結合GPS軌跡於遊憩承載量之評估

Integrating GPS Tracking Data in Recreational Carrying Capacity Assessment

林晏州(Yann-Jou Lin)；游欽忠(Chin-Chung Yu)；張涵君(Han-Chin Chang)；林寶秀(Bau-Show Lin)

擁擠感受 ； 時空分佈 ； 即時定位追蹤應用程式 ； 野柳地質公園 ； Old House Reuse ； Nostalgic Emotion ； Experiential Value ； Place Attachment

造園景觀學報

25卷3期（2021 / 12 / 01）

29 - 46

繁體中文

遊憩承載量對遊憩經營管理者至關重要，考量現今GPS應用的普及性，遊憩利用量與遊客擁擠感受的關係可透過GPS軌跡紀錄真實呈現。本研究以野柳地質公園為例，在遊客量部份，以入園計數資料與抽樣調查GPS軌跡，推估遊客於園區內的時空分佈狀況，擁擠感受方面以遊客問卷進行調查，再利用統計分析建立關係式用以推估遊憩承載量。研究結果顯示，園區內遊客分佈呈現時空分佈差異，遊客擁擠感受以女王頭最高，遊客人數愈高、擁擠感受愈高，並以不同擁擠感受推估不同情境下的園區遊憩承載量，研究結果可做為經營管理者策略擬定之參考依據，藉由管制女王頭景點人數，或控管遊客總入園人次，降低遊客遊園擁擠感受，並進一步結合GPS之應用，定期分析遊客行為模式。

Recreational carrying capacity is vital to managers. With the popularity of GIS applications, the relationship between recreational utilization and visitors' crowding perception could be truly explored by integrating GPS tracking data. Taking the Yehliu Geopark as the study site, this study estimated the temporal-spatial distribution of visitors by using counted visitor numbers of the park and GPS tracking data. We used a structured questionnaire to collect visitors' crowding perceptions toward spots in the park. Then, this study analyzed the relationship between the number of visitors and crowding perception and utilized the association to assess the recreational carrying capacity of Yehliu Geopark. The results show that the visitor distribution in the park was a temporal-spatial variant. The crowding perception was the highest in Queen's Head; the more visitors, the higher perception of crowding. The park's recreational carrying capacity in different situations was further estimated. The results could inform management strategy making; by controlling the number of visitors in Queen's Head or controlling the total number of visitors to the park to reduce the crowding perception. In addition, managers could further integrate the guide and the GPS to develop APP programs to establish an extensive database to formulate corresponding strategies to provide visitors with a better experience in the park.

