營造職災因果關係與影響模型之發展

Development of Construction Accident Causation and Influence Model

張毅斌(Yi-Pin Chang)；鄒子廉(Tzu-Lien Tzou)

職災因果關係與影響模型 ； 工程設計考量工作者安全 ； 起源影響 ； 貢獻因子 ； 營造業 ； Accident causation and influence model ； Design for construction worker safety ； Originating Influences ； Contributing factors ； Construction industry

勞動及職業安全衛生研究季刊

30卷1期（2022 / 03 / 20）

23 - 43

繁體中文

臺灣傳統的職業災害預防方法主要注重在立法規定雇主應設置和採取之職業安全衛生（以下簡稱職安衛）設備和措施並予以執法，以減少工作者之危害暴露。這些減災方法包括檢查、提出誘因、宣導和輔導，以提高營造業利害關係人的能力和強調其責任。儘管這些方法有助於降低職災發生率，但它們缺乏藉由高階控制層級來實施職災的因果分析，以進一步的預防職災。本文從職安衛控制層級、現有的職災因果關係模型理論、臺灣營造業職災死亡報告書分析、以及對工程設計考量工作者安全之問卷調查分析結果等得出結論，對營造業提出概念性但具實用性的職災因果關係與影響模型（Accident Causation and Influence Model, ACIM）。ACIM由起源影響、貢獻因子及職業災害所組成，起源影響是職災貢獻因子的性質、程度和存在的高階決定因素，在工程開始時，它們可以作為職災的安全預防措施；貢獻因子可以協助識別死亡職災的發生。起源影響會相互作用並影響貢獻因子，各貢獻因子會依序的相互影響並導致職業災害的發生；另本文中的2個職災個案研究用於說明和測試ACIM。ACIM展示職災發生的方式和原因，因此預期ACIM可增加對職災因果過程的暸解、有助於對職災進行系統性的調查、並提供有效的職災預防措施之指導。

The traditional approaches to accident prevention in Taiwan concentrated on prescribing health and safety equipment and measures and enforcing them to decrease workers' exposure to hazards. These accident mitigation approaches included inspections, motivations, promotion, and guidance to improve and highlight stakeholders' competence and liability. Although these approaches have contributed to the reduction of accident rates, they have lacked accident causation analysis by high-level hierarchy of controls to further prevent accidents. This paper draws findings from the hierarchy of controls, existing accident causation model theories, construction fatality reports in Taiwan, and the results of survey about Design for Construction Worker Safety; a conceptual but practical model-the Accident Causation and Influence Model(ACIM)has been proposed for the construction industry. ACIM is composed of ＂Originating influences＂, ＂Contributing factors＂, and ＂Occupational accidents＂. The Originating influences are the high-level determinants of the nature, extent and existence of contributing factors of accidents. They can serve as a safety precaution in accident prevention at the beginning of projects. Contributing factors can help identify the occurrence of fatality accidents. Originating influences interact and affect Contributing factors, and Contributing factors influence each other in sequence and lead to Occupational accidents. Two case studies in the paper were used to illustrate and test the ACIM. ACIM demonstrates how and why accidents happen and is thus expected to improve the understanding of the accident causation process, to aid in the systematic investigation of accidents, and to provide guidance on effective accident prevention measures.

