十九世紀末至二十世紀前半葉美國進步教育流派分法與Dewey的流派歸屬

Analyzing the Classification of Various Factions of Progressive Education and J. Dewey's Position in Progressive Education from the End of the 19th Century to the First Half of the 20th Century

10.3966/102887082021096703002

單文經(Wen-Jing Shan)

Dewey的流派歸屬 ； 美國進步教育 ； 美國進步教育流派 ； 理智與品格發展 ； Dewey's position ； progressive education movement in the USA ； factions of progressive education movement ； intellectual and moral development

教育研究集刊

67:3期（2021 / 09 / 30）

43 - 93

繁體中文

本文以適切的研究文獻為據，解答十九世紀末至二十世紀前半葉美國進步教育流派分法與Dewey流派歸屬的有關問題。先確認Cremin雖未刻意將其分流別派，卻確實為之；次蠡測學者們刻意將進步教育分流別派的緣由與作法；再經層層論述試提行政、教學、自由至上、社會重建、生活適應五分之議；隨後以翱翔在天空中的飛龍詮解Dewey不屬於任一流派之論。文末反思指出，學者們所做進步教育流派分法的討論似未慮及Dewey晚年重視的理智與品格發展，因而須予商榷；又，傳統與進步教育並非截然的二元對立，以兼而有之的觀點截長取短，或較妥當。

Based on appropriate research literatures, this article intends to answer the questions about the classification of American progressive education and the belonging of Dewey from the end of the 19th century to the first half of the 20th century. First, despite Cremin did not explicitly claimed the need to divide progressive education into different factions, in actuality he did. Secondly, the reasons and practices of later scholars who intentionally classified progressive education into different factions were examined. Five factions were classified: administratives, pedagogicals, libertarians, social reconstructionists, and life adjustment educators, after a series of justifications were made. Subsequently, ＂the flying dragon in the sky＂ was employed to explain the situation that Dewey does not belong to any faction. Finally, this article argues that the classification of progressive education should be discussed because intelligence and character development, emphasized by later-stage Dewey, is not included. It also suggests that traditional and progressive education are not completely binary. oppositions. It is recommended to employ ＂both-and＂ thinking to extract the strengths and discard the shortcomings of the two.