1. 林晏州(2000)。社會遊憩容許量評估方法之比較。戶外遊憩研究，13(1)，1-20。
   連結：
2. Arnberger, A.,Mann, C.(2008).Crowding in European forests: A review of recent research and implications for forest management and policy.Forestry,81(4),559-571.
3. Beeco, J. A.,Brown, G.(2013).Integrating space, spatial tools, and spatial analysis into the human dimensions of parks and outdoor recreation.Applied Geography,38,76-85.
4. Bultena, G.,Field, D.,Womble, P.,Albrecht, D.(1981).Closing the gates: A study of backcountry use-limitation at Mount McKinley National Park.Leisure Sciences,4(3),249-267.
5. Daamen, W.,Hoogendoorn, S. P.(2007).Free speed distributions –based on empirical data in different traffic conditions.Pedestrian and Evacuation Dynamics 2005,Berlin:
6. D'Antonio, A.,Monz, C.(2016).The influence of visitor use levels on visitor spatial behavior in off-trail areas of dispersed recreation use.Journal of Environmental Management,170,79-87.
7. Donnelly, M.,Vaske, J.,Whittaker, D.,Shelby, B.(2000).Toward an understanding of norm prevalence: a comparative analysis of 20 years of research.Environmental Management,25,403-414.
8. Dye, A. S.,Shaw, S. L.(2007).A GIS-based spatial decision support system for tourists of Great Smoky Mountains National Park.Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services,14,269-278.
9. Gibson, A. W.,Newman, P.,Lawson, S.,Fristrup, K.,Benfield, J. A.,Bell, P. A.,Nurse, G. A.(2014).Photograph presentation order and range effects in visual-based outdoor recreation research.Leisure Sciences,36(2),183-205.
10. Goktug, T. H.,Bulut, Y.,Demir, M.,Yildiz, N. D.(2013).Estimating carrying capacity of Olympos Bey Mountains Coastal National Park.Fresenius Environmental Bulletin,22,3730-3738.
11. Heywood, J. L.,Murdock, W. E.(2002).Social norms in outdoor recreation: Searching for the behavior-condition link.Leisure Sciences,24,283-295.
12. Holyoak, N.,Carson, D.(2009).Modelling self-drive tourist travel patterns in desert Australasian.Proceedings of the 32nd Australasian transport research forum (ATRF) meeting,Auckland, Australia:
13. Kim, J.,Thapa, B.,Jang, S.(2019).GPS-based mobile exercise application: An alternative tool to assess spatio-temporal patterns of visitors' activities in a national park.Journal of Park and Recreation Administration,37(1),124-134.
14. Klanjšček, J.,Geček, S.,Marn, N.,Legović, T.,Klanjšček, T.(2018).Predicting perceived level of disturbance of visitors due to crowding in protected areas.PloS one,13(6),e0197932.
15. Laven, D. N.,Manning, R. E.,Krymkowski, D. H.(2005).The relationship between visitor-based standards of quality and existing conditions in parks and outdoor recreation.Leisure Sciences,27(2),157-173.
16. Li, L.,Zhang, J.,Nian, S.,Zhang, H.(2017).Tourists’ perceptions of crowding, attractiveness, and satisfaction: a second-order structural model.Asia Pacific Journal of Tourism Research,22(12),1250-1260.
17. Lime, D.,Anderson, D.,Thompson, J.(2004).Identifying and monitoring indicators of visitor experience and resource quality: A handbook for recreation resource managers.Minnesota:Department of Forest Resources, University of Minnesota.
18. Lime, D.,Stankey, G. H.(1971).Carrying capacity: maintaining outdoor recreation quality.Recreation Symposium Proceeding
19. Lyon, K.,Cottrell, S. P.,Siikamaki, P.,Van Marwijk, R. B. M.(2011).Biodiversity hotspots and visitor flows in Oulanka National Park, Finland.Scandinavian Journal of Hospitality and Tourism,11,100-111.
20. Manning, R.(2001).Visitor experience and resource protection: A framework for managing carrying capacity of National Parks.Journal of Park and Recreation Administration,19,93-108.
21. Manning, R.(2007).Parks and carrying capacity: Commons without tragedy.Washington:Island Press.
22. Manning, R.,Freimund, W.(2004).Use of visual research methods to measure standards of quality for parks and outdoor recreation.Journal of Leisure Research,36(4),557-579.
23. Manning, R.,Lime, D.,Hof, M.(1996).Social carrying capacity of natural areas: Theory and application in the U.S. National Parks.Natural Areas Journal,16,118-127.
24. Manning, R.,Valliere, W.,Minteer, B.,Wang, B.,Jacobi, C.(2000).Crowding in parks and outdoor recreation: A theoretical, empirical, and managerial analysis.Journal of Park and Recreation Administration,18(4),57-72.
