科學博物館、生物學知識與國族意識

Science Museums, Biological Knowledge, and National Consciousness

10.6686/MuseQ.201207_26(3).0003

陳叔倬(Shu-Juo Chen)

科學博物館 ； 生物學知識 ； 國族意識 ； Science Museum ； Biological Knowledge ； National Consciousness

博物館學季刊

26卷3期（2012 / 07 / 01）

21 - 35

繁體中文

博物館史的相關研究已經顯示，國族意識在博物館制度化的過程中產生關鍵性的影響，舉世皆然。即使到了當代，博物館的公民性、開放性被不斷地強調，國族意識似乎仍然存在於許多博物館展示空間中。歷史性或藝術性的博物館或許較容易操作以貼近國族意識；相對而言，科學性的博物館標榜著科學理性，並且肩負著傳播科學知識的使命，又如何面對國族意識？如果科學博物館選擇貼近國族意識，則其中科學性知識──尤其是生物學知識又會如何詮釋國族意識，溝通國族認同？本論文藉由研究國立自然科學博物館，以及臺大醫學人文博物館的博物館展示與博物館誌歷史檔案，探討科學博物館中生物學知識與國族意識的關聯性。

The research on museum history has shown how national consciousness has influenced museums worldwide. Even in modern museums, in which citizenship and public access are well emphasized, nationalism affects exhibitions. Historical or art museums might be able to operate close to national consciousness. In contrast, how should a science museum, which is based on scientific rationality and is responsible for disseminating scientific knowledge, deal with national consciousness? In this paper, two of Taiwan's science museums, the National Museum of Natural Science and the Medical Humanities Museum of National Taiwan University, were studied to understand the relationships between biological knowledge and national consciousness in science museums.

1. 陳叔倬、段洪坤(2008)。平埔血源與臺灣國族血統論。臺灣社會研究季刊，72，137-173。
   連結：
2. 陳叔倬、段洪坤(2009)。臺灣原住民祖源基因檢驗的理論與統計謬誤。臺灣社會研究季刊，76，347-356。
   連結：
3. 臺灣國民會議，2009。臺灣民族獨立運動常識。臺灣國民會議。
4. Abizadeh, A.(2001).Ethnicity, race, and a possible humanity.World Order,33,23-34.
5. Anderson, B.(1983).Imagined Communities: Reflection on the Origins and Spread of Nationalism.New York:Verso.
6. Barth, F.(Ed.)(1969).Ethnic Groups and Boundaries: The Social Organization of Culture Difference.London:Little, Brown and Company.
7. Benedict, P. K.(1984).Austro-Tai parallel, a tonal Chamic language on Hainan.Computational Analyses of Asian and African Languages,22,83-86.
8. Brown, M. J.(2004).Taiwan Chinese? The Impact of Culture, Power,and Migration on Changing Identities.CA:University of California Press.
9. Brown, M.(Ed.)(1996).Negotiating Ethnicities in China and Taiwan.Berkeley, CA:Institute of East Asian Studies, University of California.
10. Cann, R. L.,Stoneking, M.,Wilson, A. C.(1987).Mitochondria DNA and human evolution.Nature,325,31-6.
11. Chu, J. Y.,Huang, W.,Kuang, S. Q.,Wang, J. M.,Xu, J. J.,Chu, Z. T.,Yang, Z. Q.,Lin, K. Q.,Li, P.,Wu, M.,Geng, Z. C.,Tan, C. C.,Du, R. F.,Jin, L.(1998).Genetic relationship of populations in China.Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci.,95,11763-11768.
12. Descola, P.(1996).Constructing natures: Symbolic ecology and social practice.Nature and Society: Anthropological Perspectives,London:
13. Eriksen, T. H.(2004).Place, kinship, and the case for non-ethnic nations.Nations and Nationalism,10,49-62.
14. Geertz, C.(1973).The Interpretation of Cultures.New York:Basic Books.
15. Gellner, E.(1983).Nations and Nationalism.Ithaca, N.Y.:Cornell University Press.
16. Giddens, A.,Pierson, C.(1999).Consercation with Anthony Giddens: Making Sense of Modernity.CA:Stanford University Press.
17. Ke, Y.,Su, B.,Song, X.,Lu, D.,Chen, L.,Li, H.,Qi, C.,Marzuki, S.,Deka, R.,Underhill, P.,Xiao, C.,Shriver, M.,Lell, J.,Wallace, D.,Wells, R. S.,Seielstad, M.,Oefner, P.,Zhu, D.,Jin, J.,Huang, W.,Chakraborty, R.,Chen, Z.,Jin, L.(2001).African origin of modern humans in East Asia: A tale of 12,000 Y chromosomes.Science,292,1151-1153.
18. Keyes, C. F.(1976).Toward a new formulation of the concept of ethnic group.Ethnicity,3,202-13.
19. Lavine, S. D.,Karp, I.(1991).Exhibiting Cultures.Washington:Smithsonian Institution Press.
20. Li, H.,Wen, B.,Chen, S.-J.,Su, B.,Pramoonjago, P.,Liu, Y.,Pan, S.,Qin, Z.,Liu, W.,Cheng, W.,Yang, N.,Li, X.,Tran, D.,Lu, D.,Hsu, M.,Deka, R.,Marzuki, S.,Tan, C.-C.,Jin, L.(2008).Paternal genetic affinity between western Austronesian and Daic populations.BMC Evolutionary Biology,8,146.
21. McLean, F.(1997).Marketing the Museum.London:Routledge.
22. Ni, D. B.(1994).Relationship between Austronesian and Bai-Yue languages.Ethnic Language and Literature,3,21-35.
23. Smith, A. D.(1998).Nationalism and Modernity: A Critical Survey of Recent Theories of Nations and Nationalism.New York:Routledge.
24. Thames, N.(1991).Entangled Objects: Exchange, Material Culture, and Colonialism in the Pacific.Cambridge:Harvard University Press.
25. Wade, P.(Ed.)(2007).Race, Ethnicity, and Nation: Perspectives from Kinship and Genetics.Oxford:Berghahn Books.
26. Wen, B.,Li, H.,Lu, D.,Song, X.,Zhang, F.,He, Y.,Li, F.,Gao, Y.,Mao, X.,Zhang, L.,Qian, J.,Tan, J.,Jin, J.,Huang, W.,Deka, R.,Su, B.,Chakraborty, R.,Jin, L.(2004).Genetic evidence supports demic diffusion of Han culture.Nature,431,302-305.
27. Zhao, T. M.,Lee, T. D.(1989).Gm and Km allotypes in 74 Chinese populations: A hypothesis of the origin of the Chinese nation.Hum Genet,83(2),101-110.
28. 王嵩山編(2010)。博物館蒐藏的文化與科學。臺中:國立自然科學博物館。
29. 王嵩山編(2005)。博物館、知識建構與現代性。臺中:國立自然科學博物館。
30. 王嵩山編(2009)。製作博物館。臺中:國立自然科學博物館。
31. 沈松橋(1997)。我以我血薦軒轅：黃帝神話與晚清的國族建構。臺灣社會研究季刊，28，1-77。
32. 許維德(2006)。關於「民族起源」的文化政治：以「臺灣原住民起源」相關論述為核心的探索。「文化與族群的形成與再創造」工作坊，臺北:
33. 曾信傑(2010)。政治對博物的影響：以國家博物館為例。博物館學季刊，24(4)，95-113。
34. 賈蘭坡、黃慰文(1996)。發現北京人。臺北:幼獅出版社。

1. 葉韻翠(2023)。威權時期國父紀念館的展示政治與國族想像。博物館學季刊，37(4)，5-23。