1. 李玉馨, Y.-S.(2010)。「進步」的揭示與開創：論杜威學說與美國進步主義教育各派別之差異。教育科學期刊，9(2)，53-76。
   連結：
2. 單文經, W.-J.(2017)。解析杜威有關工作活動（Occupations）的主張。課程與教學季刊，20(2)，139-164。
   連結：
3. 單文經, W.-J.(2020)。在十二年國教課綱「總綱」中遇見杜威。當代教育研究，28(2)，1-29。
   連結：
4. LW9:147-167 [1931] The way out of educational confusion.《杜威全集》資料庫（The Collected Works of John Dewey, 1882-1953 [L. Hickman, Ed.]. Electronic Edition. Charlottesville, VA, Intelex Corp.）
5. LW9:194-204 [1934] The need for a philosophy of education.《杜威全集》資料庫（The Collected Works of John Dewey, 1882-1953 [L. Hickman, Ed.]. Electronic Edition. Charlottesville, VA, Intelex Corp.）
6. MW6:177-356 [1910] How we think.《杜威全集》資料庫（The Collected Works of John Dewey, 1882-1953 [L. Hickman, Ed.]. Electronic Edition. Charlottesville, VA, Intelex Corp.）
7. MW7:152-199 [1913] Interest and effort in education.《杜威全集》資料庫（The Collected Works of John Dewey, 1882-1953 [L. Hickman, Ed.]. Electronic Edition. Charlottesville, VA, Intelex Corp.）
8. MW9 [1916a] Democracy and education.《杜威全集》資料庫（The Collected Works of John Dewey, 1882-1953 [L. Hickman, Ed.]. Electronic Edition. Charlottesville, VA, Intelex Corp.）
9. LW14:91-97 [1939] I believe.《杜威全集》資料庫（The Collected Works of John Dewey, 1882-1953 [L. Hickman, Ed.]. Electronic Edition. Charlottesville, VA, Intelex Corp.）
10. (1951).SV1:266-268 [1951] Task of educators, Interviewed by Benjamin Fine.《杜威全集》資料庫（The Collected Works of John Dewey, 1882-1953 [L. Hickman, Ed.]. Electronic Edition. Charlottesville, VA, Intelex Corp.）.
11. EW5:54-83 [1897a] Ethical principles underlying education.《杜威全集》資料庫（The Collected Works of John Dewey, 1882-1953 [L. Hickman, Ed.]. Electronic Edition. Charlottesville, VA, Intelex Corp.）
12. EW5:84-95 [1897b] My pedagogic creed.《杜威全集》資料庫（The Collected Works of John Dewey, 1882-1953 [L. Hickman, Ed.]. Electronic Edition. Charlottesville, VA, Intelex Corp.）
13. LW11:3-65 [1935] Liberalism and social action.《杜威全集》資料庫（The Collected Works of John Dewey, 1882-1953 [L. Hickman, Ed.]. Electronic Edition. Charlottesville, VA, Intelex Corp.）
14. LW13:3-63 [1938b] Experience and education.《杜威全集》資料庫（The Collected Works of John Dewey, 1882-1953 [L. Hickman, Ed.]. Electronic Edition. Charlottesville, VA, Intelex Corp.）
15. LW3:257-268 [1928] Progressive education and the science of education.《杜威全集》資料庫（The Collected Works of John Dewey, 1882-1953 [L. Hickman, Ed.]. Electronic Edition. Charlottesville, VA, Intelex Corp.）
16. LW9:147-167 [1933b] Why have progressive schools? 《杜威全集》資料庫（The Collected Works of John Dewey, 1882-1953 [L. Hickman, Ed.]. Electronic Edition. Charlottesville, VA, Intelex Corp.）
17. MW4:266-293 [1909] Moral principle in education.《杜威全集》資料庫（The Collected Works of John Dewey, 1882-1953 [L. Hickman, Ed.]. Electronic Edition. Charlottesville, VA, Intelex Corp.）
18. MW5 [1908] Ethics (with J. H. Taft) .《杜威全集》資料庫（The Collected Works of John Dewey, 1882-1953 [L. Hickman, Ed.]. Electronic Edition. Charlottesville, VA, Intelex Corp.）
19. MW8:205-404 [1915] School of tomorrow.《杜威全集》資料庫（The Collected Works of John Dewey, 1882-1953 [L. Hickman, Ed.]. Electronic Edition. Charlottesville, VA, Intelex Corp.）
20. SV1:248-250 [1947] Attracting the best minds to teaching, Interview by Benjamin Fine.《杜威全集》資料庫（The Collected Works of John Dewey, 1882-1953 [L. Hickman, Ed.]. Electronic Edition. Charlottesville, VA, Intelex Corp.）
21. LW11:407-417 [1937] Education and social change.《杜威全集》資料庫（The Collected Works of John Dewey, 1882-1953 [L. Hickman, Ed.]. Electronic Edition. Charlottesville, VA, Intelex Corp.）
22. LW12 [1938a] Logic.《杜威全集》資料庫（The Collected Works of John Dewey, 1882-1953 [L. Hickman, Ed.]. Electronic Edition. Charlottesville, VA, Intelex Corp.）
23. LW5:289-298 [1930a] Philosophy and education.《杜威全集》資料庫（The Collected Works of John Dewey, 1882-1953 [L. Hickman, Ed.]. Electronic Edition. Charlottesville, VA, Intelex Corp.）
