利用心智圖介入生理學教學對五專護理學生的學習影響

The teaching effects in physiology by concept mapping strategy in junior college nursing students

10.6902/JNTUST.201612_3(1).0013

洪慧娟(Hui-Chuan Hung)；陳夏蓮(Shiah-Lian Chen)；蔡崇煌(Chung-Huang Tsai)

心智圖 ； 生理學教育 ； 自我導向學習 ； 批判性思考能力 ； 護理教育 ； concept mapping ； physiology ； self-directed learning ； critical thinking ； nursing education

中科大學報

3卷1期（2016 / 12 / 01）

251 - 264

繁體中文

本研究利用心智圖介入生理學的教學，期望能促進學生的自我導向學習，並提升獨立思考能力。實驗採用護理系五專一年級學生，分成兩次進行。長期實驗進行18週，實驗組以心智圖介入生理學教學，控制組以平常授課方式進行。短期實驗則是如同長期實驗，但在進行9週後，控制組班級加入心智圖的介入，而實驗組則停止心智圖的介入，繼續進行另外9週課程。結果顯示，自我學習意願與能力，在長期與短期實驗，均有一致的顯著提升。特別是效率學習部分，在兩個實驗中，不管控制組或實驗組，都同時有增強的效果。但是長期實驗的心智圖訓練（18週），卻會對顯著降低實驗組學生批判性思考的能力。但這樣的干擾現象，在短期實驗，只進行9週的心智圖訓練時，即不復存在。此外，相關係數的分析顯示，批判性思考能力越高的同學，能得到更高的生理學成績。本研究顯示，在生理學的教學中，以心智圖輔助的介入方式，確能提高學生自我學習的意願，但是，除了心智圖以外，需要再輔以其他學習與教學的技巧，才能有效提升學生批判性思考的能力。

The purpose of this study was to explore the teaching effects of physiology by concept mapping in developing critical thinking ability and self-directed learning. Study was designed with a sample being drawn from a group in first-year junior college nursing students. Students in the experimental group were taught to use concept mapping in their physiology lectures. And students in the control group were taught by means of traditional methods. The long-term study was conducted for 18 weeks. And the short-term study was conducted for 9 weeks first, and then the concept mapping intervention was changed between control and experimental groups. After that the students got on another 9 weeks training courses. Both parts of the studies had shown consistently better overall self-directed learning than before. In particular the performance of effective learning was increased significantly in both control and experimental groups. However, the critical thinking ability was shown statistically significantly lower in experimental group than in control group in the long-term study. But this interference was not shown in the short-term study. The present study revealed that concept mapping is an effective tool to improve students' self-directed learning. However, the interference in critical thinking ability was found in the long-term study, which suggest that the elevation of critical thinking needs more than concept mapping intervention. Other teaching skills and tools should be involved in physiology teaching.

1. 林凱胤(2015)。從學習風格和科技接受模式看混成式評量策略融入教學。中等教育，66(3)，138-156。
   連結：
2. Abraham R. R.,Upadhya, S.,Torke, S.,Ramnarayan, K.(2004).Clinically oriented physiology teaching: strategy for developing critical-thinking skills in undergraduate medical students.Advances in Physiology Education,28(3),102-104.
3. Chao, C.-S.C.(2004)。Taiwan nursing accreditation for nursing education。The Journal of Nursing，51(4)，22-26。
4. Chen, S.-L.,Liang, T.,Mei-Li Lee, M.-L.,Liao, I.-C.(2011).Effects of Concept Map Teaching on Students’ Critical Thinking and Approach to Learning and Studying.Journal of Nursing Education,50(8),466-469.
5. Girot, E. A.(2000).Graduate nurses: Critical thinkers or better decision makers.Journal of Advanced Nursing,31(2),288-297.
6. Guglielmino, L. M.(1977).University of Georgia.
7. Gul, R.B.,Boman, J.A.(2006).Concept mapping: A strategy for teaching and evaluation in nursing education.Nurse Education in Practice,6,199-206.
8. Klunklin, A.,Viseskul, N.,Sripusanapan, A.,Turale, S.(2010).Readiness for self-directed learning among nursingstudents in Thailand.Nursing and Health Sciences,12,177-181.
9. Novak, J.D.,Cañas, A.J.(2008).,Pensacola:Institute for Human and Machine Cognition.
10. Novak, J.D.,Hillsdale, N. J.(1998).Learning, creating and using knowledge: Concept maps as facilitative tools in schools and corporations.Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
11. Reem Rachel, A,Murray, F.,Asha, K.,Aizan, I. T.,Saidatul, N.,Nik Nur, A.(2011).Exploring first-year undergraduate medical students’ self-directed learning readiness to physiology.Advances in Physiology Education,359(4),393-395.
12. 周佳慧,陳淑齡(2011)。探討護理能力—從護理系畢業生的觀點。中山醫學雜誌，22，307-318。
13. 張文蕙,許麗齡(2012)。糖尿病足部檢查實務創作。護理雜誌，59(6)，98-103。
14. 許淑蓮,林惠賢,李明儀(2000)。技職體系二年制護理系學生批判性思考能力之評估。醫學教育，4(4)，466-475。
15. 許麗齡,章美英,謝素英(2008)。心智圖—一種促進學生學習策略的新工。護理雜誌，55(2)，76-80。
16. 陳玉枝(2010)。護理人員應具備的專業核心能力。護理雜誌，57(5)，12-17。
17. 陳夏蓮,陳品玲,李美麗,李薇莉,李文昭(2006)。護生批判性思考能力和學習策略關係之探討。實證護理，2(1)，43-52。
18. 黃素雲,洪慧娟,蔡崇煌,王素美,胡蓮珍(2015)。心智圖軟體在醫護教育的應用。澄清醫護管理雜誌，11(2)，30-38。
19. 黃淑芸,陳夏蓮,胡庭禎(2012)。探討加護病房護理人員應具備之臨床能力。榮總護理，29(3)，243-254。
20. 葉玉珠(2005)。,未出版
21. 趙可式(2004)。台灣護理教育評鑑制度初探。護理雜誌，51(4)，22-26。
22. 蔡崇煌,黃青貞,張健淵(2009)。應用軟體於搜尋、整理、管理資料及用於教學、自學之經驗。家醫研究，7(2)，45-53。
23. 鄧運林(1995).成人教學與自我導向學習.臺北市:五南圖書.

1. 曾采楨,郭文英,張寧郁,唐敏華,林玉蘭(2020)。讀心術－運用多元教學提昇參與兩年期訓練課程之護理師異常心律判讀及處理能力。護理雜誌，67(6)，61-69。
2. 戴慧如,陳殷哲,何世華(2021)。自我導向學習之統合分析研究。科技與人力教育季刊，7(4)，109-126。
3. 林志哲,王智瑩(2021)。心智圖融入會計學課程對技術型高中學生學習動機及學習成效之影響。臺北市立大學學報.教育類，52(1)，75-96。