從「理一分殊」論朱子的經權思想

Discussion of Zhu Zi's Constancy-expediency Thought Based on ＂One Principle; Many Manifestations＂

10.29907/JRTR.201010.0003

姜龍翔(Jiang Long-Xiang)

經 ； 權 ； 朱熹 ； 仁義禮智 ； 理一分殊 ； constancy ； expediency ； Zhu Zi ； Virtue ； Morality ； Propriety and Wisdom ； One Principle ； Many Manifestations

成大中文學報

30期（2010 / 10 / 01）

71 - 99

繁體中文

經權思想是儒學為解決義理衝突所提出的應對原則，歷代儒者對經權觀念的闡述各有偏重，而朱子的經權思想由於缺少專門文章討論，一直未有系統性的建立。此文則透過朱子「理一分殊」的哲學架構，分析朱子經權思維，指出理一之道與分殊之理在朱子經權思想中的地位，並藉由仁義禮智作為分殊之理，建構朱子處理經權爭議的原則，再以散見於語錄及文集中的資料，分析歸納各種衝突關係的處理， 最後並透過朱子對於聖人及常人用權的限制，釐清朱子提出聖人行權的內在意涵及由此啟示常人行權的修養方法。

Constancy-expediency thought is the correspondent principle that suggested by Confucianism to solve the conflicts of justice and meaning. Scholars of different generations have different focuses on the explanations of the constancy-expediency concept. Zhu Zi's Constancy-expediency thought is spread in articles and quotations, hence there is no systemic establishment of Zhu Zi's Constancy-expediency system. This article analyzes Zhu Zi's Constancy-expediency thought via the ＂one Principle; many manifestations＂ architecture, and indicates the positions of ＂one principle＂ and ＂many manifestations＂ in Zhu Zi's Constancy-expediency though. It also establishes Zhu Zi's principle of handling the constancy-expediency arguments by using virtue, morality, propriety and wisdom as the scattered meaning formats. In addition, it analyzes and concludes various ways of handling the conflicts through information that appear in articles and quotations. Finally it analyzes the meaning of the sages executing power through Zhu Zi's limitations of the sages and common people executing power, and analyzes the meaning of Zhu Zi introducing the sages executing power, and concludes the training of common people executing power.

1. 林維杰(2005)。知行與經權─朱熹哲學的詮釋學模式分析。中國文哲研究集刊，27
   連結：
2. (1983)。景印文淵閣四庫全書。臺北:臺灣商務印書館。
3. 朱熹、朱傑人 編(2002)。朱子全書。上海:上海古籍出版社。
4. 朱熹、朱傑人編(2002)。朱子全書。上海:上海古籍出版社。
5. 牟宗三(1995)。心體與性體。臺北:臺灣學生書局。
6. 李幼武、趙鐵寒編(1976)。宋名臣言行錄五集。臺北:文海出版社。
7. 林維杰(2008)。朱熹與經典詮釋。臺北:國立臺灣大學出版中心。
8. 林憶芝(2002)。朱子的經權說探微。國立中央大學文學院人文學報，25
9. 柯玫妃(2007)。理念與境遇─以朱熹《四書集註》為討論範圍。美和技術學院學報，26(2)
10. 韋政通(1991)。儒家與現代中國。臺北:東大圖書公司。
11. 陳來(2008)。朱子哲學研究。上海:華東師範大學出版社。
12. 黎靖德編(2004)。朱子語類。北京:中華書局。