抗拒乎？拒絕乎？偏差乎？學生文化研究中抗拒概念之誤用與澄清

Is Resistance Different From Rejection or Deviance? Clarifying the Meaning of Resistance in Student Culture Research

10.3966/102887082011095703004

黃鴻文(Horng-Wen Huang)

學生抗拒 ； 理論效度 ； 抗拒研究 ； student resistance ； theoretical validity ； resistance research

教育研究集刊

57:3期（2011 / 09 / 30）

123 - 154

繁體中文

許多學生文化的研究中，誤將「拒絕」或「偏差」當成「抗拒」，疏於描述支配群體的壓迫，或只聚焦於特定層面的抗拒，使文化的描述不夠厚實，徒具抗拒理論的浪漫色彩，降低其理論效度與分析的效力，殊為可惜。本研究之主要目的即在澄清抗拒概念的意義，並提出研究抗拒時宜蒐集哪些資料、考量哪些議題、避免哪些問題。本研究並延伸討論過去在質性研究經常被忽略的理論效度，期盼後續的質性研究能對教育理論與實務，有更多的貢獻。

This article clarifies the meaning of resistance and other related concepts employed in qualitative research of student cultures. In addition, it discusses the theoretical validity of resistance. Based on literature review and the author's ethnographic research, this article points out several mistakes in the research on student resistance culture such as 1) interpreting rejection or deviance as resistance; 2) focusing only on a particular life aspect of student resisters; 3) omitting to recount the concrete targets of student resistance. These mistakes make the description of student culture too ＂thin＂ to grasp the holistic picture of student life and produce some problems of theoretical validity. Critical issues of performing resistance research are also suggested.

