimedia learning materials in primary education using eye tracking.Computer Standards and Interfaces,59,45-60.
32. Muldner, K.,Burleson, W.(2015).Utilizing sensor data to model students' creativity in a digital environment.Computers in Human Behavior,42,127-137.
33. Nakano, Y. I.,Ishii, R.(2010).Estimating user's engagement from eye-gaze behaviors in human-agent conversations.Proceedings of the 15th international conference on Intelligent user interfaces,New York, NY:
34. Pierce, K.,Marinero, S.,Hazin, R.,McKenna, B.,Barnes, C. C.,Malige, A.(2016).Eye tracking reveals abnormal visual preference for geometric images as an early biomarker of an autism spectrum disorder subtype associated with increased symptom severity.Biological psychiatry,79(8),657-666.
35. Rayner, K.(2009).Eye movements and attention in reading, scene perception, and visual search.The Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology,62(8),1457-1506.
36. Rayner, K.(1998).Eye movements in reading and information processing: 20 years of research.Psychological Bulletin,124(3),372-422.
37. Rayner, K.,Liversedge, S. P.(2011).Linguistic and cognitive influences on eye movements during reading.The Oxford handbook on eye тovements,New York, NY:
38. Schimpf, F.,Spannagel, C.(2011).Reducing the graphical user interface of a dynamic geometry system.ZDM Mathematics Education,43(3),389-397.
39. Schindler, M.,Lilienthal, A.(2018).Eye-tracking for studying mathematical difficulties: Also in inclusive settings.Proceedings of the 42nd Conference of the International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics Education,Sweden:
40. Schindler, M.,Lilienthal, A. J.(2019).Domain-specific interpretation of eye tracking data: Towards a refined use of the eye-mind hypothesis for the field of geometry.Educational Studies in Mathematics,101(1),123-139.
41. Sharma, A.,Abrol, P.(2013).Eye gaze techniques for human computer interaction: A research survey.International Journal of Computer Applications,71(9),18-29.
42. Sinclair, N.,Bartolini Bussi, M. G.,de Villiers, M.,Jones, K.,Kortenkamp, U.,Leung, A.,Owens, K.(2016).Recent research on geometry education: An ICME-13 survey team report.ZDM Mathematics Education,48(5),691-719.
43. Toerner, G.,Arzarello, F.(2012).Grading mathematics education research journals.Newsletter of European Mathematical Society,86,52-54.
44. van Gog, T.,Paas, F.,van Merriënboer, J. J.,Witte, P.(2005).Uncovering the problem-solving process: Cued retrospective reporting versus concurrent and retrospective reporting.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied,11(4),237-244.
45. van Gog, T.,Scheiter, K.(2010).Eye tracking as a tool to study and enhance multimedia learning.Learning and Instruction,20(2),95-99.
46. van Marlen, T.,van Wermeskerken, M.,Jarodzka, H.,van Gog, T.(2016).Showing a model's eye LT movements in examples does not improve learning of problem-solving tasks.Computers in Human Behavior,65,448-459.
47. van Marlen, T.,van Wermeskerken, M.,Jarodzka, H.,van Gog, T.(2018).Effectiveness of eye movement modeling examples in problem solving: The role of verbal ambiguity and prior knowledge.Learning and Instruction,58,274-283.
48. Verdine, B. N.,Bunger, A.,Athanasopoulou, A.,Golinkoff, R. M.,Hirsh-Pasek, K.(2017).Shape up: An eye-tracking study of preschoolers' shape name processing and spatial development.Developmental Psychology,53(10),1869-1880.
49. Wu, C. J.(2018).Eye movements as reflections of cognitive processes in mathematics.Proceedings of the 8th ICMI-East Asia Regional Conference on Mathematics Education,Taipei, Taiwan:
50. Yen, M. H.,Yang, F. Y.(2016).Methodology and application of eye-tracking techniques in science education.Science education research and practices in Taiwan,Singapore:
51. 林寀雯, T.W.,吳昭容, C. J.(2016)。從眼動型態探討閱讀幾何文本的視覺化與推理歷程。教育學刊，47(2)，41-77。