T. W. Adorno的審美政治學及其美育意涵

T. W. Adorno's Aesthetic Politics and Its Implications on Aesthetic Education

10.6910/BER.200309_(49-3).0002

楊深坑(Shen-Keng Yang)；楊忠斌(Chung-Ping Yang)

審美政治學 ； 批判美育 ； 自主性 ； aesthetic politics ； critical aesthetic education ； autonomy

教育研究集刊

49:3期（2003 / 09 / 30）

31 - 61

繁體中文

本文旨在以理論分析法探究Adorno的審美政治學，評析其對於藝術與社會、群眾、政治權力之間複雜關係的論述，並據以闡釋在美育理論與實踐上的蘊義。首先探討Adorno否定辯證法的主張，指出其中心理念「非同一性」實為Adorno審美政治學的方法論基礎。次就Adorno對於文化工業的批判、為現代主義藝術的辯護、對藝術介入論的批判，以及對藝術的政治實踐性之主張等四個面向，深入評析其審美政治學的主要內涵，並以此闡述一種批判取向的美育理論與實踐。結論指出，在美育的理論與實施上，應加強美育、文化與政治意識型態之間關係的研究，評析文化工業、各類新興媒體及藝術文化中具有的社會政治性，培育學生的批判意識與自主性人格。最後，根據研究所得結果，提出八點建議，以作為未來美育理論發展及實踐改善之參考。

Through theoretical analysis, this article attempts to offer a critical exposition of Adorno's aesthetic politics and investigates its implications on the possibility of critical aesthetics education. The authors analyze Adorno's negative dialectics as the meth-odological foundation of his aesthetic politics and present the critical exposition of the content of aesthetic politics. With ＂non-identity＂ as the key-concept in his methodology, Adorno has developed his aesthetic politics in four areas: (1) critique of culture industry, (2) defense of modern arts, (3) opposition to the engaged arts, and (4) support for the practical significance of the dialectical relationship between art's truth and political power. On the basis of Adorno's politics of aesthetics, the authors propose a critical aesthetic education, which emphasizes the political functions of education and includes a critique of new media and mass culture in the curriculum, with a view to cultivating mature, autonomous, and responsible character.

1. Adorno, T. W.(1979).Letters to Walter Benjamin.Aesthetics and politics
2. Adorno, T. W.(1992).Freudian theory and the pattern of fascist propaganda..The culture industry: Selected essays on mass culture
3. Adorno, T. W.(1979).Reconciliation under duress.Aesthetics and politics
4. Adorno, T. W.(1979).Commitment.Aesthetics and politics
5. Adorno, T. W.(1994).Philosophy of modern music.
6. Adorno, T. W.(1992).Culture industry reconsidered.The culture industry: Selected essays on mass culture
7. Adorno, T. W.(1998).Negative Dialektik..Gesammelte Schriften
8. Adorno, T. W.(1973).Negative dialectics..
9. Adorno, T. W.(1993).Theory of pseudo-culture.
10. Adorno, T. W.(1989).Introduction to the sociology of music.
11. Adorno, T. W.(1999).Aesthetic theory.
12. Adorno, T. W.(1992).Transparencies on film.The culture industry: Selected essays on mass culture
13. Adorno, T. W.(1998).Asthetische Theorie..Gesammelte Schriften
14. Adorno, T. W.(1998).Critical models: Interventions and catchwords.
15. Adorno, T. W.(1991).Minima moralia: Reflections from damaged life.
16. Benjamin, W.(1969).The work of art in the age of mechanical reproduction.Illuminations
17. Beyer, L. E.(1995).Beyond the formal and the psychological: The arts and social possibility..Critical conversations in philosophy of education
18. Bloch, E.(1979).Discussing expressionism.Aesthetics and politics
19. Eagleton, T.(1991).The ideology of the aesthetic..
20. Gibson, R.(1986).Critical theory and education..
21. Horkheimer, M.(1972).Critical theory: Selected essays..
22. Horkheimer, M.,Adomo, T. W.(1989).Dialectic of enlightenment.
23. Horkheimer, M.,Adomo, T. W.(1998).Dialektik der Aufklarung..Gesammelte Schriften
24. Jarvis, S.(1998).Adorno: A critical introduction..
25. Jay, M.(1984).Adorno..
26. Jay, M.(1996).Dialectical imagination: A history of the Frankfurt school and the institute of social research.
27. Kelly, M.(2000).The political autonomy of contemporary art: The case of the 1993 Whitney Biennial..Politics and aesthetics in the arts
28. Kemal, S.,Gaskell, I.(2000).Contesting the arts: Politics and aesthetics..Politics and aesthetics in the arts
29. Lukacs, G.(1979).Realism in the balance.Aesthetics and politics
30. Pauline, J.(1984).Marxist aesthetics: The foundations within everyday life for an emancipated consciousness..
31. Zuidervaart, L.(1991).Adorno's aesthetic theory: The redemption of illusion..
32. 王逢振、陳永國(1999)。政治無意識。
33. 余匡復(1996)。德國文學史(下)。
34. 吳國淳(1997)。戰後五十年來臺灣地區中小學美術教育研究。
35. 林政華(1995)。審美教育的理論與實踐。藝術學報，56
36. 林曼麗(2000)。臺灣視覺藝術教育研究。
37. 崔光宙(2000)。美學中人的概念及其教育內涵。教育美學
38. 梁鎮福(2001)。審美教育學。
39. 郭禎祥(1999)。二十一世紀藝術赴育的展望。美育，106
40. 陳郁秀(1999)。臺灣音樂教育品顧與前瞻。教師天地，100
41. 黃念慈、李明芬、李昆翰、吳知賢、吳翠珍、周韞維(2002)。媒體素養教育政策白皮書。
42. 楊索(2002)。不買芭比娃娃的理由。中國時報
43. 蔡佩君、徐明松(1998)。前衛藝術理論。
44. 羅鋼、劉象愚(2000)。文化研究讀本。
45. 欒棟、關寶艷(1990)。Adorno:藝術、意識型態與美學理論。

1. 楊忠斌(2013)。Lucian Freud 作品中的身體美學及其在生命教育上的意涵。當代教育研究季刊，21(3)，1-39。