1. Akom, A. A.(2003).Reexamining resistance as oppositional behavior: The nation of islam and the creation of a black achievement ideology.Sociology of Education,76,305-325.
2. Alpert, B.(1991).Students' resistance in the classroom.Anthropology and Education Quarterly,22,350-366.
3. Anyon, J.(1983).Intersections of gender and class: Accommodation and resistance by working class and affluent females to contradictory sex-role ideologies.Gender, class and education,Sussex, UK:
4. Anyon, J.(1981).Social class and school knowledge.Curriculum Inquiry,11(1),3-42.
5. Bourdieu, P.,Passeron, J. C.(1977).Reproduction in education, society, and culture.Beverly Hills, CA:Sage.
6. Bowles, S.,Gintis, H.(1976).Schooling in capitalist America.New York:Basic.
7. Brayboy, B. M. J.(2005).Transformational resistance and social justice: American Indians in Ivy league universities.Anthropology and Education Quarterly,36(3),193-211.
8. Brown, M. F.(1996).On resisting resistance.American Anthropologist,98(4),729-749.
9. Burkam, D. T.,Ready, D. D.,Lee, V. E.,Logerfo, L. F.(2004).Social-class differences in summer learning between kindergarten and first grade: Model specification and estimation.Sociology of Education,77,1-31.
10. Cammarota, J.(2004).The gendered and racialized pathways of Latina and Latino youth: Different struggles, different resistances in the urban context.Anthropology and Education Quarterly,35(1),53-74.
11. Carspecken, P. F.(1996).Critical ethnography in educational research: A theoretical and practical guide.New York:Routledge.
12. Chin, T.,Phillips, M.(2004).Social reproduction and child-rearing practices: Social class, children's agency, and the summer activity gap.Sociology of Education,77,185-210.
13. Connell, R. W.(1987).Gender and power: Society, the person and sexual politics.Stanford, CA:Stanford University Press.
14. Denzin, N.(1989).The research act: A theoretical introduction to sociological methods.Englewood Cliffs, NJ:Prentice Hall.
15. Downey, D. B.,von Hippel, P. T.,Broh, B. A.(2004).Are schools the great equalizer? Cognitive inequality during the summer months and the school year.American Sociological Review,69,613-635.
16. Entwisle, D. R.,Alexzander, K. L.,Olson, L. S.(1997).Children, schools, & inequality.Boulder, CO:Westview.
17. Fordham, S.(1996).Blacked out: Dilemmas of race, identity, and success at capital high.Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
18. Giroux, H. A.(1983).Theories of reproduction and resistance in the new sociology of education: A critical analysis.Harvard Educational Review,53(3),257-293.
19. Hargreaves, A.(1982).Resistance and relative autonomy theories: Problems of distortion in recent Marxist analyses of educaiton.British Journal of Sociology of Education,3(2),107-126.
20. Heyns, B.(1978).Summer learning and the effects of schooling.New York:Academic.
21. Kipnis, A.(2001).Articulating school countercultures.Anthropology and Education Quarterly,32(4),472-492.
22. McFadden, M. G.(1995).Resistance to schooling and educational outcomes: Questions of structure and agency.British Journal of Sociology of Education,16(3),293-308.
23. McLaren, P. L.(1985).The ritual dimensions of resistance: Clowning and symbolic inversion.Journal of Education,167(2),84-97.
24. Merton, R. K.(1968).Social theory and social structure.Glencoe, IL:Free.
25. Mills, C. W.(1959).Sociological imagination.New York:Oxford University Press.
26. Munns, G.,McFadden, M. G.(2000).First chance, second chance or last chance? Resistance and response to education.British Journal of Sociology of Education,21(1),59-75.
27. Ogbu, J.(1974).The next generation.New York:Academic.
28. Ogbu, J.(1981).School ethnography: A multilevel approach.Anthropology and Education Quarterly,12(1),3-29.
29. Ogbu, J. U.,Fordham, S.(1986).Black students' school success: Coping with the "burden of 'acting White'".The Urban Review,18(3),177-206.
30. Ogbu, J. U.,Simons, H. D.(1998).Voluntary and involuntary minorities: A cultural-ecological theory of school performance with some implications for education.Anthropology and Education Quarterly,29(2),155-188.
31. Ortner, S. B.(1995).Resistance and the problem of ethnographic refusal.Comparative Studies in Society and History,37(1),173-193.
32. Roberts, J. I.(Ed.),Akinsanya, S. K.(Ed.)(1976).Educational patterns and cultural configurations.New York:David McKay.
33. Sanjek, R.(1990).On ethnographic validity.Fieldnotes: The makings of anthropology,Ithaca, NY:
34. Scott, J.(1986).Everyday forms of peasant resistance.Journal of Peasant Studies,13(2),5-35.
35. Solorzano, D. G.,Bernal, D. D.(2001).Examining transformational resistance through a critical race and latcrit theory framework: Chicana and Chicano students in an urban context.Urban Education,36(3),308-342.
36. Spindler, G. B.(Ed.),Spindler, L. S.(Ed.)(1987).Interpretive ethnography of education at home and abroad.Hillsdale, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum.
37. Walker, J. C.(1985).Rebels with our applause? A critique of resistance theory in Willis's ethnography of schooling.Journal of Education,167(2),63-83.
38. Willis, P.(1977).Learning to labor: How working class kids get working class jobs.New York:Columbia University Press.
39. Willis, P.(1983).Cultural production and theories of reproduction.Race, class and education,London:
40. 邱珮雯(2007)。臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan，國立臺灣師範大學教育學系=National Taiwan Normal University。
41. 翁士勛(2002)。臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan，國立臺灣師範大學教育學系=National Taiwan Normal University。
42. 黃鴻文(1994)。學生次文化：研究、理論與方法論之檢討。社會教育學刊，23，149-193。

1. 曾碩彥(2022)。吾乃男兒身，何來女人心？－就讀師範院校中文系所男生文化初探。教育學誌，47，21-46。
2. 楊巧玲(2017)。學習做勞工，同時做男人：反學校文化中階級與性別的交織之民族誌研究。教育研究集刊，63(4)，1-36。
3. 鄭英傑(2017)。學做工還是怕做工？臺灣社會高學業成就勞動階級學生及其家長的反再製心態之分析。教育研究集刊，63(4)，65-100。