24. LW5:319-325 [1930b] How much freedom in new schools?《杜威全集》資料庫（The Collected Works of John Dewey, 1882-1953 [L. Hickman, Ed.]. Electronic Edition. Charlottesville, VA, Intelex Corp.）
25. LW5:3-40 [1929] The sources of a science of education.《杜威全集》資料庫（The Collected Works of John Dewey, 1882-1953 [L. Hickman, Ed.]. Electronic Edition. Charlottesville, VA, Intelex Corp.）
26. LW8:107-352 [1933a] How we think? 《杜威全集》資料庫（The Collected Works of John Dewey, 1882-1953 [L. Hickman, Ed.]. Electronic Edition. Charlottesville, VA, Intelex Corp.）
27. MW10:234-243 [1916b] Progress.《杜威全集》資料庫（The Collected Works of John Dewey, 1882-1953 [L. Hickman, Ed.]. Electronic Edition. Charlottesville, VA, Intelex Corp.）
28. SV1: 261-263 [1949] Dewey sees ripe old age ahead, Interview by David Taylor Marke.《杜威全集》資料庫（The Collected Works of John Dewey, 1882-1953 [L. Hickman, Ed.]. Electronic Edition. Charlottesville, VA, Intelex Corp.）
29. Ackerman, D. B.(2003).Taproots for a new century: Tapping the best of traditional and progressive education.Phi Delta Kappan,84(5),344-349.
30. Bode, B. H. (1938). Progressive education at the crossroads. New York, NY: Newson.
31. Church, R. L.,Sedlak, M. W.(1976).Education in the United States: An interpretative history.New York, NY:Free.
32. Clapp, E. R.(Ed.)(1952).The use of resources in education.New York, NY:Harper.
33. Cohen, R. D.,Mohl, R. A.(1979).The paradox of progressive education: The Gary plan and urban schooling.Port Washington, NY:National University Publications.
34. Cohen, S.(1999).Challenging orthodoxies: Towards a new cultural history of education.New York, NY:Peter Lang.
35. Cremin, L. A.(1988).American education: The metropolitan experience, 1876-1980.New York, NY:Harper & Row.
36. Cremin, L. A.(1961).The transformation of the school: Progressivism in American education, 1876-1957.New York, NY:Alfred A. Knopf.
37. Cuban, L.(1984).How teachers taught: Constancy and change in American classrooms, 1890-1980.New York, NY:Teachers College Press.
38. Cuban, L.(1993).How teachers taught: Constancy and change in American classrooms, 1890-1990.New York, NY:Teachers College Press.
39. Dewey, J.(1998).Experience and education, The 60th anniversary edition.West Lafayette, IN:Kappa Delta Pi.
40. Dewey、 J.,林玉体（譯）, Y.-T.(Trans.)(2000).民主與教育.臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan:師大書苑=Lucky Bookstore.
41. Eryaman, M. Y.(Ed.),Bruce, B. C.(Ed.)(2015).International handbook of progressive education.New York, NY:Peter Lang.
42. Gordon, T.(1986).Democracy in one school?: Progressive education and restructuring.London, UK:Falmer Press.
43. Graham, P. A.(1967).Progressive education: From arcady to academe: A history of the Progressive Education Association, 1919-1955.New York, NY:Teachers College Press.
44. Guthrie, J. W.(Ed.)(2003).Encyclopedia of education.New York, NY:MacMillan.
45. Hirsch, E., Jr.(1996).The schools we need and why we don’t have them.New York, NY:Doubleday.
46. Hunt, T. C.(Ed.),Carper, J. C.(Ed.),Lasley, T. J.(Ed.),Raisch, C. D.(Ed.)(2010).Encyclopedia of educational reform and dissent.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
47. Kliebard, H. M.(2004).The struggle for the American curriculum, 1893-1958.New York, NY:RoutledgeFalmer.
48. Kliebard, H. M.(1986).The struggle for the American curriculum, 1893-1958.New York, NY:RoutledgeFalmer.
49. Kridel, C.(2000).Books of the century catalog.Columbia, SC:The University of South Carolina Museum of Education.
50. Krug, E. A.(1972).The shaping of the American high school, Vol. II, 1920-1941.Madison, WI:University of Wisconsin Press.
51. Krug, E. A.(1964).The shaping of the American high school, 1880-1920.New York, NY:Harper & Row.
52. Labaree, D.(2004).The trouble with Ed Schools.New Haven, CT:Yale University Press.
53. Labaree, D.(2005).Progressivism, schools and schools of education: An American romance.Paedagogica Historica,41(1&2),275-288.