25. Manning, R.,Valliere, W.,Wang, B.,Jacobi, C.(1999).Crowding norms: alternative measurement approaches.Leisure Sciences,21,97-115.
26. Mansfeld, Y.,Jonas, A.(2006).Evaluating the socio-cultural carrying capacity of rural tourism communities: A ‘value stretch’ approach.Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geografie,97(5),583-601.
27. Mathieson, A.,Wall, G.(1982).Tourism, economic and social impacts.Longman:Essex.
28. Morales, G. G.,Arreola-Lizarraga, J. A.,Grano, P. R.(2018).Integrated assessment of recreational quality and carrying capacity of an urban beach.Costal management,46(4),316-333.
29. Navarro, E.,Tejada, M.,Almeida, F.,Cabello, J.,Cortes, R.,Delgado, J.,Fernández, F.,Gutiérrez, G.,Luque, M.,Málvarez, G.,Marcenaro, O.,Navas, F.,Ruiz, F.,Ruiz, J.,Solis, F.(2012).Carrying capacity assessment for tourist destinations. Methodology for the creation of synthetic indicators applied in a coastal area.Tourism Management,33(6),1337-1346.
30. Needham, M. D.,Szuster, B. W.,Bell, C. M.(2011).Encounter norms, social carrying capacity indicators, and standards of quality at a marine protected area.Ocean & Coastal Management,54(8),633-641.
31. Neuts, B.,Nijkamp, P.(2012).Tourist crowding perception and acceptability in cities: an applied modelling study on Bruges.Annals of Tourism Research,39(4),2133-2153.
32. O’Connor, A.,Zerger, A.,Itami, B.(2005).Geo-temporal tracking and analysis of tourist movement.Mathematics and Computers in Simulation,69,135-150.
33. Peterson, B. A.,Perry, E. E.,Brownlee, M. T. J.,Sharp, R.(2020).The transient nature of concentrated use at a national park: A spatiotemporal investigation into visitor behavior.Journal of Outdoor Recreation and Tourism,31,100310.
34. Salemi, M.,Jozi, S. A.,Malmasi, S.,Rezaian, S.(2019).A new model of ecological carrying capacity for developing ecotourism in the protected area of the North Karkheh, Iran.Journal of the Indian Society of Remote Sensing,47,1937-1947.
35. Sayan, M. S.,Atik, M.(2011).Recreation carrying capacity estimates for protected areas: A study of Termessos National Park.Ekoloji,20(78),66-74.
36. Sayan, S.,Karagüzel, O.(2010).Problems of outdoor recreation: The effect of visitors’ demographics on the perceptions of Termessos National Park, Turkey.Environmental Management,45,1257-1270.
37. Shelby, B.,Heberlein, T. A.(1984).A conceptual framework for carrying capacity determination.Leisure Sciences,6,433-451.
38. Shelby, B.,Vaske, J.,Donnelly, M.(1996).Norms, standards and natural resources.Leisure Sciences,18,103-123.
39. Shelby, B.,Vaske, J.,Heberlein, T.(1989).Comparative analysis of crowding in multiple locations: results from fifteen years of research.Leisure Sciences,11,269-291.
40. Tarrant, M. A.,Cordell, H. K.,Kibler, T. L.(1997).Measuring perceived crowding for high‐density river recreation: The effects of situational conditions and personal factors.Leisure Sciences,19(2),97-112.
41. United Nations World Tourism Organizatio=UNWTO(1999).Global code of ethics for tourism.Proc. of Thirteenth session of General Assembly,Santiago:
42. Vanclay, F.(2012).The potential application of social impact assessment in integrated coastal zone management.Ocean & Coastal Management,68,149-156.
43. Vaske, J.,Whittaker, D.(2004).Normative approaches to natural resources.Society and natural resources: A summary of knowledge,Jefferson:
44. Wolf, I. D.,Hagenloh, G.,Croft, D. B.(2012).A spatial exploration of informal trail networks within Great Falls Park, VA.Journal of Environmental Management,92,1012-1022.
45. Zehrer, A.,Raich, F.(2016).The impact of perceived crowding on customer satisfaction.Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Management,29,88-98.
46. 王皖麟,林晏州,黃文卿(2006)。太魯閣國家公園合歡山地區雪季遊憩容許量之研究。國家公園學報，16(2)，1-20。
47. 交通部觀光局（2022）。主要觀光遊憩據點遊客人數，下載日期：2020 年 11 月 26 日，取自：https://admin.taiwan.net.tw/FileUploadCategoryListC003330.aspx?CategoryID=2638da16-f46c-429c-81f9-3687523da8eb&appname=FileUploadCategoryListC003330。
48. 林晏州(1988)。社會心理遊憩容許量之研究。東海學報，29，819-848。
49. 胡英浩(2012)。臺北，國立臺灣大學地理環境資源學研究所。
50. 陳沛悌,林晏州(1997)。秀姑巒溪泛舟活動社會心理容許量之探討。戶外遊憩研究，10(3)，19-236。