1. Council Directive (1989). 89/391/EEC of 12 June 1989 on the introduction of measures to encourage improvements in the safety and health of workers at work. Official journal L.
2. Abdelhamid, T. S.,Everett, J. G.(2000).Identifying root causes of construction accidents.Journal of construction engineering management,126,52-60.
3. ANSI=American National Standards Institute(1995).ANSI (American National Standards Institute) (1995). American national standards for information management for occupational safety and health. New York: National Safety Council, ANSI 16.2-1995..
4. Baxendale, T.,Jones, O.(2000).Construction design and management safety regulations in practice-progress on implementation.International journal of project management,18,33-40.
5. Behm, M.,Schneller, A.(2013).Application of the Loughborough construction accident causation model: a framework for organizational learning.Construction management economics,31,580-595.
6. Biggs, H. C.,Biggs, S. E.(2013).Interlocked projects in safety competency and safety effectiveness indicators in the construction sector.Safety science,52,37-42.
7. BLS ( Bureau of Labor Statistics ) . Occupational injury and illness classification manual. [pdf]BLS, U.S. Department of Labour Available at: [Accessed 9 June 2017].
8. CDC (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention). Hierarchy of controls [Online]. Available at: [Accessed 14 May 2019].
9. Chang, Y. P.(2020).University of Bristol.
10. Cheetham, D.(2000).Improving site safety–enforcement of the CDM Regulations.16th Annual ARCOM Conference,Glasgow, UK:
11. Choudhry, R. M.,Fang, D.(2008).Why operatives engage in unsafe work behavior: Investigating factors on construction sites.Safety science,46,566-584.
12. De Castro, B. L.,Gracia, F. J.,Peiró, J. M.,Pietrantoni, L.,Hernandez, A.(2013).Hernandez, A. Testing the validity of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) safety culture model.Accident analysis & prevention,60,231-244.
13. Gambatese, J. A.,Behm, M.,Hinze, J. W.(2005).Viability of designing for construction worker safety.Journal of construction engineering management,131,1029-1036.
14. Gambatese, J.,Hinze, J.(1999).Addressing construction worker safety in the design phase: Designing for construction worker safety.Automation in construction,8,643-649.
15. Haslam, R. A.,Hide, S. A.,Gibb, A. G.,Gyi, D. E.,Pavitt, T.,Atkinson, S.,Duff, A. R.(2005).Contributing factors in construction accidents.Applied ergonomics,36,401-415.
16. Heinrich, H. W.(1969).Industrial accident prevention: A scientific approach.New York:McGraw-Hill.
17. Heinrich, H. W.(1959).Industrial accident prevention.New York:McGraw-Hill.
18. Hosseinian, S. S.,Torghabeh, Z. J.(2012).Major theories of construction accident causation models: A literature review.International journal of advances in engineering technology,4,53.
19. Howarth, T.,Stoneman, G.,Hill, C.,Howarth, T.,Stoneman, G.,Hill, C.(2000).A review of the Construction (Design and Management) Regulations.16th Annual ARCOM Conference
20. HSE . The Construction ( Design and Management) Regulations 2015. [online]London: Health and Safety Executive. Available at: [Accessed 1 August 2015].
21. HSE. Health and safety policy: An example. HSE. Available at: [Accessed 15 May 2019].
22. HSE (2019b). Prepare a health and safety policy. HSE. Available at: [Accessed 15 June 2019].
23. HSE. The Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999. [online]London: Health and Safety Executive. Available at: [Accessed 1 August 2015].
24. HSE . Common topic 4: Safety culture. [online]London: Health and Safety Executive. Available at: [Accessed 28 May 2019].
25. Huang, X.,Hinze, J.(2006).Owner’s role in construction safety.Journal of construction engineering management,132,164-173.
26. IAEA(1998).Developing safety culture in nuclear activities: Practical suggestions to assist progress.Vienna:International atomic energy agency.
27. INSAG, S. C.(1991).Safety series No. 75-INSAG 4. IAEA International nuclear safety advisory group.
28. Langford, D.,Rowlinson, S.,Sawacha, E(2000).Safety behaviour and safety management: its influence on the attitudes of workers in the UK construction industry.Engineering, construction architectural management,7,133-140.
29. Larsen, G. D.,Whyte, J(2013).Safe construction through design: perspectives from the site team.Construction management economics,31,675-690.
30. Lingard, H.,Rowlinson, S(1994).Construction site safety in Hong Kong.Construction management economics,12,501-510.
31. Lorenzo, D. K.(1990).A manager's guide to reducing human errors: Improving human performance in the chemical industry.Chemical Manufacturers Association.
32. Manu, P.,Poghosyan, A.,Mahamadu, A.-M.,Mahdjoubi, L.,Gibb, A.,Behm, M.,Akinade, O. O(2019).Design for occupational safety and health: key attributes for organisational capability.Engineering, Construction and architectural manage
33. Mckinnon, R. C.(2000).Cause, effect, and control of accidental loss with accident investigation kit.CRC Press.
34. MOL. Enforcement Rules of the Occupational Safety and Health Act. [Online]. Taiwan: Ministry of Labour, [online]Available at: . [Accessed 8 March 2021].
35. MOL. Occupational Safety and Health Act. [Online]. Taiwan: Ministry of Labour, [online]Available at: [Accessed 8 March 2021].
36. OSHA ( 2017a ) . The inspection information management system of labour inspection agency of OSHA [Online]. Taiwan: Occupational Safety and Health Administration, Ministry of Labour. Available at: [Accessed 8 June 2017].
37. Peng, J.-L.,Ho, C.-M.,Chang, Y.-P.,Chan, S.-L. J. J. O. C. S. R.(2019).Study on collapse of steel-reinforced concrete structure caused by self-weight during construction.Journal of Constructional Steel Research,156,276-286.
38. Reason, J(2000).Human error : models and management.Bmj,320,768-770.
39. Sawacha, E.,Naoum, S.,Fong, D.(1999).Factors affecting safety performance on construction sites.International journal of project management,17,309-315.
40. Suraji, A.,Duff, A. R.,Peckitt, S. J.(2001).Development of causal model of construction accident causation.Journal of construction engineering management,127,337-344.
41. Teo, E. a. L.,Ling, F. Y. Y.,Chong, A. F. W.(2005).Framework for project managers to manage construction safety.International journal of project management,23,329-341.
42. Trethewy, R.,Atkinson, M.(2003).Enhanced safety, health and environmental outcomes through improved design.Journal of occupational health and safety Australia and New Zealand,19,465-476.
43. Tymvios, N.(2013).Oregon State University.
44. Zhou, W.,Whyte, J.,Sacks, R.(2012).Construction safety and digital design: A review.Automation in construction,22,102-111.

1. 顏廷峻,潘乃欣(2023)。施工架組配（拆除）作業之職業災害分析。勞動及職業安全衛生研究季刊，31(1)，18-33。