题名

顧憲成的《大學》改本與「格物」說─兼論顧憲成、高攀龍的格物之辯

并列篇名

Gu Xian Cheng's Rewrite of The Great Learning and Theory of "Investigation of Things" - A Debate on the Investigation of Things of Gu Xian Cheng and Gao Pan Long

作者

侯潔之(Hou, Chieh-Chih)

关键词

顧憲成 ; 高攀龍 ; 格物 ; 大學 ; 明明德 ; Gu Xian Cheng ; Gao Pan Long ; Investigation of Things ; The Great Learning ; Illustrating Illustrious Virtue

期刊名称

成大中文學報

卷期/出版年月

80期(2023 / 03 / 01)

页次

77 - 79+81-117

内容语文

繁體中文;英文

中文摘要

為了平息晚明「格物」說競起聚訟,涇陽改本申明其旨。他反對朱子格物補傳,通過格致釋文以「知本」與「修身」充實「格物」,再從「物有本末」賅攝八目並融會三綱以作為工夫總則,規定「致知」方向並結合為內返格知至善之性的立本工夫。由此架構出識性為要,以「明明德」為依歸、以「親民」為實地的「格物」義涵,為其《大學》詮釋的最大特色。由於涇陽要格的是物之本,「物」指的是能依於本而動的心意知家國天下,是以反對「格草木」;景逸要格的是心物相接,「物」還涵蓋了經驗世界的具體存在,因此肯定「格草木」。顧高格物之辯主要來自物我合一的意見分歧,即使後來涇陽不再限定知本取徑只有內求一路,但「格物只是辨箇本末」的基本立場並未改變。

英文摘要

In an attempt to quell the late Ming "Investigation of Things" that had been the subject of so much controversy, Gu Xian Cheng rewrote the text as clarification. In contrast to Zhu Zi's Investigation of Things supplementary, he enriches the study of the nature of things with an explanation of "knowing the nature" and "self-cultivation", and then highlights the eight categories of "things have their origin and end" and integrates the three principles as a general principle of study method, prescribing the direction of "investigation" and integrating it into the fundamental work of returning to the nature of things and supreme goodness within. In this way, the importance of knowing a thing's nature is established, and the connotation of "Investigation of Things", which is based on "Illustrating illustrious virtue" and "affectionate to the people", is the most distinctive feature of his interpretation of The Great Learning. Since Gu Xian Cheng wanted to grasp the essence of things, "things" refers to the mind that can change according to the nature, which is used to know the whole world, so he opposed the "investigation of the little things in nature"; Gao Pan Long wanted to grasp the connection between mind and matter, and his "things" also covers the concrete existence of the world of experience, so he affirmed "investigation of the little things in nature". Gu and Gao's argument on the investigation of things mainly comes from the differences of opinion on the unity of things and oneself. Even though Gu Xian Cheng later ceased to restrict the path of investigating of the nature to only the inner study, his basic stand that "the investigation of things is only the identification of the nature of trivial things" remained unchanged.

主题分类 人文學 > 中國文學
参考文献
  1. 侯潔之(2022)。顧涇陽、高景逸的脩身知本之說─以李見羅為參照系。臺大中文學報,76,143-190。
    連結:
  2. (1997).續修四庫全書.上海:上海古籍出版社.
  3. (2003).Continuous Revision of Siku Series.Shanghai:Shanghai Chinese Classics Publishing House.
  4. (1995).四庫全書存目叢書.濟南:齊魯書社.
  5. (2002).續修四庫全書.上海=Shanghai:上海古籍出版社=Shanghai Chinese Classics Publishing House.
  6. (1995).四庫全書存目叢書.臺南:莊嚴文化事業有限公司.
  7. (宋)朱熹,朱傑人(編),嚴佐之(編),劉永翔(編)(2002).朱子全書.上海:上海古籍出版社.
  8. (宋)楊時,林海權(點校)(1993).楊時集.福州:福建人民出版社.
  9. (宋)黎靖德(編), Jing De(2004).朱子語類.北京=Beijing:中華書局=Zhonghua Book Company.
  10. (明)王守仁, Shou Ren(1997).王陽明全集.上海=Shanghai:上海古籍出版社=Shanghai Chinese Classics Publishing House.
  11. (明)胡直, Zhi(2015).胡直集.上海=Shanghai:上海古籍出版社=Shanghai Chinese Classics Publishing House.
  12. (明)高攀龍, Pan Long(2020).高攀龍全集.南京=Jiangsu:鳳凰出版社=Phoenix Publishing & Media, Inc..
  13. (明)許孚遠(1990).大學述.臺北:漢學研究中心.
  14. (明)黃綰(1959).明道編.北京:中華書局.
  15. 明‧黃綰:《石龍集》,明嘉靖原刊本。
  16. (明)顧憲成(2011).顧端文公遺書.南京:鳳凰出版社.
  17. (明)顧憲成, Xian Cheng(2011).大學重定.南京=Nanjing:鳳凰出版社=Phoenix Publishing & Media, Inc..
  18. (明)顧憲成, Xian Cheng(1975).小心齋劄記.臺北=Taipei:廣文書局=Kwangwen Book Company.
  19. (明)顧憲成, Xian Cheng(2011).大學質言.南京=Nanjing:鳳凰出版社=Phoenix Publishing & Media, Inc..
  20. 古清美(2004).顧涇陽、高景逸思想之比較研究.臺北:大安出版社.
  21. 步近智,張安奇(2011).顧憲成高攀龍評傳.南京:南京大學出版社.
  22. 沈善洪(編), Shan Hong(ed.)(2000).黃宗羲全集.杭州=Hangchow:浙江古籍出版社=Zhejiang Classics Publishing House.
  23. 容肇祖(1982).明代思想史.臺北:臺灣開明書店.
  24. 張學智(2000).明代哲學史.北京:北京大學出版社.
  25. 陳民裕(1978)。高雄,高雄師範大學國文學系。
  26. 劉勇(2016).變動不居的經典:明代《大學》改本研究.北京:生活‧讀書‧新知三聯書局.
  27. 鄧克銘(2013).晚明四書說解研究.臺北:里仁書局.