54. Labaree, D.(2012).Someone has to fail: The zero-sum game of public schooling.Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press.
55. Levine, B.(2016).Works about John Dewey, 1886-2016.Carbondale, IL:Southern Illinois University Press.
56. Martin, J. E.(2018).School was our life: Remembering progressive education.Bloomington, IN:Indiana University Press.
57. Puckett, J. L., & Johanek, M. C. (2021). American education reform: History, policy, practice. Retrieved from https://www.coursera.org/learn/edref#syllabus
58. Ratner, S.(Ed.)(1968).Philosopher of the common man.New York, NY:Greenwood.
59. Ravitch, D.(2000).Left back: A century of failed school reforms.New York, NY:Simon & Schuster.
60. Ravitch, D.(1983).The troubled crusade: American education, 1945-1980.New York, NY:Basic.
61. Rousmaniere, K.(2013).The principal’s office: A social history of the American school principal.Albany, NY:State University of New York Press.
62. Rury, J. L.(2016).Education and social change: Contours in the history of American schooling.New York, NY:Routledge.
63. Rury, J. L.(2005).Education and social change: Themes in the history of American schooling.Mahwah, NJ:L. Erlbaum Associates.
64. Rury, J. L.(2002).Education and social change: Themes in the history of American schooling.Mahwah, NJ:L. Erlbaum Associates.
65. Russell, J.(2013).Yellow Springs, OH,Antioch University.
66. Spring, J.(1972).Education and the rise of the corporate state.Boston, MA:Beacon.
67. Tyack, D. B.(1974).The one best system: A history of American urban education.Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press.
68. Urban, W.,Wagoner, J.(1996).American education: A history.Boston, MA:McGraw-Hill.
69. Urban, W.,Wagoner, J.(2014).American education: A history.Boston, MA:McGraw-Hill.
70. Urban、 W.,Wagoner, J. L.,周晟（譯）, C.(Trans.),謝愛磊（譯）, A.-L.(Trans.)(2009).美國教育：一部歷史檔案.北京市=Beijing, China:中國人民大學出版社=China Renmin University Press.
71. Webb, L. D.(2006).The history of American education: A great American experiment.Upper Saddle River, NJ:Pearson/Merrill/Prentice Hall.
72. Webb、 L. D.,陳露茜（譯）, R.-C.(Trans.),李朝陽（譯）, T.-Y.(Trans.)(2010).美國教育史：一場偉大的美國實驗.合肥市=Hefei, China:安徽教育=Anhui Education Press.
73. Zilversmit, A.(1993).Changing schools: Progressive education theory and practice, 1930-1960.Chicago, IL:University of Chicago Press.
74. 吳俊升, T.-C.(1972)。教育與文化論文選集，臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan:
75. 周愚文（編）, Y.-W.(Ed.)(2010).進步主義與教育.臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan:師大書苑=Lucky Bookstore.
76. 林逢祺（編）, H.-C.(Ed.),洪仁進（編）, J.-C.(Ed.)(2014).教育哲學—方法篇.臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan:五南=Wu-Nan Book.
77. 張建成, C.-C.(2002).批判的教育社會學研究.臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan:學富=Pro-ED.
78. 教育部=Ministry of Education(1975).國民小學課程標準.臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan:正中=Cheng-chung.
79. 教育部（1948）。修訂中學程課標準。南京市：作者。[Ministry of Education. (1948). Revised curriculum standard for high school. Nanking, China: Author.]
80. 教育部（1983）。國民中學課程標準總綱。臺北市：正中。[Ministry of Education. (1983). Curriculum standard for junior high school. Taipei, Taiwan: Cheng-chung.]
81. 教育部（2014）。十二年國民基本教育課程綱要總綱。取自https://www.naer.edu.tw/files/15-1000-7944,c639-1.php?Lang=zh-tw[Ministry of Education. (2014). Curriculum Guidelines of 12-Year Basic Education-General Guidelines. Retrieved from https://www.naer.edu.tw/files/15-1000-7944,c639-1.php?Lang=zh-tw]
82. 陳佩英（編）, P.-Y.(Ed.),簡菲莉（編）, F.-L.(Ed.)(2015).高中優質化藍海航程紀實.臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan:高等教育=Higher Education.
83. 單文經, W.-J.(2015).經驗與教育（六十周年重新譯注本）.臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan:聯經=Linking.
84. 單文經, W.-J.(2013)。杜威《經驗與教育》一書蘊含的教育改革理念。教育學刊，40，1-35。
85. 賈馥茗, F.-M.(1983).教育哲學.臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan:三民=San-Min.